‘Moronic' vandals jailed for cutting down iconic Sycamore Gap tree
The tree, in a saddle between two hills, had been known to locals but became famous after a cameo in Kevin Costner's 1991 film Robin Hood: Prince Of Thieves. It drew tourists, lovers, landscape photographers and those who spread the ashes of loved ones. It was voted English 'Tree of the Year' in 2016.
At trial, the two men testified they were at their homes on the night in question and had nothing to do with destroying the tree.
But faced with spending up to 10 years behind bars, they changed their tune when interviewed by a probation officer in advance of sentencing, though they sought to minimise their culpability, the judge said.
Carruthers said he drank a bottle of whisky after a rough day and everything was a blur, Lambert said. While Graham admitted he had joined Carruthers on the journey, he said he was shocked that his former friend had actually cut the tree down.
'Although there may be grains of truth in what you have each said, I do not accept that your explanations to the probation officers are wholly honest or the whole story,' Lambert said.
The tree's felling in Northumberland National Park on September 28, 2023, caused fury and condemnation as news quickly spread beyond the ancient wall built by Emperor Hadrian in A.D. 122 to protect the northwest frontier of the Roman Empire.
Messages of heartbreak poured in from around the world, said Andrew Poad, general manager of the heritage and nature conservation charity National Trust.
'This iconic tree can never be replaced,' Poad said in a statement read by a prosecutor.
Loading
'It belonged to the people. It was a totemic symbol for many; a destination to visit whilst walking Hadrian's Wall, a place to make memories, take photos in all seasons; but it was also a place of sanctuary.'
Prosecutors said the tree's value was estimated at £460,000 ($945,000), while Graham's lawyer said it was valued at about £150,000.
Graham, who had a small construction business, and Carruthers, a mechanic who sometimes worked with him, had once been close friends. But the men who showed up together for their initial court appearance with their faces masked had a falling-out as the case progressed.
Graham said Carruthers was guilty and asserted that his friend had tried to frame him. Carruthers' lawyer said Graham's story was implausible and accused him of trying to deflect blame.
Jurors quickly convicted both in May based on a trove of digital evidence.
Graham's Range Rover was tracked to a location near the tree around the time it fell. Grainy video of the felling was found on his phone – with metadata showing that it was shot at the tree's location.
As digital data showed Graham's vehicle on its way back to where the two lived about 40 minutes away, Carruthers got a text from his girlfriend with footage of their 12-day-old son.
'I've got a better video than that,' Carruthers replied.
The black-and-white video showed a single figure next to the tree's silhouette as a chainsaw sparked to life. The person leaned into the trunk and in less than three minutes the tree that had stood for about 150 years teetered and fell.
Prosecutors couldn't say at trial who cut down the tree and who memorialised the senseless act, but said both were equally culpable.
Lambert agreed that both shared equal responsibility. But she said the men's recent admissions made it clear that Carruthers wielded the saw while Graham shot the video. Graham sent the video to Carruthers.
'Unfortunately, it is no more than drunken stupidity,' defence lawyer Andrew Gurney said. 'He felled that tree and it is something he will regret for the rest of his life. There's no better explanation than that.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
17 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Apprentice never came home from work after supervisor's 'reckless, negligent choices'
THE mother of a young man killed when his supervisor lost control on a bend and slammed into a power pole at Cardiff has faced the driver in court and said her son's tragic death was the result of "gross, avoidable negligence". Apprentice carpenter Jacob Mostyn, 19, went to work and never came home on November 3, 2023, and now his mother, Christine, says she is living every parent's worst nightmare. Jacob's supervisor, 36-year-old Jeremy Howard, pleaded guilty to negligent driving occasioning death after he lost control of his BMW on a sweeping bend at Munibung Road at Cardiff and slid into a power pole. Jacob, a passenger in the car, was critically injured and died in hospital 11 days later. Howard faced a sentence hearing in Belmont Local Court on Thursday, during which Christine read a powerful victim impact statement, outlining the devastation the crash had caused her family and the promising young man Howard's "reckless choices" had taken away. "Jacob was a passenger in a vehicle driven by his supervisor," Christine said. "Someone entrusted with leadership, responsibility, and the safety of others. "But instead of exercising that duty with care, his supervisor made reckless, negligent choices behind the wheel. "Choices that cost Jacob his life. "Choices that shattered me, my family and his friends forever." Christine described getting the phone call about the crash and the realisation that "every parent's worst nightmare had just become my reality". "I can't describe to you what it's