
Penalty rebounds could be OUTLAWED under drastic new rules with plans for VAR changes for yellow cards and corners
And
VAR
checks for second yellow cards and corners could also be brought in as
football
lawmakers consider more radical changes.
7
The new rules could be brought in for the 2026 World Cup
Credit: Getty
7
Iconic moments such as Harry Kane's winning goal for England against Denmark in the Euro 2020 semi-final wouldn't have stood under these suggested changes
Credit: Getty
7
Kasper Schmeichel saved his penalty, but the England captain scored from the rebound
Credit: Getty
7
Xabi Alonso scored from the rebound of his saved penalty in Liverpool's iconic 2005 Champions League final comeback against AC Milan
Credit: News Group Newspapers Ltd
In a major break, the serious move to alter more than 134 years of football
history
would see a missed spot-kick bringing a goal-kick for the opposing side.
While any decision would have to be approved by the law-making International FA Board (Ifab), there is growing backing for the idea that would turn a penalty shot into literally ONE shot.
Senior figures believe that on a majority of occasions the punishment for a handball or foul in the box - the penalty kick - gives the attacking side a far greater chance of scoring a goal than the original infringement had prevented.
To then give the attacking side a second chance of scoring from the rebound is an unfair extra advantage, especially as goalkeepers must have one foot on or behind the line when the kick is taken.
Read more in football
The other argument is that by making the penalty a one-off kick - similar to the rules in
hockey
for a penalty
stroke
- it will end all arguments over players 'encroaching' as doing so will be irrelevant.
Under the proposed
law
change, there will automatically be a restart with a dead ball after the initial kick is taken, either a kick-off on the half-way line if the penalty is scored, or a goal-kick if it is not converted, irrespective of whether the keeper turns the ball behind and out of play.
That means iconic moments such as Harry Kane's extra-time rebound to beat Denmark after Kasper Schmeichel saved his spot kick in the Euro 2020 semi-final would no longer count.
Nor would Xabi Alonso's equaliser in Liverpool's incredible 2005 Champions League final comeback to beat AC Milan.
Most read in Football
The possible law changes are being discussed at the highest levels as world chiefs aim to improve the game ahead of the first 48-team World Cup.
And while the timetable is short, with any alterations needing to be agreed by the end of February to be in force for the 2026 tournament, there is growing momentum in favour of the radical laws rewrite.
BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK
Discussions on 'expanding the scope' of VAR interventions first surfaced at the end of 2023, when they were on the table at the 'annual
business
meeting' of the law-making International FA Board held at a Heathrow hotel.
It would see video officials potentially able to intervene and recommend decisions overturned on second yellow cards - preventing 'unfair' dismissals - and also corners when a 'clear error' has been made by the on-field officials.
7
Players would have one chance to get their penalty on target if the new law comes in
Credit: Getty
7
Video officials could even intervene on second yellow cards too
Credit: PA
7
Corners could be affected as well if referees make a clear error
Credit: Getty
When the matter was last debated, Ifab agreed there was a consensus in favour of 'considering possible amendments and improvements' to VAR protocols.
However, it is understood that only decisions that can be recommended for overturns in a matter of seconds will be considered as within the scope of the VAR changes, with Ifab concerned there should be 'no extra delay' caused by checks.
Those worries saw the idea kicked, gently, into touch when it was initially mooted, with senior Ifab figures fearing it was a step too far.
But the possible changes were discussed by football's high command during the Club World Cup in the
USA
, which Fifa considered a huge success.
Ifab has shown a willingness to make major changes to the laws in the past two years in a bid to make the game more attractive.
Trials are ongoing for Arsene Wenger's 'daylight' offside Law proposals, although it is felt more likely the former Arsenal manager's 'torso' proposal will be adopted eventually.
That would see assistant referees and VAR officials no longer looking at feet, head and any other body parts, with any overlap deeming the attacker to be onside and effectively bringing the 'Sunday league' interpretation to the top levels of the game.
At this year's AGM in
Belfast
, at the urging of Fifa President
Gianni Infantino
, Ifab agreed to introduce the new 'eight second' rule for goalkeepers, including the 'five second hand countdown' by referees, which was introduced from June 1 and used at the under-21
Euros
and the Club World Cup..
And at the start of last month, Ifab 'clarified' penalty laws to change the rule around 'accidental' double-touch penalties.
That followed the Julian Alvarez shoot-out effort against Real
Madrid
in the
Champions League
which helped eliminate Atletico Madrid when it was ruled out.
Instead, Ifab determined that similar situations will now see a retake ordered - if the kick is scored - rather than result in no goal and a free-kick for the defending team.
COMMENT
LET me start by laying my cards on the table.
Unlike the vast majority of my colleagues - and, more importantly, the fans - I LOVE VAR.
Yes, there have been too many elongated delays, and that is something that has to be addressed.
Yet there are now far fewer bad and costly decisions.
Fewer offside goals that are allowed. Fewer onside goals disallowed because the flag went up in error.
More accurate decisions on whether fouls were inside or outside the box.
