Unions to vote on Leaving Cert reform proposals after talks end
Talks aimed at easing teachers' concerns about proposed incoming changes to the Leaving Cert between the post-primary teacher unions and the education minister have concluded.
Both the Association of Secondary Teachers Ireland (ASTI) and Teachers' Union of Ireland (TUI) are to now put Helen McEntee's latest proposals on senior cycle reform to a vote of their members.
Both unions had strongly opposed the Leaving Cert reforms, set to begin in September, with teachers raising concerns around the readiness of schools to roll out the changes, along with the introduction of new project work components.
This project work, called additional assessment components (AACs), is to be worth at least 40% of a student's overall grade in a subject.
Many teachers have also raised concerns around the authentication of work completed as part of these components given the rapid advancements in AI technology.
Last month, teaching delegates passed emergency motions at their annual congress calling for their unions to take industrial action if this round of talks failed to 'deliver an acceptable outcome".
The TUI is recommending that its members accept the negotiated proposals published on Thursday night in an upcoming ballot.
The ASTI has yet to decide which way it will advise its members to vote. The union's leadership and executive committees are due to meet in the coming days to consider the proposals.
On Thursday night, education minister Helen McEntee said: 'It is now a matter for the ASTI and TUI to consider this package as part of their own processes.'
Proceeding with the introduction of new and revised subjects under senior cycle redevelopment in September is in the best interest of students
'It will help to reduce the pressure faced by students, while recognising a broader range of skills and ensuring that students have the skills necessary to thrive and succeed in a rapidly changing world.'
Working groups
The proposals include the establishment of various working groups to support the implementation of the senior cycle reform programme, including in areas related to AI, and the implementation of this agreement and workload in schools.
It also includes a 'commitment' to early rapid reviews of revised subjects, including their assessment arrangements and emerging trends in student uptake levels, as well as the development of a right to disconnect policy applicable to schools.
According to the TUI, the proposals also include the payment of the 3% pay increase due under the local bargaining provision of the current public service agreement for co-operation with senior cycle.
The proposals on the table also include a 'rebalancing' of the "Croke Park hours" to allow for teacher-led activities related to senior xycle, as well as a shorter qualifying period of one year for teachers to attain permanency.
The accelerated pace of redevelopment has led to significant concerns from TUI members, TUI president David Waters said on Thursday.
The TUI executive committee has assessed the document and is recommending that members accept it, he added.
'The union believes that these proposals are the best that that could be achieved through negotiation, and that they have the potential to allay concerns expressed by teachers in terms of both workload and the resources required by schools and teachers to implement senior cycle redevelopment," he said.
'In a separate ballot, the union will seek that — in the event of the negotiated document not being accepted — members vote to engage in a campaign of industrial action, up to and including strike action.'
Ballot material will be issued to TUI members next week.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Could you pass English paper 1? First Leaving Cert exams of 2025 'very balanced'
Podcasting, underdogs, a 'love letter to Ireland', a rally cry to young people from the author of The Handmaid's Tale and an extract from the Booker Prize winner all featured on the higher level 2025 English paper 1. Overall, the first papers to open the 2025 Leaving Cert exams were 'very balanced' and themed around perspectives. Podcasting and poetry made appearances on the Junior Cycle papers, where a question on short stories may have caused some students to stumble. There were lots of opportunities for students when it came to the higher level English paper 1 Leaving Cert questions, according to Kate Barry. The English teacher with Loreto Secondary School, College Road in Fermoy and subject spokesperson for the Association of Secondary Teachers Ireland (ASTI) said she believed this year's papers were 'very fair on the whole.' 'I really liked the three texts they gave,' she added. This included an article by science writer David Robson, a speech made by Margaret Atwood, author of The Handmaid's Tale, and an extract from Samantha Harvey's 2024 novel Orbital which won last year's Booker Prize. In her speech, Margaret Atwood gives advice to young people, referring to herself, 'a wise old counsellor'. 'It's good to see someone of her calibre appearing,' Ms Barry said. "There was a good level of challenge in the Section A questions.' 