Chinese seller on Amazon sold ‘defective' tools linked to deaths, life-changing injuries: lawsuits
Allegedly defective tools and hardware from a China-based seller on Amazon have been linked to two deaths and at least one serious injury — the latest in an alarming spike in product liability lawsuits against the Seattle-based e-tailing giant, The Post has learned.
On March 25, 2024, Jacob 'Jake' Todd — 30-year-old father of three in Menifee, Calif. — was working under his Toyota Tacoma when a car jack he'd bought on Amazon from Vevor, a Shanghai-based third-party seller, buckled and broke.
The grisly mishap caused fatal 'blunt force trauma,' according to a January lawsuit filed on behalf of his sons in California state court in Riverside County.
In February, an Alabama truck driver, James Ryan Stokes, was using a Vevor 'chain load binder' to tie down items on his flatbed truck when the chain broke, sending him violently backwards and fatally breaking his neck, according to William Poole, a lawyer hired by Stokes' family.
6 James Ryan Stokes of Mobile, Ala. left a wife and six children when he died this year.
Hughes Funeral Home
The 49-year-old trucker left a wife and six children who are preparing a lawsuit against Amazon, Vevor and Austal USA, a ship manufacturer in Mobile, Ala. where the accident happened, according to Poole.
'It was the first time he was using the Vevor product,' Poole added.
Vevor – which has previously drawn whistleblower complaints to US agencies about allegedly fake reviews on Amazon, as reported by The Post – also has amassed 1,430 Better Business Bureau complaints over allegedly faulty products and poor customer service.
Meanwhile, the number of overall product liability cases against Amazon has spiked between 2020 and 2024, when the lawsuits more than doubled to 84 in federal court alone, according to Lex Machina, a LexisNexis company that provides legal data analytics.
'Although the number of federal cases are small compared to Amazon's [size] the trend shows an identifiable, steady increase of product liability cases that could be reflected in state court as well where the majority of these cases are filed,' Ron Porter, Lex Machina's legal data expert for product liability told The Post.
6 This jack sold by Vevor on Amazon.com buckled and collapsed while it was holding up a truck, killing a California man last year, according to a lawsuit.
Amazon
Most of the 84 cases have either been settled or dismissed on procedural grounds, although the breakdown isn't clear, Porter added.
Amazon's liability over defective third-party products has become a thorny question, with laws and legal outcomes varying from state to state. The company has typically argued that it is not directly responsible for products sold on its site that are manufactured by outside firms.
In 2020, a California state appeals court ruled that Amazon was liable for injuries caused to Angela Bolger, who suffered severe burns from an exploding laptop battery from a third-party Chinese seller called Lenoge Technology. Lenoge, which was named as a defendant, did not appear in court.
'Whatever term we use to describe Amazon's role, be it 'retailer,' 'distributor,' or merely 'facilitator,' it was pivotal in bringing the product here to the consumer,' the appeals court ruled at the time.
6 Links in this Vevor chain broke, causing an Alabama truck driver to break his neck, a lawyer representing the man's family said.
VEVOR
While other states have sided with Amazon in similar cases, the Bolger case is a favorable precedent for plaintiffs – especially where they seek restitution from a third-party seller based in China or another country overseas, according to Keith Hylton, a law professor at Boston University.
'If I had to make a prediction, I would guess the Bolger case will be accepted in most jurisdictions,' Hylton said in an interview.
'I don't think courts will accept an outcome where Amazon sells dangerously defective products made by foreigners in places where Americans have no legal recourse and escapes liability,' Hylton added. 'Holding Amazon liable will force it to do some monitoring, or at least to charge a price that will cover the costs Amazon will bear in compensating injured consumers.'
Amazon did not respond to multiple requests for comment for this story.
As recently as May 28, Amazon was still listing the Vevor products that were involved in the two deaths. That's despite customer reviews that have flagged safety issues — including one purporting to be from a friend of Todd.
6 A Vevor 'tie down' chain in use.
VEVOR
'A very good friend of mine died using one of these vevor stands,' the reviewer wrote. 'Got crushed when one of the legs failed and what he was welding fell on him, total weight was like 3000lbs supported by 2 of these. RIP jake.'
Vevor, for its part, denies all the allegations in the car jack complaint and declined to comment on the Alabama case as it has not yet been filed, according to a statement from its attorney, Alan Tan.
