logo
Penalty rebounds could be OUTLAWED under drastic new rules with plans for VAR changes for yellow cards and corners

Penalty rebounds could be OUTLAWED under drastic new rules with plans for VAR changes for yellow cards and corners

The Irish Sun16-07-2025
REBOUNDS from penalties could be SCRAPPED by next year's World Cup finals.
And
VAR
checks for second yellow cards and corners could also be brought in as
football
lawmakers consider more radical changes.
7
The new rules could be brought in for the 2026 World Cup
Credit: Getty
7
Iconic moments such as Harry Kane's winning goal for England against Denmark in the Euro 2020 semi-final wouldn't have stood under these suggested changes
Credit: Getty
7
Kasper Schmeichel saved his penalty, but the England captain scored from the rebound
Credit: Getty
7
Xabi Alonso scored from the rebound of his saved penalty in Liverpool's iconic 2005 Champions League final comeback against AC Milan
Credit: News Group Newspapers Ltd
In a major break, the serious move to alter more than 134 years of football
history
would see a missed spot-kick bringing a goal-kick for the opposing side.
While any decision would have to be approved by the law-making International FA Board (Ifab), there is growing backing for the idea that would turn a penalty shot into literally ONE shot.
Senior figures believe that on a majority of occasions the punishment for a handball or foul in the box - the penalty kick - gives the attacking side a far greater chance of scoring a goal than the original infringement had prevented.
To then give the attacking side a second chance of scoring from the rebound is an unfair extra advantage, especially as goalkeepers must have one foot on or behind the line when the kick is taken.
Read more in football
The other argument is that by making the penalty a one-off kick - similar to the rules in
hockey
for a penalty
stroke
- it will end all arguments over players 'encroaching' as doing so will be irrelevant.
Under the proposed
law
change, there will automatically be a restart with a dead ball after the initial kick is taken, either a kick-off on the half-way line if the penalty is scored, or a goal-kick if it is not converted, irrespective of whether the keeper turns the ball behind and out of play.
That means iconic moments such as Harry Kane's extra-time rebound to beat Denmark after Kasper Schmeichel saved his spot kick in the Euro 2020 semi-final would no longer count.
Nor would Xabi Alonso's equaliser in Liverpool's incredible 2005 Champions League final comeback to beat AC Milan.
Most read in Football
The possible law changes are being discussed at the highest levels as world chiefs aim to improve the game ahead of the first 48-team World Cup.
And while the timetable is short, with any alterations needing to be agreed by the end of February to be in force for the 2026 tournament, there is growing momentum in favour of the radical laws rewrite.
BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK
Discussions on 'expanding the scope' of VAR interventions first surfaced at the end of 2023, when they were on the table at the 'annual
business
meeting' of the law-making International FA Board held at a Heathrow hotel.
It would see video officials potentially able to intervene and recommend decisions overturned on second yellow cards - preventing 'unfair' dismissals - and also corners when a 'clear error' has been made by the on-field officials.
7
Players would have one chance to get their penalty on target if the new law comes in
Credit: Getty
7
Video officials could even intervene on second yellow cards too
Credit: PA
7
Corners could be affected as well if referees make a clear error
Credit: Getty
When the matter was last debated, Ifab agreed there was a consensus in favour of 'considering possible amendments and improvements' to VAR protocols.
However, it is understood that only decisions that can be recommended for overturns in a matter of seconds will be considered as within the scope of the VAR changes, with Ifab concerned there should be 'no extra delay' caused by checks.
Those worries saw the idea kicked, gently, into touch when it was initially mooted, with senior Ifab figures fearing it was a step too far.
But the possible changes were discussed by football's high command during the Club World Cup in the
USA
, which Fifa considered a huge success.
Ifab has shown a willingness to make major changes to the laws in the past two years in a bid to make the game more attractive.
Trials are ongoing for Arsene Wenger's 'daylight' offside Law proposals, although it is felt more likely the former Arsenal manager's 'torso' proposal will be adopted eventually.
That would see assistant referees and VAR officials no longer looking at feet, head and any other body parts, with any overlap deeming the attacker to be onside and effectively bringing the 'Sunday league' interpretation to the top levels of the game.
At this year's AGM in
Belfast
, at the urging of Fifa President
Gianni Infantino
, Ifab agreed to introduce the new 'eight second' rule for goalkeepers, including the 'five second hand countdown' by referees, which was introduced from June 1 and used at the under-21
Euros
and the Club World Cup..
And at the start of last month, Ifab 'clarified' penalty laws to change the rule around 'accidental' double-touch penalties.
That followed the Julian Alvarez shoot-out effort against Real
Madrid
in the
Champions League
which helped eliminate Atletico Madrid when it was ruled out.
Instead, Ifab determined that similar situations will now see a retake ordered - if the kick is scored - rather than result in no goal and a free-kick for the defending team.
COMMENT
LET me start by laying my cards on the table.
Unlike the vast majority of my colleagues - and, more importantly, the fans - I LOVE VAR.
Yes, there have been too many elongated delays, and that is something that has to be addressed.
Yet there are now far fewer bad and costly decisions.
Fewer offside goals that are allowed. Fewer onside goals disallowed because the flag went up in error.
More accurate decisions on whether fouls were inside or outside the box.
If those calls would otherwise cost a side the World Cup Final, the Champions League or the Prem title, the fans, players and clubs would have every reason to be spewing blood.
But while I hear the arguments over extending the scope of VAR for second yellow cards and 'clearly wrong' corners, it feels like the thin end of the wedge.
If you allow the video bunker to intrude on these decisions, where will it stop?
Next, surely, will be VAR checks on free-kicks and throw-ins - after all, aren't they equally likely to end up with goals being scored?
And can you imagine just how long that would take?
The last World Cup saw matches routinely lasting way over 100 minutes and even in the Prem last season there was an average of just under 10 minutes added time per game.
But add in another layer of VAR oversight and we'll be lucky to see matches finish inside two hours.
Even for me, this would be too much. Thanks, but no thanks.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Enya Breen: Eight-year wait makes World Cup special
Enya Breen: Eight-year wait makes World Cup special

