The concept album is dead – and it was never great to begin with
There is no greater example of musical verschlimmbessern than that of the concept album – vaguely defined as a record designed around a central narrative, a unifying theme or a particular artistic device. The definition may be hazy, but the very whiff of it sends music critics into fits of schwärmerei (German for 'unbridled and excessive enthusiasm').
The intention is to elevate an LP into a literary work of art, and the artist into a mythical genius. Yet more often than not, the 'concept' serves only to confuse and complicate, resulting in a record that succeeds neither as a collection of songs nor a cohesive piece of storytelling – a half-built ship with a fancy paint job, lost in a desolate sea of compromised ideas.
The concept album emerged in the 1960s, with Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band by the Beatles and its like, and it endures to this day. The Waterboys just released Life, Death and Dennis Hopper, inspired by the Hollywood icon, and Car Seat Headrest will release The Scholars in early May, told from the perspective of various students at a fictional college.
It's an exciting idea. Taking a listener on a sonic journey, immersing them in an experience that is both cinematic and enthralling. Occasionally, it works: Kendrick Lamar's good kid, m.A.A.d city, for example, transports us to one particularly wild day in the Compton of Kendrick's childhood, explores characters with depth and provides narrative payoff to those who listen from start to finish. The result is the greatest album of the 21st century.
But make no mistake: this is the exception, not the rule. Almost always, a concept album (no matter how good the concept might be on paper) quickly devolves into a conceited exercise in ego and forced-together puzzle pieces. Whether the artist is trying to tell an overarching story, write songs from different perspectives, or experiment with the form itself, it's nearly impossible to pull off.
Some concept albums try to reinvent the wheel, and find themselves buried beneath their ambition, with the gimmick swamping the songs themselves. Commercial Album by the Residents consists of 40 songs, all one minute long. It's a fun idea, but it runs out of juice quickly, becoming tedious and distracting. The Turtles Present the Battle of the Bands sees the Turtles pretend to be 12 bands across 12 songs of wildly different genres, including country, psychedelia, surf rock, pop and R&B – a baffling listening experience.
Far worse is the narrative-driven concept album. If, when you look up a recipe online, your favourite part is the long, needlessly complicated story serving no purpose and obscuring the actual food, then concept albums are for you!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
12 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Fake heiress Anna ‘Delvey' Sorokin cops death threats after rabbits used in photo shoot dumped in park
Anna 'Delvey' Sorokin says she has received hundreds of death threats since she was accused of dumping pet rabbits she posed with for a photo shoot in a New York City park. Sorokin, the fake German heiress who stole tens of thousands of dollars from banks, posed alongside three bunnies on the streets of Manhattan's posh Tribeca neighborhood last week. The bunnies were recognised and discovered in Brooklyn's Prospect Park days later, prompting fierce online backlash. But the headline-making New York City socialite — who vehemently denied responsibility for the discarded bunnies — said she's particularly shocked by the strong reaction to the incident. 'It just seems to me like everything I do is just wrong,' Sorokin said. 'I can never do right by these people.' Sorokin shared screenshots of dozens of hateful messages she has received within the last few days to her Instagram account — which she called 'unusable'. Some of them suggest that she should be killed or take her own life, including one that advises her to get someone to 'make a carpet out of your skin'. 'It seems like a lot of these people, just because they're engaged in animal rescue, they feel like they're entitled to insult you or talk to you or say anything because they're hiding behind this thing that they're doing,' she said. Sorokin, 34, whose life was depicted in Netflix's hit 2022 series Inventing Anna, took the photos with the bunnies on August 3 to create content for Instagram, where she has more than 1.1 million followers. Shortly before the shoot, Sorokin asked whether any of her followers in the New York City metropolitan area had a pet rabbit she could borrow, she said. Christian Batty, 19, a hairstylist Sorokin met briefly last year, reached out and offered what he described as a friend's rabbits, she said. Sorokin added that she paid Batty to provide the rabbits and for his Uber ride to return the rabbits to their owner in Yonkers — or so she thought. A screenshot of an Uber receipt Sorokin shared with NBC News shows the ride's drop-off location was just south of Prospect Park, where the rabbits were later spotted. Days later, she said, she started receiving messages on social media about the rabbits' being spotted in Prospect Park. A Facebook user posted images of the domesticated bunnies in the park to a public Facebook group dedicated to rabbits, House Rabbit Society, and other users connected them to Sorokin's photos. Sorokin initially thought the posts were fake, but the flood of messages did not stop. At first, Batty denied having dumped the rabbits, according to screenshots of text messages between Sorokin, Batty and photographer Jasper Soloff. Sorokin posted those messages on her Instagram story. 'Jasper had no knowledge or input as to how the bunnies were obtained or what happened to them after the photo shoot,' Soloff's attorney, Gary Adelman, said in a statement. Batty did not immediately reply to a request for comment. Hours later, Batty said, he did dump the rabbits, and he absolved Sorokin of any involvement, according to a statement on his Instagram account, which has since been taken down. 'When I realised the rabbits were being surrendered to me, I panicked,' Batty said in the statement, screenshots of which Sorokin provided. 'At 19, with no experience caring for animals, no pet-friendly housing, and no knowledge of available resources, I felt overwhelmed and made the worst possible choice.' 