'As regards [to] the larger question of quality,' Tan added, 'we must say that the existence of the above lawsuit against us does not imply in any manner that products sold by us are quality inferior.'
Tan pointed to a return and refund rate in the US of 3% as evidence of the quality of Vevor's products.
Tan addressed the California wrongful death case in a March 25 letter to a do-it-yourself influencer on YouTube – Jeff King of Den of Tools. King recently posted Tan's letter on YouTube in which Tan responded to a previous Den of Tools post about Vevor's products causing deaths and injuries.
6 This letter was sent by Vevor's legal counsel to a YouTube host who had reported on product safety issues involving Vevor.
YouTube/The Den of Tools
Vevor hired a local California litigator who is 'working together with the lawyer hired by Amazon to proactively prepare filing answer against the complaint,' according to Tan's letter.
The letter caught the attention of the Todd family's lawyer, Vanessa Pena.
'It raises questions that they contacted Amazon's attorneys to work directly with them,' Pena told The Post.
She added that Vevor reached out to Amazon before it responded to the wrongful death lawsuit on April 10. 'It infers me to me that they have a relationship with Amazon's attorneys.'
The letter from Tan also claims that Vevor is being unfairly attacked with litigation in the US, where it's facing at least a half-dozen patent and trademark cases alleging that it's selling knockoffs.
6 The number of product safety liability lawsuits against Amazon more than doubled between 2020 and 2024, a legal expert reports.
REUTERS
'You correctly pointed out that companies doing business in the US get sued because Americans like to sue no matter who you are or how well you behave,' Tan wrote to King.
Colby Lord of Huntsville, Texas fell more than 40 feet when the 'Vevor half body safety harness' he had purchased on Amazon fell apart while he was trimming a tree. He fractured both ankles, his back and left hand, according to his lawyer, Sam Palermo, a partner in the Sorrels personal injury law firm.
Lord's fall resulted 'in serious and lasting injuries,' according to a complaint filed against Vevor and several affiliated companies in federal court in Houston, Texas in October.
Amazon is not a defendant in that case. In 2021, Texas' highest court ruled that Amazon cannot be held liable for injuries caused by a third-party seller's product that the e-commerce giant shipped from its warehouse.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
New Gold Star on Hamilton's west side is open and has an expanded menu
Jun. 6—A relocated Hamilton west side Gold Star restaurant is now open and is much larger than its former location on Main Street. It is in a plaza on North Brookwood Avenue that will see explosive growth in the next few years. A Valvoline is being built nearby, next to Wendy's and a newly announce Kroger Marketplace will be close, too. The Gold Star is corporate-owned as it replaces a building owned by now-former franchisee Carlo Salem, who is retiring. Gold Star Chili CEO Roger David said the work to select a location and build it took at least five years. However, it's been his priority for just about his entire 10-year tenure as CEO. Plans for the project were approved by Hamilton City Council in 2023. "It's very, very rewarding to be here," he said. David said patrons will notice a few things walking through the door, one being "an elevated level of hospitality." Another is an expanded menu, which in addition to the classic conies and ways, the restaurant will serve single and double burgers, deckers, fried chicken sandwiches, milkshakes and garlic parmesan fries, which David says "are the best in the city." The westside Hamilton store is a little bigger than the newer prototype restaurants being built over the past few years. The new Gold Star store replaced an old Pizza Hut, but David said they used that pizza restaurant's existing footprint, which resulted in a bigger space. "It has a tremendous dining room in there, we can accommodate a large group," he said. Gold Star plans to continue its partnership with community groups, including the schools, churches "and any organization that congregates." "We'll be a part of whatever their needs may be," he said. But helping with food banks and pantries is where the 60-year-old restaurant chain "really, really leans in heavily." "Understanding community needs is kind of where it starts, but with hunger, that's typically where we lean in a little heavier," he said. While the North Brookwood Gold Star has been open for a couple of weeks, the Cincinnati-based chain will formally celebrate its opening the weekend of Aug. 9 and 10, where guests can get free cheese coneys with the purchase of a drink, and chances to win free burgers for a year. The restaurant is open daily from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. at 108 N. Brookwood Ave.
