‘Devoid of any meaning': Why experts call the Paris AI Action Summit a ‘missed opportunity'
The Paris Artificial Intelligence (AI) Action Summit closed this week with a declaration that outlined policies for ensuring AI is 'open, inclusive, transparent, ethical, safe, secure and trustworthy'.
Some 60 countries signed the declaration but notably the United Kingdom and the United States did not.
The UK cited national security concerns as its reason while the US did not specify exactly why it did not sign the doctrine but the country's vice president, JD Vance, warned delegates in Paris that too much regulation would stifle innovation.
However, experts at the summit told Euronews Next that the declaration did not go far enough to address the possible risks and harms caused by AI.
Need for addressing risks and inequities
'I think that the communique doesn't adequately speak to the sort of real-world risks and harms,' said David Leslie, director of ethics and responsible innovation research at The Alan Turing Institute.
Some of the most pressing risks of AI include bias, cybersecurity, and data privacy issues.
'Action obviously means forward action and progressive action in terms of advancing opportunities for growth and economic benefit,' he told Euronews Next.
'But action also has to do with redressing the set of existing risks and harms that over the last couple of years, and especially with the scaling of the production and user-generated AI systems, has become sort of obvious to researchers in the field,' he added.
The AI summit comes as tech companies race to release AI models with competition heating up across the globe.
The latest release by China-based company DeepSeek a month ago challenged the status quo of Western tech companies dominating the market with AI models that are more expensive to train.
Governments are also ensuring they do not get left behind in the AI race. The newly installed Trump administration in January rescinded previous initiatives under the former government that prioritised AI safety, citing them as obstacles to US innovation.
Another approach to the summit that did not go far enough was 'addressing the ecosystem level inequities,' Leslie said, adding that they were 'real barriers to the advancement of inclusive and equitable innovation'.
He argued that having globally equitable structures for trade between larger tech companies and small and medium-sized countries, especially in the Global South, and access to compute or digital infrastructures, were discussions that could have been spoken more about at the summit.
Anthropic's CEO and co-founder Dario Amodei said in a statement that he was disappointed the summit did not do more to address the risks of artificial general intelligence (AGI) and called it a 'missed opportunity'.
'Greater focus and urgency is needed on several topics given the pace at which the technology is progressing,' Amodei said in a statement shared with Euronews Next.
'The need for democracies to keep the lead, the risks of AI, and the economic transitions that are fast approaching—these should all be central features of the next summit'.
Open for AI business
Unlike the previous AI summits held in the United Kingdom and in South Korea, which focused more on the potential harms and risks of AI, France made its intentions clear that it was open for business.
The Paris summit resembled more of a tech fair or even festival atmosphere with many fancy corporate side events and even a DJ closing the first day at the Grand Palais, which followed French President Emmanuel Macron telling the audience 'I have a good friend in the other part of the ocean saying 'drill, baby, drill',' referring to his US counterpart.
'Here there is no need to drill. It's 'plug, baby, plug'. Electricity is available, you can plug [it in], it's ready,' Macron added.
But while strong statements were echoed, a lot of the words from the declaration were just that, experts say.
'Being familiar with the diplomatic aspect of these things, I know that when this many countries get together to draft a text, identifying the smallest common denominator often leads to a very weak statement, or even platitudes,' said Jessica Galissaire, studies and partnership manager at the France-based Renaissance Numerique think tank.
'The use of words like 'sustainable' and 'inclusive' are devoid of any meaning if we don't have a shared understanding of what they mean - which I'm not sure we do at such a high level,' she told Euronews Next.
'In the end, on the specific topic of ensuring AI developments respect fundamental rights and freedoms, signatories just committed to talking more…so much for an AI 'Action' Summit,' she added.
However, Galissaire said she was more positive about the environmental pledge and looked forward to seeing the results of a proposed observatory to asses AI's energy impact with the International Energy Agency (IEA).
Max Tegmark, the MIT physicist who is the founder and president of the Future of Life Institute, also said he was disappointed in the outcomes of the summit, saying the declaration was weak and did not address security threats.
'Given the urgency of the situation, appeasing words that lack substance represent a step backwards for international and technical collaboration, and this weakness led countries not to sign,' he said in a statement.
'As AI continues to soar ahead, the next summit must reset the conversation, and embolden decisive action to ensure secure, controllable and beneficial AI," he added.
The next AI summit will be held in India, which jointly hosted the Paris summit with France. It is unclear what the topics of the next AI summit will tackle.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
34 minutes ago
- France 24
Russia cuts interest rates from two-decade high as economy slows
Russia's economy has been marked by volatility since it launched its full-scale military offensive on Ukraine in 2022, with growth now slowing after a period of what officials called "overheating". The Kremlin has massively ramped up military spending to support the campaign, pouring funds into weapons production and the army -- outlays which have helped secure strong growth despite a barrage of Western sanctions. "The Russian economy is gradually returning to a balanced growth path," the bank said in a statement, acknowledging the slowdown. Inflation is still running above 10 percent, though it noted that price "pressures" were "continuing to decline." The bank had come under increasing political pressure this year to cut interest rates, which businesses said was throttling the economy and killing investment. Friday's decision was the first time the central bank has moved to cut rates since September 2022. It warned that despite the one percentage-point cut, "monetary policy will remain tight for a long period."
