'Lying and dishonest': RFK Jr. grilled over error-ridden MAHA report during House hearing
Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. was on the defense Tuesday during an appearance before a House subcommittee. While Kennedy was there to answer questions about his department's fiscal 2026 budget request, Democratic lawmakers seized on the opportunity to grill him over three-plus hours.
Democratic Rep. Raul Ruiz of California used his time to question Kennedy about 'The MAHA Report: Make Our Children Healthy Again.' The congressman asked whether Kennedy, as chair of the Make America Healthy Again Commission, had read and fact-checked the report's sources before publication.
After Kennedy conceded that he had not fact-checked the report, Ruiz pointed out that the document had several citation errors, with references to papers that do not exist.
'How does that happen under your leadership, sir?' Ruiz asked. Kennedy responded by telling the congressman that 'all of the foundational assertions in that report are accurate.'
'They did not exist,' Ruiz interjected. 'How can they be accurate if they did not exist, sir?'
Ruiz added: 'I was a premed [student] at UCLA. … If somebody turned this in, as an undergrad, to their professor at UCLA, they would have received an 'F,' sir, an 'F' — for the misinterpretation, the falsehoods, the denials, and also citing references that don't even exist. That's lying and dishonest, sir.'
When it came time for Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to question Kennedy, the New York Democrat asked whether he knew that the Justice Department is reportedly investigating UnitedHealth Group over allegations of Medicare fraud.
'I am not aware of that investigation,' Kennedy replied.
Ocasio-Cortez appeared to be in disbelief: 'You are not aware that the Trump Department of Justice is investigating the largest insurance company in America for fraud in Medicare Advantage?'
Kennedy repeated that he was not aware but said it did not surprise him.
At one point, the hearing was halted after Kennedy hurled accusations at Rep. Frank Pallone after the New Jersey Democrat questioned the health secretary about his recent changes to the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, or ACIP.
'You have made a number of major decisions about vaccines. And … there's been no public comment process or public accountability on that either. What are you afraid of?' Pallone asked.
He added: 'The bottom line is here: We have no transparency. ... You feel no responsibility to Congress whatsoever, and you just continue this ideology that's anti-science, anti-vaccine.'
While answering a subsequent question from Rep. Neal Dunn, R-Fla., Kennedy turned back to Pallone and accused him of changing his views on vaccines after allegedly receiving money from pharmaceutical companies.
'Fifteen years ago, you and I met. You were, at that time, a champion for people who had suffered injuries from vaccines. ... Since then, you've accepted $2 million from pharmaceutical companies in contributions, more than any other member of this committee,' Kennedy alleged. 'And your enthusiasm for supporting the old ACIP committee, which was completely rife and pervasive with pharmaceutical conflicts, seems to be an outcome of those contributions.'
Rep. Diana DeGette, D-Colo., quickly raised a point of order with the subcommittee's chair, Republican Rep. Buddy Carter of Georgia, accusing Kennedy of 'impugning the reputation of a member of Congress.'
Shortly thereafter, Carter said DeGette had raised a valid point of order, and he asked the health secretary to 'please take back those words.'
'They're retracted,' Kennedy said.
This article was originally published on MSNBC.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
18 minutes ago
- Politico
RFJ Jr. says US won't donate to global vaccine effort
The United States won't contribute anymore to Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, until the global health organization has 're-earned the public trust,' U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said Wednesday. In an inflammatory video speech delivered to the Gavi pledging summit, seen by POLITICO, Kennedy accused Gavi of neglecting vaccine safety, making questionable recommendations around Covid-19 vaccines and silencing dissenting views. 'When the science was inconvenient, Gavi ignored the science,' Kennedy alleged. 'I call on Gavi today to re-earn the public trust and to justify the $8 billion that America has provided in funding since 2001,' he said. 'And I'll tell you how to start taking vaccine safety seriously: Consider the best science available, even when the science contradicts established paradigms. Until that happens, the United States won't contribute more to Gavi.' Gavi leaders are in Brussels on Wednesday for the organization's pledging summit, where they are hoping to raise $9 billion for the 2026-2030 period. This will allow another 500 million childhood vaccinations and save at least 8 million lives by 2030, Gavi's plan said. Going into the summit, the question of the U.S. pledge was one of the hottest ones. While an early pledge under former President Joe Biden of $1.58 billion has been announced, it was unclear whether Kennedy was going to commit to this. The Trump administration previously signaled it planned to cut its funding for Gavi, representing around $300 million annually. During his speech, Kennedy accused Gavi and the World Health Organization of working together during the Covid-19 pandemic to 'recommend best practices for social media companies to silence dissenting views, to stifle free speech and legitimate questions during that period.' Facebook and Twitter restricted U.S. President Donald Trump's accounts during the pandemic. Kennedy also criticized what he alleged are Gavi's 'questionable recommendations encouraging pregnant women to receive Covid-19 vaccines.' There are things he 'admires' about Gavi, Kennedy said, such as its commitment to make medicine affordable to all. But in its attempt to promote universal vaccination, he accused Gavi of having 'neglected the key issue of vaccine safety.' 'When vaccine safety issues have come before Gavi, Gavi has treated them not as a patient health problem, but as a public relations problem,' Kennedy alleged. 'Business as usual is over, unaccountable and opaque policymaking is over. I invite all of you to join us in a new era of evidence-based medicine, old-standard science and integrity,' he added. POLITICO has contacted Gavi for a response to Kennedy's accusations. Since Kennedy, a longtime vaccine skeptic, has been health secretary, he has restricted Covid-19 vaccine access and fired all members of the vaccine advisory panel for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, replacing them with his own picks, with several having a controversial history around immunizations.
