Birkenstock sandals are not art, German court rules
They may be the trendy footwear of choice for Hollywood A-listers and pop stars, but Birkenstock sandals are not works of art, Germany's top court ruled Thursday.
The German sandal maker had sought a ruling that its footwear, known for its cork and latex soles, could be classified as art and thus afforded strong copyright protections.
The company, whose sandals have over the years transformed from unglamourous footwear to coveted fashion items, wanted to stop three of its competitors from selling similar products.
It had wanted the products of the trio -- German retailers Tchibo and shoe.com, as well as the Danish retailer Bestseller -- to be pulled from the shelves and destroyed.
But the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe sided with the judgement of a lower court, ruling that Birkenstock's sandals could not be considered "copyrighted works of applied art".
"For copyright protection to apply, there must be such a degree of design that the product displays some individuality," the court said.
"Pure craftsmanship using formal design elements" was not enough, said the court, bringing a close to a legal saga that began in May 2023.
Despite the ruling, Birkenstock defended bringing the case.
"We want to ensure that copycats can no longer make money at the expense of our brand," said company spokesman Jochen Gutzy.
Founded in 1774 in a small community in southwest Germany as a firm focused on making orthopaedic footwear, Birkenstock has grown into a global footwear titan.
Its sandals are popular among VIPs, with singers Katy Perry and Britney Spears donning the footwear in recent years.
They also appeared in the hit 2023 movie "Barbie" when actress Margot Robbie swapped high heels for a pink pair.
In 2021 the Birkenstock family sold its majority stake in the group to LVMH-linked equity firm L Catterton and French billionaire Bernard Arnault's family holding fund Financiere Agache.
It launched an international public offering on the New York Stock Exchange in 2023.
vbw/sr/rl
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Unironically Attends 'Les Misérables' As Protests Spread
As protests against his immigration policies balloon nationwide, President Donald Trump is seeing one of his favorite musicals on Wednesday night: 'Les Misérables,' the story of an anti-government uprising, abusive police and harsh imprisonment. Trump is going to opening night of the famous musical's one-month run at Washington, D.C.'s John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, whose entire board of trustees he replaced in February and had them name him chairman. 'We've seen it many times,' Trump said upon arriving at the Kennedy Center with first lady Melania Trump. 'Love it. One of my favorites.' When a reporter asked him which side of the musical's conflict he most identified with, Trump laughed and refused to answer. 'That's tough. You better answer that one, honey,' he said, gesturing to the first lady. 'I don't know.' When another reporter asked how he felt about reports that some of the 'Les Misérables' cast would be boycotting the night of his performance, Trump said he 'couldn't care less.' 'All I do is run the country well,' he retorted. Trump received a mixture of cheers and boos when he took his seat at the theater. His attendance comes after he deployed National Guard troops to face largely peaceful protesters in Los Angeles and announced he was sending in Marines, despite pushback from local leadership. 'Les Misérables,' the musical based on the 1862 novel of the same name, tells the story of French peasant Jean Valjean after he emerges from a 19-year prison sentence for stealing a loaf of bread for his niece. Much of the musical centers around student demonstrations against the French monarchy. One of the musical's most recognizable songs ― 'Do You Hear The People Sing?' ― has a long history as an anthem at pro-democracy demonstrations. It's also an apparent favorite of Trump's, as he played the song right before walking onstage to announce his third presidential run in 2022. Several drag performers also attended the show Wednesday night to protest Trump, who announced in February there would be 'NO MORE DRAG SHOWS, OR OTHER ANTI-AMERICAN PROPAGANDA' at the Kennedy Center going forward. They received applause as they walked in to the theater, social media videos show. Vagenesis, whose government name is Anderson Wells, was one of the planned attendees. 'Theater is supposed to be a place of community, a place of storytelling, a place of celebration, joy, catharsis and it should be open and available to all,' Vagenesis told NPR on Wednesday. Trump's former Vice President Mike Pence similarly caused a stir when he went to see 'Hamilton' shortly after winning the 2016 election. He was loudly booed when he arrived at the Manhattan theater. When Pence was trying to exit the theater after the final curtain call, actor Brandon Dixon, who was playing the part of Aaron Burr, asked him to stay and delivered a message to him. 'We, sir, we are the diverse America, who are alarmed and anxious that your new administration will not protect us, our planet, our children, our parents or defend us and uphold our inalienable rights,' Dixon said. 'We truly hope that this show has inspired you to uphold our American values and to work on behalf of all of us,' he continued. Pam Bondi Warns Of More Arrests In California Amid Protests Against Immigration Raids Karoline Leavitt Snaps At Reporter For 'Stupid Question' About Peaceful Protests There's Growing Anger Over Flags Flown At LA Protests. Here's What Everyone Is Getting Wrong.
