Queensland's shark control plan facing court challenge and federal intervention, experts say
The expansion of Queensland's lethal shark control program will be challenged in court – should it escape a looming entanglement with federal laws – according to marine scientists and policy experts.
The Queensland government announced plans to pump $88m over four years into the state's shark management plan, which would see shark nets and baited drumlines rolled out at more beaches, as well as the expanded use of non-lethal technology such as drone surveillance.
The Crissafuli government announced its plan was one that 'prioritised beach goers' safety' which it said was 'put at risk' by the previous government to 'appease radical agendas'.
'It's clear the program had lost its way under previous Labor governments who failed to act and put people after the demands of environmental activists,' primary industries minister Tony Perrett said in a statement.
But Humane World for Animals marine biologist Lawrence Chlebeck said the LNP was 'simply playing politics' with a highly emotive issue, describing their shark policy as a 'thinly veiled ruse' to appear supportive of the fishing industry by picking a legal fight 'they know they'll lose'.
Many commercial anglers are clamouring for more sharks to be culled amid rising rates of depredation of their catch.
Chlebeck confirmed HWA was already looking into a legal challenge – but federal intervention could mean that it 'may not even come to that'.
As well as catching and culling target sharks, Queensland's shark nets and drumlines kill, injure and entangle non-target species. Chlebeck said public data showed that last year 1,639 animals were caught in the program – fewer than half of which were targeted sharks – including 22 whales and dolphins, 37 turtles and 46 rays. More than 980 animals were killed.
Queensland's shark control program has been running since 1962 and is grandfathered into the federal Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act, designed to protect threatened species.
But Chlebeck said that exemption comes with a clause that the shark control program be assessed if it is expanded and shown to have a significant impact on threatened species
'The catch of protected species like whales and dolphins, the catch of threatened species like marine turtles and a number of shark species, including the critically endangered grey nurse, that could and most likely will open it up to review under the EPBC Act,' he said.
'The Queensland state government, they know all of this, so if they really want to push forward with these plans, they're going to come into conflict with the federal government and the new federal environment minister – which may or may not have been their plan all along.'
But Chlebeck said the state's 'bluster' would end up 'opening up their own program to a scrutiny it has never before faced'.
And the marine biologist has form when it comes to lethal shark control in Queensland.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
In 2019 the then Humane Society International had the state's plans for the lethal use of nets and drumlines in the Great Barrier Reef quashed by the federal court of Australia, with a judge ruling the scientific evidence presented was 'overwhelming' that the program's culling of sharks did 'not reduce the risk of unprovoked shark interactions'.
University of Sydney associate professor of public policy and expert in the politics of shark attacks, Chris Pepin-Neff, agreed the Queensland government's announcement was more about taking culture wars to the open water than implementing evidence-backed policy.
'I think there's no doubt that the Queensland government believes that this is kind of a war on woke,' Pepin-Neff said. 'This is definitely a tough-on-sharks kind of policy decision and it includes killing sharks – and making sure everyone knows that they're killing sharks – as a way to provide political cover.'
'There's no real way to interpret this other than that the politicians have decided that they are going to win elections by killing sharks'.
A spokesperson for the federal environment department confirmed the Queensland shark control program was exempt from the EPBC Act 'in its current form … as it was in operation prior to commencement of the act'.
'It is the responsibility of the Queensland Government to ensure any changes to its program are still covered by the exemption and refer any action that requires an approval under the EPBC Act,' the spokesperson said.