Politico
18 minutes ago
- Politico
Pritzker to run for a 3rd term
Happy Wednesday, Illinois. New York's ranked choice voting has us interested. TOP TALKER HE's DOING IT: Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker is set to announce on Thursday that he'll seek a third term in 2026, leaving open the possibility that he could also run for president in 2028. The Democratic governor, who's been on a media blitz criticizing President Donald Trump's administration, will make the announcement at events starting Thursday in Chicago before traveling to Springfield and across the state in the coming days, according to two people in the campaign. Pritzker is seen as a shoo-in to win the Democratic primary in March. Republicans have yet to step up with a challenger. Illinois does not have term limits for its statewide offices, though there hasn't been a three-term governor since Republican Gov. Jim Thompson, who won four times and held office from 1977 to 1991. Pritzker's campaign kick-off comes after months of speculation about whether the state's top Democrat would run for re-election at a time of budget uncertainty — and then run for president in 2028, too. Watch for that to be a Republican talking point. Pritzker has headlined numerous national speaking engagements in recent months, fueling the buzz about a presidential run. In an interview with POLITICO, Pritzker insisted he's just trying to bring attention to Illinois and highlight the Trump administration's tariffs and cuts to his constituents. The big question for Thursday's announcement is whether he will also bring out a running mate. We hear that's not likely. Watch him announce his No. 2 down the road, allowing for another media bump. Current Lt. Gov. Juliana Stratton, who has served with him both terms, is now running for the U.S. Senate seat held by the retiring Sen. Dick Durbin. Pritzker self-funded his past two campaigns — spending a combined $350 million to do so — and will do the same this time around. THE BUZZ GETTING INTERESTING: State Rep. Kam Buckner, former County Commissioner Richard Boykin and SEIU's Anthony Driver Jr. are considering running for Congress in the IL-07 District now represented by Rep. Danny Davis. They join a growing list of potential and declared candidates who are tip-toeing around Davis as he has yet to reveal his future political plans. We hear he'll announce in early July. It's starting to irk some folks who wonder if Davis is just holding out to make it hard for candidates to start a campaign, allowing him to open a lane for an anointed candidate. Davis' chief of staff insists the congressman is just 'assessing' his next move. 'More people are telling him to run than telling him not to run,' said Tumia Romero. Our assessment: Davis is 83. His back hurts. And he's facing a political moment of increased scrutiny on age. Meanwhile, potential candidates are waiting in the wings. Buckner is the Illinois speaker pro tempore and co-leader of House budget negotiations and an education and transit modernization advocate. Boykin is a former Cook County commissioner who previously worked as Davis' chief of staff for nearly 10 years. He's an attorney and president of Bridge Builders Consulting and Legal Services. Driver is executive director of the SEIU Illinois State Council and president of the Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability, which works to improve police oversight and public safety. Driver, Boykin and Buckner are still just 'considering' a run and won't jump in until Davis makes an announcement. Announcing Thursday: Marine Corps veteran and Chicago comedian John McCombs, who served as a public affairs officer at Camp Lejeune in North Carolina and currently works at the Naval Station Great Lakes training new sailors. He's also traveled the world doing stand-up comedy, something he started while in college. Politics is part of his show, says the 34-year-old McCombs, who describes himself as progressive. 'My experience as a Marine was to fight and win battles, and as a standup comedian it's to communicate in any room.' He joins state Rep. La Shawn Ford and businessman Jason Friedman, who also have filed to run along with fellow Democrats Kamaria Kali and Jerico Brown. Others still considering: Chicago Ald. Walter Burnett Jr., who serves as vice mayor and is the longest-serving West Side elected official next to Davis; Chicago City Treasurer Melissa Conyears-Ervin, who ran for the seat in 2024; Forest Park Mayor Rory Hoskins; and Metropolitan Water Reclamation District President Kari Steele. You counted right: That's 12 candidates. If you are Danny Davis, Playbook would like to hear from you! Email: skapos@ WHERE'S JB No official public events WHERE's BRANDON At Arie Crown Theater at 9 a.m. for the Chicago Fire Department firefighter and EMT graduation Where's Toni At the Cook County building at 10 a.m. to launch the next phase of the Cook County Down Payment Assistance Program Have a tip, suggestion, birthday, new job or a (gasp!) complaint? Email skapos@ BUSINESS OF POLITICS — IL-09: The progressive 314 Action Fund is endorsing Evanston Mayor Daniel Biss for Illinois' 9th Congressional District. 