logo
Man who was nearly three times over legal limit has conviction overturned on appeal

Man who was nearly three times over legal limit has conviction overturned on appeal

Sunday World12-07-2025
Daniel Keelan (47) was convicted in the District Court and given a two-year driving disqualification, along with a €200 fine
A man who had denied drunk driving has had his conviction overturned on appeal, after a judge found the validity of the defendant's arrest was in question.
Daniel Keelan (47) with an address in Ashbourne, Co Meath, had pleaded not guilty in the District Court to drink driving in the town on August 21, 2022, contrary to section 4(4)(a) & (5) of the Road Traffic Act 2010.
Mr Keelan was convicted in the District Court and given a two-year driving disqualification, along with a 200 euro fine. He launched an appeal against his conviction, which was heard at the District Court Appeals Court sitting in Trim on Wednesday.
Stock image
News in 90 Seconds - Saturday July 12
Garda Saoirse Horan, of Ashbourne Garda Station, told the court that she was on patrol along Frederick Street in Ashbourne at around 9.55pm when she noticed a black BMW driving at speed past the garda patrol car.
Garda Horan said that she pursued the car but it failed to stop when she indicated for it to do so. She said that the car then turned into the car park of an apartment complex.
She said that when she approached, she observed a male slouched in the driver's seat who refused to get out of the car. She said that the man gave her his licence at the scene, where she said she got Mr Keelan's details and address.
Garda Horan said that Mr Keelan was argumentative with gardai, that there was a strong smell of alcohol coming off him and that his speech was slurred.
Garda Horan said that she cautioned Mr Keelan that he was being arrested under section 4.8 of the Road Traffic Act 2010 and that she handcuffed him due to what she said was his 'initial non-compliance and aggressive demeanour'.
She said that Mr Keelan was taken into custody, where a test for alcohol was carried out which she said recorded an alcohol level of 59mg per 100ml of breath. The legal limit is 22mg of alcohol per 100ml of breath.
Defence counsel for Mr Keelan, Martin Dully BL, said that his client recalls that when the garda vehicle stopped at an angle, a garda member jumped out, immediately pulled open Mr Keelan's door and pulled him out of the vehicle.
Mr Dully said that the first thing Mr Keelan knew about what was happening, he found himself between the garda vehicle and his own with handcuffs on, and the garda hadn't spoken to him.
Garda Horan said that she did not put handcuffs on Mr Keelan without explaining the reason for his arrest.
Mr Keelan also maintained that he could not have been speeding on the road, as there were roadworks and 'traffic bumps' present at the time.
Mr Keelan said that the first time that his driver's licence was requested was in the garda station and not at the scene.
Garda Horan said that she got the information about the defendant's home address being in Ashbourne from his driving licence at the scene of the arrest.
However, Mr Dully produced Mr Keelan's driving licence in court and said it actually reads that his address is in Baldoyle, and so Garda Horan's evidence could not have been correct.
Judge John Martin said that the conflicting information regarding when and where the driver's license was obtained 'casts a doubt' over which version of events is correct.
He said that, as he had a slight doubt about what had happened in the car park, this put the validity of the arrest into question.
Judge Martin decided in those circumstances to allow the appeal of Mr Keelan's conviction.
Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Woman is second person charged over road deaths of couple on St Stephen's Day
Woman is second person charged over road deaths of couple on St Stephen's Day

Sunday World

timea day ago

  • Sunday World

Woman is second person charged over road deaths of couple on St Stephen's Day

Nicole Fallon (35) is the second person to be charged following the deaths of husband and wife Anthony Hogg and Georgina Hogg Moore in Blanchardstown last Christmas. John Halpin (left) and Nicola Fallon are both charged This is the Dublin woman who appeared in court this week in connection with the deaths of a married couple in Dublin on St Stephen's Day last year. Nicole Fallon (35) is the second person to be charged following the deaths of husband and wife Anthony Hogg and Georgina Hogg Moore in Blanchardstown last Christmas. She has been charged with impeding the apprehension or prosecution of a driver who was allegedly involved in a fatal hit-and-run that claimed the lives of the couple of December 26 2024. Nicole Fallon, of Whitestown Avenue, Blanchardstown, Dublin pictured at Blanchardstown District Court. Photo: Mr Hogg, 40, and his wife Georgina, 39, were struck while crossing a road near Blanchardstown Shopping Centre at around 5.45pm on December 26, 2024. The couple, married with children, lived in the nearby Whitestown area. John Halpin (45) is currently before the courts charged with dangerous driving causing the deaths of the couple, as well as failing to offer assistance at the scene. John Halpin (left) and Nicola Fallon are both charged News in 90 Seconds - Wednesday, July 29 Both Mr Halpin and Ms Fallon were further charged when they appeared before Blanchardstown District Court on Tuesday. The court heard they are facing trial in the circuit court after the DPP ruled the allegations were too serious for the district court. Judge David McHugh adjourned the cases to September for the service of the book of evidence. Ms Fallon, with an address at Whitestown Avenue in Blanchardstown, is charged with unlicensed and uninsured driving at Whitestown Avenue in Blanchardstown on December 26, 2024. Detective Garda Niamh Crowe gave evidence of further charging Ms Fallon with two new charges. It is alleged that Ms Fallon, knowing or believing that another individual committed an offence, namely dangerous driving causing death, did "without reasonable excuse an act with intent to impede the apprehension or prosecution of the said person". The second new charge alleges Ms Fallon did an act with intent to impede the apprehension or prosecution of a person while "knowing or believing that person had breached their duties in relation to the occurrence of an accident with intent to escape civil or criminal liability". Garda Shane Wood gave evidence to Blanchardstown court of further charging Mr Halpin with four new charges. Mr Halpin is accused of failing to stop a vehicle, which was allegedly involved in causing injury to Mr Hogg and Ms Hogg Moore. He is also charged with failing to offer assistance to the couple with the intent to escape civil or criminal liability. Gda Crowe and Gda Wood said gardai had no objection to bail being extended to the new sheets. Gardai said the DPP had directed trial on indictment in the circuit court on the charges. Defence solicitors Tertius Van Eeden and Aoife McNicholl said there was consent to an adjournment to a date in September. The accused have not yet indicated how they intend pleading to the charges.

