BBC accused of 'North Korean-style censorship' in royal coverage
Trooping the Colour – the King's annual birthday parade – was covered live by the BBC at the weekend.
But Graham Smith, CEO of Republic, has written to the boss of the events team at BBC Studios Productions accusing the broadcaster of 'censoring and erasing' the presence of 'highly visible' protests against the monarchy.
It is the first time Republic has approached the factual entertainment and events team about its coverage and has threatened to go to people 'higher up in the BBC' if there is no response.
READ MORE: Pete Wishart calls for Labour Government not to remove whip from MPs
Smith – who says he has had several meetings with the BBC about their news coverage – told The National the broadcaster was being 'dishonest' in painting a picture of a 'devoted nation fawning over the royals'.
'Generally our focus has been on their news coverage [so far], but these big events are not done by their news teams, it's done by a separate events team,' he said.
'It's only been the last couple of years that we've been at those events, and we've started to notice […] how they are deliberately editing things out.
'Some of the commentary from people like Clare Balding at the weekend just presents this picture of a devoted nation fawning over the royals. It's not just about them cutting us out, it's about them misrepresenting the crowds, suggesting it's much larger than it is and suggesting it's royalists.'
He went on: 'There's a bit where they are showing the carriages coming down the Mall and you can see the crowds at the barriers, and then we can see – because we know what we're looking for – we can see where we are and they zoom in and you can just about see some feet and a bit of yellow [the colour Republic uses].
(Image: Aaron Chown) 'They should be covering it as it is, not doing the royals' job as a press office.
'This is why we say it's like North Korea, it's such a dishonest representation of what is going on and how people feel about it.'
At the start of last year, a Savanta poll showed support for the monarchy had fallen to just 48%.
A YouGov poll that followed a few months later showed support for the monarchy in Scotland at 50% compared to 34% backing a republic.
Smith cited how a few years ago, David Dimbleby revealed the level of control exerted by the royal family over broadcasters' rights for the Queen's funeral.
He told the Henley Book Festival that as he broadcast from St George's Chapel in Windsor the BBC was receiving emails 'almost simultaneously' from palace officials, dictating which clips of footage could not be shown in any subsequent broadcast.
'There was this complete list of things that no broadcaster could show because the copyright belongs to Buckingham Palace. I think that's wrong, just wrong,' he said.
READ MORE: BBC chief responds to landmark report exposing bias on Gaza
The letter to Hannah Wyatt, managing director of factual entertainment and events at BBC Studios, claims the BBC's coverage of Trooping the Colour 'completely ignored' the protests held by Republic, even when they could be heard in the background.
'It is not going too far to suggest that you have chosen a North Korean style of coverage which censors and erases the presence of noisy, growing and highly visible protests against the monarchy,' the letter says.
'Aerial shots of the crowd showed numbers are falling, with huge swathes of empty space outside the palace and along the Mall.
'Yet still you convey a misleading image of a packed Mall full of fawning royalists, while your commentary included no input from critics of the institution.
'These protests will get bigger and louder, and they will not stop. So, I'm asking that we meet to discuss these concerns and hopefully convey to you the seriousness of this issue.'
Smith said there has been a 'consistent pattern' at the BBC of editing out signs of opposition to the monarchy, as he claimed similar incidents had occurred the coronation and Commonwealth Day.
The BBC has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Gavin and Stacey star Larry Lamb admits 'we knew it was a hit from Day One'
The 'nation's favourite dad' as Mick Shipman, Larry Lamb says his role in the series has made him a 'better person' but there is no chance of a date with Pam in real life Larry Lamb laughs out loud when asked if he could have a real life romance with his 'TV wife' Alison Steadman. In ' Gavin and Stacey ', his character Mick Shipman, the 'nation's favourite dad', is married to Pam, played by Steadman. Their relationship was loved by millions of fans; the Gavin and Stacey finale was seen by almost 20m last Christmas, making it one of the most watched scripted TV shows of the century. But Larry assures fans on his nationwide book tour that their love affair comes from the 'wonderful' script. Asked if they could get together if they were both single, he says: "Hang on a minute, I have to be careful, we have the Daily Mirror in the room." The veteran actor, star of TV and Hollywood films, tells a sell-out crowd that he would never name his favourite leading lady. And he jokes that there is not a 'cat in hell's chance' of a dalliance with Steadman. "The reason it works is because it's written that way," he explained."It's a brilliant creative relationship on screen. "We live ten minutes away from each other, but we never see each other. If it's her birthday, I may send a flower. You know what I mean? It is a really wonderful relationship playing those two characters. But Alison is nothing like Pam in real life. She's a very, very private person, not at all like that character. And I'm not nice." Larry, 77, has just written his first novel, 'All Wrapped Up', based on his own