'He's a proven leader, delivering results rooted in facts and data. As Trump and Republicans try to strip millions of their health care to give tax breaks to billionaires, Daniel will work tirelessly to protect the district,' said Shaughnessy Naughton, the group's president, noting Biss' experience as mayor, state legislator and local activist. 314 Action is a national nonprofit that recruits, trains and helps elect STEM candidates up and down the ballot. — Speaking of IL-09: State Sen. Mike Simmons is considering a run for the congressional seat now held by Rep. Jan Schakowsky. Simmons is taking part in a candidate forum Sunday with other announced candidates. Details here — IL-06 REMATCH: Republican Niki Conforti is running for the seat held by Democratic Congressman Sean Casten. The two faced each other in 2024, too. 'With our strong foundation from the 2024 election and my background in business and policy, I am confident we can flip this seat in 2026,' Conforti said in announcing her campaign. 'People feel disenfranchised. Something needs to give, and I am the change agent.' — Nick Uniejewski has been endorsed by Dick Simpson, the former Chicago alderman and political consultant, in his bid for the 6th District state Senate seat. Uniejewski is a Democrat primarying state Sen. Sara Feigenholtz. THE STATEWIDES — New Illinois laws: Gas tax, hotel offerings set for changes on July 1, via NBC 5 — CDC confirms Illinois' first human case of West Nile virus this year, by USA Today's Hannah Hudnall — Challenges persist for women, minorities breaking into Illinois' skilled trades, by Capitol News' Maggie Dougherty TAKING NAMES — Janice Jackson is stepping down as founding CEO of Hope Chicago, a nonprofit that offers debt-free college scholarships and wrap-around services to students and their parents. She's exiting 'to pursue other career opportunities, effective Aug. 1,' according to a statement. Jackson, the former head of Chicago Public Schools, has been mentioned as a potential 2027 mayoral candidate. — Michael O'Grady has been named chair of the Civic Committee. In his day job, O'Grady is CEO of Northern Trust. He succeeds Jennifer Scanlon, president and CEO of UL Solutions, by Crain's Brandon Dupré. CHICAGO — City mum on what documents it provided ICE in Streets and Sanitation subpoena, by the Tribune's Alice Yin — Bucking policy trend, public access to video of CPD Officer Krystal Rivera's fatal shooting is delayed, by the Tribune's Madeline Buckley and Sam Charles — After objections, Chicago Police agree officers won't search vehicles based on smell of raw cannabis, advocates tell judge, by WTTW's Heather Cherone — New Jersey solar company Nautilus relocates headquarters to Chicago, by the Sun-Times' Abby Miller — Woman charged with driving car through downtown anti-ICE protest, by the Sun-Times' Cindy Hernandez — 'Danke Schoen": Ferris Bueller vest sells for $279,400 at auction, by the Block Club's Gwen Ihnat COOK COUNTY AND COLLARS — Suburban lawmakers, Democratic and Republican, address concerns about political violence: 'It's unfortunately a real consideration that any time I am going to have a public event I have to think about what the security situation is,' said Democratic state Rep. Bob Morgan. 'The temper and tone of political rhetoric has been out of control for quite some time,' added Republican state Rep. Marty McLaughlin, by the Pioneer Press' Daniel I. Dorfman. — DuPage to establish community land bank, trust to incentivize more affordable housing, by the Tribune's Tess Kenny — OPINION: Cook County stands with public servants as feds purge workers, Toni Preckwinkle writes in the Sun-Times Reader Digest We asked who you're hoping the Bulls get in the draft. Brian Caminer: 'Derrick Queen of Maryland.' Rev. Tyrone McGowan: 'Anyone other than another guard.' Ron Michelotti: 'Rasheer Fleming of St. Joseph's College. He's 6-8 and can shoot threes.' Omari Prince: 'Ace Bailey is definitely out of the picture, but I hope the Bulls land Will Riley or Danny Wolf.' Timothy Thomas: 'Another University of Illinois veteran to join Ayo Dusomo, specifically either Kasparas Jakučionis or