RTÉ News​

timean hour ago

  • RTÉ News​

Enya Breen: Eight-year wait makes World Cup special

Enya Breen was there at one of the lowest points in Irish rugby and that makes the upcoming World Cup all the more special for the Cork woman. The Ireland centre was injured for the qualifier play-off defeat to Scotland in Parma in 2021 but was among the extended squad who cut stunned and dejected figures strewn across the pitch when the final whistle blew that evening, the team losing to a last-minute converted try. There was to be no trip to New Zealand for the 2022 World Cup. Some of the pain many of the players felt came from knowing that was their last chance, while others knew their time would come; seven of the 15 starters that evening have retired or are injured this time around. But the gap to the last time Ireland ran out for World Cup action will be eight years by the time they face Japan on 24 August in Northampton. A third-place finish in the 2024 Six Nations, after a winless 2023 campaign, meant that Scott Bemand's side avoided a potentially tricky play-off route and qualified automatically for the tournament, where they will also face Spain and New Zealand in Pool C. "It's huge. We didn't make it in 2022 and that was devastating at the time, but it probably put a bit more importance on this one," Munster centre Breen told RTÉ Sport's Michael Corcoran. "We've been building for this for eight years now at this stage since the last one was held here. "It's really important to us as a group, we know it's really important for the country. "It's the pinnacle of the rugby calendar for us and we're loving the build-up, we're loving every second of it." Ireland have been training all summer with an extended preparation squad named last May. Most of the work is being done at the HPC in Blanchardstown, Dublin, while they also decamped to Ennis for a two-day stint. It's all building up to two 'Summer Send Off' warm-up games against Scotland in Cork on Saturday week and against Canada in Belfast seven days later as Bemand and his fellow coaches whittle the squad down to 32 players. "We're not rugby players to be training, everyone is buzzing to get into games now," added the 26-year-old, who has 29 caps, speaking at the Canterbury and Elverys launch of the new Ireland kit. "It'll probably show what we've done over the last few months. We've been training hard but you never know what's going to come out until you step into a Test game, into that cauldron. "Once the pressure is on, we'll see how it goes. "It's important to put ourselves in a good light, but everyone is putting the team first. "We back everyone to put in a shift and do the job the best they can. "It's going to be tough, the squad is smaller and selection is tight. It's been a tough summer but it's been great as well. "It's the longest block we've had together as a team without games so to be able to bring that intensity through the summer and bring that intensity that we need building into a World Cup. "We've hard some really hard sessions and we're pushing each other bloody hard. "There's been plenty of bite to everything. "Everyone is blowing all the time but we are chasing quality as well. We are growing every day and taking small steps in the right direction." For second row Fiona Tuite, it will also be a maiden World Cup campaign. The Dubliner, who plays with Ulster, made her Ireland bow at the victorious WXV3 tournament against Colombia in 2023. "Playing in a World Cup is absolutely huge, one of the best competitions in the world, in any sport," said the 28-year-old, who has been capped 15 times. "It's absolutely phenomenal. "Some of our girls have gone through heartbreak before and not qualified for the World Cup so this is huge. "This is massive for us and really exciting, a huge competition and we're looking forward to continuing the success that we've been building the last couple of years."