If those calls would otherwise cost a side the World Cup Final, the Champions League or the Prem title, the fans, players and clubs would have every reason to be spewing blood.
But while I hear the arguments over extending the scope of VAR for second yellow cards and 'clearly wrong' corners, it feels like the thin end of the wedge.
If you allow the video bunker to intrude on these decisions, where will it stop?
Next, surely, will be VAR checks on free-kicks and throw-ins - after all, aren't they equally likely to end up with goals being scored?
And can you imagine just how long that would take?
The last World Cup saw matches routinely lasting way over 100 minutes and even in the Prem last season there was an average of just under 10 minutes added time per game.
But add in another layer of VAR oversight and we'll be lucky to see matches finish inside two hours.
Even for me, this would be too much. Thanks, but no thanks.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Irish Sun
6 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Evan Ferguson scores FOUR on Roma debut alongside World Cup winner as Italian giants win 9-0
EVAN FERGUSON scored FOUR goals on his debut for new club AS Roma. The Premier League star bagged himself a perfect hat-trick on his first showing for I Giallorossi. 3 Evan Ferguson notched four goals on his debut for AS Roma, including a perfect hat-trick Credit: Getty 3 Ferguson joined the Italian outfit on loan with a £32million buy option Credit: Getty Ferguson lined up alongside World Cup winner Paulo Dybala in Roma's second pre-season contest of the year. He also notched an assist to accompany his four goals, making it five goal contributions for the day. The Italian giants won 9-0 against newly promoted Serie D side UniPomezia. Ferguson, 20, was once one of the Premier League highest-rated young talents. READ MORE ON FOOTBALL He joined Roma earlier this month on a season-long loan from Brighton. The deal includes a buy option worth around £32million. Ferguson broke through with He was once valued at over £100million thanks to his promising first seasons in the Premier League, drawing interest from the likes of Chelsea and Man Utd. Most read in Football CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS 3 Ferguson is looking to turn around a lacklustre season which saw him score only one league goal Credit: Getty But the Ireland international subsequently fell out of favour on the South Coast before an unfulfilling loan spell with He scored one goal in 21 Premier League appearances last season between his spells with Brighton and West Ham. European giants release 'absolute worldie' third shirt but it leaves fans divided as others compare it to tennis kit He has already quadrupled that number since arriving in the Italian capital.


Irish Daily Mirror
7 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Italian media in a frenzy over Evan Ferguson's four-goal display
It's times like these where you long for the return of Gazzetta Football Italia, that iconic Channel 4 show that beamed the best of Serie A into Irish and UK living rooms in the 1990s. James Richardson's newspaper review - where the show's presenter would sit outside a cafe and go through the big stories of the week - was one of the highlights of the wildly popular highlights show. Oh for a return of that segment so that Richardson could run through the headlines marking Evan Ferguson's arrival and his sensational first appearance in Roma colours. Fair enough, it was a behind-closed-doors friendly against a team from Serie D. But what's the saying? You can only play what's in front of you. And you will be hard pressed to find a better way to settle into a new environment than with four goals and an assist. And after just a day training with his new teammates, Ferguson's link-up play at this early stage shows great promise ahead of the tougher tests that are to come. He combined well with Paulo Dybala, and teed up the Argentine World Cup winner for his goal in the 9-0 rout. Roma have Kaiserslautern on Saturday, then French sides Cannes and Lens, and finally Premier League duo Aston Villa and Everton, before their Serie A opener at home to Bologna on August 23. That's when Ferguson will truly come under the microscope. But already the Italian media are drooling over the Ireland striker. Here's where we need Richardson. One of his favourites was Corriere dello Sport and their first report on a Ferguson performance was glowing. Evan Ferguson scores for Roma against Uni Pomezia (Image: Luciano Rossi/AS Roma via Getty Images) 'The star performer is undoubtedly Evan Ferguson,' writes reporter Jacopo Aliprandi. 'He scored four of the nine goals with which Roma won the second friendly by a landslide, to which he added an assist.' He adds: 'Given that this friendly match was only seen by the accredited press, the fans' curiosity to understand and see the actions of the new arrival Ferguson is great. Four goals and an assist are a calling card that, at the very least, gives us hope.' Francesco Balzani of Gazzetta dello Sport, another Richardson staple, intros his report with: 'Four goals and an assist from the Irish striker in his first with the Giallorossi, in the test against the Serie D club.' He continues: 'Evan Ferguson made his debut today with the Roma shirt in the friendly against UniPomezia. And it was a debut with a bang: four goals and an assist for Dybala in the 9-0 defeat given by the Giallorossi to the team that plays in Serie D. 'Soft test, but the signals coming from Gasp's team are encouraging. With particular reference to Ferguson who scored a hat-trick in less than half an hour and showed all the qualities seen so far in his short career. 'The Irishman, who arrived from Brighton just two days ago and with only one real training session under his belt, broke the deadlock in the match with a powerful header from Dybala's cross… 'With the Argentine, Ferguson has shown that he already has a good understanding.' Evan Ferguson scores for Roma against Uni Pomezia (Image: Luciano Rossi/AS Roma via Getty Images) Michael Di Chiaro of Goal writes: 'The great protagonist of the friendly match which Roma easily won was Evan Ferguson himself, author of four goals and an assist to Dybala.' These are just a few of the early reports on Ferguson's first outing in a Roma shirt. Bring back James Richardson and Gazzetta Football Italia. Or even better, send me to Rome with an expense budget for a season-long supply of coffees, ice creams and newspapers. Get the latest sports headlines straight to your inbox by signing up for free email .


