Convicted head of human smuggling plot gets 10 years after Indian family dies on US-Canada border
Federal prosecutors had recommended nearly 20 years for Harshkumar Ramanlal Patel, and nearly 11 years for the driver who was supposed to pick them up, Steve Anthony Shand.
Shand also was to be sentenced Wednesday.
The two men appeared before US District Judge John Tunheim, who declined last month to set aside the guilty verdicts, writing, 'This was not a close case'.
The judge handed down the sentences at the federal courthouse in the northwestern Minnesota city of Fergus Falls, where the two men were tried and convicted on four counts apiece last November.
The smuggling operation
Prosecutors said during the trial that Patel, an Indian national who they say went by the alias 'Dirty Harry', and Shand, a US citizen from Florida, were part of a sophisticated illegal operation that brought dozens of people from India to Canada on student visas and then smuggled them across the US border.
They said the victims, Jagdish Patel, 39; his wife, Vaishaliben, who was in her mid-30s; their 11-year-old daughter, Vihangi; and 3-year-old son, Dharmik, froze to death.
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police found their bodies just north of the border between Manitoba and Minnesota on January 19, 2022.
The family was from Dingucha, a village in the western Indian state of Gujarat, as was Harshkumar Patel.
Patel is a common Indian surname, and the victims were not related to the defendant.
The couple were schoolteachers, local news reports said.
So many villagers have gone overseas in hopes of better lives — legally and otherwise — that many homes there stand vacant.
The harsh conditions
The father died while trying to shield Dharmik's face from a 'blistering wind' with a frozen glove, prosecutor Michael McBride wrote. Vihangi was wearing 'ill-fitting boots and gloves'.
Their mother 'died slumped against a chain-link fence she must have thought salvation lay behind,' McBride wrote.
A nearby weather station recorded the wind chill that morning at -38C.
Seven other members of their group survived the foot crossing, but only two made it to Shand's van, which was stuck in the snow on the Minnesota side.
One woman who survived had to be flown to a hospital with severe frostbite and hypothermia.
Another survivor testified he had never seen snow before arriving in Canada.
Their inadequate winter clothes were only what the smugglers provided, the survivor told the jury.
What prosecutors say
'Mr. Patel has never shown an ounce of remorse. Even today, he continues to deny he is the 'Dirty Harry' that worked with Mr. Shand on this smuggling venture — despite substantial evidence to the contrary and counsel for his co-defendant identifying him as such at trial,' McBride wrote.
Prosecutors asked for a sentence of 19 years and 7 months for Patel, at the top end of the recommended range under federal sentencing guidelines for his actions.
They asked for Shand's sentence to be 10 years and 10 months, in the middle of his separate guidelines range.
'Even as this family wandered through the blizzard at 1am, searching for Mr. Shand's van, Mr. Shand was focused on one thing, which he texted Mr. Patel: 'we not losing any money,'' McBride wrote.
'Worse, when Customs and Border Patrol arrested Mr. Shand sitting in a mostly unoccupied 15-passenger van, he denied others were out in the snow — leaving them to freeze without aid.'
What defence attorneys say
Patel's attorneys, who have argued that the evidence was insufficient, did request a government-paid attorney for his planned appeal.
Patel has been jailed since his arrest at O'Hare International Airport in Chicago in February 2024 and claimed in the filing to have no income and no assets.
Shand has been free pending sentencing.
His attorney called the government's requested sentence 'unduly punitive' and requested just 27 months.
The attorney, federal defender Aaron Morrison, acknowledged that Shand has 'a level of culpability' but argued that his role was limited — that he was just a taxi driver who needed money to support his wife and six children.