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Soldier Who 'Hates Himself' for Dismembering Pregnant Wife, Unborn Child with Chainsaw Learns Fate
Pfc Dewayne Johnson II, a former Hawaii-based U.S. Army soldier, was sentenced to 23 years in prison on June 3 after he admitted to killing his 19-year-old wife Mischa Johnson Dewayne used a machete and chainsaw to dismember Mischa and threw out her body parts in a dumpster in trash bags According to prosecutors, Dewayne had messaged 18 different women on a dating app and they found photos of him on his phone with another womanA Hawaii-based U.S. Army soldier was sentenced to 23 years in prison on June 3 after he admitted that he killed his 19-year-old wife and unborn child in the midst of a heated argument — and then dismembered her body to cover up the crime. Pfc Dewayne Johnson II, 29, pleaded guilty at a court-martial to voluntary manslaughter, obstruction of justice and providing false statements, according to a statement from the U.S. Army. He received the maximum sentence, plus a reduction in rank and a dishonorable discharge from the military. On July 12, 2024, Dewayne and his wife, Mischa Johnson, were at their home when they got into a heated argument, the Army statement said. In a military courtroom, Dewayne testified to the judge that he struck Mischa in the head with a machete that they had in their home. The machete then got stuck in Mischa's temple, Hawaii News Now reported. Dewayne eventually freed the machete from Mischa's head and tried to dismember her corpse with it. He was unsuccessful in doing so and bought a chainsaw to dismember what remained of her body. Dewayne admitted in court to severing Mischa's arms and legs from her head and torso, which he kept intact, per the local outlet. He then told the military judge that he separated Mischa's body parts into three trash bags and put them in a dumpster on the military barracks, knowing they would later be incinerated. During the June 3 sentencing, Dewayne offered an apology to Mischa's family, his own family and colleagues on his base, Hawaii News Now reported. 'My wife didn't deserve that. She wasn't trash,' he said. 'I hate myself for what I did, every day.' Mischa's remains and the remains of her unborn child have never been found, according to the statement from the U.S. Army. Both of their remains are presumed to have been transported to Hawaii's trash incinerator. 'While no amount of confinement will ever be able to truly ease the pain of the loss of Ms. Johnson and her unborn child for her family and friends, it is my hope that Pfc. Johnson's admission of guilt and the information he provided as a part of the plea agreement can provide some element of closure,' Lt. Col. Nicholas Hurd, a prosecutor for the Seventh Circuit in the U.S. Army, said in a statement. Dewayne didn't report Mischa missing to authorities until two weeks after he killed her, according to the U.S. Army statement. He even participated in community search parties across Hawaii to look for her. According to prosecutors, Dewayne had messaged 18 different women on a dating app and they found photos of him on his phone with another woman which showed him kissing and performing sexual acts on her, KTIV sister, Mariana Tapiz, spoke to Island News about how painful it was to hear about the details of how her sister was killed. 'As a family together, we're just trying not to focus on the horrific details of her last moment with him. And instead, right now, we're trying to remember the happy memories that we have and remember her in that life,' Tapiz said. If you are experiencing domestic violence, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, or go to All calls are toll-free and confidential. The hotline is available 24/7 in more than 170 languages. Read the original article on People
Axios
21 minutes ago
- Axios
Buc-ee's opens store an hour from New Orleans
Buc-ee's opens its massive travel center Monday in Mississippi just off Interstate 10 in Pass Christian. Why it matters: It's the popular chain's closest location to New Orleans (it's about one hour away) as it works on building its first two stores in Louisiana. The big picture: Buc-ee's is a cult favorite for road trippers. It's known for clean bathrooms, fresh food and beaver-themed merchandise. The Mississippi location has all the classics, the company says, including Texas barbeque, jerky, fudge, kolaches, pastries and snacks. It also has 120 gas pumps and 24 EV charging stations, according to a press release. The store opens at 6am and will be open 24 hours, seven days a week. By the numbers: It's the company's first store in Mississippi and has one of its largest footprints at 74,000 square feet. Its largest store, which it claims is the world's largest convenience station, is in Luling, Texas, at 75,593 square feet. Until now, the closest one to New Orleans was in Alabama near Mobile. Zoom out: Buc-ee's is a Texas-based chain that has been expanding its footprint nationally. Its first Louisiana store is expected to open in Ruston late next year, a company spokesperson tells Axios. A Lafayette store is projected to open in 2027, the spokesperson says. If you go: Expect crowds and traffic on I-10 near the new store. The Pass Christian location is at 8245 Firetower Road, which is accessed via exit 24 (Menge Avenue) on I-10.