experiences on a movie set, and he talks about that and his colourful life off screen at Newcastle's Tyneside cinema. He loves the region and had a role in the 1996 BBC series 'Our Friends in the North'. His 50-year career includes three Superman movies with Christopher Reeve, the first filmed in 1977, villain Archie Mitchell in EastEnders (2008/9) and ' I'm a Celebrity ' nine years ago. There were also TV series like Triangle, Minder, and Lovejoy. He revealed that the entire cast of 'Gavin and Stacey' knew they were onto a winner from their first day together, at a first read through of the script back in 2006. He recalled: "Everybody knew when we read it for the first time; it is the day when you will gather in some room somewhere, usually in Soho, that's when you kind of get a feeling of how it's going to work. "You meet the people in person and you get a feel for the first production of it. Clearly was something that really, really worked and we all got that. Everyone knew it." The show missed out on the BAFTA 'Memorable Moment' award this year Larry 'wrote a little speech' on behalf of the cast and crew. "The last line was that in writing Gavin and Stacey, Ruth Jones and James Corden had created a family that everyone could be a part of forever," he said. "For that I thanked them from the bottom of my heart. That's really the way I felt, and I know the way we all felt. It was this super special thing, and they finished it in a way that satisfied everybody." For his novel, Larry drew on his experiences filming in the Dominican Republic, in the 1985 mini-series 'The Life of Christopher Columbus' with Faye Dunaway and hellraiser Oliver Reed. "The one thing I learned about filming in the Caribbean is forget it, don't go anywhere near it," he said. "It is absolutely diabolical. I was playing a Spanish conquistador. I've got a great big bronze helmet on. I've got a big breastplate, I've got a kilt on, great big tights, it's insane. On a hot horse all day long; I would say, no don't do it." But he loved the camaraderie of the set, a feeling of belonging which he did not have in his troubled childhood in Edmonton, London. The British actor Jeremy Brett helped Larry land his big break on Broadway. Brett was offered a role with a Northern Irish accent. Larry, a complete novice, had just given up a highly paid job in Canada to get into acting. But he had lived in Ireland and is a gifted mimic. "So I went to New York, I did an audition and finished up in a big Broadway show, 20 months after I had become an actor," he said. "Fluke, fluke, fluke, Broadway. It went quite well, but it was so nerve wracking." He returned to the UK in 1977 to film the first of the Superman movies with Christopher Reeve. He recalls the set at Shepperton Studios with hidden script devices for Brando. "They had big idiot boards up on the walls for his lines," he said. "I walked onto the set and they were left up on the wall, you know, and I still can't believe it. I was a new boy on the block. I didn't have anything to say. You just move at the right time, distanced from the main roles. I would leave to get the bus and there was a long line of chauffeur driven cars ready to take all the stars home. "One night, there was Gene Hackman walking towards me. I introduced myself to him, he was nice. It was a huge production. There was one guy whose only task seemed to be trimming the director's cigars. I thought: 'that's the job I'd like." He loved playing the bad guy in EastEnders. "Villains are much easier," he told the Mirror as he signed copies of his book for fans. "With comedy, everything has to be spot on." Off screen, he has had a complicated love life. At 21, he was already married and living in London; after the split, there came a marriage to an American nurse; when that marriage broke up, he was involved with a former nun. He then fell in love and married the mother of his son, George Lamb; there were dalliances with Lady Colin Campbell, and an Iberia airline stewardess. At the end of 'I'm a Celebrity' in 2016, he was seen with former partner Marie Hugo, the artist and great granddaughter of the Les Miserables author Victor Hugo. They also parted and he spoke of living alone this year. Now, he wants to tell how playing Mick Shipman changed his outlook on life, a follow up to his 2011 memoir 'Mummy's Boy'. "The point where Gavin and Stacey came into my life, that's what I think I'm going to be writing about next," he said. "Touching on this extraordinary career, but just about me and Mick. I feel there's something else in me that touches on the relationship between me and Mick. I'm a much better person for having played him. A lot of Mick has come though in me. "I am writing poems about the end of life; you get into your 70s, there is a door, it says 'Way Out'. And it fascinates me. It is easier to deal with if I am writing about it and thinking about it and not making light of it, just confronting it. Because we don't confront it here. "I've had a house in Normandy for years and am very involved with local people there. Every year, there is Saint's Day. And so the tradition is everybody goes to the graveyard. There was an old lady there, she was 97, 98 and she said: 'I really didn't want to be buried next to him. I hated him.' She was moving her grave. They are much more realistic about death over there. "And my way of looking about it is to write about it." At the end of the night, he tells me that has no regrets. "That is what I have loved about looking back and reflecting on life," he said. "Your realise there is no point in having regrets." * All Wrapped Up, by Softwood Books, is available now, RRP £9.99. To purchase the book, or tickets to Larry's other tour dates, go to larrylambofficial.