Forbes
37 minutes ago
- Forbes
Why LVMH's $1.5B Formula 1 Bet Is No Average Luxury Partnership
Max Verstappen of Red Bull Racing during the Formula 1 pre-season testing at Sakhir Circuit in ... More Sakhir, Bahrain on February 26, 2025. (Photo by Jakub Porzycki/NurPhoto via Getty Images) When my favorite Cashmere Wolf, Bernard Arnault, chairman of luxury behemoth LVMH Group, watches Max Verstappen navigate treacherous corners at 180 mph during the Formula 1® Bahrain circuit, he does so with an eye towards his calculated $1.5 billion, 10-year investment into a competition rapidly growing in popularity. Like the Group's 2024 Paris Olympic Games sponsorship, this unprecedented partnership, announced in late 2024 and aligned with the sport's 75th anniversary and season, represents far more than logo placement on fast cars. Three distinct LVMH maisons—TAG Heuer, Louis Vuitton, and Moët & Chandon — each now play carefully choreographed roles in what amounts to luxury's most ambitious sporting investment in Arnault's latest exercise of strategic narrative layering. Arnault orchestrated TAG Heuer's takeover from Rolex the role of official timekeeper for Monaco's Grand Prix; integrated Louis Vuitton's bespoke trunks as carrying cases for Formula 1 trophies; and ensured Moët & Chandon's omnipresence across newly rebranded races, Formula 1 TAG Heuer Monaco GRAND PRIX; Formula 1 Louis Vuitton Australian GRAND PRIX 2025; and Formula 1 Moët & Chandon Belgian GRAND PRIX 2025. These LVMH brands will peacock on 24 global stages across nine months—stages that drew 1.5 billion cumulative TV viewers last year with an average viewership of 70 million per race—reaching a sundry audience that may never have entered a Louis Vuitton boutique or considered a TAG Heuer timepiece. With these spectators skewing younger and more diverse than traditional luxury consumers, Arnault clearly has his eyes set on future customer cultivation, something many luxury brands often eschew in favor of those who can afford their products today. With Formula 1 now making scheduled Grand Prix stops in my Miami backyard for the next 15 years, I ventured onto the tracks last month to understand the sport's growing entanglement with luxury. What I discovered were strategic partnerships navigating a balance between a rich motorsport tradition, a lifestyle signature, and a technologically savvy fanbase increasingly led by women. KEITH, SCOTLAND – OCTOBER 30: (EDITORS NOTE: This image is a composite, and has been digitally ... More retouched) The Aston Martin AMR24 is showcased inside the historic Still House at the Glenfiddich Distillery in Keith, Scotland, on October 30, 2024. This unique setting celebrates the newly announced global partnership between Glenfiddich and Aston Martin Formula One® Team. (Photo by Guidofor Glenfiddich) 'Formula 1 is really having a moment,' Rob Bloom, CMO of Aston Martin Formula 1, told me over a dram of Glenfiddich 50YO Simultaneous Time, part of the single malt scotch whisky brand's Time Re:Imagined collection, and the rarest of the scotches Bloom and I would taste that evening. 'There are still new people discovering Formula 1 today. [This growth is attracting] After racing McLarens at the McLaren Track Driving Event, followed by a MIAMI GRAND PRIX® Track Preview Experience & Paddock Tour, both courtesy of Chase Sapphire Reserve, I traded my track day sneakers for heels and a Donna Karan silk dress as I headed to the Mandarin Oriental for an exclusive dining experience with the Aston Martin Aramco Formula One TeamTM to sample Glenfiddich's impressive lineup. The dinner was part of Aston Martin F1's multi-year partnership with the scotch brand, announced at the November Las Vegas Grand Prix, where Glenfiddich unearthed a rare cask from 1959 – the very year Aston Martin debuted in Formula 1 – to create a commemorative single bottle expression. In aligning origin stories, both brands enlisted the marketing strategy of borrowed equity from each brand's legacy to augment their respective audience. In this well curated pairing, an Aston Martin enthusiast and a Glenfiddich connoisseur both share a love of the artisanal, of precision engineering, and a deep appreciation for heritage, innovation, and the relentless pursuit of distinction. 'The growth mindset that exists in the team is that we'll never settle,' Bloom said. 'There is that ongoing pursuit of excellence and betterment. Even when we win a race, the only thing we're thinking about is the next race and the next win. Which in a way is addictive. It feeds you and everybody in the organization lives with this growth mindset.' Under Bloom's marketing leadership, the brand is leveraging F1's burgeoning popularity by actively engaging with new audiences through lifestyle integrations and collaborations, such as with Glenfiddich. Beyond just winning races, Aston Martin F1's marketing strategy is towards continuously exalting the brand's image to an impassioned community. He continued, 'The sport itself is having a real moment. It's not just about that amazing tech racing story and the growth mindset and the competitive nature of the sport. It's actually about an extension into culture and lifestyle, and the fact that F1 shows up in everyday currency.' This cultural expansion has fundamentally changed how luxury brands approach Formula 1 partnerships. 