NEPRA issues notice to K-Electric over load-shedding
Prior approval to NEPRA K-electric consumer may seen a huge relief over electricity bills. PHOTO: FILE
Listen to article
The National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) has served a show-cause notice on K-Electric (KE) over failure to comply with its instructions relating to forced load-shedding.
The regulator pointed out that KE had been resorting to load-shedding based on aggregate technical and commercial (AT&C) losses, which violates the Nepra Act and the Performance Standards (Distribution) Rules, 2005.
According to the authority, distribution companies (DISCOs) are bound to maintain plans and schedules to shed up to 30% of their connected load at any time upon instructions from the National Transmission and Despatch Company (NTDC).
This load must be divided into separate, switchable blocks that can be disconnected as directed by NTDC. Copies of these plans must be shared with NTDC.
Nepra emphasised that NTDC, where possible, should provide distribution companies with advance warning of impending load-shedding to help maintain system voltage and frequency in line with the Grid Code.
NTDC is also responsible for instructing distribution companies about the specific amount of load to be disconnected and the timing, using clear and unambiguous communication based on approved plans.
Previously, on January 8, 2025, Nepra issued an explanation to KE under Regulations 4(1) and 4(2) of the Nepra (Fine) Regulations, 2021, citing non-compliance with its directives.
The regulator stated that KE had been implementing load-shedding based on AT&C losses, which violates the Nepra Act and the Performance Standards (Distribution) Rules, 2005.
In this practice, entire feeders with commercial losses – such as electricity theft and non-payment – are shut down for hours, even when some consumers on those feeders are fully compliant and regularly pay their bills. "Nepra considers this unfair to compliant consumers."
In response to this practice, the authority had initiated and concluded legal proceedings, resulting in a Rs50 million penalty on KE.
"Nepra continues to stress that load-shedding should only be carried out at the Pole Mounted Transformer (PMT) level and only when absolutely necessary – such as in the case of generation shortages or transmission constraints, and only under instructions from system operators."
Meanwhile, KE launched a project in 2021 to install Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) and Automated Meter Reading (AMR) system at the distribution transformer level, costing Rs600 million.
The project aimed to identify energy losses due to theft and non-payment and to facilitate commercial benefits. KE also claimed that these meters would enable remote connection and disconnection at the transformer level. The project was completed in December 2021, with a test run conducted through June 2022.
Nepra reviewed the project's records, reports and KE submissions and found that while the company has reaped commercial benefits from the AMI/AMR system, it has not utilised the technology to provide relief to consumers by performing targeted load-shedding at the PMT level, despite the capability to do so.
Furthermore, during public hearings on monthly fuel cost adjustments (FCA), Karachi residents widely complained about excessive and unfair load-shedding, reinforcing Nepra's concerns.
A KE spokesperson regarding Nepra's show-cause notice stated, "KE is currently reviewing the show-cause notice received from Nepra. After a comprehensive review, we will submit our response in line with the timeframe set by the authority."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
14 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Karachi
Karachi appears to be Pakistan's orphaned child. Once the country's capital, it now holds the dubious distinction of being among the most unliveable cities in the world. Despite contributing over 20% to Pakistan's GDP and hosting around 10% of the nation's population, Karachi struggles significantly to complete critical projects like the BRT and K-4 water supply schemes. Videos highlighting its crumbling infrastructure became memes during the recent India-Pakistan clash, which speaks volumes. For decades, Karachi has absorbed a continuous influx of migrants from various regions of Pakistan, expanding rapidly and without adequate planning, thus becoming a hub for crime and unrest. Despite these challenges, the city has remained Pakistan's economic backbone, functioning as the nation's industrial centre and sole significant link to the global supply chain for seven decades. In short, Karachi has the potential to pull Pakistan out of its financial difficulties with minimal effort—provided it receives proper attention and prioritization. Instead, it consistently receives minimal support. Political parties routinely stage protests against the federal government for neglecting Karachi, yet minor changes. Consider the energy sector, for instance. Karachi hosts the country's only privatized power utility, K-Electric (KE). According to recent communications, KE has become the most improved DISCO since 2009 regarding transmission and distribution losses, reducing its aggregated technical and commercial losses from a staggering 43.2% to approximately 20.3% by 2024. Within Karachi alone, the exempted feeder network increased dramatically from a mere 6.6% to 70%. These achievements, supported by a complete management turnaround, have gained global recognition, including a Harvard Business School case study and positive World Bank reports. However, despite these notable improvements, KE faced significant setbacks, such as delays in the Multi-Year Tariff determination, hindering its financial planning. The private utility, intended as a model for other DISCO privatizations, was inexplicably left in limbo, ultimately punishing Karachi residents more than the company itself. Another example is the denial of Fuel Cost Adjustment (FCA) relief—a substantial amount of Rs4.69 per unit—to KE's customers in a recent NEPRA hearing. The justification given was to maintain a uniform tariff across the country, exemplifying bureaucratic rigidity and the shortsighted decisions of temporary ministers. Karachi is also burdened with inefficiencies from other DISCOs. For nearly two years, Karachi's consumers have borne the Power Holding Limited (PHL) surcharge—debt repayment they did not contribute to or benefit from. Now, due to a new banking agreement, this surcharge is extended for another six years, meaning 72 more months of inflated electricity bills for Karachi residents. Even if the government manages to find buyers for its other DISCOs—a considerable challenge—the current treatment of KE sends a negative message. Potential buyers witnessing such hurdles and neglect may reconsider their interest, fearing similar treatment. Karachi deserves better.
