Historical echoes in Trump cases
Welcome back, Deadline: Legal Newsletter readers. If you're at least a casual news consumer, you've probably seen a rash of retrospectives on the first 100 days of Donald Trump's second term. I contributed to the genre here. This week's newsletter continues along that reflective theme, looking at how judges are invoking American history to help us understand the moment we're in.
The Red Scare in the 1920s and McCarthyism in the 1950s featured in a ruling ordering the release of Mohsen Mahdawi on Wednesday. The legal U.S. resident was seized by immigration agents at his citizenship interview last month in Vermont. He argued that he was targeted for exercising his right to speak out for Palestinians. U.S. District Judge Geoffrey Crawford seemed to agree, finding that his continued detention would likely have a 'chilling effect' on protected speech.
The judge also marked the moment by noting 'the extraordinary setting of this case and others like it.' He observed that legal residents who haven't been charged with any crimes are being threatened with deportation for stating their views on political issues of the day. Against that backdrop, Crawford summoned the anti-communist Red Scare and McCarthyism panics of the last century. 'The wheel of history has come around again,' the Obama-appointed judge wrote, 'but as before these times of excess will pass.'
To be sure, it's been a bipartisan judicial affair calling out this administration. Crawford's ruling reminded me of last month's lesson from Reagan-appointed appellate Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III. Lamenting the government's resistance to returning the illegally deported Kilmar Abrego Garcia, Wilkinson wrote that '[t]he Executive may succeed for a time in weakening the courts, but over time history will script the tragic gap between what was and all that might have been, and law in time will sign its epitaph.' The government is still resisting Abrego Garcia's return.
This week, another Reagan appointee zoomed out to rebuke claims 'from both inside and outside government' that the courts are causing a constitutional crisis by usurping Trump's power. U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth ordered the government to disburse congressionally approved funds to pro-democracy nonprofit Radio Free Europe. In doing so, the judge wrote that he was 'humbly fulfilling my small part in this very constitutional paradigm — a framework that has propelled the United States to heights of greatness, liberty and prosperity unparalleled in the history of the world for nearly 250 years.' Lamberth concluded that '[i]f our nation is to thrive for another 250 years, each co-equal branch of government must be willing to courageously exert the authority entrusted to it by our Founders.'
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson joined the historical conversation in remarks to a judicial conference in Puerto Rico. Politico reported that she condemned attacks on judges who have ruled against the administration. The Biden appointee reportedly encouraged judges to be courageous and 'keep doing what is right for our country, and I do believe that history will vindicate your service.'
Jackson and her high court colleagues wrapped up the term's regularly scheduled arguments this week. Among them was a case that could make history because at stake is whether the justices will approve the nation's first-ever publicly funded religious charter school. While Justice Amy Coney Barrett's recusal from the appeal could make the vote closer, the remaining Republican appointees were largely sympathetic to the school, which the Trump administration backs. It could come down to Chief Justice John Roberts' vote.
The Supreme Court's next hearing is a rare one over Trump's quest to curb birthright citizenship, set for a special May 15 session. Besides that, the justices are busy writing their final opinions of the term, which are typically published by July. In the meantime, they're frequently fielding emergency litigation that could produce orders at odd hours, including on the administration's pending appeal to enforce a ban on transgender military service. The administration added yet another emergency request on Friday, seeking permission for Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency to access Social Security data.This article was originally published on MSNBC.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Rangers appoint former Southampton boss Martin as new head coach
Former Southampton boss Russell Martin is the new man in charge at Rangers (Glyn KIRK) Scottish Premiership club Rangers on Thursday confirmed the appointment of former Southampton boss Russell Martin as their new head coach on a three-year deal. The 39-year-old guided Southampton to promotion to the Premier League last year but was sacked in December following one win from their first 16 games. The club were subsequently relegated. Advertisement Rangers finished last season under the caretaker management of former captain Barry Ferguson, having dismissed Philippe Clement in February. Ex-Scotland defender Martin, who had a short loan spell as a player at Rangers in 2018, faces the daunting task of challenging Celtic, who have just won a 13th Scottish title in 14 seasons. "From my time here, I had a taste of how special this club is, the expectation, the passion and the history," he told the club's website. "Now, as I return, I'm determined to bring success back, for the supporters, the players, and everyone inside this club. Advertisement "There's a lot to be done, but the goal is clear -- win matches, win trophies and give Rangers fans a team that they can be proud of." Martin's arrival is the latest in a series of major changes at the club. An American consortium led by Andrew Cavenagh and 49ers Enterprises secured a majority shareholding on Friday, while new sporting director Kevin Thelwell officially began work on Monday. Rangers chief executive Patrick Stewart, who led the recruitment process alongside Thelwell, said: "Our criteria for our next coach were clear: we wanted a coach who will excel in terms of how we want to play, improve our culture, develop our squad, and ultimately win matches. Russell was the standout candidate." jw/lp
27 minutes ago
Russian strike kills 5 in Ukraine, including a 1 year old
KYIV, Ukraine -- At least five people, including a one-year-old child, were killed in a Russian drone strike on the northern Ukrainian city of Pryluky overnight, regional governor Viacheslav Chaus said Thursday. The attack came just hours after Donald Trump spoke with Russian President Vladimir Putin. According to Trump, Putin 'very strongly' said that Russia will retaliate for Ukraine's weekend drone attacks on Russian military airfields. Six more people were wounded in the attack and have been hospitalized, Chaus said. According to him, six Shahed-type drones struck residential areas of Pryluky early Thursday morning, causing severe damage to residential buildings. Hours later, seventeen people were wounded in a Russian drone strike on the eastern Ukrainian city of Kharkiv early Thursday, including children, a pregnant woman, and a 93-year-old woman, regional head Oleh Syniehubov wrote on Telegram. At around 1:05 a.m., Shahed-type drones struck two apartment buildings in the city's Slobidskyi district, causing fires and destroying several private vehicles. 'By launching attacks while people sleep in their homes, the enemy once again confirms its tactic of insidious terror,' Syniehubov wrote on Telegram.
