Coalition of mistrust -- Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael tensions grow
There are also increasing concerns over the relationship between the two most powerful politicians in the country amid a series of housing and health controversies.
One senior Government source said: 'The Taoiseach [Micheál Martin] and the Tánaiste [Simon Harris], it is very polite, but they just aren't getting on. Fine Gael leader Simon Harris and Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin. Pic: RollingNews.ie via Oireachtas Press Office
'It didn't start very well between [former Taoiseach and Fine Gael leader] Leo [Varadkar] and Micheál either, but once it became clear that Leo wasn't keen on hanging around, they got on much better.
'Micheál is uneasy about Simon's ambition. He cleared all that out of Fianna Fáil, so he is not used to dealing with it.'
Another source described the relationship between the leaders of the old Civil War rival parties as 'very icy, very polite, very formal'. Leinster House. Pic: Clare O'Beara/Shutterstock
The deteriorating relations come as the Coalition finds itself under increasing pressure to deliver key pre-election promises, in particular its pledge to significantly increase new home builds.
A senior Coalition figure noted: 'Sometimes it feels like it's been five years rather than five months. There's no bedding in, no sense of cohesion that this is a shared project.'
Other sources pointed to Cabinet tensions over the extent of media coverage ministers from either party are securing. One minister told Extra.ie: 'There are bushfires everywhere. There have been blazing rows between advisors. Fine Gael leader Simon Harris and Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin. Pic: Sasko Lazarov/RollingNews.ie
'It is coming from the top. The ministers are being told to dominate the [news] agenda, especially in Fine Gael.'
Another Government source added: 'There are wars between the advisors. They are tearing into each other about lines of demarcation, and that spills over to the ministers. [Media] appearances are being counted up. The spats start before [RTÉ Radio current affairs programme] Morning Ireland is over. It's total paranoia.'
Sources compared the comparatively better cohesion that existed between the party leaders in the previous administration, which included the Green Party.
One minister noted: 'In the last administration, we could always blame the Greens, we are almost missing them.
'The Regional Independents are foxes; they go missing when there's trouble. Now there's only Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael in the room.' Independent TD Michael Lowry. Pic: Brian Lawless/PA Wire
One senior advisor said the debacle over Dáil speaking rights got the current Coalition off to the worst possible start.
'The problem is everything has been off kilter from the start.'
Referring to chaotic Dáil scenes during the prolonged row over whether a group of independent TDs, including Michael Lowry, should be granted speaking rights to question the government they support, they added: 'The Lowry kingpin thing was a disaster. It set the image of the Coalition in stone as a collection of strokers and the do-nothing Dáil.
'We should have been looking to divide the opposition from the start and get Labour in. We didn't, and now we have a united opposition thanks to Lowry.'
One Fine Gael minister added: 'We were drowned in Lowry for three months but what really took the wind out of things was the housing figures. That has put us on the back foot from the start.' Minister for Housing, James Browne. Pic: Sam Boal/Collins Photos
A Fianna Fáil minister said: 'Everything is polite, but there's no deep collegiality. There's a lot of suspicion over Fine Gael's plans for [Housing Minister] James Browne.'
Referring to the embarrassing U-turn on plans to install the €430,000-a-year Nama boss Brendan McDonagh as Minister Browne's housing 'czar', the minister added: 'They've tasted blood once with McDonagh. Will they come for another head, and what will we do if they do?'
The source noted there is no longer a 'backdoor where [Coalition] difficulties can be ironed over, a sort of Fine Gael minister for dealing with Fianna Fáil, and a Fianna Fáil minister for Fine Gael, but that isn't there this time.'
They added: 'The parties are retreating in on themselves. Even there, the parties are divided. Fine Gael are in leadership silly season mode with the [Health Minister] Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and Simon Harris soap opera, and we are no better.
'Micheál is back to his old tricks, playing one off against the other. The party is already asking, is [Public Expenditure Minister] Jack Chambers or James Browne the real Minister for Housing?'