like to bury your child," Christine said. "There is no word in the English language for a parent who loses their child, because it is not supposed to happen. "It's unnatural. It's unbearable. This is my nightmare." Christine detailed all the important life events that had been stolen from her son, from finishing his apprenticeship to buying a home and having a family. "He didn't get to live," she said. "This was all stolen from him and us in a split second." She stressed that her son was not a statistic, that his life mattered and that his death was avoidable. "What makes this so much worse is knowing that his death didn't have to happen," Christine said. "The driver, Jeremy, made decisions that endangered not only my son's life but his own and everyone else on the road that day. "This was negligence. "Gross, avoidable negligence. "The kind that deserves accountability." Finally, with a framed photograph of her son held aloft beside her, she spoke directly to Howard. "I don't hate you," Christine said. "I don't know if I will ever be able to forgive you, but I want you to understand something; you didn't just end my son's life, you ended mine in many ways, too. "You took away my reason for getting up in the morning. "You took away a brother, a grandson, a friend, a mate, a partner, and a young man with so much life left to live. "I hope that you carry that weight every day. "And I hope that, one day, you truly understand the full consequences of what you have done." Crown prosecutor Jillian Kelton had argued the crash involved a significant degree of negligence because Howard was driving too quickly for the sweeping curve, was fatigued and had deactivated the BMW's traction control system, which she said may have prevented the crash. But defence barrister, Ben Bickford, said the degree of negligence was at a lower level and Howard had made an error in judgment and the impact with the pole had occurred a second after he lost traction. Magistrate Stephen Olischlager found the degree of negligence was significant but said Howard had no prior criminal record and was unlikely to re-offend. He said Howard would have to live with causing Jacob's death for the rest of his life and had the physical scars as a reminder of his mistake. Mr Olischlager said he would impose a nine-month sentence, but adjourned the matter until October to see whether Howard is suitable to serve the sentence in home detention as part of an intensive corrections order. THE mother of a young man killed when his supervisor lost control on a bend and slammed into a power pole at Cardiff has faced the driver in court and said her son's tragic death was the result of "gross, avoidable negligence". Apprentice carpenter Jacob Mostyn, 19, went to work and never came home on November 3, 2023, and now his mother, Christine, says she is living every parent's worst nightmare. Jacob's supervisor, 36-year-old Jeremy Howard, pleaded guilty to negligent driving occasioning death after he lost control of his BMW on a sweeping bend at Munibung Road at Cardiff and slid into a power pole. Jacob, a passenger in the car, was critically injured and died in hospital 11 days later. Howard faced a sentence hearing in Belmont Local Court on Thursday, during which Christine read a powerful victim impact statement, outlining the devastation the crash had caused her family and the promising young man Howard's "reckless choices" had taken away. "Jacob was a passenger in a vehicle driven by his supervisor," Christine said. "Someone entrusted with leadership, responsibility, and the safety of others. "But instead of exercising that duty with care, his supervisor made reckless, negligent choices behind the wheel. "Choices that cost Jacob his life. "Choices that shattered me, my family and his friends forever." Christine described getting the phone call about the crash and the realisation that "every parent's worst nightmare had just become my reality". "I can't describe to you what it's like to bury your child," Christine said. "There is no word in the English language for a parent who loses their child, because it is not supposed to happen. "It's unnatural. It's unbearable. This is my nightmare." Christine detailed all the important life events that had been stolen from her son, from finishing his apprenticeship to buying a home and having a family. "He didn't get to live," she said. "This was all stolen from him and us in a split second." She stressed that her son was not a statistic, that his life mattered and that his death was avoidable. "What makes this so much worse is knowing that his death didn't have to happen," Christine said. "The driver, Jeremy, made decisions that endangered not only my son's life but his own and everyone else on the road that day. "This was negligence. "Gross, avoidable negligence. "The kind that deserves accountability." Finally, with a framed photograph of her son held aloft beside her, she spoke directly to Howard. "I don't hate you," Christine said. "I don't know if I will ever be able to forgive you, but I want you to understand something; you didn't just end my son's life, you ended mine in many ways, too. "You took away my reason for getting up in the morning. "You took away a brother, a grandson, a friend, a mate, a partner, and a young man with so much life left to live. "I hope that you carry that weight every day. "And I hope that, one day, you truly understand the