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Well-known Trump critic David Jolly enters race for Florida governor
Former Rep. David Jolly has officially filed to run for governor of Florida in a race that still favors Republicans but remains wide open in the Democratic primary. Winning as a Democrat will be a long shot. Jolly, a former GOP, one-term representative from Pinellas County near Tampa, enters the race at a time when Florida has shifted decidedly right after years of topping the list of swing states. Making Jolly's candidacy especially difficult is that — even this early in the game — the governor's race is expected to be a three-way battle with both Republican and independent candidates. Jolly will additionally have to fend off perceptions that he's similar to Democrat Charlie Crist, another ex-Republican and independent who Gov. Ron DeSantis crushed in 2022. But he could also have a clear path to the nomination. So far, no Democrat aside from Jolly is clamoring to replace term-limited DeSantis. Other Democrats who openly expressed interest in running for governor a year ago have since petered out, underscoring just how dismal the political landscape is for Democrats after Trump won Florida by 13 points in 2024. Former Democratic state Sen. Jason Pizzo has also said he wants to run for governor. But he ended his time as leader of his chamber a month ago while declaring the party 'dead' in a dramatic exit at the Capitol in Tallahassee. He now plans to mount a run as an independent, a move numerous Democrats say will only serve as a spoiler to hand the race to Republicans. But Jolly is more optimistic about Democrats' chances, especially if the 2026 cycle is poised to be what he calls a 'change election.' His announcement Thursday came roughly five weeks after he revealed he was switching his no-party affiliation to Democrat and started a state political committee. He first expressed public interest in running in March, about a month after President Donald Trump endorsed Republican Rep. Byron Donalds for governor. Jolly has since traveled the state to do more than a dozen town halls and told POLITICO in an interview he would be foregoing a formal campaign kickoff event in favor of continuing the listening tour. 'They're making me a stronger, smarter advocate for change, and we're just going to keep doing that,' he said. 'This is a campaign that's going to look and feel different on the inside and out.' He said Florida's affordability crisis was his reason for running and blamed Republicans in Tallahassee for the fact that so many people at his town halls say they're anxious about how they'll afford to live in Florida. Democrats have an opportunity to show they'll fight for an economy that helps people, he said, predicting that Donalds or any other Republican would 'have a hard time defending the affordability crisis.' 'Republicans have created it,' he said. 'They're not doing anything about it, and we will. And that message in every corner of the state, in every conversation, is what resonates.' If elected governor, Jolly plans to push to expand Medicaid, a government health coverage program, to low-income Floridians and to 'dramatically reinvest' in public education. He also said he would push to reverse laws signed by DeSantis that shield the governor's travel and visitors' log from the public. One area where he does agree with DeSantis is that property tax laws need reform, though he dismissed the all-out tax repeal the governor is calling for, which would apply only to people's primary homes, saying the math still has to work to pay for safety and education services. He'd want to study it and bring in experts, he said. Jolly declined to share how much he has fundraised up to this point, but his committee will soon have to regularly publish donations publicly under state law. It's possible that he'll be able to tap into a national network of donors given that he frequently appeared on cable television, including formerly contributing regularly to MSNBC. In Florida, candidates are allowed to be directly involved in the operation and decision-making of political committees — which isn't the case for federal campaign committees. Jolly already has plans for the dollars that do come in, saying he thought it was up to statewide candidates like himself to 'bear responsibility for raising resources and deploying them towards voter registration.' The party is currently facing a 1.3 million active voter deficit compared with Republicans — one Democrats argue has been disproportionately affected by marking voters as inactive if they've abstained from voting in the last two election cycles. Donalds remains the only major candidate who has filed to run on the Republican side and has already raised $12 million into the first month of his campaign, though Florida first lady Casey DeSantis is also considering a bid. Donalds also has put together a team of officials who successfully helped Trump take back the White House, including pollster Tony Fabrizio and senior adviser Danielle Alvarez. In the coming months, Jolly plans to go to towns where 'Democrats haven't gone before,' including talking to agriculture communities about how they're being affected by Florida's strict immigration laws and to faith communities 'to talk about how Republican politicians have perverted policy issues around issues of faith and how I believe Democratic values better reflect the teachings of faith.' One of the biggest doubts Jolly will face is to make the case that he'll have a different outcome from Crist, the same politician who defeated him in his 2016 House race. Jolly admits he has changed his positions on issues like abortion, climate change and firearms, and said he doesn't try to argue — like Crist — that the party changed, but said he has changed his mind and thinks a lot of other voters have, too. His goal, he said, would be to create a wide coalition of supporters that appeal to independents and some Republicans because 'there are not enough Democratic votes to win the governorship.' 'We need a campaign, a candidate and a party that can win hearts and minds back,' he said. 'And that's our job.'
