
North Korea denies warship was severely damaged as full investigation underway on its failed launch
Here is what you need to know about the failed ship launch:
How much damage was there to the ship
North Korea's state news agency, KCNA, said Friday that the severity of the damage to the 5,000-ton-class destroyer was 'not serious' as it cancelled an earlier assessment that the bottom of the hull had been left with holes.
It said the hull on the starboard side was scratched and some seawater had flowed into the stern section. But it said it'll take a total of 10 days to pump up the seawater, set the ship upright and fix the scratches.
It's almost impossible to verify the assessment because of the extremely secretive nature of North Korea. It has a history of manipulating or covering up military-related setbacks, policy fiascoes and other mishaps, though it has periodically acknowledged some in recent years.
Advertisement
Lee Illwoo, an expert with the Korea Defense Network in South Korea, said the North Korean warship likely suffered much worse damage, including the flooding of its engine room located in the stern section, and holes in the starboard. He said North Korea could simply set the ship upright, paint it and claim the ship has been launched, but that repairs could take more than a year as the replacement of an engine requires cutting the hull.
Why the ship's launch failed
According to the North Korean account, the destroyer was damaged when a transport cradle on the ship's stern detached early during a launch ceremony at the northeastern port of Chongjin on Wednesday.
Moon Keun-sik, a navy expert who teaches at Seoul's Hanyang University, said North Korean workers are probably not familiar with launching a 5,000-ton-class warship, which is nearly three times heavier than its existing main navy ships.
Observers say North Korea tried to launch the destroyer sideways, a method it has never used for warships, although it has previously employed it with big cargo and passenger ships.
Compared with those non-military vessels, Lee sad it would be more difficult to maintain balance with the destroyer because it's equipped with heavy weapons systems. He suspected North Korean scientists and workers likely did not factor that in.
How Kim has reacted
The damaged ship is assessed as the same class as North Korea's first destroyer, launched with great fanfare last month with a floating dry dock at a western shipyard. It is North Korea's biggest and most advanced warship to date, and Kim called its construction 'a breakthrough' in modernizing North Korea's naval forces to cope with what he calls U.S.-led security threats.
Advertisement
Subsequently, a failure to launch the second destroyer was an embarrassment for Kim. But by disclosing it to both internally and externally, Kim could be trying to show his resolve in modernizing naval forces and boost discipline at home. He ordered officials to thoroughly investigate the case and repair the warship before a high-level ruling Workers' Party meeting in late June.
North Korea said Friday the country's Central Military Commission summoned Hong Kil Ho, manager of the Chongjin shipyard, as it begun its investigation of the failed launch.
'No matter how good the state of the warship is, the fact that the accident is an unpardonable criminal act remains unchanged, and those responsible for it can never evade their responsibility for the crime,' the commission said, according to state media.
Kim Dong-yub, a professor at the University of North Korean Studies in Seoul, said North Korea appears to be using the failed launch as a chance to strengthen the ruling party's control over science and technological sectors.
Lee Choon Geun, an honorary research fellow at South Korea's Science and Technology Policy Institute, said that North Korea's handling of the damaged warship could have long-term consequences for its defense science sector, especially if military scientists face harsh punishment.
'If scientists are held severely accountable, I would say the future of North Korea's defense science doesn't look very bright, as it would be a sign that political responsibility is being prioritized over technical accountability,' Lee wrote on Facebook.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


UPI
27-06-2025
- UPI
On This Day, June 27: Dennis Rader pleads guilty to 'BTK' slayings
1 of 6 | On June 27, 2005, Dennis Rader, the so-called "BTK" (bind, torture, kill) killer, pleaded guilty to 10 slayings in the Wichita, Kan., area. He was sentenced to life in prison. File Phot courtesy of the Sedgwick County Sheriff's Dept. | License Photo On this date in history: In 1829, English scientist James Smithson left a will that eventually funded the establishment of the Smithsonian Institution in Washington -- in a country he never visited. In 1844, Mormon founder Joseph Smith was slain by a mob at a jail in Carthage, Ill. In 1847, the first telegraph wire links were established between New York City and Boston. In 1859, Louisville, Ky., schoolteacher Mildred Hill composed a tune for her students and called it "Good Morning To You." Her sister, Patty, who wrote the lyrics, later added a verse that began "Happy Birthday To You." In 1950, U.S. President Harry S. Truman ordered naval and air forces to help repel the North Korean invasion of South Korea. UPI File Photo In 1979, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled private employers could give special preferences to Black people to eliminate "manifest racial imbalance" in traditionally white-only jobs. In 1991, Associate Justice Thurgood Marshall announced he was retiring from the U.S. Supreme Court. He