Industrialisation of Scotland's wild heartland must be put to an end
It's time for a pause, to review the cumulative impacts, so we can all understand the consequence of the current free-for-all on the Scottish landscape. As a nation, we deserve better, and so do the communities and wild places affected.
TV documentaries regularly show us the scale of destruction human activities inflict on wild places across the world. These images are shocking and rightly provoke outrage. It is time to open our eyes to what is happening in our own country.
READ MORE: Donald Trump – peacemaker-in-chief or a global agitator?
As an example, one of our iconic landscapes in the northwest of Scotland is now the proposed site for wind turbines. Located beside Kinlochbervie, their shadow would be seen from Sandwood Bay to Quinag, changing forever an iconic landscape.
We are acutely aware that the communities in these areas need inward investment. They face declining populations, school closures and below-average incomes, and are in desperate need of jobs and investment. Wind farms offer these communities a carrot in the form of tiny percentages of their profit – is the legacy of irreparable damage they bring worth it?
Championing wild places
THE John Muir Trust is sounding the alarm on the cumulative impact of these projects, their unprecedented pace and scale, and asking for the disjointed planning system to be reviewed. Sadly, the planning processes for energy generation and transmission have no strategic guidance or connection beyond the economic drivers. The impact on the landscape is clear for all to see, and the cost-to-benefit ratio for local communities is questionable.
Formed more than 40 years ago to protect the wild qualities of the Knoydart peninsula from being destroyed, the Trust now advocates for areas throughout the UK where wild places, natural process and natural landscapes are valued for future generations.
READ MORE: Scottish attraction named among the best in the world by Tripadvisor
Our willingness and ability to protect these natural assets for future generations is under question. As a society, are we really destined to exploit for profit with no regard to the long-term impacts on our landscapes?
Speaking out
THERE'S no denying we are living in a climate emergency but Scotland's contribution to global emissions of carbon is low, our key contribution is leadership.
We are speaking out now because we believe that Scotland
can lead the way in demonstrating how to protect its wild places for future generations and to decarbonise its economy.
The impact of onshore wind farms, in less than 40 years, cannot be understated. There are now only three Munro summits left in Scotland from which you can experience a wild place and rugged landscape without seeing the creep of wind turbines, the scarring of vehicle access tracks and giant power lines.
Collective action
THE Trust seeks to bring together an alliance of existing groups – political parties from all sides, landowners, local councils and development trusts, environmental NGOs, community energy co-ops, crofters, and outdoor access groups – around a shared manifesto to deliver integrated planning and regulation for the protection of wild places, now and in future.
Our ambition is simple. Scotland's wild places are irreplaceable, and we must protect what remains.
READ MORE: Greens co-leader Patrick Harvie on 10 things that changed his life
This alliance will commit to finding ways to safeguard our best wild places from industrial-scale development that compromise the natural beauty, ecological integrity, and cultural heritage of these places.
We are calling for a 'time out' to allow for the implementation of an integrated approach to planning and consent. Crucially, this must link energy generation and transmission with independent oversight.
Scotland at a crossroads
SCOTLAND stands at a crossroads. The dual challenges of climate emergency and biodiversity loss require bold action – action that respects our landscapes and our identities. Wild places are the soul of nationhood, they are the engine room of ecological resilience and our tourism sector, and they are vital for carbon sequestration.
