Highways to hell: province's worst roads
A Pembina Valley highway has earned the dubious distinction of being Manitoba's nastiest road in 2025.
CAA's Worst Roads Campaign results revealed Highway 34, specifically the stretch between Holland and Gladstone, was Manitobans' No. 1 choice for its combination of jarring potholes, poor maintenance, bad signage and unpaved sections.
It was the highway's sixth appearance as a finalist since CAA Manitoba began asking drivers, cyclists, transit users and pedestrians to serve as judges in the far-from-beauty contest in 2012.
Ruth Bonneville / Free Press
Potholes remain the worst culprits in why roadways rank poorly in the CAA surveys.
This year's nomination period began March 18 and ended April 11.
Ewald Friesen, CAA Manitoba's government relations manager, said the highway is one of nine rural roads that made the top — or bottom, really — 10 this year, a first. The lone Winnipeg street on the list was Saskatchewan Avenue, which made its seventh consecutive appearance.
Winnipeg roads dominated last year's list, with six of the 10 finalists inside the Perimeter.
But city drivers can usually find alternative routes.
'If you live in a rural part of this province, you depend on your road in a way that's a little bit more critical than any place else,' Friesen said. 'There are no other options if your road isn't passable.'
A CAA Manitoba member-only survey in February found 96 per cent of 1,014 respondents were concerned about road conditions, he said.
This year saw 723 different roads nominated, a 50 per cent spike compared to 2024's survey. Half of those that cracked the top 10 were first appearances.
Friesen said past successes from surveys getting provincial and municipal governments to act on repairs have driven more people to vote. There were no available numbers on total voters, he said.
Last year, Brandon's 18th Street was named the worst road in the province, getting a pledge from Premier Wab Kinew to get it repaired. Construction began last fall and is still under way.
Wednesdays
A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom.
'The government's co-ordinated and very swift response to the repair of 18th street has sort of empowered rural Manitobans,' said Friesen.
Potholes were the leading sore spot for Manitobans when voting for the worst roads, he said.
'If your budget is already stretched and you're holding on to the car and you get vehicle damage as a result of bad roads, you're out the money,' he said.
As the federal and provincial governments look to pull down inter-provincial trade barriers, Friesen said poor road conditions could also impact how effectively goods can be transported by truck. He's hopeful 2025's list will bring action from the province and municipalities to improve the situation.
matthew.frank@freepress.mb.ca
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
2 days ago
- CBC
Looking for a bumpy ride? Hamilton home to the 2 worst roads in Ontario, says CAA
Social Sharing Hamilton has the worst road in Ontario for the fourth year running, according to a Canadian Automobile Association (CAA) campaign. CAA's worst roads list, which has been running since at least 2003, declared Aberdeen Avenue the worst in the province, with Barton Street E. coming in second. CAA named Aberdeen Avenue the worst road in 2024, too. According to a CAA news release Thursday, "frustrations with potholes and poor road maintenance have kept this road in the number one spot." Barton Street E. held the worst road distinction in 2023 and 2022. Hamilton also held the number one spot in 2017 and 2018 with Burlington Street E. The top 10 worst roads in the province, according to the 2025 campaign, are: Aberdeen Avenue, Hamilton. Barton Street E., Hamilton. County Road 49, Prince Edward County. Eglinton Avenue W., Toronto. Hurontario Street, Mississauga. Leveque Road, South Frontenac. Highway 50, Caledon. Sider Road, Fort Erie. Gardiner Expressway, Toronto. Sheppard Avenue West, Toronto. 'Reflection of public concern': city Hamilton's director of transportation Carolyn Ryall said that while she hasn't had any direct correspondence with CAA yet, the city is well aware of public concerns regarding those roads and suspected they may be on the list. "We recognize the importance of the report and we understand that it's really a reflection of public concern. It's something that we take very seriously," Ryall told CBC Hamilton. She said city teams are always working to maintain roads, filling 70,000 to 90,000 potholes per year. Hamilton invested $190 million in the transportation network in 2025, Ryall said, including a $5 million increase in the city's resurfacing fund, which is used to patch up areas that are harder to maintain. "We know that the city of Hamilton is aware of this and they've continued to invest in infrastructure," Brian Pirvu, a government relations consultant for CAA South Central Ontario, told CBC Hamilton. "We want to continue having those conversations with them in order to ensure that [funding]." He noted potholes can form more easily in our polarizing climate, where the ground can freeze and thaw rapidly, weakening asphalt. "We are seeing from certain reports that the cost of maintaining roads has increased." Aberdeen work in progress: Transportation