US women's-only spa barred from excluding transwomen with penises
A federal appeals court has obliged a Korean spa in Lynnwood, Washington to provide services to transgender females. The beauty parlor had attempted to bar transwomen who have not undergone gender-affirming surgery from entering its ladies-only facilities.
The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled Thursday, in a 2–1 vote, that Olympus Spa must change its admissions policy to comply with the anti-discrimination law. The court found that the spa's owners were not being deprived of their First Amendment rights, such as the right to free exercise of religion, freedom of speech and right of association, by the State of Washington's requirement.
Olympus Spa, which operates two locations in the state, is a traditional Korean bathhouse offering massages, body scrubs, and hot tubs that require full nudity. In 2020, the Washington State Human Rights Commission filed a complaint after a transgender woman—who had not undergone genital surgery—was denied entry.
The Commission argued that the spa's ladies-only policy violated the Washington Law Against Discrimination (WLAD), which prohibits discrimination in public accommodations based on gender identity and gender expression.
In response, Olympus Spa filed a lawsuit claiming the state was violating the owners' constitutional rights to freedom of religion, speech, and association. The spa, run by a Christian Korean-American family, cited religious and cultural beliefs in opposing the inclusion of individuals with male genitalia in female-only spaces where nudity is required.
'The family-run business is owned by Korean Christians who hold sincere faith-based convictions against allowing persons whose genitals are external (males) to be present with persons whose genitals are internal (females) while in a state of partial or full undress if such persons are not married to one another,' the complaint stated.
However, the Ninth Circuit ruled that enforcement of the state law does not violate the First Amendment. Writing for the majority, Judge Margaret McKeown said that providing a Korean body scrub or massage does not constitute protected expressive conduct. She added that accepting the spa's argument would essentially make every gym or massage parlor exempt from nondiscrimination laws.
The ruling comes amid broader national debates on transgender rights. Earlier this year, President Donald Trump reversed several protections for trans individuals, ending federal support for child sexual mutilation procedures for minors and issuing executive orders banning transwomen from women's sports and removing 'radical gender ideology' from the military.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Russia Today
15 hours ago
- Russia Today
White House covered up chemical spill cancer risk
The administration of former US President Joe Biden tried to cover up serious public health risks related to a 2023 toxic chemical spill in East Palestine, Ohio, a whistleblower protection and advocacy group has claimed. The Government Accountability Project (GAP) has published a set of documents obtained through a lawsuit from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), which allegedly prove that the White House deliberately chose to withhold the true scale of the catastrophe while intentionally avoiding contact with affected residents. On February 3, 2023, a Norfolk Southern freight train carrying toxic chemicals, including vinyl chloride, derailed near the village of East Palestine, spilling its hazardous contents into a nearby waterway. Five tankers were later also deliberately ignited in a controlled burn. The incident forced evacuations, was linked to animal deaths, and led to reports of unexplained illnesses in the weeks that followed. Several months later, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) publicly declared that East Palestine residents were 'not in danger,' citing air and water monitoring results. Biden had also praised what he called his administration's 'herculean efforts' to resolve the crisis. The government's response was heavily criticized at the time, with many calling out Biden for not visiting East Palestine sooner, downplaying the severity of the disaster, and prioritizing public relations over the health and safety concerns raised by residents and experts. According to GAP investigator Lesley Pacey, the public's fears have turned out to be justified, with internal documents showing that the White House, the EPA, and FEMA had privately discussed the serious dangers associated with the chemical spill, described internally as 'really toxic,' and 'deliberately kept this information from the community.' In an interview with NewsNation published on Saturday, Pacey explained that FEMA knew that the controlled chemical burn resulted in a 'really toxic plume' and that it could cause cancer clusters in the region and other health risks that would require 20 years of medical monitoring. The information was never publicly disclosed or acknowledged by FEMA or the White House as the Biden administration chose to focus on 'public reassurances' rather than 'worrying about public health,' Pacey told the New York Post. The emails obtained by GAP have also shown that FEMA's coordinator – sent to East Palestine to oversee recovery efforts, communicate with residents and assess their needs – was actually directly instructed to avoid engaging with the locals. 'They completely botched this event from the very beginning,' Pacey surmised.
Russia Today
17 hours ago
- Russia Today
US-born Ukrainian military trans spokesperson sentenced in Russia
An American transgender woman who was dismissed from the Ukrainian military after issuing death threats to journalists has been sentenced in absentia in Russia for acting as a mercenary. The Prosecutor General's Office in Moscow announced on Monday that Sarah Ashton-Cirillo was convicted by a court in the Donetsk People's Republic. She was sentenced to 20 years in prison for taking part in combat roles with the Ukrainian military and for making defamatory statements against the Russian military on behalf of Kiev in 2023. Ashton-Cirillo, who transitioned in 2019, gained public attention in 2021 after claiming to have infiltrated the far-right Proud Boys group by posing as a sympathizer. In 2023, she was appointed as an English-language spokesperson for Ukraine's territorial defense forces, producing anti-Russian videos in her new role. She was suspended in September of that year after declaring that 'Kremlin propagandists' would soon be 'hunted down.' Her comments sparked backlash in the US, prompting then-Senator J.D. Vance to contact the Department of State, the Pentagon, and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, and question whether Ashton-Cirillo was acting on behalf of the US government. 'I've seen claims this individual is an American, a former intelligence operative in the United States, and an employee of the Ukrainian government,' Vance, now the vice president under US President Donald Trump, wrote. 'Others have argued Ashton-Cirillo is pulling an elaborate prank. If so, kudos for the delivery of high quality humor.' Ashton-Cirillo referenced the controversy during the 2024 US presidential race, when she mentioned viral online rumors disparaging Vance and mockingly offered her sympathies. 'I support you during this time of confusion and during this time of really weird behavior,' she said. 'I have served a lot more at the line of contact here in Ukraine than you ever did in Iraq. And that's fine. Some of us are infantry. Some of us are press officers.' Trump's reelection campaign centered on criticism of the administration of former President Joe Biden. He blasted its policy of sending aid to Kiev and promoting transgender rights, including allowing trans women to compete in women's sports and mandating diversity-based hiring in government. Since returning to office, Trump has moved to reverse many of these policies.
Russia Today
a day ago
- Russia Today
Trump promotes claim Biden was replaced by ‘robotic clone'
US President Donald Trump has shared on social media a claim that his predecessor, Joe Biden, was secretly executed and replaced by a 'robotic entity.'The original post, published by an anonymous user on Saturday afternoon, included a link to an article alleging that Biden's family feared they were 'running out of time to exploit' the former president following his cancer diagnosis.'There is no #JoeBiden – executed in 2020. #Biden clones doubles & robotic engineered soulless mindless entities are what you see. #Democrats don't know the difference,' the message read. Trump reposted it on his Truth Social platform hours later without comment. Biden, who has shown signs of cognitive decline for years, abruptly withdrew his candidacy from the 2024 presidential race after a disastrous debate performance that alarmed the Democratic Party. He named then-Vice President Kamala Harris as his replacement, who subsequently lost to have long accused Democratic leadership of covering up Biden's mental and health issues during his presidency and reelection campaign. Last month, Biden revealed he had been diagnosed with stage 4 prostate cancer that had spread to his their recently released book, Original Sin, journalists Jake Tapper of CNN and Alex Thompson of Axios detailed how Biden's staff worked to conceal his decline from the public. The authors claimed that a 'Politburo' of Biden's family members and close aides were the real decision-makers during his term in office.