LeMonde
2 hours ago
- LeMonde
Russia pummels Kyiv in deadly attack after Putin retaliation vow
Moscow launched dozens of missiles and hundreds of drones at Ukraine early on Friday, June 6, killing at least three people in Kyiv, after President Vladimir Putin vowed retaliation for an audacious Ukrainian attack on Russian airbases. Agence France-Presse (AFP) journalists heard air raid sirens and explosions ring out in Kyiv throughout the night as Ukrainian air defense batteries intercepted waves of Russian drones and missiles. Following the attack, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky called on allies to "decisively" ramp up pressure on Russia to halt its invasion, which has left tens of thousands dead after more than three years of brutal and costly fighting. One image published by the head of Zelensky's office showed a children's playground scattered with rubble and shards of glass. Zelensky said at least three people had been killed in the capital, and that Russia had targeted nine regions of Ukraine, including Lviv and Volyn in the west, which border EU and NATO member Poland. 'Act decisively' "If someone does not put pressure and gives the war more time to take lives, they are complicit and responsible. We need to act decisively," Zelensky wrote on social media. Deadly attacks have escalated in recent weeks even as the two sides hold talks aimed at ending the conflict triggered by Russia's February 2022 invasion. Cities and villages have been destroyed across eastern Ukraine and millions have been forced to flee their homes, with Russia's forces controlling around one fifth of Ukraine's territory. The Ukrainian air force said Friday's barrage consisted of 45 missiles and 407 drones. Russian aerial assaults have become larger in recent weeks as concerns build over Ukraine's strained air defense capacity. Putin had earlier this week told US President Donald Trump he would retaliate over Sunday's Ukrainian drone attack, which damaged nuclear-capable military planes at Russian air bases, including thousands of kilometres behind the front lines in Siberia. The brazen operation, 18 months in the planning, saw Kyiv smuggle more than 100 small drones into Russia, park them near Russian air bases and unleash them in a coordinated attack. Retaliation The Kremlin said Thursday it would choose "how and when" to respond. Putin has repeatedly rejected a ceasefire, and Russian negotiators have issued a host of sweeping demands on Ukraine if it wants to halt the fighting. They include completely pulling troops out of four regions claimed by Russia, but which its army does not fully control; an end to Western military support; and a ban on Ukraine joining NATO, as well as any Western military contingents or hardware being based in the country. The overnight attack left multiple fires burning in various neighborhoods of the capital, and also damaged train tracks in the surrounding Kyiv region, leading to lengthy delays, the national railway operator said. Three first responders from the state emergency service were killed in Kyiv, Interior Minister Igor Klymenko said. Kyiv's mayor said earlier that four were killed in the capital. "They worked under fire to help people. Another nine rescuers were wounded. Some of them are seriously injured, and doctors are fighting for their lives," Klymenko wrote on social media. Several strikes also hit the city of Lutsk and the Ternopil region in western Ukraine. "Today, the enemy carried out the most massive air attack on our region to date," said Ternopil's regional military administration chief, Vyacheslav Negoda. At least 49 people were wounded in total, Zelensky said. Moscow said Ukrainian strikes overnight on Russia wounded three people in the western Tula region, while Kyiv claimed to have staged successful attacks on two airfields deep inside Russian territory. Footage shared on social media showed a large fire and smoke billowing into the air at an oil facility that serves a military site in Russia's Saratov region, which has been frequently targeted. The Russian Defense Ministry said it downed 174 Ukrainian drones overnight. Ten downed drones were headed for the Russian capital, according to Moscow Mayor Sergei Sobyanin.
