The Trump administration has a high bar in trying to remove the Perkins Coie judge
Recall that the DOJ under then-special counsel Jack Smith didn't take the step that the DOJ under Trump is taking against Howell. When Smith appealed Cannon's decision to dismiss Trump's documents case, outside groups supporting Smith called for her ouster; but the appeals court didn't rule before Trump won the 2024 election, after which Smith moved to dismiss the case based on DOJ policy against prosecuting sitting presidents.
But with the DOJ making a motion for Howell's disqualification, we should get a court ruling on the subject.
And what is the Justice Department arguing? From its motion filed Friday, here's a summary of the government's position why, in its words, the judge 'has repeatedly demonstrated partiality against and animus towards the President' in several past cases in addition to the present one:
Examples include this Court enabling the improper efforts of disgraced former prosecutor Jack Smith despite a readily apparent lack of venue in this District; wrongly suggesting in public that President Trump is an authoritarian; and incorrectly finding that President Trump — the most well-known man on Earth — presents a flight risk where even the prior Administration's Department of Justice had to retract such a suggestion. This Court's comments at the hearing on the meritless motion for a temporary restraining order ('TRO') in this case, including gratuitous and biased references by this Court regarding the investigation of Special Counsel Robert Mueller ('Mueller Report'), confirm that reasonable observers may view this Court as incapable of fairly adjudicating these claims against the Commander-In-Chief.
At the outset, there's an important distinction to draw between a judge's rulings and other things such as their outside comments, relationships and the like. That's because, according to a Supreme Court precedent that the DOJ cites in its disqualification motion, rulings alone 'almost never constitute a valid basis for a bias or partiality motion.'
To be sure, the DOJ doesn't only cite Howell's rulings. DOJ lawyers pointed to a 2023 speech she gave at a conference in which, they wrote, she 'lamented that America is at a 'crossroads' and, in an apparent reference to President Trump, indicated that one path would lead to authoritarianism.' They also cited her remark at a hearing in the Perkins Coie case about Trump having 'a bee in his bonnet.'
When it comes to judicial statements, a party has an even more difficult task when the statements come from the judge's participation in the relevant legal proceedings, as opposed to from what's known as an 'extrajudicial' source. That subject came up when Trump tried to remove U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan from his other federal criminal case, and she rejected his motion, citing that distinction.
While there are distinctions between the situations, it would be surprising if Howell rules differently than Chutkan did when she decides on the motion. Given the high bar for disqualification, if she does in fact deny it, then the Trump DOJ could have a tough time if it presses the matter on appeal.
Subscribe to the Deadline: Legal Newsletter for expert analysis on the top legal stories of the week, including updates from the Supreme Court and developments in the Trump administration's legal cases.
This article was originally published on MSNBC.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Associated Press
8 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Justice Department says 2 Chinese nationals charged with spying inside the US for Beijing
WASHINGTON (AP) — Two Chinese nationals have been charged with spying inside the United States on behalf of Beijing, including by taking photographs of a naval base, coordinating a cash dead-drop and by participating in efforts to recruit members of the military who they thought might be open to working for Chinese intelligence. The case, filed in federal court in San Francisco and unsealed Monday, is the latest Justice Department prosecution to target what officials say are active efforts by the Chinese government to secretly collect intelligence about American military capabilities — a practice laid bare in startling fashion two years ago with China's launching of a surveillance balloon that U.S. officials ultimately shot down over the coast of South Carolina. 'This case underscores the Chinese government's sustained and aggressive effort to infiltrate our military and undermine our national security from within,' Attorney General Pam Bondi said in a statement announcing the case. 'The Justice Department will not stand by while hostile nations embed spies in our country – we will expose foreign operatives, hold their agents to account, and protect the American people from covert threats to our national security.' Officials identified the defendants as Yuance Chen, 38, who arrived in the U.S. on a visa in 2015 and later became a lawful permanent resident, and Liren 'Ryan' Lai, 39, who prosecutors say lives in China but came to Texas this past spring as part of an effort to supervise clandestine espionage operations on behalf of China's Ministry of State Security or MSS. The two were arrested on charges of secretly doing China's bidding without registering as foreign agents with the Justice Department, as required by law. It was not immediately clear if they had lawyers. A spokesperson for the Chinese embassy in Washington did not immediately return a message seeking comment Tuesday. According to an FBI affidavit filed in connection with the case, investigators believe Lai had been developing Chen to be a Chinese intelligence asset since at least mid-2021. Their activities, the FBI says, included coordinating on a dead-drop of at least $10,000 in cash to another person operating at the direction of the MSS. They also conducted surveillance of a Navy recruiting station in California and Navy base in Washington state, including through photographs and videos that investigators believe were sent to Chinese intelligence. Authorities say Lai and Chen also discussed recruiting Navy employees to work for China, with Chen obtaining during a tour of a Navy installation photographs of names and hometowns of recent recruits. Many listed China as their hometown and investigators believe the information was sent to China, the FBI affidavit says. The case is one in a series of prosecutions concerning Chinese intelligence-gathering, including concerning the military. Last year, for instance, the Justice Department charged five Chinese nationals with lying and trying to cover their tracks, more than a year after they were confronted in the dark near a remote Michigan military site where thousands of people had gathered for summer drills. And in 2023, two Navy sailors were charged with providing sensitive military information to China, including details on wartime exercises, naval operations and critical technical material.