Scotland can show the world how to power a country without destroying its heritage – please join the fight to protect our wild places at johnmuirtrust.org
David Balharry is the CEO of the John Muir Trust
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
25 minutes ago
- Reuters
US could require up to $15,000 bonds for some tourist visas under pilot program
WASHINGTON, Aug 4 (Reuters) - The U.S. could require bonds of up to $15,000 for some tourist and business visas under a pilot program launching in two weeks, a government notice said on Monday, an effort that aims to crack down on visitors who overstay their visas. The program gives U.S. consular officers the discretion to impose bonds on visitors from countries with high rates of visa overstays, according to a Federal Register notice. Bonds could also be applied to people coming from countries where screening and vetting information is deemed insufficient, the notice said. President Donald Trump has made cracking down on illegal immigration a focus of his presidency, boosting resources to secure the border and arresting people in the U.S. illegally. He issued a travel ban in June that fully or partially blocks citizens of 19 nations from entering the U.S. on national security grounds. Trump's immigration policies have led some visitors to skip travel to the United States. Transatlantic airfares dropped to rates last seen before the COVID-19 pandemic in May and travel from Canada and Mexico to the U.S. fell by 20% year-over-year. Effective August 20, the new visa program will last for approximately a year, the government notice said. Consular officers will have three options for visa applicants subjected to the bonds: $5,000, $10,000 or $15,000, but will generally be expected to require at least $10,000, it said. A similar pilot program was launched in November 2020 during the last months of Trump's first term in office, but it was not fully implemented due to the drop in global travel associated with the pandemic, the notice said. The State Department was unable to estimate the number of visa applicants who could be affected by the change. Many of the countries targeted by Trump's travel ban also have high rates of visa overstays, including Chad, Eritrea, Haiti, Myanmar and Yemen. Numerous countries in Africa, including Burundi, Djibouti and Togo also had high overstay rates, according to U.S. Customs and Border Protection data from fiscal year 2023.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Edinburgh Castle closes due to high winds amid Storm Floris
Central and northern Scotland are also covered by a more serious amber warning from 10am to 10pm on Monday with gusts of 50 to 70 mph expected for many parts of the country and some regions facing winds up to 90 mph. Following the weather warning, visitors in the capital have been spotted being turned away from Edinburgh Castle by staff and police officers. READ MORE: Scottish pupils' exam results to be delayed due to Storm Floris, SQA says The popular tourist attraction has reportedly been closed until further notice amid safety concerns. The news follows the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo being cancelled on Sunday evening amid warnings caused by Storm Floris. It is the first weather-related cancellation in the event's 75-year history. Performances were previously cancelled during the pandemic in both 2020 and 2021. (Image: Tattoo) An emergency planning meeting had been called on Sunday afternoon to discuss the latest developments as the storm made its way across the Atlantic towards Scotland. The team had told the public to keep an eye out for updates as 'the safety and well-being of our audience members, performers, and staff remain our top priority'. In a statement posted after the meeting, Edinburgh Tattoo organisers stated on social media: 'We're sorry to announce that due to adverse weather warnings, we have made the difficult decision to cancel tomorrow's performance on 4 August at 9:30pm.
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Magical clifftop castle with stunning views and exquisite architecture an hour from Glasgow
The historic estate in Ayrshire was a favourite of former US president Dwight D Eisenhower, who used it as his Scottish holiday home. A Scottish clifftop retreat with history, mystery and panoramic sea views has been named one of the UK's top hidden gems by a travel expert. For families seeking a slice of fantasy on Scotland's west coast, few places feel more like a fairytale than Culzean Castle. Perched dramatically on a clifftop overlooking the Firth of Clyde, this historic estate in Ayrshire has long captured the imagination of visitors young and old, Glasgow Live reports. Just over an hour's drive from Glasgow, Culzean Castle was recently highlighted by travel expert Francesca Houldsworth as one of the UK's best hidden gems. Speaking to Verdant Leisure, she said the landmark was the first on her list of must-see destinations. 'On the west coast of Scotland, Culzean Castle is a must-see for architecture fanatics and historians alike,' Houldsworth said. 'Built in the 16th century, this property has a haunted past and is rumoured to be home to several paranormal residents. The castle is perched on the top of a cliff so not only boasts spectacular architecture, but stunning views and gardens.' The castle has earned praise from visitors and travel bodies alike. Last year, it was awarded five stars by Which? Magazine for its facilities and the accuracy of its promotional descriptions. Culzean Castle has a rich and fascinating history. Originally constructed in the late 18th century at the request of David Kennedy, 10th Earl of Cassilis, the estate later became a favourite of former US President and World War II general Dwight D. Eisenhower. He used the castle as a holiday home and was a regular visitor with family and friends. Now cared for by the National Trust for Scotland, the site is a major draw for both history enthusiasts and families looking for a memorable day out. Inside the castle, visitors can admire architectural highlights such as the sweeping Oval Staircase, while outside, the extensive grounds feature the beautifully maintained Walled Garden. In recent years, over £500,000 has been invested in improvements, enhancing its appeal as a family destination. The castle's Adventure Cove play area caters to younger children, while older kids can explore the Wild Woodland playpark. The wider country park spans 120 hectares of mixed woodland, home to Swan Pond, a herd of deer, and even llamas. There's also plenty to enjoy for those seeking a more relaxed experience. The Home Farm Kitchen offers hearty meals, and the Swan Pond Ice Cream Parlour is a favourite on warmer days. For those wanting to explore further, the nearby beach is perfect for rockpooling and enjoying the sea air. Accommodation options in the area let visitors extend their castle experience. Nearby Cloncaird Castle in Maybole, where Wowcher is offering deals on holiday cottages, provides a luxury base for exploring the region. For a more immersive stay, the National Trust also offers cottages on the Culzean Estate, including North Segganwell, once home to an estate worker, and the picturesque North Firbank.