'Mr. Shand was on the outside of the conspiracy, he did not plan the smuggling operation, he did not have decision-making authority, and he did not reap the huge financial benefits as the real conspirators did,' Morrison wrote.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
19 hours ago
- Perth Now
Why the dark truth of domestic violence is unbelievable
When police quizzed forensic psychologist Helen Paterson about the crimes of a serial arsonist, she had a lightbulb moment that illuminated her career. Now arguably Australia's leading researcher on domestic violence memory, she was then a Canadian exchange student living in a cheap Sydney apartment. There was a firebug residing in her building who kept setting it alight and during repeated questioning from police, "I gathered that the questions they were asking were not the questions I was learning about in academia that they should be asking". "I realised there's a disconnect between what's happening in the ivory tower of academia and the real world," she says. "Is the advice they're getting from academia not practical or are they just not hearing it? So that's what sparked my interest." After completing a PhD on the risks of witnesses discussing crimes and the impact on their memories, the University of Sydney academic conducted years of research on how to ask questions about single-event crimes before the impact of COVID prompted a focus switch. "I was seeing the increases in domestic and family violence rates, and it was terrible," she explains. At first she considered stepping back into the real world to volunteer part-time in a family violence refuge but then realised she could use her position within the university to fight for abused women to be heard and believed. Her subsequent groundbreaking research has made her a finalist in the country's leading science awards, the Australian Museum Eureka Prizes, in a new category of Excellence in Forensic Science. Dr Paterson's work addresses a crucial issue at the intersection of psychology and law: how to support victim-survivors of domestic violence in providing credible, accurate and admissible court testimony. "When people recall a repeated event, it can become less detailed because we stick to the script of what would typically happen," she says. "But detail is really important because the judge, jury and police officers see detail as being indicative of higher credibility." Her laboratory studies reached the disturbing conclusion that the more often a domestic violence survivor is victimised, the less likely they are to be believed. Because many situations involve divorce and child custody, people also believe "there is some potential motivation to tell a lie", she says. As a result, "people are always judging them within that context". Repeat victims also make "internal intrusion" errors, she adds, where they can mix up a Tuesday event with a Thursday event. "And then it's defence 101 for lawyers to say, 'he was out of town on the Thursday, so it couldn't have been him and we think you're making everything up'." Former NSW Director of Public Prosecutions Nicholas Cowdery, KC, believes Dr Paterson's findings have had direct application in policing and criminal prosecution and contributed to improving evidence reliability and credibility. Her research has been used to train police, provide objective reassurance to victims and improve forensic outcomes, he says. "Her work (as an expert witness and otherwise) has enabled court practices to evolve in a scientifically supported manner and, ultimately, many victims to be relieved of ongoing abuse," Mr Cowdery says. "That is no mean achievement." Australian Bureau of Statistics data estimates one in four women and one in eight men have experienced violence by an intimate partner or family member since age 15. Even so, exasperated anti-violence advocates launched a national online forum in the lead-up to the May federal election, citing the fact virtually no political attention had been paid to the crisis during the campaign. "To truly stop domestic, family and sexual violence, to keep families strong and communities safe, we must stop the violence at its source," organiser and No to Violence CEO Phillip Ripper said at the time. "We are looking forward to hearing from some of our leaders on how they will make that happen." But more disconcerting still than the raw victim data, the bureau points to domestic violence matters having a 77 per cent conviction rate compared to non-DV cases achieving a rate of 92 per cent. It's here that the results of Dr Paterson's lab work provide insight into crucial contributing factors. Participants in her studies either watch one video of domestic violence or four videos of domestic violence that are similar with the same perpetrator but different events. The four-video participants are asked to describe the last video they viewed and the researchers compare how memory is affected by multiple events. "What's interesting is if we video these people and show it to mock jurors and get them to rate their credibility, they rate the repeated event participants as less honest, less cognitively competent and less credible," she says. "That's really problematic because it potentially means the more repeatedly you are victimised, the less likely you are to be believed." But "it gets worse than that" because in the studies where participants are instructed to lie about having witnessed a domestic violence event, their credibility is rated the same as single-event witnesses. "So that tells us (repeat-event witnesses) are also less likely to be believed than people who are lying … which is really concerning," Dr Paterson says. Her research also shows repeat-event witnesses are more likely to use hedge words such as "think", "perhaps" and "maybe", which could contribute to lower credibility ratings. It's a pattern observed among study participants but could even be more pronounced in the context of domestic violence. "If we consider the experience of someone who has been repeatedly gaslit and subjected to coercive control, it's highly likely their confidence would be impacted," Dr Paterson says. Gaslighting, which is a form of coercive control, is another crucial element of the research. So how does the justice system improve victim outcomes in the face of such challenges? Dr Paterson says it is crucial to educate judges, juries, lawyers and police officers about memory. "We need them to hear from experts who can tell them that this is what we expect of repeated event memory," she says. "We expect it to be less detailed ... that they might use more hedge words but what they're saying is typically quite accurate in that it happened to them, although they may confuse details of one event with another. "And when you do give that kind of expert testimony, people don't rate victims as being less credible when they have a more thorough understanding." 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) Lifeline 13 11 14 Men's Referral Service 1300 766 491
The Advertiser
2 days ago
- The Advertiser
International students allegedly steal $10m in baby formula, toiletries
A multimillion-dollar retail syndicate allegedly operated by Indian international students has been dismantled. More than $10 million worth of items were stolen in the past five months, including baby formula, medicines, vitamins, skincare products, electric toothbrushes and toiletries. Operation 'Supanova' uncovered the alleged syndicate that targeted major supermarket retailers. Those arrested are predominantly Indian nationals on temporary, student, or bridging visas, Victoria Police said. They are alleged to be working in a coordinated network to supply stolen goods to 'receivers', who then on-sell the products to end users for profit. READ MORE: Average grocery shop tops $12,000 per year despite shoppers changing habits Detective acting inspector Rachele Ciavarella described it as one of the most significant operations police had undertaken in recent times to target organised retail theft. "We will allege that this syndicate is not only stealing for themselves, but they are part of a coordinated criminal enterprise profiting from stolen goods," she said. "By working with major retailers, we've been able to identify alleged offenders quickly and build a strong intelligence picture, allowing us to target the right people at the right time." Retail theft is one of the fastest-growing crimes in Victoria, with 41,270 offences recorded in the past year - a 38% increase state-wide. A multimillion-dollar retail syndicate allegedly operated by Indian international students has been dismantled. More than $10 million worth of items were stolen in the past five months, including baby formula, medicines, vitamins, skincare products, electric toothbrushes and toiletries. Operation 'Supanova' uncovered the alleged syndicate that targeted major supermarket retailers. Those arrested are predominantly Indian nationals on temporary, student, or bridging visas, Victoria Police said. They are alleged to be working in a coordinated network to supply stolen goods to 'receivers', who then on-sell the products to end users for profit. READ MORE: Average grocery shop tops $12,000 per year despite shoppers changing habits Detective acting inspector Rachele Ciavarella described it as one of the most significant operations police had undertaken in recent times to target organised retail theft. "We will allege that this syndicate is not only stealing for themselves, but they are part of a coordinated criminal enterprise profiting from stolen goods," she said. "By working with major retailers, we've been able to identify alleged offenders quickly and build a strong intelligence picture, allowing us to target the right people at the right time." Retail theft is one of the fastest-growing crimes in Victoria, with 41,270 offences recorded in the past year - a 38% increase state-wide. A multimillion-dollar retail syndicate allegedly operated by Indian international students has been dismantled. More than $10 million worth of items were stolen in the past five months, including baby formula, medicines, vitamins, skincare products, electric toothbrushes and toiletries. Operation 'Supanova' uncovered the alleged syndicate that targeted major supermarket retailers. Those arrested are predominantly Indian nationals on temporary, student, or bridging visas, Victoria Police said. They are alleged to be working in a coordinated network to supply stolen goods to 'receivers', who then on-sell the products to end users for profit. READ MORE: Average grocery shop tops $12,000 per year despite shoppers