Will Riley.' Noah Walch: 'Derik Queen seems like the consensus answer and would be fine with me, but something about the height and rawness of Yang Hansen appeals to me. Otherwise, cross your fingers Khaman Maluach falls to 12.' NEXT QUESTION: What do you like or not about ranked-choice voting? THE NATIONAL TAKE — Mamdani topples Cuomo in NYC mayoral primary: It was a race about affordability v. fear and affordability won, by POLITICO's Jeff Coltin and Joe Anuta — Dems struggle to respond as Trump's Iran strikes sow chaos, by POLITICO's Elena Schneider and Nicholas Wu — Rubio credits president for pushing NATO allies to increase spending, by POLITICO's Felicia Schwartz — White House sends Dr. Oz to calm Senate nerves, by POLITICO's Adam Cancryn TRANSITIONS — Paula R. Worthington has been named senior policy adviser at the Civic Federation. She's a long-time senior lecturer at the Harris School of Public Policy at the University of Chicago. EVENTS — July 1: Screening of 'Drop Dead City,' a documentary about New York City's financial crisis in the 1970s. It's presented by the Chicago Policy Center, Civic Federation and Better Government Association. Their pitch: 'What New York fixed with courage and oversight, Chicago can fix too, if we learn from history.' Details here TRIVIA TUESDAY's ANSWER: Congrats to Barbara Flynn Currie for correctly answering that Jeanne Hurley and Paul Simon were Illinois House members (not Senate) who married each other. TODAY's QUESTION: What year did Mayor Richard M. Daley first suggest closing Meigs Field? Email skapos@ HAPPY BIRTHDAY Former state Sen. Mike Jacobs, The Strategy Group partner Aviva Bowen, Globetrotters Engineering CEO Ajay Shah, philanthropy pro Francee Harrington, Fisher Broyle Deputy General Counsel Jayne Reardon, blogger John Kass and Tribune political reporter and POLITICO alum Olivia Olander -30-
The Hill
23 minutes ago
- The Hill
Mamdani declares victory in NYC mayoral primary
New York State Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani declared victory early Wednesday after emerging with a commanding lead over former Gov. Andrew Cuomo in the Democratic mayoral primary's first-choice ballot. Mamdani — a democratic socialist, who ran a progressive campaign focusing on the state's affordability crisis — addressed his supporters at a rally shortly after midnight on Wednesday in Queens. 'Tonight, we made history. In the words of Nelson Mandela, it always seems impossible until it is done,' the 33-year-old state lawmaker said. 'My friends, we have done it. I will be your Democratic nominee for the mayor of New York City.' 'Today, eight months after launching this campaign, with a vision of a city that every New Yorker could afford, we have won,' he added. Mamdani told his supporters during the presser that Cuomo called him an hour earlier to concede the race and that he stressed to the former governor 'the need to bring this city together.' 'I will be the mayor for every New Yorker, whether you voted for me, for Governor Cuomo, or felt too disillusioned by a long-broken political system to vote at all, I will fight for a city that works for you, that is affordable for you, that is safe for you,' he said. No candidate won a majority in the first-choice ballots, but Cuomo trailed Mamdani by a significant margin and would have a difficult path toward victory once the ballots were redistributed in the city's ranked-choice voting system. The former governor congratulated Mamdani and also told his supporters that he conceded. 'Tonight was Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani's night,' Cuomo said, adding, 'Tonight is his night. He deserved it. He won.' Incumbent New York City Mayor Eric Adams was not on the ballot in the Tuesday primary election, instead opting to run as an independent in the general election in November. Republican Curtis Silwa, who founded the Guardian Angels, is also running in the general election. Cuomo could decide, too, to run as an independent in the general election. 'We're going to take a look. We'll make some decisions,' he told his supporters. The governor who resigned from his position during the COVID-19 pandemic had been seen as the favorite in the race — but Mamdani managed to pull off a stunning upset. As of Wednesday morning, Mamdani leads with 43.5 percent of first ballot voters, according to Decision Desk HQ estimates. Cuomo trails with 36.4 percent followed by New York City Comptroller Brad Lander — who entered the national spotlight earlier this month after being arrested by immigration officials — with 11.3 percent and City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams with 4.1 percent.