Referring to the deepening Coalition tensions and fears of an escalating health crisis over revelations about abuses of the State scheme to combat hospital waiting lists, another Cabinet source said: 'We are facing a poly-crisis scenario. People are genuinely starting to wonder if all this is tenable beyond three years. Five-year governments are not a given, you know.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on Ireland and Japan: a deepening relationship
The Taoiseach's visit to Japan last week, where he opened Ireland House Tokyo and visited the Irish pavilion at Expo 2025 in Osaka, reflects that country's growing importance as a trade partner and a source of inward investment. But Micheál Martin's meeting with Japanese prime minister Shigeru Ishiba on Wednesday highlighted the growing prominence of geopolitical and security issues in the bilateral relationship. At a cost of more than € 21 million, Ireland House Tokyo is the most expensive capital project the State has ever undertaken outside the country. But bilateral trade between Ireland and Japan is worth more than € 21 billion a year and its volume has doubled over the past decade. The protectionist mood generated by Donald Trump will make it politically difficult for American companies to announce major new investments overseas, including in Ireland. This makes Japan's investment in technology, life sciences, financial services, engineering and other industries in Ireland all the more important. Enterprise Ireland represents more than 300 Irish companies in Japan and the country is the biggest market in Asia after China for Irish food and drink. The Taoiseach's visit followed trips to Japan in recent weeks by Enterprise Minister Peter Burke and Agriculture Minister Martin Haydon, reflecting its important as a market for Irish exporters. READ MORE As Japanese investment in Ireland has increased, its government has taken a closer look at the security of the infrastructure on which it depends. Ishiba questioned the Taoiseach closely on what steps the Government was taking to protect the subsea cables off the Irish coast which are used to transmit data. The Japanese prime minister was concerned about the activities of Russian trawlers close to the cables and to the interconnector between Britain and Ireland. The Taoiseach cited Ireland's arrangements with organisations like Nato and Pesco as evidence that the Government was taking action to protect essential offshore infrastructure but Japan's concerns will be shared by other trading partners. Japan's population is shrinking by 800,000 every year and Ireland's growing population is a major attraction for Japanese investors. Japanese regulations mean Ireland's tax regime is less important for their companies than access to talent from across Europe and around the world. The Taoiseach acknowledged that anti-immigration rhetoric was in danger of drowning out the truth that Ireland's growing population and diverse, international labour force are economic strengths. It is essential that the Government continues to make that case to the public at home as persuasively as the IDA makes it to Japanese investors.
The Journal
6 hours ago
- The Journal
Sinn Féin TD's case against 'Super Junior' ministers at Cabinet at the High Court tomorrow
SINN FÉIN TD Pa Daly's case against the Taoiseach regarding the appointment of the controversial 'Super Junior' Ministers will go to full hearing tomorrow morning at the High Court. In February , the case appeared before court for a hearing. Daly is asking the court to declare that the attendance of the super juniors at government meetings is unconstitutional . The super junior ministers appointed include Fine Gael's Hildegarde Naughton, as well as Independents Sean Canney and Noel Grealish. Fianna Fáil's chief whip Mary Butler is also a minister of state attending Cabinet. Advertisement Attorney General Rossa Fanning represented all of the respondents – himself, the Taoiseach and the Government – in the hearing in court in February . Speaking today, Daly said that the case challenges what he believes 'is a deeply problematic and unconstitutional practice that has taken root in recent decades – the attendance and participation of so-called 'Super Junior' Ministers at meetings of the Government'. He said that the case was as a constitutional challenge aimed at protecting the integrity of Ireland's system of government – 'which Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Lowry-Led Independents are playing fast and loose'. There is a constitutional limit of 15 members of Cabinet. Daly is arguing that the four super junior ministers who also sit at Cabinet is unconstitutional. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald and TD Pearse Doherty are expected to speak to the media outside the High Court tomorrow morning before the hearing begins. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
7 hours ago
- The Journal
Fine Gael to open nominations for its presidential candidate tomorrow
FINE GAEL IS to open its nomination process for anyone seeking the party's candidacy for the upcoming presidential election tomorrow. The nominations will close at 4pm on the following Tuesday, 15 July, a statement from the party said. To be nominated, a candidate needs the nomination of 20 members of the Parliamentary Party, 25 Fine Gael Councillors and five members of the Executive Council, it said. Advertisement If a public representative is also a member of the Executive Council, they must indicate in which capacity they are nominating. In the event of a contest where more than one person is successful in being nominated for the candidacy, an electoral college voting system applies. Under the voting system, every member of the party in compliance with the two-year rule has a vote. The membership element of the college is worth 30% of the overall vote, councillors' votes are worth 15%, and the parliamentary party accounts for 55%. There will be a number of hustings held in late July and a postal ballot of members will take place across August. The parliamentary party will vote in September, as will councillors. The selected candidate will be ratified at an event in September. President Michael D Higgins's term will conclude on 11 November. Related Reads Two more names surface for presidency bids as Mary Hanafin confirms intent to run Why are so few candidates dipping their toe in the water in the race for the Áras? The election of the next President must take place within the sixty days before that, leaving the election open to be held from any stage from 13 September to 10 November. It is understood that at present, former European Commissioner Mairead McGuinness is the frontrunner for the party's nomination for the presidency, although MEP Seán Kelly has also declared his interest in contesting. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