The Irish Sun
7 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Inside Newcastle's nightmare summer from hijacked transfers to Isak drama – and why it could get worse
YOU CAN'T help feel a little sorry for Eddie Howe. It was supposed to be the summer that it all finally started happening for Newcastle. 7 Eddie Howe has experienced something of a nightmare transfer window thus far Credit: Getty 7 The latest blow came from star striker Alexander Isak's request to leave the club Credit: PA Not only had he secured the club's first piece of major silverware for 70 years, the Toon boss also had the Champions League to look forward to again. He achieved all of that without making a major first-team signing for 18 months while selling several members of his squad amid the battle to meet PSR rules. But it feels like all that excitement is quickly evaporating as the feelings of frustration mount. Here's why Newcastle's summer window is threatening to turn into a real dampener: READ MORE ON FOOTBALL ALEXANDER ISAK The Swede is THE hot topic right now and, despite the club's insistence that it's down to injury, his All of the current drama and concern over his future stems all the way back to last summer. Former co-owners But then incoming sporting director Paul Mitchell, who we have more on below, decided to postpone negotiations due to a feeling Isak was already handsomely paid and having the security of knowing he was tied down on a contract until 2028. Most read in Football SUN VEGAS WELCOME OFFER: GET £50 BONUS WHEN YOU JOIN The striker kept producing the goods on the pitch but, even though Mitchell has now departed, there has still been no progress on an extension. Newcastle contract blunder could cost them Isak Though the last thing anyone wants is for the drama to keep dragging on and a decision needs to be made fast to avoid any potential hangover affecting the start of the season. SPORTING DIRECTOR And with no replacement lined-up or yet appointed, the head coach has found himself playing a more central role in transfer business. That led to him, head of recruitment Steve Nickson and assistant head of recruitment Andy Howe being tasked with overseeing transfer deals. Howe revealed: 'My phone exploded. I was enjoying my second day of my holiday and that quickly went sour. 'It was a complete surprise to me. And a big disappointment because we had stability, we were planning the summer ahead and then that's a big upheaval internally that we've been through before with Dan Ashworth leaving. 7 Howe has found himself at the centre of transfer affairs in the absence of a sporting director Credit: Getty 7 Former sporting director Paul Mitchell stepped away from the role at the end of June Credit: Getty 'It's been a busier summer in that respect than I wanted. Naturally with Paul leaving, that left a hole in terms of that role. And of course someone in that role protects the manager from a lot of things. And of course his departure left that open for me to do some things that I wouldn't have normally done. 'The summer certainly wasn't a relaxing one for me to switch off and see what happens.' The search for Mitchell's replacement, which saw former TRANSFERS Newcastle finally had something to celebrate when Howe managed to get the deal over the line for But the Howe, and the likes of skipper But, Elanga aside, it has been a hugely frustrating window with Toon missing out on four top targets with a FIFTH now looking likely. The Magpies saw deals for A squad that included a host of young, raw and untested academy players was thrashed at 7 Anthony Elanga joined the Magpies from Nottingham Forest for a fee of £55million earlier in the window Credit: Getty 7 Newcastle's other business has not been as successful, with Liverpool snatching away top target Hugo Ekitike in a £79million deal Credit: Getty Howe said: 'My wish was for us to do our business early and we certainly tried, but it wasn't to be. 'We've had a frustrating time in terms of losing targets to other clubs. I'd be very open with that. That's happened on several occasions. 'You just have to accept it. In order for a transfer to really work, in my opinion, the player has to be desperate to come to your club. If we don't get that, the transfer doesn't work. 'We're seeking players that are good enough, that are desperate to come, and that can make the difference that they're in short supply for us. 'We're confident that we can try and get some more players in to strengthen the depth of the squad. We're certainly aware that we need to and we're trying as hard as we can to do that.' Newcastle are set to table a £30m offer for 7 UPSTAIRS UNCERTAINTY The expected arrival of Wilson as sporting director will be just the latest in a series of changes in the hierarchy. A replacement for much-loved CEO Darren Eales is still yet to be confirmed. It was last September when he announced he was serving his notice after being diagnosed with blood cancer. Ex- And to add to the upheaval and change, Newcastle appointed Atalanta's director of football intelligence Sudarshan Gopaladesikan as new technical director this week. He will report to whoever comes in to take over from Eales. Any club trying to operate without a proper and in-place executive team will always face issues. And the sooner the upstairs gets sorted then the better for everybody.