Was he the greatest? Debate on as SA footy legend dies
There's no solution to who is SA's best Australian rules player, but arguments settled on two: Port Adelaide great Russell Ebert, or North Adelaide legend Barrie Robran.
And despite Ebert's astonishing four Magarey Medals, many plump for Robran, who won the SANFL medal three times.
"Robran was universally regarded across South Australia as the finest footballer the state has produced in its history across the past 150 years," an AFL statement said.
The chief of his SANFL club North Adelaide, Craig Burton, had no doubt, extending the Robran-Ebert debate to a national one.
"We think he's number one, the greatest ever footballer," Burton said.
"You'll get an argument from people in Victoria … but he was definitely right up there."
The SANFL didn't take sides in its tribute, referring to the Roosters great as "among" the state's players ever.
"Barrie was a champion of our game and has left an indelible mark on football in South Australia through his on-field brilliance," SANFL president Rob Kerin said.
Robran was an inaugural member of the Australian Football Hall of Fame in 1996 and the first South Australian honoured with "legend'' status, in 2001.
He dominated the SANFL from his debut in 1967 until retirement in 1980, playing 201 games for North Adelaide. He also played 17 state games and captained SA.
A seven-time consecutive club best-and-fairest and dual premiership player at North, Robran's career stalled in 1974 when, playing for SA, he injured a knee in a clash with Victoria's Leigh Matthews.
"As the years have gone by I've often thought: 'Had that have not happened …'," Robran had said.
"It probably cost me about 150 league games here in South Australia because I was 26 when that happened.
"My ambition in football was always to play until I was 40 at some appropriate level where I could play and not embarrass myself."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
2 minutes ago
- Perth Now
WA teen Hannah Slyth already world jnr squash champs veteran
At just 18, and still in school, Perth's Hannah Slyth is a veteran competitor at world junior squash championships. She's already experienced the best in international junior squash in Houston (2024) and Melbourne (2023), but this year's championships in Cairo, Egypt, will be her swansong in the event; after this year, the Blue Gum Squash Club product will be too old for the junior circuit. Slyth, who took up the sport aged nine, is the only West Aussie in the 12-strong Australian team for Cairo and told Squash Australia's website she'll be aiming for her best finish yet in the individual competition and to her help the team also improve on previous championship placings. Over the past decades, the honour roll for both boys' and girls' events at the junior championships includes many champions who progressed to reach the top in the professional game – such as Pakistan's Jansher Khan, who won the World Open a record eight times and didn't lose a pro match from 1990-1996; Malaysia's Nicol David, also an eight-time World Open winner and Australians Sarah Fitzgerald and Rachael Grinham, who both hit No.1 in the world. Grinham, at 48, is still playing regularly on the pro circuit. After graduating Year 12 (she's studying PE), Slyth's focus will shift to more tournament play, interstate and internationally, to work on her world ranking, currently 459. Meanwhile Squash WA is gearing up to host the Australian Masters Championships, with hundreds of competitors from around the country and region expected to play in individual and team events at Squashworld Mirrabooka from September 2-13. This is only the entrée to an even bigger coup for squash locally; next year the state will host the 2026 World Masters Championships from August 30 – September 6, with up to 1200 overseas players, coaches and fans expected to attend. It's the first time since 2001 Australia has hosted the championships. As well as matches on the Mirrabooka courts and the Belmont State Squash Centre, for the first time in WA an all-glass portable court will be used to bring finals action to spectators. The World Junior Squash Championships is in Cairo from July 21 to August 1.