changing habits Detective acting inspector Rachele Ciavarella described it as one of the most significant operations police had undertaken in recent times to target organised retail theft. "We will allege that this syndicate is not only stealing for themselves, but they are part of a coordinated criminal enterprise profiting from stolen goods," she said. "By working with major retailers, we've been able to identify alleged offenders quickly and build a strong intelligence picture, allowing us to target the right people at the right time." Retail theft is one of the fastest-growing crimes in Victoria, with 41,270 offences recorded in the past year - a 38% increase state-wide. A multimillion-dollar retail syndicate allegedly operated by Indian international students has been dismantled. More than $10 million worth of items were stolen in the past five months, including baby formula, medicines, vitamins, skincare products, electric toothbrushes and toiletries. Operation 'Supanova' uncovered the alleged syndicate that targeted major supermarket retailers. Those arrested are predominantly Indian nationals on temporary, student, or bridging visas, Victoria Police said. They are alleged to be working in a coordinated network to supply stolen goods to 'receivers', who then on-sell the products to end users for profit. READ MORE: Average grocery shop tops $12,000 per year despite shoppers changing habits Detective acting inspector Rachele Ciavarella described it as one of the most significant operations police had undertaken in recent times to target organised retail theft. "We will allege that this syndicate is not only stealing for themselves, but they are part of a coordinated criminal enterprise profiting from stolen goods," she said. "By working with major retailers, we've been able to identify alleged offenders quickly and build a strong intelligence picture, allowing us to target the right people at the right time." Retail theft is one of the fastest-growing crimes in Victoria, with 41,270 offences recorded in the past year - a 38% increase state-wide.
Perth Now
2 days ago
- Perth Now
Cops smash alleged $10m theft syndicate
Police have arrested 19 people alleged to be part of a syndicate stealing $10m worth of items from Melbourne supermarkets, ranging from medicines to baby formula products. The alleged syndicate members were mostly Indian nationals on temporary, student and bridging visas, Victoria Police said in a statement. 'We will allege this syndicate are not only stealing for themselves, but they are part of a co-ordinated criminal enterprise profiting from stolen goods,' eastern region Acting Inspector Rachele Ciavarella said. The thieves were allegedly targeting items such as baby formula, medicines, vitamins, skincare products, electric toothbrushes and toiletries. Victoria Police say they have dismantled a major supermarket theft syndicate, making 19 arrests over an alleged $10m operation. Victoria Police Credit: Supplied Police say the syndicate was targeting toiletries. Victoria Police Credit: Supplied Footage of some of the arrests shows one man has been detained while carrying a backpack full of toothpaste boxes and honey. Shopping bags seized when another man was arrested contained at least five tins of baby formula. Police announced on Friday that 19 people had been arrested and more arrests were likely. In a statement, Victoria Police highlight seven men as 'main arrests'. These men are aged between 21 and 43, three of them are on student visas and one is on a bridging visa. These men face allegations of stealing items worth $37,000 to $136,000. Police made a series of arrests in July and August. Victoria Police Credit: Supplied Baby formula is another item the syndicate was allegedly stealing. Victoria Police Credit: Supplied The seven men have 'no fixed address' and are being held in custody until various court appearances in the coming weeks. Asked by NewsWire to clarify whether they men are homeless, a police spokeswoman said they were likely living in student accommodation, the details of which were not able to be shared. Investigators have also highlighted a 54-year-old woman from Springvale, who has been bailed and faces 30 charges of handling stolen goods. This woman is an alleged 'receiver', a police spokesperson said, who was selling the allegedly stolen items. Police say most of the people arrested were on student or bridging visas. Victoria Police Credit: Supplied Melbourne police say they have dismantled a major supermarket theft syndicate, making 19 arrests over an alleged $10m operation. Victoria Police Credit: Supplied 'This has been one of the most significant operations we've undertaken in recent times to target organised retail theft,' Acting Inspector Ciavarella said. 'By working with major retailers, we've been able to identify alleged offenders quickly and build a strong intelligence picture, allowing us to target the right people at the right time. 'Our message is simple: if you target our retail sector, we will target you. We will continue to work with our partners to protect businesses and hold offenders to account.' Police data shows retail theft has increased 38 per cent across Victoria in the past year. Acting Inspector Ciavarella is expected to provide further details about the allegations later on Friday.