'The three questions were very similar, they were very consistent, and nice and general. They asked students to write about elements of language that are elegant, thought-provoking, or inspiring. Sometimes those questions can be very 'tick the box', whereas I thought this was nice and broad, you can bring in a lot there. However, she was more critical of the paper's Question Bs, which carry 50 marks. In particular, a question that asked students to imagine they are a contributor to a podcast while reflecting on how their perspective on a significant issue changed. 'I don't see why that question needs to be for a podcast,' Ms Barry said. 'It's a lovely invitation to write, it's a very nice topic and encourages them to think and reflect, but I don't see why it needs to be for a podcast.' 'I think they are trying to be current, and they think 'well a lot of people listen to podcasts'.' The other two Question Bs were more creative, asking students to imagine they are either a sports captain or a hotel manager. 'Not everybody is up for that so it was good to have a question where they could write as themselves.' Meanwhile, the higher-level essay topics, which carry 100 marks, were 'really nice'. 'There were some really nice options there, I thought,' Ms Barry said. In particular, she liked the option that asked students to write a speech for or against the motion that: Truth has become a valueless currency in today's world. 'I really like the questions where students can take it personally, and can write about their own lives, but there was plenty of scope there if they do want to engage in current events.' Another of the questions she liked was the option to write a love letter to Ireland. 'Some of these essay questions can be a bit doom and gloom, but this question asked students to view contemporary Ireland from an optimistic lens. It gives them an opportunity to be positive, which actually can be a challenge.' The only essay question she has concerns about was one asking students to reflect on some of the factors that would influence their voting intentions in future elections. 'You'd really expect and hope that all the people correcting that would put their own views to the side. I don't think it would be a popular one anyway." Ordinary level English paper 1 The ordinary level English paper 1 had some 'accessible' texts that included extracts from the writing of Paul Howard and Rosaleen McDonagh as well a visual image question themed around 'Love in Many Guises' which included song lyrics from The Beatles, Ed Sheeran and Taylor Swift as well as Mark Twain and Lao Tzu among others. In particular, Ms Barry liked the essay question on this paper that asked students to reflect on the importance of people standing up for their views and beliefs. "Sometimes people have different reasons for taking ordinary level English,' she said. 'Sometimes they haven't been in Ireland very long and wouldn't have enough English to do the higher-level paper but they would be well able to come up with their own thoughts and opinions. "It's not aimed too young, it takes into account that they are emerging adults, grappling with adult themes too.' Junior Cycle Overall, the Junior Cycle papers were 'lovely and clear', Ms Barry said. Similarly, the idea of perspectives came up on the Junior Cycle exam. Podcasting made another appearance on the 2025 Junior Cycle exam, with a question based around 'The Black & Irish Podcast'. However, a question asking students to write about a short story they have covered may have caused some to stumble. 'That technically is on the course, it is a specification but that specification is huge,' Ms Barry explained. 'The amount of material they must cover on it, and that is the first year they have specifically been asked to cover a short story they have studied. It's very, very difficult to teach the whole specification,' she added. 'I would expect they would interpret short stories there liberally when they go to correct it. It's something they might not have done. They would have read them as part of the Junior Cycle, but they mightn't have been expecting them as an exam question.' 'It's come up in the past to write their own short story, rather than analyse one as a text. Some of our students here, they were able to take something they had read and answer that way but I do think out of all the questions, that was so new and that would have been the one that caused some to stumble.' 'That will all be reflected when they come to the marking scheme, I would reassure people about that.' The ordinary level Junior Cycle paper was very 'nice and straightforward', she added. 'I'm not sure about this way they have of testing vocabulary where they ask what this word means, and they mightn't know the word, they just get given a random five words, but overall, I did think it was very candidate friendly.' Read More Record number of students to sit State exams this year
Irish Independent
13 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Will the Class of 2025 be the last traditional Leaving Cert year – or will reforms be voted down?