The state government was contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
Australian Robert Pether released from Iraqi prison four years after being arbitrarily detained
Australian engineer Robert Pether has been released from his Iraq jail cell more than four years after he was arbitrarily detained. Pether was working on a project to help build the new headquarters for the Central Bank of Iraq when he was detained in Baghdad in April 2021. He had flown in for a meeting with bank officials to resolve a dispute they were having with his engineering firm, CME Consulting, over the project. Pether was later sentenced and fined over allegations that his firm spent money that should have gone to an architect and a subcontractor. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email In a report in March 2022, the United Nations working group on arbitrary detention found Pether had been arbitrarily detained in breach of international law. It also heard allegations that Pether and his Egyptian colleague's trials were compromised and that he had been subjected to torture-like practices. The body called for their immediate and unconditional release. After more than four years in prison, Pether has now been released. Pether's wife, Desree, welcomed the development and said her family were 'grateful to everyone who contributed to this happening'. But she also warned her husband remains trapped in Iraq due to a travel ban, and urgently needs medical care. 'He's unrecognisable,' she told Guardian Australia. 'So frail and weak. He needs urgent medical care and that's not possible in Iraq.' The foreign minister, Penny Wong, said the Australian government had raised the case with Iraqi authorities more than 200 times. 'I want to thank Australian officials for their tireless work on Mr Pether's case, including Australia's special envoy who travelled to Iraq in recent weeks to negotiate for this outcome,' she said. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion The case has prompted prime ministerial intervention, with Anthony Albanese raising Pether's detention with then Iraqi prime minister Mustafa al-Kadhimi in 2022. In 2022, the Guardian obtained an emotional letter from Pether to his family, penned from behind bars. The letter warned his family that his prognosis was 'bleak' and that he was facing a potential 'death sentence'. Pether also wrote of his daily torment about how he should break it to his children that he might not be coming home. 'How do you tell a little girl who loves unicorns and cats that her daddy will not be coming home? How do you tell your children that you are proud of them, but will not be sharing the accolades (and pitfalls) of their lives with them?,' Pether wrote. 'And toughest of all, how do you tell your wife, who is very much the other half of you, that you will not be keeping the promise you made to grow old together?'
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Channel Seven star wants 'brutal' sport BANNED after joining Anthony Albanese in campaign against event championed by UFC bad boy Conor McGregor
Plans to bring bare-knuckle boxing to Perth have been dealt a serious blow - and now, former Channel Seven personality turned Opposition Leader Basil Zempilas is leading calls for the sport to be permanently banned. The Bare Knuckle Fighting Championship [BKFC], co-owned by UFC icon Conor McGregor, was expected to stage its Australian debut in Perth this July. Instead, the WA Combat Sports Commission has declined the application, leaving organisers scrambling and critics relieved. Zempilas, once a mainstay of Seven's AFL and Olympic coverage, now serves as Leader of the Opposition and head of the WA Liberal Party. He's demanding the State Government take the next step and outlaw the sport altogether, arguing it has no place in Western Australia. 'It was very clear that a significant majority of Western Australians did not want this brutal sport to be coming to Perth,' Zempilas said. 'It should not have taken this long, and there are still lots of questions.' He urged the Combat Sports Commission, chaired by former Labor Minister Bob Kucera, to publicly explain why the permit was denied. 'We don't know what criteria was not met, or how the decision was reached,' he said. 'We don't know whether there were discussions between the Minister and the Commission, and it would appear the door is still open.' Zempilas said a full ban would be the only way to prevent future applications. 'That's what we want. Clearly that's what the people of Western Australia want.' 'It sets a bad example, there is very little demand.' 'And it took the long way and a confusing way to get there, but I'm pleased that the common sense decision was ultimately reached.' His stance has been echoed by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, who also voiced concerns earlier this week. Speaking to Triple M, Albanese said: 'A bit of common sense - you've got to look after people's health a bit and maybe save people from themselves.' He referred to the rising awareness of concussion and long-term brain damage in sport. 'I just think we've got to be much more conscious about health issues,' he said. Albanese mentioned a recent conversation with former rugby league great Mark Carroll about the long-term effects of concussion. 'It's a bit crazy,' the Prime Minister said, when asked directly about bare knuckle fighting. The Australian Medical Association WA has also taken aim at the proposed event. 'We have a domestic violence crisis,' said AMA WA President Michael Page. 'We have people sorting out their problems with their fists in Northbridge on Saturday night.' 'This is not the type of example our community needs. 'We don't need this type of race to the bottom with bloody violence.' The WA Government had faced pressure over the event's approval, particularly as Sports Minister Rita Saffioti had previously defended it. She argued it was difficult to justify banning bare-knuckle fighting while continuing to support UFC events for tourism purposes. 'I can't differentiate between this and UFC,' she said. 'Just because it's not my cup of tea, or the Premier's cup of tea, doesn't mean we have the right to say no.' Still, the application was ultimately rejected. A statement from the Combat Sports Commission confirmed the decision but offered no detailed explanation. 'After careful consideration, the Board was not satisfied the event met the required criteria,' it read. BKFC President David Feldman had previously insisted the show would go ahead, calling Australia 'perfect for showcasing BKFC.' Among the scheduled bouts was a heavyweight clash between former UFC fighter Ben Rothwell and Australian strongman Alex 'Godly Strong' Simon. Simon, who once tipped the scales at 181kg and has a background in powerlifting, has spoken openly about his time in prison. The co-main event would have featured Tasmania's 'Rowdy' Bec Rawlings, the competition's first-ever female champion. Rawlings was set to face off against Canadian fighter Jade Masson-Wong. The proposed matches were set to take place at RAC Arena on July 19. But with the permit denied and calls for a ban intensifying, the future of BKFC in Australia looks doubtful. Zempilas has called for a full explanation from the WA Government and a clear statement that the sport is unwelcome. 'The Premier and Sports Minister are still duty-bound to act,' he said.