was the first African American to sit on the high court. In 1995, the space shuttle Atlantis was launched from Cape Canaveral, Fla., on a historic mission to dock with the Russian space station Mir. Docking occurred two days later. In 2003, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission opened a long-awaited nationwide registry for people who want to block unwanted telemarketing calls. In 2005, Dennis Rader, the so-called "BTK" (bind, torture, kill) killer, pleaded guilty to 10 slayings in the Wichita, Kan., area. He was sentenced to life in prison. In 2007, Tony Blair officially stepped down after a decade as British prime minister, submitting his resignation to Queen Elizabeth II. Blair was succeeded by Gordon Brown and became Britain's envoy to the Middle East. File Photo by Hugo Philpott/UPI In 2009, a top health official said the H1N1 virus, known as swine flu, killed 127 people of the more than 1 million infected in the United States. About 3,000 were reported hospitalized. In 2011, a federal court jury in Chicago convicted former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich on 17 felony corruption charges that included trying to sell the U.S. Senate seat vacated by Barack Obama after the 2008 presidential election. Blagojevich was sentenced to 14 years in prison. In 2017, the FARC rebel group officially disarmed in a ceremony with the Colombian government. In 2019, the Supreme Court ruled the federal government can't include a question about citizenship in the U.S. census. In 2023, producers of Wheel of Fortune announced Ryan Seacrest would succeed Pat Sajak as the host of the long-running game show. Sajak's final episode aired June 7, 2024.
Yahoo
12-06-2025
- Yahoo
North Korea's Partially Sunk Frigate Has Already Been Ceremoniously Relaunched
New satellite imagery indicates that North Korea has held a new launch ceremony or a similar event for its second Choi-Hyun class frigate, or that one may be imminent. The warship is currently in a dry dock after a botched launch attempt in May that left it partially sunk. TWZ obtained the new images of the frigate, the name of which has not yet been publicly announced, which were taken today, from our friends at Maxar Technologies. The initial failed launch occurred on May 21 in the port city of Chongjin. The ship had been righted by June 2 and was subsequently towed to the dry dock facility in the port city of Rajin to the northeast. 'On today's imagery, a large crowd of spectators are seen on the dock next to the destroyer, ceremonial flags are seen hanging on the ship and dozens of buses are positioned nearby that brought people to the ceremony,' Maxar noted in a statement accompanying the images. In addition, the imagery shows what looks to be pavilions, viewing stands, and/or other temporary structures that align with a major event like a launch ceremony. Those structures are also not present in an earlier image from Maxar taken on June 8 after the ship's arrival in Rajin. At the time of writing, there do not appear to be any announcements about a new ceremony around the ship from North Korean state media, at least in English. As TWZ has noted from the start, state outlets in the Hermit Kingdom have been unusually proactive in reporting on the incident, likely to keep ahead of the narrative. In the imagery now available, the second Choi-Hyun class frigate looks strikingly pristine, at least externally, as well. To what extent this is just a facade is unknown, but there was significant structural damage to the superstructure plainly visible as recently as June 8, as seen below. How the North Koreans were able to achieve this 'restoration,' even superficially, is unclear. It also raises the question of whether a swap-out with the first-in-class Choi-Hyun might have occurred. However, this seems close to an impossibility based on a review of other satellite images, including of Choi-Hyun's homeport in Nampo on North Korea's western coast, all the way on the opposite side of the peninsula. That ship appears to be visible in port in available low-resolution imagery. There is also no evidence of a swap-out in low-resolution images of Raijin since June 8. Furthermore, North Korea sending a warship from one side of the Korean Peninsula to the other would be a major move that would be exceedingly hard, if not impossible, to make without incident. Maritime boundaries between North and South Korea are heavily monitored and have been the site of violent skirmishes in the past. The full scale and scope of the damage that the second frigate suffered during the failed launch, and what actual repairs have been made so far, also remain unclear. The North Koreans were able to meet an ambitious goal of having the ship at least righted within 10 days of the initial incident. It is still highly questionable whether they will be truly able to meet an additional directive to restore the ship to its prior condition before the end of this month. As TWZ previously explained: 'The ship clearly has structural damage to its superstructure, with mangled metal and bent lines appearing in the satellite images. Some areas of the ship were flooded with seawater, which would have had a major impact on any machinery and electronics in those areas. All this will take time to remediate, and we still don't know the condition of the ship's hull, although it did make the 50-mile voyage to its current resting spot.' 