Express Tribune
15 hours ago
- Express Tribune
NEPRA considers 10 paisa power tariff hike for May
Listen to article Power consumers across Pakistan, excluding K-Electric (KE) and lifeline users, may face a 10-paisa per unit increase in electricity tariffs under the Fuel Charges Adjustment (FCA) for May 2025. The National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) is scheduled to hear the proposed hike of Rs0.1015 per kilowatt-hour (kWh) on June 30, 2025, at NEPRA Tower, Islamabad. The session will also be available online via Zoom. The proposal has been submitted by the Central Power Purchasing Agency Guarantee Limited (CPPA-G) on behalf of Ex-WAPDA Distribution Companies (XWDISCOs). According to CPPA-G, the actual fuel cost in May stood at Rs7.4940/kWh, compared to a reference cost of Rs7.3925/kWh, resulting in the requested hike. In May, 12,755 GWh of electricity was generated at a cost of Rs99.153 billion, averaging Rs7.7739/kWh. After deducting transmission losses of 355 GWh (2.78%) and adjustments, 12,367 GWh was delivered to DISCOs at Rs92.676 billion or Rs7.4940/kWh. Hydel power led the generation mix with 37.98% (4,844 GWh), followed by RLNG (16.99%), nuclear (15.77%), and local coal (11.08%). Imported coal contributed 6.24%, while gas added 6.92%. Other sources included RFO, solar, wind, and bagasse. NEPRA has invited stakeholders to join the hearing and submit feedback. If approved, the FCA will apply for one month only.
Express Tribune
15 hours ago
- Express Tribune
NEPRA issues notice to K-Electric over load-shedding
Prior approval to NEPRA K-electric consumer may seen a huge relief over electricity bills. PHOTO: FILE Listen to article The National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) has served a show-cause notice on K-Electric (KE) over failure to comply with its instructions relating to forced load-shedding. The regulator pointed out that KE had been resorting to load-shedding based on aggregate technical and commercial (AT&C) losses, which violates the Nepra Act and the Performance Standards (Distribution) Rules, 2005. According to the authority, distribution companies (DISCOs) are bound to maintain plans and schedules to shed up to 30% of their connected load at any time upon instructions from the National Transmission and Despatch Company (NTDC). This load must be divided into separate, switchable blocks that can be disconnected as directed by NTDC. Copies of these plans must be shared with NTDC. Nepra emphasised that NTDC, where possible, should provide distribution companies with advance warning of impending load-shedding to help maintain system voltage and frequency in line with the Grid Code. NTDC is also responsible for instructing distribution companies about the specific amount of load to be disconnected and the timing, using clear and unambiguous communication based on approved plans. Previously, on January 8, 2025, Nepra issued an explanation to KE under Regulations 4(1) and 4(2) of the Nepra (Fine) Regulations, 2021, citing non-compliance with its directives. The regulator stated that KE had been implementing load-shedding based on AT&C losses, which violates the Nepra Act and the Performance Standards (Distribution) Rules, 2005. In this practice, entire feeders with commercial losses – such as electricity theft and non-payment – are shut down for hours, even when some consumers on those feeders are fully compliant and regularly pay their bills. "Nepra considers this unfair to compliant consumers." In response to this practice, the authority had initiated and concluded legal proceedings, resulting in a Rs50 million penalty on KE. "Nepra continues to stress that load-shedding should only be carried out at the Pole Mounted Transformer (PMT) level and only when absolutely necessary – such as in the case of generation shortages or transmission constraints, and only under instructions from system operators." Meanwhile, KE launched a project in 2021 to install Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) and Automated Meter Reading (AMR) system at the distribution transformer level, costing Rs600 million. The project aimed to identify energy losses due to theft and non-payment and to facilitate commercial benefits. KE also claimed that these meters would enable remote connection and disconnection at the transformer level. The project was completed in December 2021, with a test run conducted through June 2022. Nepra reviewed the project's records, reports and KE submissions and found that while the company has reaped commercial benefits from the AMI/AMR system, it has not utilised the technology to provide relief to consumers by performing targeted load-shedding at the PMT level, despite the capability to do so. Furthermore, during public hearings on monthly fuel cost adjustments (FCA), Karachi residents widely complained about excessive and unfair load-shedding, reinforcing Nepra's concerns. A KE spokesperson regarding Nepra's show-cause notice stated, "KE is currently reviewing the show-cause notice received from Nepra. After a comprehensive review, we will submit our response in line with the timeframe set by the authority."