What time and TV channel is Liverpool v AC Milan today in a pre-season friendly
What time and TV channel is Liverpool v AC Milan today in a pre-season friendly

Irish Daily Mirror

time2 hours ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

What time and TV channel is Liverpool v AC Milan today in a pre-season friendly

Liverpool play their second game of pre-season following a 3-1 over Preston in an emotional day where the club remembered Diogo Jota after his, and his borther, Andre Silva's passing earlier this summer. Conor Bradley, Darwin Nunez and Cody Gakpo all got on the scoresheet with debuts for Giorgi Mamardashvili, Jeremie Frimpong and Milos Kerkez. Florian Wirtz was not involved in the matchday squad but could feature over the coming weeks for the Reds with their first game of the year against Crystal Palace in the Community Shield. READ MORE: Shelbourne bank €1.7m Champions League progress and edge closer to league phase READ MORE: Former Shamrock Rovers and Inter Milan youngster scores in trial game for Sligo Rovers AC Milan will hope to see new signing Luka Modric involved after coming in from Real Madrid on a short-term deal to replace Man City new boy Tijjani Reijnders Where is the game? The game is at the Kai Tak Sports Park in Hong Kong. What time is kick-off? The game begins at 12.30pm (Irish time) today. What TV channel is the game on? The game can be watched live on LFCTV, Liverpool's official channel, for a fee. Can the game be streamed live? The game will be streamed on LFCTV. Get the latest sports headlines straight to your inbox by signing up for free email alerts.

Lucas Paqueta ‘set to be CLEARED of betting charges as FA faced with paying West Ham star's £1MILLION legal fees'
Lucas Paqueta ‘set to be CLEARED of betting charges as FA faced with paying West Ham star's £1MILLION legal fees'

The Irish Sun

time9 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

Lucas Paqueta ‘set to be CLEARED of betting charges as FA faced with paying West Ham star's £1MILLION legal fees'

LUCAS PAQUETA is set to be cleared of spot-fixing charges, according to reports. The West Ham star has played for two years while allegations of being deliberately yellow carded were hanging over his head. Advertisement 2 Lucas Paqueta is set to be cleared of spot-fixing charges Credit: Getty 2 Paqueta was accused of being deliberately carded on four occasions Credit: PA It was alleged that Paqueta picked up bookings on four separate occasions between November 2022 to August 2023 amid suspicious betting patterns being flagged. A guilty verdict could have seen the 27-year-old slapped with a lifetime ban from football. But reports from The FA are set to confirm their decision early next week. Advertisement West Ham and Paqueta are said to be furious over how long it has taken to reach a verdict. The FA could now face having to cover the cost of the midfielder's legal fees, which is in the region of £1million. Shortly before the investigation became public, Manchester City had agreed an £85million deal to sign the former Lyon man from West Ham. But that move collapsed once City became aware of the allegations. Advertisement Most read in Football An investigation was launched after suspicions betting patterns were identified originating from Paqueta Island in Brazil, where the player was born. Bets ranging from just £7 to £400 were placed on the four separate cards, in matches against Leicester, Aston Villa, Leeds and Bournemouth. A total of £100,000 in winnings came from bets placed on the four bookings. West Ham's then shirt sponsor, Betway, as well as a number of other high-profile bookmakers, raised concerns after their automatic systems which monitor suspicious betting were triggered. Advertisement After the nine-month FA probe, Paqueta was charged in May last year but did not face a hearing until March 2025, which finished following the end of the Premier League season. During the hearing, evidence was heard from former West Ham boss David Moyes. Paqueta's form has nosedived during the process, with the playmaker in tears on the pitch following a booking in a West Ham game versus Tottenham in May. Following that match, Paqeuta's wife released an emotional statement saying the family had been living through a "nightmare" for two years. Advertisement Sources close to the player have revealed that the allegations have had a serious impact on Paqueta's mental well-being. Read more on the Irish Sun THIS IS A DEVELOPING STORY.. The Sun is your go to destination for the best football, boxing and MMA news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video . Like us on Facebook at

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store