'This is a large and complex vessel for North Korea to repair, and the facilities at Rajin are not extensive. It is still possible that the North Koreans are getting help from China or Russia, something we had initially speculated. The latter of the two, in particular, is working extensively with Pyongyang in terms of military assistance in return for North Korea's support of its invasion of Ukraine. The location of the ship near the Russian border in an economic zone dominated by cross-border trade also points to the possibility that Moscow is lending a hand.' From the start, there has been a clear incentive for authorities in North Korea to at least claim that the ship has been fixed in record time. The initial incident was highly embarrassing and impossible to hide, with state media having made clear the furor of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un over what had happened right in front of him. A number of officials from the Chongjin Shipyard have been detained as part of an ongoing investigation. At least one senior party official has been at least summoned before the state law enforcement apparatus, as well. In addition, the heavily armed Choi-Hyun class frigates represent a major new development for North Korea's navy, though there are still questions about the full extent of their capabilities, as you can read more about in our past reporting on the first of these warships. If a new launch ceremony has now been held, or is about to occur, and goes off without incident, it is likely that North Korean media will then publish propaganda pictures from the event that could offer additional clues as to the actual state of the second Choi-Hyun class frigate. Contact the author: joe@


American Military News
06-06-2025
- American Military News
North Korean warship that tipped over during launch is upright again
This article was originally published by Radio Free Asia and is reprinted with permission. A North Korean warship that tipped over during its launch ceremony as the supreme leader looked on appears to have been righted, satellite imagery shows. The U.S.-based website 38 North, which specializes in North Korea, said that imagery taken on Monday showed the 5,000-ton naval destroyer now standing upright at a shipyard in the northeastern port city of Chongjin. The warship fell sideways into the sea during its launch at the shipyard on May 21, stoking the anger of leader Kim Jong Un, who called it a 'grave and unacceptable accident' and a 'serious criminal act.' He had demanded the vessel be fully restored before a key ruling party meeting later this month. Monday's imagery shows the vessel upright for the first time, with its bow on land, 38 North said. While parts of the ship remain obscured by thin cloud cover, the helipad markings near the stern are clearly visible, it said. 38 North said the recovery operation was likely conducted manually. In satellite imagery taken on May 29, workers could be seen pulling ropes attached to the vessel from the dock. More than 30 flotation balloons had been placed along one side of the warship apparently to help lift it upright. Imagery also suggested potential damage to the ship's sonar system, located on the lower hull. 38 North noted that any repair would require dry-docking the vessel, adding that Chongjin Shipyard lacks the necessary facilities, such as a large floating dock. North Korea's state-run Korean Central News Agency had reported on May 23 that contrary to initial assumptions, no hull breach had occurred. It stated that draining the flooded compartments and restoring balance would take two to three days, while full side repairs would require roughly 10 days. Choi Il, director of South Korea's Submarine Research Institute, told Radio Free Asia on Wednesday that the warship's upright position represents significant progress in North Korea's recovery effort. 'Since the ship has been righted, it's fair to say that a substantial step has been taken,' Choi said. 'There may have been some flooding, but probably nothing severe.' While acknowledging the technical limitations of North Korea's shipbuilding sector, Choi said the country has built up a degree of expertise over time. 'North Korea's capabilities are not to be underestimated. Their shipbuilding may be outdated, but they do have experience,' he said. Retired U.S. Navy Capt. James Fanell, former director of intelligence for the U.S. Pacific Fleet, echoed that assessment, and said that fear of the supreme leader would have been a strong incentive to get the job done. 'My take on this is that the power of life and death has a remarkable impact on one's abilities,' Fanell told RFA. 'In this case, it is clear that Kim Jong Un has threatened people with severe penalties if they were unable to meet his timeline for getting this destroyer upright and fixed.' State media reported on May 25 that several officials from the Chongjin Shipyard have been arrested over the launch failure. Last year, a South Korean news outlet reported that North Korean officials were shot to death after devastating floods hit part of the communist country. Although the warship launch accident was a major embarrassment for Pyongyang, Fanell said the recovery was likely more manageable because the ship had not sunk or been lost at sea. 'While it is a national embarrassment, the ship was not in the open ocean and it did not sink,' he said. 'So, in essence, this was a 'controlled evolution' — one that would have the highest attention and support from the top to get it upright.' Doubts remain, however, about whether North Korea can fully restore the vessel. On May 27, the Beyond Parallel project at the Center for Strategic and International said it would be difficult to return the ship to pre-launch condition. It noted that realignment, replacement of electronics and wiring, and removal of saltwater corrosion would require extensive work.