full consequences of what you have done." Crown prosecutor Jillian Kelton had argued the crash involved a significant degree of negligence because Howard was driving too quickly for the sweeping curve, was fatigued and had deactivated the BMW's traction control system, which she said may have prevented the crash. But defence barrister, Ben Bickford, said the degree of negligence was at a lower level and Howard had made an error in judgment and the impact with the pole had occurred a second after he lost traction. Magistrate Stephen Olischlager found the degree of negligence was significant but said Howard had no prior criminal record and was unlikely to re-offend. He said Howard would have to live with causing Jacob's death for the rest of his life and had the physical scars as a reminder of his mistake. Mr Olischlager said he would impose a nine-month sentence, but adjourned the matter until October to see whether Howard is suitable to serve the sentence in home detention as part of an intensive corrections order. THE mother of a young man killed when his supervisor lost control on a bend and slammed into a power pole at Cardiff has faced the driver in court and said her son's tragic death was the result of "gross, avoidable negligence". Apprentice carpenter Jacob Mostyn, 19, went to work and never came home on November 3, 2023, and now his mother, Christine, says she is living every parent's worst nightmare. Jacob's supervisor, 36-year-old Jeremy Howard, pleaded guilty to negligent driving occasioning death after he lost control of his BMW on a sweeping bend at Munibung Road at Cardiff and slid into a power pole. Jacob, a passenger in the car, was critically injured and died in hospital 11 days later. Howard faced a sentence hearing in Belmont Local Court on Thursday, during which Christine read a powerful victim impact statement, outlining the devastation the crash had caused her family and the promising young man Howard's "reckless choices" had taken away. "Jacob was a passenger in a vehicle driven by his supervisor," Christine said. "Someone entrusted with leadership, responsibility, and the safety of others. "But instead of exercising that duty with care, his supervisor made reckless, negligent choices behind the wheel. "Choices that cost Jacob his life. "Choices that shattered me, my family and his friends forever." Christine described getting the phone call about the crash and the realisation that "every parent's worst nightmare had just become my reality". "I can't describe to you what it's like to bury your child," Christine said. "There is no word in the English language for a parent who loses their child, because it is not supposed to happen. "It's unnatural. It's unbearable. This is my nightmare." Christine detailed all the important life events that had been stolen from her son, from finishing his apprenticeship to buying a home and having a family. "He didn't get to live," she said. "This was all stolen from him and us in a split second." She stressed that her son was not a statistic, that his life mattered and that his death was avoidable. "What makes this so much worse is knowing that his death didn't have to happen," Christine said. "The driver, Jeremy, made decisions that endangered not only my son's life but his own and everyone else on the road that day. "This was negligence. "Gross, avoidable negligence. "The kind that deserves accountability." Finally, with a framed photograph of her son held aloft beside her, she spoke directly to Howard. "I don't hate you," Christine said. "I don't know if I will ever be able to forgive you, but I want you to understand something; you didn't just end my son's life, you ended mine in many ways, too. "You took away my reason for getting up in the morning. "You took away a brother, a grandson, a friend, a mate, a partner, and a young man with so much life left to live. "I hope that you carry that weight every day. "And I hope that, one day, you truly understand the full consequences of what you have done." Crown prosecutor Jillian Kelton had argued the crash involved a significant degree of negligence because Howard was driving too quickly for the sweeping curve, was fatigued and had deactivated the BMW's traction control system, which she said may have prevented the crash. But defence barrister, Ben Bickford, said the degree of negligence was at a lower level and Howard had made an error in judgment and the impact with the pole had occurred a second after he lost traction. Magistrate Stephen Olischlager found the degree of negligence was significant but said Howard had no prior criminal record and was unlikely to re-offend. He said Howard would have to live with causing Jacob's death for the rest of his life and had the physical scars as a reminder of his mistake. Mr Olischlager said he would impose a nine-month sentence, but adjourned the matter until October to see whether Howard is suitable to serve the sentence in home detention as part of an intensive corrections order. THE mother of a young man killed when his supervisor lost control on a bend and slammed into a power pole at Cardiff has faced the driver in court and said her son's tragic death was the result of "gross, avoidable negligence". Apprentice carpenter Jacob Mostyn, 19, went to work and never came home on November 3, 2023, and now his mother, Christine, says she is living every parent's worst nightmare. Jacob's supervisor, 