Euronews
2 hours ago
- Euronews
EU deplores US sanctions on ICC judges, including Slovenian
The European Union has roundly deplored the United States for sanctioning four judges of the International Criminal Court (ICC), including one citizen from the bloc, Slovenia's Beti Hohler, further deepening the divide between transatlantic allies. The sanctions, which also target nationals from Benin, Uganda and Peru, were announced on Thursday by US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who said the decision was based on the court's "baseless and politicised" investigations of war crimes allegedly committed by US forces in Afghanistan and Israel in the Gaza Strip. The second probe led to arrest warrants on Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Natayanhu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant. Judge Hohler ruled in favour of the orders. As a result of the measures, the four judges will be unable to access their property and assets on US soil and will be blocked from making transactions with American entities. The bans risk hindering the magistrates' ability to perform their day-to-day work. "We call on our allies to stand with us against this disgraceful attack," Rubio said. Rubio's call was met with the opposite reaction: emphatic support for the Hague-based tribunal and forceful rejection of the sanctions. "The ICC holds perpetrators of the world's gravest crimes to account & gives victims a voice. It must be free to act without pressure," said Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission. "We will always stand for global justice & the respect of international law." António Costa, the president of the European Council, voiced a similar message. "The EU strongly supports the International Criminal Court, a cornerstone of international justice," Costa wrote on social media. The ICC "does not stand against nations—it stands against impunity. We must protect its independence and integrity. The rule of law must prevail over the rule of power." The Netherlands, which serves as the host country for the ICC, also expressed strong condemnation, stressing the tribunal's work must remain "as unhindered as possible". "The Netherlands disapproves of the new sanctions against officials of the International Criminal Court," said Dutch Foreign Minister Caspar Veldkamp. "Independent international courts and tribunals must be able to carry out their work without hindrance. We stand firmly behind the Court." Rejecting outside "pressure on judicial institutions", the Slovenian government said it would provide Judge Beti Hohler with "all necessary support in the performance of her mandate in the current situation". The country called on Brussels to immediately activate the so-called blocking statute, a decades-long regulation meant to protect EU individuals and companies from the extraterritorial application of sanctions by non-EU countries. The law was introduced in reaction to the sanctions that Washington introduced in 1996 against Cuba, Iran and Libya, which had ripple effects on European operators that engaged in legitimate trade with the three countries, particularly Cuba. The blocking statute came back to the fore in 2018, when the first Donald Trump administration withdrew from the Iran nuclear deal, reintroduced sanctions that had been previously lifted and threatened to punish companies for doing business with Tehran, regardless of their geographic location or ownership. Although Brussels tried to mitigate the damaging impact of these secondary sanctions, many European companies voluntarily cut off relations with Iran out of fear of losing access to America's highly profitable, dollar-based market. Neither von der Leyen nor Costa spoke about the statute in their responses. In a statement, the ICC insisted it would "continue its work undeterred, in strict accordance with the Rome Statute and the principles of fairness and due process". "Targeting those working for accountability does nothing to help civilians trapped in conflict. It only emboldens those who believe they can act with impunity," it said. "These sanctions are not only directed at designated individuals, they also target all those who support the Court, including nationals and corporate entities of States Parties. They are aimed against innocent victims in all situations before the Court." The US, which is not a party to the 1998 Rome Statute, has long had tense relations with the ICC, viewing with suspicion its ability to conduct probes into nationals around the world. The arrest warrant against Netanyahu was met with bipartisan condemnation in Washington and prompted a renewed assault by the Trump administration. Earlier this year, Hungary openly defied the ICC by ignoring the warrant and inviting Netanyahu to Budapest. Hungary later announced its intention to withdraw from the Rome Statute, becoming the first member state to do so. Russia launched a large-scale missile and drone attack on Ukrainian cities overnight on Friday, killing at least five people and injuring more than 70. According to Ukraine's Air Force spokesperson Yuri Ihnat, Kyiv forces intercepted 368 out of 407 drones and shot down 36 out of 45 missiles, including four out of six ballistic Iskander missiles launched by Russia. Ukraine's Air Forces activated the air raid alerts in all Ukrainian regions last night, warning people that multiple Russian bombers had taken off for the attack. Many people proceeded to bomb shelters with the warning. Ukraine's capital Kyiv was hit the hardest. The city Mayor Vitali Klitschko said search and rescue operations were under way at several locations. Multiple explosions were heard in Kyiv overnight, where falling debris sparked fires across several districts as air defence systems attempted to intercept incoming targets, said Tymur Tkachenko, head of the Kyiv City Administration. 'Our air defence crews are doing everything possible. But we must protect one another — stay safe,' Tkachenko wrote on Telegram. Authorities reported damage in several districts, and rescue workers were responding at multiple locations. They urged residents to seek shelter. In Solomyanskyi district, a fire broke out on the 11th floor of a 16-story residential building. Emergency services evacuated three people from the apartment, and rescue operations were ongoing. Another fire broke out in a metal warehouse. Tkachenko said the metro tracks between two stations in Kyiv were damaged in the attack, but no fire or injuries occurred. In the northern Chernihiv region, a Shahed drone exploded near an apartment building, shattering windows and doors, according to regional military administration chief Dmytro Bryzhynskyi. He added that explosions from ballistic missiles were also recorded on the outskirts of the city. The nighttime attack came hours after US President Donald Trump said it might be better to let Ukraine and Russia 'fight for a while' before pulling them apart and pursuing peace, in comments that were a remarkable detour from Trump's often-stated appeals to stop the three-year war. Trump spoke as he met with Germany's new Chancellor Friedrich Merz, who appealed to him as the 'key person in the world' who could halt the bloodshed by pressuring Russian President Vladimir Putin. Trump this week spoke on the phone with Putin, who vowed to respond "very strongly" to Ukraine's daring drone attacks on Russian military airfields that had taken place on Sunday.