Dublin mum denies knocking woman to ground and pulling hair in supermarket attack
Dublin mum denies knocking woman to ground and pulling hair in supermarket attack

Sunday World

timea day ago

  • Sunday World

Dublin mum denies knocking woman to ground and pulling hair in supermarket attack

Nikita Murray (29) is accused of leaving the alleged victim with cuts and bruises following an assault A woman has denied knocking another woman to the ground, pulling her hair and kicking her in an attack at a Dublin supermarket. Nikita Murray (29) is accused of leaving the alleged victim with cuts and bruises following an assault. She is pleading not guilty and her case was adjourned at Blanchardstown District Court for hearing on a later date. Ms Murray, with an address at Hillcrest Avenue, Lucan, Dublin, is charged with assault causing harm to a woman at Tesco, Hillcrest. The court heard the incident was alleged to have happened on September 13 last year. Garda Sergeant Maria Callaghan said the DPP consented to the case being dealt with at district court level. Investigating gardaí saw the alleged victim had soft tissue injuries afterwards Judge David McHugh asked to hear an outline of the prosecution's case so he could consider the issue of jurisdiction. Sgt Callaghan said the accused and alleged victim were known to each other and there were 'issues over their young children.' The woman alleged Ms Murray knocked her to the ground, grabbed her by the hair and kicked her. Investigating gardaí saw the alleged victim had soft tissue injuries afterwards – cuts and bruising. Judge McHugh accepted jurisdiction, allowing the case to remain in the district court. Defence solicitor Wayne Kenny said the case could go 'straight to a hearing date' and the judge set a date of March 11 next year, when the non-jury trial will take place. The charge is under Section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act. Stock image News in 90 Seconds - Wednesday, July 29

Who was Didarul Islam? NYPD officer shot by Shane Tamura
Who was Didarul Islam? NYPD officer shot by Shane Tamura

The Irish Sun

time2 days ago

  • The Irish Sun

Who was Didarul Islam? NYPD officer shot by Shane Tamura

THE NYPD officer killed in the New York skyscraper shooting on July 28, 2025, has been named as Didarul Islam. Here's everything we know so far about 'heroic' cop Didarul, as well as what happened during the Advertisement 4 Didarul Islam was killed in the mass shooting on Monday, July 28, 2025, in New York City Credit: Getty 4 The suspected shooter was caught on CCTV entering the Manhattan skyscraper with a rifle 4 Officials have named Shane Tamura as the gunman Three civilians and an NYPD officer were tragically killed during the attack on the Midtown high-rise, which is home to corporate giants including Blackstone and the NFL. Those trapped in Blackstone's office New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch named the gunman as On July 28, 2025, he attacked 345 Park Avenue on East 52nd Street between Park Avenue and Lexington Avenue at about 6.30pm (11.30pm BST). Advertisement read more on Didarul Islam Tamura was caught on CCTV exiting a double-parked BMW with an M4 rifle and walking across a public plaza into the 44-storey building. He opened fire in the lobby, killing a woman who tried to take cover behind a pillar, as well as the off-duty policeman. Tamura then made his way to the elevator bank, shooting a guard at a security desk and another man in the lobby, who is in a critical but stable condition, the commissioner said. He also spared the life of a woman he came face-to-face with as she exited an elevator. Advertisement Most read in The US Sun Latest Police say Tamura subsequently took the elevator to the 33rd floor offices of Rudin Management, the company that owns the building, walking the floor and opening fire, killing another man. Commissioner Tisch said he then shot himself in the chest, with the rifle found next to him covered in blood. A He wrote that he suffered from the neurodegenerative disease chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE). Advertisement 'You can't go against the NFL, they'll squash you. 'Study my brain please I'm sorry Tell Rick I'm sorry for everything." CTE is linked to repeated head trauma and can only be diagnosed through an autopsy of the brain. Advertisement 4 Office workers fleeing the area during the horrific shooting Credit: The NYPD named the off-duty officer killed as Didarul Islam and paid tribute to the man who "represented the very best of our department". The department said: "He was protecting New Yorkers from danger when his life was tragically cut short today. "We join in prayer during this time of incomprehensible pain. We will forever honour his legacy." Advertisement Commissioner Tisch said Didarul "died as he lived. A hero." She added: "He was doing the job that we asked him to do. He put himself in harm's way. He made the ultimate sacrifice." New York Mayor Eric Adams said he was "doing what he does best... saving lives. He was protecting New Yorkers". Who was Didarul Islam? Didarul Islam was a 36-year-old NYPD officer, who originally hailed from Bangladesh. Advertisement He was killed in the line of duty during the mass shooting. Didarul had served with the NYPD for three and a half years and was a member of the 47th Precinct in the Bronx. Didarul leaves behind two young boys and a pregnant wife.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store