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Why Donald Trump's latest meltdown with Elon Musk will hit Australia
Donald Trump 's fallout with the world's richest man Elon Musk is set to hurt Australia economically because it could squeeze our exports to China. Musk became the 'First Buddy' as Trump was elected and led the Department of Government Efficiency - tasked with trying to find $US2trillion in savings - but the pair have traded barbs this week on their respective platforms, X and Truth Social. Multi-billionaire Musk owns the biggest stake in Tesla, which makes its electric cars in Shanghai, and was also the loudest critic of Trump's punitive tariff hikes against the communist superpower this year. Musk's absence from Trump's inner circle could huge ramifications for Australia if the US re-escalates its trade war with China - who, importantly, is the biggest buyer of our iron ore used to make steel. Professor Peter Dean, the director of foreign policy with the University of Sydney 's United States Studies Centre, said Trump would no longer hear the views of Musk, a businessman with strong ties to China. 'It's less likely [Trump would hold back on China tariffs] now that Elon Musk is out of government,' Prof Dean told Daily Mail Australia. 'Donald Trump will still continue to pursue the policies that he has, irrespective of what Elon says and Elon's influence on Trump has basically dissipated. 'What is Musk now? Musk is a businessman inside the United States like anybody else.' The Trump Administration in April slapped 145 per cent tariffs on China. While the US and China are in talks to substantially reduce them, Musk was clearly frustrated and predicted the American-led trade war would result in a recession in late 2025. 'The Trump Tariffs will cause a recession in the second half of this year,' he said on his social media platform X. Prof Dean said Trump's cabinet secretaries, with differing opinions on how to handle China, would no longer hear an alternative point of view within the administration. 'Elon Musk is connected to China in many, many ways that actually work against some of the views of President Trump and his team and particularly their tariffs on China,' he said. 'This is another area of concern that's caused this rift between Musk and between Trump. 'He was clearly not listening to Elon Musk's view on China and tariffs and he's even less likely to do now.' The fallout occurred just four months after Trump signed an executive order establishing DOGE, and putting Musk in charge with access to departmental files. 'There's a long history in the United States of billionaires and their involvement in politics - it normally always ends pretty quickly and it often doesn't end very well because of the personalities involved,' Prof Dean said. 'I'm actually in one way surprised it's last as long as it has.' Sarah Hunter, the Reserve Bank of Australia's assistant governor in charge of economic policy, said Australia would suffer from the US-China trade war if the Chinese government was too slow to put in place a stimulus package to spur demand. 'If this were to occur the income flows from commodity exports would fall significantly,' she told a Brisbane business lunch this week. Iron ore prices have plunged by 15 per cent, from $US112 to $US95.70 as of Friday afternoon, after the US doubled steel tariffs to 50 per cent, including on Australia. Weaker commodity prices reduce Australian government revenue from company taxes, leading to even bigger Budget deficits. This could in turn make Australian companies less likely to invest as consumers cut back on spending in an already weak economy. 'While key parts of Australia's export volumes may be relatively resilient to global demand conditions and uncertainty, domestic demand is unlikely to be completely insulated,' Ms Hunter said. 'Greater uncertainty about the future can lead households and businesses to save instead of spending and investing, and this is likely to be the case for Australian households and businesses too. 'And increased borrowing costs and risk premia in global financial markets are likely to spill into domestic markets, further weighing on activity.' Prof Dean said Trump's tariffs lacked any kind of strategy, with the American President having second thoughts about banning Chinese social media platform TikTok, despite concerns about spyware. 'He overturned the ban on TikTok because he personally likes TikTok,' he said.