36-year-old Jeremy Howard, pleaded guilty to negligent driving occasioning death after he lost control of his BMW on a sweeping bend at Munibung Road at Cardiff and slid into a power pole. Jacob, a passenger in the car, was critically injured and died in hospital 11 days later. Howard faced a sentence hearing in Belmont Local Court on Thursday, during which Christine read a powerful victim impact statement, outlining the devastation the crash had caused her family and the promising young man Howard's "reckless choices" had taken away. "Jacob was a passenger in a vehicle driven by his supervisor," Christine said. "Someone entrusted with leadership, responsibility, and the safety of others. "But instead of exercising that duty with care, his supervisor made reckless, negligent choices behind the wheel. "Choices that cost Jacob his life. "Choices that shattered me, my family and his friends forever." Christine described getting the phone call about the crash and the realisation that "every parent's worst nightmare had just become my reality". "I can't describe to you what it's like to bury your child," Christine said. "There is no word in the English language for a parent who loses their child, because it is not supposed to happen. "It's unnatural. It's unbearable. This is my nightmare." Christine detailed all the important life events that had been stolen from her son, from finishing his apprenticeship to buying a home and having a family. "He didn't get to live," she said. "This was all stolen from him and us in a split second." She stressed that her son was not a statistic, that his life mattered and that his death was avoidable. "What makes this so much worse is knowing that his death didn't have to happen," Christine said. "The driver, Jeremy, made decisions that endangered not only my son's life but his own and everyone else on the road that day. "This was negligence. "Gross, avoidable negligence. "The kind that deserves accountability." Finally, with a framed photograph of her son held aloft beside her, she spoke directly to Howard. "I don't hate you," Christine said. "I don't know if I will ever be able to forgive you, but I want you to understand something; you didn't just end my son's life, you ended mine in many ways, too. "You took away my reason for getting up in the morning. "You took away a brother, a grandson, a friend, a mate, a partner, and a young man with so much life left to live. "I hope that you carry that weight every day. "And I hope that, one day, you truly understand the full consequences of what you have done." Crown prosecutor Jillian Kelton had argued the crash involved a significant degree of negligence because Howard was driving too quickly for the sweeping curve, was fatigued and had deactivated the BMW's traction control system, which she said may have prevented the crash. But defence barrister, Ben Bickford, said the degree of negligence was at a lower level and Howard had made an error in judgment and the impact with the pole had occurred a second after he lost traction. Magistrate Stephen Olischlager found the degree of negligence was significant but said Howard had no prior criminal record and was unlikely to re-offend. He said Howard would have to live with causing Jacob's death for the rest of his life and had the physical scars as a reminder of his mistake. Mr Olischlager said he would impose a nine-month sentence, but adjourned the matter until October to see whether Howard is suitable to serve the sentence in home detention as part of an intensive corrections order.
7NEWS
a day ago
- 7NEWS
Man pleads guilty to killing English teacher whose body was found in wheelie bin
A man has admitted to killing a teacher whose body was found inside a wheelie bin. Stephen Fleming formally entered a guilty plea to manslaughter in the Victorian Supreme Court on Thursday after he was originally charged with the murder of Annette Brennan. He admitted to killing the 67-year-old English teacher at Coolaroo in Melbourne's north on July 1, 2024. Tip workers found Brennan's body while moving green waste at a facility in Epping on July 3, the court was previously told. Fleming faced a sentence indication hearing on Tuesday but the court was closed to the media. Details of the manslaughter were not read out during Thursday's brief arraignment hearing. Justice Christopher Beale remanded Fleming in custody ahead of a plea hearing in September. The killer only spoke to formally enter his plea of guilty.
Sydney Morning Herald
a day ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Man admits he killed teacher found in a wheelie bin
Warning: Distressing content A Melbourne man has admitted to killing a teacher whose body was found inside a wheelie bin last year. Stephen Fleming entered a guilty plea to manslaughter in the Victorian Supreme Court on Thursday after he was originally charged with the murder of Annette Brennan. He admitted to killing the 67-year-old English teacher in Coolaroo, in Melbourne's north, on July 1, 2024. Tip workers found Brennan's body while moving green waste at a facility in Epping on July 3, the court was previously told. Fleming faced a sentence indication hearing on Tuesday, but the court was closed to the media. Details of the manslaughter were not read out during Thursday's brief arraignment hearing. Justice Christopher Beale remanded Fleming in custody ahead of his plea hearing in September.