Perth Now
32 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Albanese to cap China trip with panda diplomacy
Pandas and bionic ears are on Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's agenda as his six-day tour of China reaches its final leg. Mr Albanese touched down in Chengdu, in China's southwest on Wednesday afternoon, where he announced the Sichuan capital would be given hosting rights to an Australian Open wildcard play-off tournament for a second year running. In the sweltering 37C heat, the prime minister turned down the offer of a hit on centre court, instead hailing the role of sport in boosting people-to-people and cultural links between Australia and China. "I know that my dear friend (former professional tennis player) Glenn Busby comes here and coaches and spends a lot of time here each year, and he tells me that China will dominate the sport in the years to come," he said. Chengdu, a provincial hub home to 21 million residents, is best known outside of China as the home of giant pandas. Mr Albanese will visit a breeding research centre at the forefront of efforts to save the species from extinction. As well as a beloved cultural icon, pandas are a central part of China's efforts to exert soft power in the world. In a meeting with local party secretary Wang Xiaohui, Mr Albanese said pandas "have been such an important feature" of building positive relations between Australia and China. He noted the two new pandas who were loaned to Adelaide Zoo in 2024 in the latest example of panda diplomacy. "I thank this province for our two newest guests who have been so well received," he said. But Chengdu has another, arguably more impactful, connection to Australia. Cochlear, the Australian hearing device company, bases a manufacturing and research plant in the city, which the prime minister will visit on Thursday. More than 50,000 Chinese patients have had hearing loss restored by a Cochlear device, making it one of the company's largest markets. But with a population of 1.4 billion, there is plenty of scope for expansion "Chengdu is home to inspiring examples of world-leading Australian and Chinese co-operation in science, technology, research and education," Mr Albanese will say at a medtech luncheon. Both governments had a responsibility to invest in research and an opportunity to deepen co-operation in medical manufacturing, he will say. "This also depends on continuing to break down barriers by supporting the free and fair trade that enables Australian medtech companies to access the market here in China."
Perth Now
32 minutes ago
- Perth Now
A protester, a crash and a near-miss for Jayco at Tour
It was meant to be a quiet day before the Tour de France hits the high mountains -- yet it turned into anything but as leader Tadej Pogacar crashed and Australian team Jayco AlUla missed out agonisingly on victory as a protester tried to disrupt the sprint finale. Pogacar took a heavy tumble with four kilometres left of the dramatic 11th stage on Wednesday, and was grateful that Tour honour was upheld when, up ahead, the peloton eased up, allowing the under-pressure champion, who'd already lost about 20 seconds, to rejoin. Meanwhile, a thrilling duel between Norway's Jonas Abrahamsen and Jayco's Swiss champion Mauro Schmid was nearly compromised by the protester, in a T-shirt reading "Israel out of the Tour" and waving a Palestinian scarf, who burst on the course 50m from the line. Eventually, as a security officer did a nifty job in tackling the invader, Schmid, who'd been on course to win the Australian team's first stage of the 2025 Tour, got pipped by half a wheel by Uno-X Mobility's Abrahamsen, who completed a fabulous comeback after a recent accident. In the day's central drama, Irishman Ben Healy, while retaining the leader's yellow jersey, agreed with two-time Tour champion Jonas Vingegaard, Pogacar's main rival for the title, that the peloton should all knock off the pace after his crash. Pogacar had gone down heavily into a kerb when Tobias Johannessen cut across him at speed, clipping wheels. The Norwegian rider later apologised, revealing that he had later received hate messages on social media. Pogacar quickly remounted, after some help at roadside, and was left hugely thankful for the gesture. "I'm quite okay, a bit beaten up, but we've been through worse days," the UAE Team Emirates-XRG leader said. "Thanks to the peloton in front, they actually waited. They could have taken time. Really big respect to everybody in front. Thanks for your support, guys." In the GC, Healy remains 29 seconds clear of Pogacar, with Olympic champ Remco Evenepoel third 1:29 down on the Irishman and Vingegaard fourth at 1:46. All, though, is expected to change on Thursday's stage 12 with the race's first Pyrenean high-mountain showdown with a summit finish on the famed Hautacam. Only then will it be seen if Pogacar, who's so far looked untouchable, has endured any lasting effects from his spill. Abrahamsen's victory was his reward for attacking from the very start of the stage, a 156.8km loop around Toulouse. It ended with him and Schmid, who'd surged from the breakaway, nearly getting caught by a charging Mathieu van der Poel, who fell just short in third place. "I broke my collarbone four weeks ago. I cried at the hospital because I thought I wouldn't make it to the Tour de France," the emotional Abrahamsen explained after his maiden Grand Tour win. "I hoped, and every day I did everything I could to come back. To stand here in the Tour de France and to have won a stage is amazing."