'Believing, mistakenly, that there were existing rabbits in that area, I released them there, thinking that was my best option,' he added. Sorokin pushed back against the notion that Batty's age was an issue. 'He's old enough to move to New York and live on his own. He should have enough common sense to handle rabbits,' she said. 'We're not, like, asking him to do anything that requires high IQ from him.' Sorokin said she was concerned about how the incident might affect her pending immigration case. A Manhattan jury convicted Sorokin in April 2019 on four counts of theft services, three counts of grand larceny and one count of attempted grand larceny after she was accused of defrauding banks and friends of tens of thousands of dollars. Prosecutors said she persuaded friends and businesses to lend her money to afford a lavish lifestyle under the guise that she was the daughter of an oil baron or a diplomat worth tens of millions of dollars. In 2021, Sorokin was released on parole, and she is fighting deportation. She has been required to wear an electronic ankle monitor and cannot leave a 120km house arrest radius based in New York. 'This time, I've done nothing wrong,' she said. 'And I had the best intentions, and it's really frustrating.' The New York Times reported that the rabbits were rescued by blogger Terry Chao, who spotted them in the park. Chao could not immediately be reached for comment. Sorokin said she donated $1000 to All About Rabbits Rescue in the aftermath of the scandal. She also denied harming the rabbits by putting them on leashes, as some have suggested online. 'I don't know, I'm not a bunny professional. I didn't know the leashes were such a big deal,' she said. 'We would put them down for, I don't know, a minute or two, take a picture and pick them up. We were not walking them by any means. And they seemed to be happy.'
Sydney Morning Herald
14 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Princess Diana's enduring legacy, from conspiracy theories to drag culture
ROYALS Dianaworld: An Obsession Edward White Allen Lane, $39.99 Some believe she was a republican, some a monarchist. Others argue she was more English than the royal family itself: born into the House of Spencer, she had deeper roots in Britain than the German Windsor bloodline. It's within the margins of this contradictory and contested public image that Edward White situates his new biography, Dianaworld. The book is less interested in the royal's personal life and more in examining the 'story of a cultural obsession'. That is, how Diana as a phenomenon has rippled through popular culture and acted as a vessel for the fantasies of millions. 'In the half century of her existence as a public entity, Diana's mythology has been moulded, burnished, and appropriated by an enormous cast of people,' White writes. She is a figure that endures in the zeitgeist owing to her sudden death in 1997, her sanctified image of motherhood and her postmodern media image (with her face recycled over and over). A kind of phantasmagorical cultural autopsy, the book charts how Diana – the icon as well as the person – has shaped British politics, fuelled conspiracy theories and even influenced drag culture. In her lifetime, Diana had many adoring fans but, unlike many other celebrities, was also able to genuinely relate to people's identification with her. 'I can talk to them because I am one of them,' she once said. An unsettled public image, one that spoke to motherhood, family and even destiny, encouraged many to connect their own emotional lives to Diana's. From gay men coming out of the closet to Pakistani women suffering through arranged marriages, people mediated their own experiences through Princess Diana to find comfort in her outsider story. But was Diana ever knowable? To some, she was damaged and broken; to others, calculating and deliberate. These inconsistencies made for an unstable public persona, one where the truth could be subjective and often hard to pin down. Getting to the 'real' Diana was a press and public addiction, where Diana doing anything – and nothing – could yield profound insights.
The Age
14 hours ago
- The Age
Princess Diana's enduring legacy, from conspiracy theories to drag culture
ROYALS Dianaworld: An Obsession Edward White Allen Lane, $39.99 Some believe she was a republican, some a monarchist. Others argue she was more English than the royal family itself: born into the House of Spencer, she had deeper roots in Britain than the German Windsor bloodline. It's within the margins of this contradictory and contested public image that Edward White situates his new biography, Dianaworld. The book is less interested in the royal's personal life and more in examining the 'story of a cultural obsession'. That is, how Diana as a phenomenon has rippled through popular culture and acted as a vessel for the fantasies of millions. 'In the half century of her existence as a public entity, Diana's mythology has been moulded, burnished, and appropriated by an enormous cast of people,' White writes. She is a figure that endures in the zeitgeist owing to her sudden death in 1997, her sanctified image of motherhood and her postmodern media image (with her face recycled over and over). A kind of phantasmagorical cultural autopsy, the book charts how Diana – the icon as well as the person – has shaped British politics, fuelled conspiracy theories and even influenced drag culture. In her lifetime, Diana had many adoring fans but, unlike many other celebrities, was also able to genuinely relate to people's identification with her. 'I can talk to them because I am one of them,' she once said. An unsettled public image, one that spoke to motherhood, family and even destiny, encouraged many to connect their own emotional lives to Diana's. From gay men coming out of the closet to Pakistani women suffering through arranged marriages, people mediated their own experiences through Princess Diana to find comfort in her outsider story. But was Diana ever knowable? To some, she was damaged and broken; to others, calculating and deliberate. These inconsistencies made for an unstable public persona, one where the truth could be subjective and often hard to pin down. Getting to the 'real' Diana was a press and public addiction, where Diana doing anything – and nothing – could yield profound insights.
