Man who was nearly three times over legal limit has conviction overturned on appeal
A man who had denied drunk driving has had his conviction overturned on appeal, after a judge found the validity of the defendant's arrest was in question.
Daniel Keelan (47) with an address in Ashbourne, Co Meath, had pleaded not guilty in the District Court to drink driving in the town on August 21, 2022, contrary to section 4(4)(a) & (5) of the Road Traffic Act 2010.
Mr Keelan was convicted in the District Court and given a two-year driving disqualification, along with a 200 euro fine. He launched an appeal against his conviction, which was heard at the District Court Appeals Court sitting in Trim on Wednesday.
Stock image
News in 90 Seconds - Saturday July 12
Garda Saoirse Horan, of Ashbourne Garda Station, told the court that she was on patrol along Frederick Street in Ashbourne at around 9.55pm when she noticed a black BMW driving at speed past the garda patrol car.
Garda Horan said that she pursued the car but it failed to stop when she indicated for it to do so. She said that the car then turned into the car park of an apartment complex.
She said that when she approached, she observed a male slouched in the driver's seat who refused to get out of the car. She said that the man gave her his licence at the scene, where she said she got Mr Keelan's details and address.
Garda Horan said that Mr Keelan was argumentative with gardai, that there was a strong smell of alcohol coming off him and that his speech was slurred.
Garda Horan said that she cautioned Mr Keelan that he was being arrested under section 4.8 of the Road Traffic Act 2010 and that she handcuffed him due to what she said was his 'initial non-compliance and aggressive demeanour'.
She said that Mr Keelan was taken into custody, where a test for alcohol was carried out which she said recorded an alcohol level of 59mg per 100ml of breath. The legal limit is 22mg of alcohol per 100ml of breath.
Defence counsel for Mr Keelan, Martin Dully BL, said that his client recalls that when the garda vehicle stopped at an angle, a garda member jumped out, immediately pulled open Mr Keelan's door and pulled him out of the vehicle.
Mr Dully said that the first thing Mr Keelan knew about what was happening, he found himself between the garda vehicle and his own with handcuffs on, and the garda hadn't spoken to him.
Garda Horan said that she did not put handcuffs on Mr Keelan without explaining the reason for his arrest.
Mr Keelan also maintained that he could not have been speeding on the road, as there were roadworks and 'traffic bumps' present at the time.
Mr Keelan said that the first time that his driver's licence was requested was in the garda station and not at the scene.
Garda Horan said that she got the information about the defendant's home address being in Ashbourne from his driving licence at the scene of the arrest.
However, Mr Dully produced Mr Keelan's driving licence in court and said it actually reads that his address is in Baldoyle, and so Garda Horan's evidence could not have been correct.
Judge John Martin said that the conflicting information regarding when and where the driver's license was obtained 'casts a doubt' over which version of events is correct.
He said that, as he had a slight doubt about what had happened in the car park, this put the validity of the arrest into question.
Judge Martin decided in those circumstances to allow the appeal of Mr Keelan's conviction.
Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
33 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Former bride weeps in court over failure to get back 'priceless' wedding flowers
A Co Louth woman has wept in court over not being able to get back her 'priceless' and 'irreplaceable' wedding flowers from a woman who was hired to preserve and frame the flowers. At the Small Claims Court at Ennis District Court, former bride, Michelle Markey became visibly upset after telling Judge Alec Gabbett of her failed efforts to obtain the return of her wedding flowers from Co Clare woman, Charlotte Roche. Ms Markey of Oriel Rd, Collon, Co Louth told Judge Gabbett: "My priceless flowers. I gave them away - I would have kept them if I had known I would never get my wedding flowers back." Judge Gabbett said that "wedding flowers hold sentimental value, some people put them on their mother's graves". He told Ms Markey: "I get that sentimentality aspect." The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Ms Markey told Judge Gabbett: "I gave away my - I'm sorry..." and momentarily began to cry before quickly recomposing herself. In response, Judge Gabbett said: "You are okay. It is fine. Take your time. You find the whole thing upsetting because the lack of communication is the biggest issue?" Ms Markey agreed. She said that the flowers are 'irreplaceable'. She said: "I do have evidence to show that this is not an isolated incident and reviews on a website show that this has happened to other brides." There was no appearance in court by Charlotte Roche of Laghtagoona, Corofin, Co Clare who agreed to provide the floral service to Ms Markey. Ms Markey was claiming €350 for the loss of her wedding flowers and Judge Gabbett granted her a decree of €200 for the replacement of the flowers against Ms Roche. He said: "That is the best I can do for you." Ms Markey told Judge Gabbett that she entered a service agreement on October 9, 2023 with Ms Roche when a €50 deposit was paid to Ms Roche for drying, preserving, artwork and framing of wedding day flowers. Ms Markey said that Ms Roche set up a new company, Lush Flower Art Ltd, in 2024. She said that the flowers were received by Ms Roche on November 7, 2023 and Ms Markey said that she was told that 16 weeks would be allowed for the completion of the artworks. She said that after multiple emails and texts between December 2023 and November 2024, including several requests to return the flowers, on November 23, 2024 she was informed via email by Ms Roche that she would not be progressing with the piece. She said: "I requested a return of deposit and flowers and neither was received at this time." Ms Markey said that Ms Roche cancelled the service over a review she had left on a weddings website. Ms Markey said that the deposit was returned on January 4 but no return of flowers and subsequent requests for return of flowers were ignored. Representing herself, Ms Markey told Judge Gabbett she travelled 200km to be in court in Ennis on a six-hour round trip from Co Louth "and had to organise childcare and take a day off work". After seeing that the next Small Claims case on the list was a Kerrie Horgan vs Charlotte Roche (Bradley), Judge Gabbett remarked 'Oh dear'. There was no appearance by either party in that case and Judge Gabbett adjourned that case to September. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Sunday World
17 hours ago
- Sunday World
‘I know the craic', ex-Garda said during his arrest after car crashed into wall
Judge said she was 'quite disturbed' by the former garda's behaviour. A 34-year-old motorist and former member of An Garda Síochána has been convicted of failing to comply with a doctor's request to provide a blood or urine sample. Henry Johnston, Stoney Lane, Ardee, Co. Louth, contested the charge which arose after an incident more than two years ago when a BMW car crashed into a boundary wall close to his home. The defence contended that the demand for a sample was not made within three hours of driving. However, Judge Nicola Andrews said that the accused 'took every opportunity he could to frustrate the process'. Mr Johnston, who has no previous convictions, was convicted and referred to the Probation Service for a community service assessment. A neighbour testified that on May 31, 2023, she was in bed when awoken by a loud bang. She looked at the clock. It was 11.07pm. Her daughter, who had also woken up, said, 'It's Henry. He crashed into the wall.' Outside, they helped him. It was dark. They were afraid another car would come along. She ran to get some torches. She gave her phone to a woman to use its light as a warning and believed it was this person who rang gardaí. Stock image (Photo: Getty) News in 90 Seconds - July 25th They were trying to get the car off the road. It took a while. The left-side (of the car) was 'mangled'. It was put to her by solicitor Séamus Roe that in a statement she said '11-ish' and made no mention of 11.07pm on the clock. Gda Nuala Crossan gave evidence that at 11.25pm she responded to a report of a road traffic collision at Stoney Lane, Ardee. A car had crashed into a wall in a cul de sac. The defendant was in the driver's seat with the door open. The engine was running and the airbags had deployed. An alarm in the car had gone off. He said he was okay. His eyes were glazed and his speech slurred. Gda Crossan continued that she formed her opinion at 11.29pm that the man was incapable of having proper control over a mechanically propelled vehicle and arrested him at 11.30pm on suspicion of drink driving. She said that the man 'persisted in interrupting me' and during the caution said, 'I know the craic. I used to be a guard.'