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Gavin and Stacey star Ruth Jones reveals 26-year marriage to producer husband is over – and he's already moved on
The popular BBC sitcom star has separated from her other half final scene Gavin and Stacey star Ruth Jones reveals 26-year marriage to producer husband is over – and he's already moved on Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) GAVIN and Stacey star Ruth Jones has revealed she's split from her husband of 26 years. The actress and writer quietly separated from producer David Peet 18 months ago. Sign up for the Entertainment newsletter Sign up 3 Ruth Jones with her now estranged husband David Peet Credit: Rex 3 The sitcom star won a Bafta for her role as Nessa in Gavin and Stacey Credit: Getty He is now living in Canada where he has moved on with someone new. In a statement, the couple said: "We amicably went our separate ways 18 months ago and are now legally separated. We remain good friends. "Since our separation, Ruth is living in London and David is living in Canada, where he is in a new relationship." Ruth was a step-mum to David's three children from a previous marriage. They met while filming a BBC pilot comedy in the 1990s. David was married at the time. Ruth later said: "Affairs cause a lot of pain; they're not something one aspires to do. "You don't aspire to cause pain to people in their life." Ruth is best known for co-creating and starring in Gavin & Stacey alongside James Corden. She recently won a TV BAFTA for her role as Nessa Jenkins. The long-running comedy series aired its finale on Christmas Day 2024. Ruth Jones brings back Gavin and Stacey's Nessa one last time as she picks up comedy TV BAFTA Taking home the gong for Female Performance in a Comedy, she brought back Nessa for a final goodbye on stage, pretending to be the character as she picked up the award before an emotional thank you gave way. But speaking after picking up the Bafta statue, Ruth has teased that she and James Corden could be set to work on something new together. She said: 'I love working with James Corden, I really do, and I hope that we will carry on working together. 'I think we will. We will, because we just both, like, sort of sitting in a room together. We do a lot of napping, but we do write as well when we get going and, yeah, I just love working with him.'
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
Gavin and Stacey star Ruth Jones splits with husband
Ruth Jones, known for her role as Nessa on the popular BBC show, has said she and her producer husband David Peet have legally separated. Jones, who co-created Gavin and Stacey with friend James Corden, married in 1999. Despite the split, they "remain good friends", the couple said in a statement. Ruth Jones played Nessa in Gavin and Stacey (Image: Ian West/PA Wire) Gavin and Stacey's Ruth Jones announces split with husband The couple told the PA news agency: 'We amicably went our separate ways 18 months ago and are now legally separated. We remain good friends. 'Since our separation, Ruth is living in London and David is living in Canada, where he is in a new relationship.' Jones married Peet, a television and radio producer, in 1999. She is a stepmother to three children from his previous marriage. The Mirror reported that the pair met when she was working on a BBC Radio Wales series. Who is Ruth Jones? Ruth Jones rose to fame as the co-writer and star of Gavin and Stacey. The BBC sitcom first aired in 2007 and tells the story of two families from Billericay in Essex and Barry in the Vale of Glamorgan, Wales. Jones played Vanessa 'Nessa' Jenkins in three series and three Christmas specials. The show's finale episode, which aired on Christmas Day last year, saw Jones's character Nessa marry Neil 'Smithy' Smith, played by fellow co-writer and close friend James Corden. At this year's TV Baftas, Jones won the best female performance in a comedy for her role in Gavin and Stacey. Jones has also appeared in ITV drama Fat Friends, BBC sketch show Little Britain, BBC sitcom Saxondale, and BBC black comedy Nighty Night. Other roles include playing Carry On star Hattie Jacques in a BBC biopic. In 2014, Jones was made a Member Of The Order Of The British Empire (MBE) in the New Year Honours for her services to entertainment. Ruth Jones to feature in new BBC series It was recently revealed that Jones has landed a role in a new BBC Drama series, which is currently being filmed in Wales. Jones will play Mrs Bennet in an adaptation of Janice Hadlow's novel The Other Bennet Sister for BBC One and BBC iPlayer. She will be joined in the series by the likes of Richard E. Grant (Saltburn, Star Wars: Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker, Loki), Indira Varma (Obi-Wan Kenobi, Luther, The Night Manager) and Ella Bruccoleri (Call the Midwife, Bridgerton). Recommended reading: Filming for the 10-part series is already underway. Director of BBC Drama, Lindsay Salt, said: "It's a joy to see cameras rolling on our vibrant, witty and clever new take on Jane Austen's beloved world. "With a pitch perfect cast led by Ella, Ruth and Richard, The Other Bennet Sister will be an irresistible treat for viewers when it launches on the BBC next year."