'Aston Martin's brand is ultimately a lifestyle brand,' Bloom stated, 'and what we want to do as a brand in F1 is to make sure that we show up in a way that is more than just the sport.' Aston Martin F1 has recently collaborated with The Rolling Stones and DJ Dom Dolla to extend racing culture into the music, fashion, and nightlife territories luxury consumers inhabit. 'We want to get measured on how we bring people into the sport and our brand image,' he added. 'Whether you're wearing The Rolling Stones hoodie or drinking a glass of Glenfiddich, you should be able to experience and enjoy that as an extension of your celebration of two brands coming together.' Globant Co-Founder Guibert Englebienne interviews Jonny Haworth, F1's director of commercial ... More partnerships at the Globant and F1® Miami Garage Event 'What's really interesting is that as fans come in, they're younger, they're more diverse, they're more female and the challenge we have is that their interest in the sport spans everything,' Jonny Haworth, F1's director of commercial partnerships discussed during the Globant and F1 Miami Garage Event panel at the Miami Autodrome Paddock. 'The deep technology, the cars, everything that goes on the track all the way through to the culture and the lifestyle that goes on with drivers. And our role is to try and engage each of those audiences in a completely different way.' This diversification challenge is precisely where technology partners become essential to luxury brands' F1 strategies. Globant, through its multi-year Official Partner agreement with Formula 1, is using engineering and data to lean into human emotions. F1 has now gone from a niche automotive competition watched mostly by enthusiasts into an immersive experience accessible to global onlookers. 'Technology was getting into our pockets and therefore was changing the way we could connect 7 by 24 with the brands that we love, creating an emotional bond,' Guibert Englebienne, Globant's co-founder said. 'You need to make it memorable. It's a big investment for people to come here. So our vision is that technology can be used to improve that, to expand, to bring some gravity to the sport, and the combination of engineering with data with a very human oriented company. ' Formula 1's fundamental marketing objective, according to Donna Birkett Baida, the organization's director of marketing, is to 'make people fall in love with it, with our sport and with our brand.' She likened this to the complexity of human love, aiming for both 'incredible highs and passion' and 'a level of comfort.' The ultimate goal is to create 'moments that are so memorable' and drive engagement, 'really bringing people... from just being aware of our brand and that latent interest in our brand to actually genuinely falling in love with it.' Globant is now developing a Formula 1 customer-facing app to enhance fan experience while providing data to devise continued engagement opportunities. 'What I love about the app—and we're still in the conceptual stages—is that it's going to move us from being reactive,' Baida shared. 'Which is really important because we have to be with our fans – react to their behaviors, requirements, and needs – but moving us much more towards being proactive and trying to anticipate what their requirements are and give them the best possible Formula 1 experience.' Tag Heuer clock during the Formula 1 pre-season testing at Sakhir Circuit in Sakhir, Bahrain on ... More February 26, 2025. (Photo by Jakub Porzycki/NurPhoto via Getty Images) Shifting from efficiency to intimacy was exactly what Formula 1 needed to court new audiences, particularly the female demographic reshaping the sport's identity. This growing female F1 fanbase is inspiring entirely new forms of artistic expression within the circuit. Take Samantha Zimmermann, a fine artist whose motorsports realism captures both the technical precision and emotional sensations evoked in racing. Working primarily in oil paint and graphite pencil, Zimmermann has found her niche painting live at major IMSA and HSR events. 'Lyn Hiner, Anita Lewis, and I were invited to display our work within the Paddock Club,' Zimmerman shared with me in email. 'In addition to having art on display, we are also doing live painting demonstrations throughout the weekend! Guests who visit the marketplace space within the Paddock Club will also be invited to participate in the paint-by-numbers feature.' LVMH was undoubtedly betting on this demographic shift when structuring their billion-dollar F1 investment. TAG Heuer has been actively cultivating the sport's female future through its partnership with F1 ACADEMY™, the all-female single-seater racing series designed to propel women toward motorsport's highest levels. 