director On Aberdeen Avenue, Pirvu said, Longwood Road S., Locke Street S., and Queen Street S., were intersections respondents flagged as particularly bad. On Barton Street E., Gave Avenue N., and Ottawa Street N., were two respondents complained about. The city is looking to fully reconstruct Aberdeen Avenue and make it better for walking, cycling and driving, but that will take a long time, Ryall said, since it requires consultation and involves infrastructure below the surface such as water and wastewater systems. In the meantime, she said, the city took residents' concerns into account and worked with Coun. Maureen Wilson (Ward 1)'s office on a plan to resurface Aberdeen Avenue between Dundurn Street S., and Studholme Road as a hold-me-over. In recent years, she said, the city completed a $7.5-million reconstruction project on Barton Street E., between Parkdale Avenue N., and Talbot Street. Hamilton is planning to do more construction between Parkdale and Ferguson Avenue N., soon, Ryall said. In Hamilton, the worst roads this year according to the campaign are: Aberdeen Avenue. Barton Street E. Main Street W. King Street E. Main Street E. In Niagara, those roads are: Sider Road, Fort Erie. Portage Road, Niagara Falls. Miller Road, Port Colborne. Lundy's Lane, Niagara Falls. Facer Street, St. Catharines. How the list is determined To determine its list, CAA asks participants to nominate roads, Pirvu said. They can share why they're nominating them and can say what type of road user they are. CAA said 84 per cent of respondents cited potholes as one of their primary reason for nominating a road. About 77 per cent cited poor road maintenance, and about 15 per cent cited congestion. Most people who submitted candidates identified themselves as drivers or people who commute by vehicle, Pirvu said, but people also noted issues from the perspective of cyclists and pedestrians. People nominated over 2,400 different roads from 208 municipalities. CAA works with the Residential and Civil Construction Alliance of Ontario, which advocates for infrastructure investment, to investigate nominated roads and confirm there are issues, Pirvu said. They also work to reach out to municipalities and provinces to "promote solutions" such as accessing grants or using recycled asphalt to save money. Usually, Pirvu said, CAA sees those sorts of streets drop off the list once maintenance is done. Pirvu acknowledges that while people want well-maintained roads, maintenance can be unpopular, with CAA members reporting frustration with how long road projects take to complete. That's a balancing act, Ryall said, and city staff try to reduce disruptions by coordinating when and where different crews will work to prevent people from getting caught in multiple detours. She said people with concerns about roadways can call the city and noted potholes can be reported online.
CTV News
2 days ago
- CTV News
Roads in Waterloo, Guelph and Elmira make CAA's worst roads list
CP24's Courtney Heels speaks with CAA's Teresa Di Felice about the annual list of Ontario's worst roads and the key factors behind the rankings. Loading the player instance is taking more time than usual Loading the player instance is taking more time than usual Waterloo, Guelph and Elmira have made the Canadian Automobile Association's list of worst roads in Ontario. Ira Needles Boulevard in Waterloo ranked second in the campaign's western region, which included Brant, Huron, Middlesex, Norfolk, Oxford, Perth County and Waterloo Region. York Road in Guelph dropped from first place last year to fourth in 2025. This was also the third year in a row that Ira Needles Boulevard and York Road made the CAA's worst roads list. Rounding out the top five were two roads in Elmira. Arthur Street South and Barnswallow Drive both tied for last place in the western division. The CAA's list, which was released on Thursday, was as follows: Dundas Street, London Ira Needles Boulevard, Waterloo York Street, London York Road, Guelph Arthur Street South and Barnswallow Drive in Elmira While Waterloo, Guelph and Elmira were the worst in the region, they did not even rank in the top ten across Ontario. Here are what CAA has named as the worst roads for 2025:
CTV News
2 days ago
- CTV News
CAA releases list of worst roads in northern Ont.
Burton Avenue in Sudbury was named by the CAA the fifth worst in northern Ontario. While the north didn't make the all-Ontario list, the Canadian Automobile Association says there are still some pretty horrible roads in northern Ontario. The CAA released its list of the province's worst roads Thursday, with Hamilton and Toronto dominating the list. In northeastern Ontario, Panache Lake Road in Greater Sudbury earned the dubious nod as the worst road, followed by McNabb Street in Sault Ste. Marie and Premier Road in North Bay. Two more streets in Sudbury – Allan Street and Burton Avenue – rounded out the Top 5. The full list with regional breakdowns across the province can be found here. The last time a northern Ontario road was picked as the worst was in 2015, when Algonquin Boulevard West took home the 'honour.' Before that it was Pelican Road in Sioux Lookout (2010), Vermillion Lake Road in Sudbury (2007) and Cardwell Road in the Township of Assiginack.