. He added, 'You know I'm not going to comment and incriminate myself,' when asked about what happened. On arrival at Dundalk Garda Station at 12.10am on June 1, he said he required a doctor's attention because he was asthmatic. A doctor was contacted. Gda Crossan said it was decided not to conduct an Evidenzer breath test. Mr Johnston's behaviour 'began to escalate'. He repeated demands for a solicitor to attend. No solicitor was available. The accused called Member In Charge of the station Gda Ryan Brennan a 'retard'. He put papers down his trousers, removed them and threw them at Gda Brennan. A doctor who arrived provided him with an inhaler. He refused it and refused to engage with the doctor. He said he wanted a solicitor. He refused to enter the doctor's room. Gda Crossan said the defendant then began to tap the Evidenzer machine and remarked, 'I will provide breath'. She explained that was no longer an option because of his previous claim that he would be unable to provide a breath sample and the fact that the Evidenzer guard had left. He said, 'Yes, I'll provide urine' and began shouting at the doctor that he would provide breath. The accused was asked to leave the room. He clung to the Evidenzer machine before being escorted to the custody area. Mr Roe said that he had an email from BMW which indicated the time the car's alarm went off. The author was not present. Judge Andrews did not allow it into evidence. Mr Roe put it to Gda Crossan that the accident occurred at 10.05pm. She replied that gardaí received a call at 11.25pm and that a woman heard a loud bang at 11pm. Gda Damien Fanning attended the garda station to conduct an Evidenzer breath test. He commenced a period of observation at 12.20am. Mr Johnston said that he was asthmatic, wanted a doctor and would be unable to do a breath test. Gda Fanning said he ended the observation. He felt it better to get a doctor for a blood or urine test. The defendant became aggressive, particularly towards Gda Brennan. Mr Roe said that the demand for a sample was made at 2.01am. In her statement the woman said she heard a bang at '11-ish'. He submitted there was a doubt the demand was made within three hours of driving. Judge Andrews said she was satisfied it was a lawful arrest and satisfied that any demand was within a three-hour period. The defence did not go into direct evidence. The judge said Mr Johnston 'took every opportunity he could to frustrate the process' and engaged in 'ducks and drakes' in any prosecution that might have been brought under Section 4. He refused to comply. Judge Andrews asked if the defendant was a garda, and was told by the prosecution that he was a former member of An Garda Síochána. Mr Roe said that his client was no longer in the force. He was single and working. Judge Andrews remarked that she was 'tempted" to impose a custodial sentence and was 'quite disturbed' by the defendant's behaviour. "I'm very concerned about what I heard.' The case was referred to the Probation Service for a community service assessment, and the court warned Henry Johnston to engage or he would be sent to jail. He was told he would also be getting a fine and disqualification. He was remanded on continuing bail to November 19. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Irish Examiner
19 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Dutch national accused of stabbing in West Cork refused bail
A Dutch national who is charged with two offences in relation to an alleged stabbing in Clonakilty, West Cork, has been refused bail in the district court. Bas Mulders, aged 54, with an address at Western Road, Clonakilty, Co Cork, appeared before Judge Joanne Carroll at Bantry District Court. The court heard that Mulders was charged with assault causing harm and producing an article in the course of a dispute. Detective Garda Peter Nolan said that gardaí were objecting to Mulders being granted bail based on the O'Callaghan rules and Section 2 of the Bail Act 1997. Det Gda Nolan said gardaí had serious concerns that Mulders could coerce or intimidate a witness and/or the alleged injured party and there was also a risk he could flee the jurisdiction. The court heard that Mulders was accused of stabbing another man with a knife during an argument at a location in Clonakilty in the early hours of Tuesday, July 22. The court heard that a witness had also given a statement in relation to the alleged assault and that Mulders denied the charges. The court was told that the alleged injured party was in a stable condition in Cork University Hospital. Det Gda Nolan said that the alleged injured party lived near Mulders and that the accused had family in the Netherlands but no immediate family in Ireland. The court heard that Mulders had lived in Ireland for 22 years but did not own property and was not in employment with his principal income coming from disability allowance. Defence solicitor Flor Murphy appealed to the court to consider granting bail with conditions. He said that his client's only previous conviction was road traffic related and he had no record for violent behaviour of any kind. He said that Mulders had been living in Ireland for many years and denied the charges. Judge Carroll refused bail based on the garda objections stating there was 'a real risk' Mulders could interfere with the witness or injured party. She remanded the accused in custody to appear again at Bandon District Court on July 28 and granted legal aid to Mr Mulders. This article is funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