'We have a unique opportunity to fundamentally change our industry, driving female participation at every level of motorsport,' Susie Wolff, a former F1 test driver and managing director of F1 ACADEMY™, said in TAG Heuer's brand magazine. Since becoming F1's official timekeeper, TAG Heuer CEO Antoine Pin reports traffic in stores has increased by double digits, forcing the brand to increase production on the car-related models. The timepiece manufacturer's position jumped from 15th to 11th among top Swiss watch brands by sales in 2024. With Formula 1 now attracting over 800 million viewers annually—40 percent of whom are women—the sport's unique combination of technological sophistication, global reach, and cultural expansion creates opportunities for luxury brands to access passionate communities where, as with the pursuit of luxury, precision, innovation, and excellence are already expected. The racing platform serves as both scientist and laboratory in teaching brands how to win over consumers prioritizing experiences over products, authenticity over exclusivity, and emotional connection over transactional relationships. MIAMI, FLORIDA - MAY 04: Max Verstappen of the Netherlands driving the (1) Oracle Red Bull Racing ... More RB20 leads the field into turn one at the start during the Sprint ahead of the F1 Grand Prix of Miami at Miami International Autodrome on May 04, 2024 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by) Baida's F1 mission to 'make people fall in love with our sport and our brand' represents a seismic shift from luxury's once pragmatic exclusivity to a now fervently passionate inclusivity. When TAG Heuer reports double-digit store traffic increases and jumps from 15th to 11th in Swiss watch rankings because of the Formula 1 partnership, particularly at a time when tariffs are upending the Swiss watch industry, it reaffirms emotional connection as luxury's most recession-proof currency.
Business of Fashion
an hour ago
- Business of Fashion
Zara Owner Inditex Posts Slowing Growth
Zara owner Inditex SA reported a muted start to the second quarter and warned that foreign-exchange fluctuations could have a greater impact on results this year than anticipated. The shares tumbled. Revenue at the world's largest listed clothing retailer rose 6% in the five weeks to June 9, excluding currency effects. That was weaker than last year's start to the summer season, the Arteixo, Spain-based retailer said on Wednesday. 'The release fails to dispel concerns on slowing growth,' analysts at Barclays wrote in a note. The company's shares fell as much as 6.4 percent in early Madrid trading. The stock is down about 4.7 percent since the start of the year. Even though current trading is tracking higher than the 4.2 percent sales growth recorded in the first quarter, the latest numbers suggest that Inditex, like its peers, is not immune to a drop in demand prompted by the global trade war. The company has fared better than many of its rivals by keeping tighter controls on inventory, enabling it to remain nimble in a fickle fashion industry, but its sales-growth rates have headed down sharply from the post-pandemic boom era. Swedish rival Hennes & Mauritz AB posted disappointing first-quarter results because of stockpiles of unsold clothing. Foreign-exchange swings are likely to be a greater-than-expected drag on revenue this year, Inditex warned. The company expects currency fluctuations to shave 3 percent off sales this year, up from 1 percent it had expected previously. The adjustment follows a notable depreciation in both the US dollar and the Mexican peso against the euro, shrinking international earnings when converted back to the company's home currency. Other retailers have also signalled the cooling effect FX swings are having with H&M citing a strong kroner as another reason for its weak first-quarter. Last month, German sneaker brand Puma AG said the effect of tariffs and currency fluctuations was challenging to manage. The global garment industry tends to be a dollar-denominated business, which can particularly affect European retailers when they translate earnings back into local currencies. Inditex first spooked the market in March when it signalled a weaker start to its fiscal year, provoking a 7.5 percent fall — the biggest single-day plunge in its shares in five years. In its first quarter ended April 30, operating profit was in line with analyst estimates, while revenue was below expectations. The retailer said costs grew 2.3 percent in the period, rising faster than the 1.5 percent increase in revenue, including currency swings. Asked about the effect of President Donald Trump's tariffs, Inditex said it would use its broad range of suppliers, including those close to home in Spain, Portugal, Turkey and Morocco to manage the situation. 'In any case, I'd say that we see growth opportunities globally, not just in one market,' said Investor Relations Director Gorka Garcia-Tapia Yturriaga on a call with analysts. Over the last few years, the company has invested in both expanding its network of stores and also on refurbishing existing outlets to ensure a better shopping experience for customers. The company plans to spend €1.8 billion ($2 billion) again this year on store improvements and technology, along with an additional €900 million to expand its logistics network. By Clara Hernanz Lizarraga Learn more: The Brewing Controversy Over the Cotton in Your T-Shirt Zara owner Inditex, the world's largest fast fashion company, is ditching the industry's biggest sustainable cotton scheme amid a deforestation scandal and a wider push to prioritise organic fibres.