Members of the Teachers' Union of Ireland (TUI) have already voted to accept proposed Leaving Certificate reforms ahead of industrial action. However, the Association of Secondary Teachers in Ireland (ASTI) will announce its ballot of members on Friday. The union has not recommended a decision to its members. Originally both unions had been firmly against reforms to be rolled out in September. Educators raised concerns regarding a lack of preparation and a lack of resources. Tying reform to work and pay conditions is also really not right Lesley Byrne, principal of Clogher Road Community College in Crumlin, south Dublin, told the Irish Independent: 'Senior cycle reform is absolutely welcome and is long overdue. But the crux of the issue is that teachers feel, or have a sense, that the reform is being done to them instead of with them or by them. 'It really shouldn't be a situation where every time we have to have some reform, it ends up in unions having to balance their members. And tying reform to work and pay conditions is also really not right.' Teachers are at risk of losing up to 5pc of their salary if the move to put reforms in place isn't accepted, which makes it likely the motion will pass. In April, teachers also raised an alarm that reform was taking place without proper safeguards around artificial intelligence, which could potentially be used to gain an upper hand in written assessments. 'There's really genuine questions to be asked about the disparity in resources that different schools have access to,' Ms Byrne said. 'Some schools have good lab equipment and wifi, others don't. It might be assumed that every school has good wifi. That's not always the case. Things like that absolutely have to be addressed. 'The central issue is the CAO. It still has such a hold over the Leaving Cert system. Therefore teachers and school staff are so conscious that any minor change or any further disadvantage of some students could have a huge impact in terms of the CAO and what points students get – which obviously could have a bigger knock-on impact. 'If we really want to reform the senior cycle, none of that, I believe, can be done without a proper reform of the CAO system as it stands.' In April, teaching delegates passed emergency motions at their annual congress calling for their unions to move on industrial action if talks with the department failed to 'deliver an acceptable outcome". But educational sources believe it's inevitable the ASTI will also vote for changes, given the tie-in with wages at a time when house prices are rising and the cost of living is increasing. Resources remain a problem in some schools Concerns have been raised on the additional resourcing necessary to ensure no students are at a disadvantage due to reforms, particularly those in Deis schools. Paul Crone, director of the National Association of Principals and Deputy Principals (NAPD), said while he felt reform is the 'correct direction of travel, resources remain a problem in some schools'. 'The department has committed to doing a survey to see how many schools this applies to but there's no doubt the science labs are a critical issue,' Mr Crone added. 'There's been a pause to the Summer Works Scheme in the last few years, where updates to science labs and facilities were made. Upgrades are now critical for reform to take place. 'The Additional Assessment Component (AAC) is essential to all of this. That's to help students to spread the assessment load and for the Leaving Cert to be less of a burden on them.' Under the reform plans, the AAC would see students assessed on skills and knowledge in addition to traditional written exams, worth a minimum of 40pc of the overall grade. The AAC is expected to come in the form of practical experiments, research projects, performance assessments or the creation of projects. The class of 2026 sits on the precipice of potential historic changes to the Leaving Cert, often viewed as the most important exam of a student's life. But observers say investigation from decision-makers is also vital to establish if reforms will actually go far enough to increase equity in the Leaving Cert and higher education system. Mr Crone said reform would really be 'worthless unless we tackle how students gain entry into Higher Education via the CAO'. 'We need to take back control in post-primary education,' he added. 'Second-level education needs to be exactly that and not a filter for higher education.' The Irish Independent has asked the Department of Education for a response.
RTÉ News
19 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Record number of students to begin Leaving and Junior Cert exams
A record number of candidates will begin the State Leaving and Junior Certificate exams today. 140,457 students will sit the exams, the first time the number has exceeded 140,000. The rise is due to population growth. 61,632 candidates will take the main Leaving Certificate written exams over the next several weeks, an increase of 5% compared to last year. There has been an 11% rise in students opting for the Leaving Certificate Applied programme. 4,512 students have chosen that pathway. 74,313 candidates will begin their Junior Cycle exams this morning. The State exams will take place in examination centres across more than 800 post-primary schools and other centres across the country. The State Examinations Commission has described the process as "a massive logistical exercise involving the secure distribution of circa four million examination papers". The exams begin at 9.30am with English Paper 1 for most Leaving Certificate students. LCA and Junior Cycle candidates will also sit English papers. The last Leaving Certificate exam takes place on 24 June. Leaving Certificate results this year will once again be artificially inflated through a post-marking adjustment which will be applied after all marking of individual papers has been completed. Post-marking adjustments were introduced following the Covid pandemic in an attempt to compensate students who had missed out as a result of school closures and other restrictions arising from the pandemic. Following a request from the Department of Education and in order to facilitate a gradual return to normal pre-Covid outcomes, this year's post-marking adjustment will be reduced to bring results in aggregate on average to a point broadly midway between 2020 and 2021 levels. Leaving Certificate results will be issued to candidates on Friday 22 August. The State Examinations Commission said this date took account of the time needed to apply the post-marking adjustment. It said the timeline for results also had to allow sufficient time for an extensive range of quality assurance checks to be undertaken. Minister for Education Helen McEntee is among many public figures and organisations who have wished the Class of 2025 good luck. Sending her best wishes, Ms McEntee said: "I know the amount of work and effort you have put in to reach this point. It is the culmination of many years of effort. "This can be a very stressful time so I would remind everyone that when it comes to examinations, all we can do is our best. "We are all very much behind you over the next few weeks, and I know that regardless of the outcome of these examinations, there will be many great opportunities ahead for you all," she said.