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
US calls reported threats by pro-Iran hackers to release Trump-tied material a 'smear campaign'
WASHINGTON (AP) — Pro-Iran hackers have threatened to release emails supposedly stolen from people connected to President Donald Trump, according to a news report, a move that federal authorities call a 'calculated smear campaign.' The United States has warned of continued Iranian cyberattacks following American strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities and the threats those could pose to services, economic systems and companies. The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency said late Monday that the threat to expose emails about Trump is 'nothing more than digital propaganda' meant to damage Trump and other federal officials. 'A hostile foreign adversary is threatening to illegally exploit purportedly stolen and unverified material in an effort to distract, discredit, and divide,' CISA spokeswoman Marci McCarthy wrote in a social media post, linking to a report from Reuters about the threat. 'These criminals will be found, and they will be brought to justice.' Reuters reported that it contacted the alleged hackers online. They told the news organization that it held a large cache of emails from Trump chief of staff Susie Wiles, other top advisers and porn actor Stormy Daniels, to whom a hush money payment led to Trump's criminal conviction. Federal prosecutors charged three Iranians last year on allegations of hacking into Trump's presidential campaign. Hackers also targeted the campaign of Democrats Joe Biden and Kamala Harris and unsuccessfully tried to leak material supposedly taken from Trump to Democrats and members of the media. The threat to release more hacked emails was reported the same day that CISA, the FBI and National Security Agency issued a public bulletin warning that hacking groups supportive of Tehran may attack U.S. interests despite a fragile ceasefire between Iran and Israel. The hackers, authorities warned, could seek to disrupt or disable critical infrastructure systems such as utilities, transportation and economic hubs. They also could target defense contractors or other American companies with ties to Israel, the agencies said. The bulletin outlined recommendations, including the use of regular software updates and strong password management systems to shore up digital defenses. Hackers backing Tehran have targeted U.S. banks, defense contractors and energy companies following American strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities — but so far have not caused widespread disruptions.
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘Signs Of Broken Brains': Trump's Latest Sharpie Scrawl Has People Howling
President Donald Trump on Monday renewed his attacks on Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell for refusing to cut interest rates ― and he did it with one of his go-to moves: a Sharpie-scrawled message, complete with his signature across the bottom. Trump printed out a list of central bank rates from 44 nations around the world. Switzerland topped the list at 0.25%, while 10 nations, including the United States, shared the bottom spot with 4.5%. 'Should be here,' Trump wrote, with an arrow near the top of the list. He also had a personal message for the Fed chair in his trademark block letters. 'Jerome ― You are, as usual, 'too late.' You have cost the USA a fortune ― and continue to do so ― you should lower the rate ― by a lot!' Trump wrote. 'Hundreds of billions of dollars being lost! No inflation!' White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt showed off the note during a Monday briefing. In a Truth Social post with an image of the note, Trump added that Powell and the rest of the board 'should be ashamed of themselves' and called for a 1% interest rate. Trump has threatened to fire Powell, which is not a power the president has. He is also reportedly considering naming Powell's replacement this summer, nearly a year ahead of time, effectively creating a 'shadow chair.' But the president's critics couldn't get over the Sharpie-scrawled note: Ex-GOP Strategist Warns How A Lara Trump Run Could Backfire Badly On Republicans Peter Doocy Asks Karoline Leavitt If Trump Will Try To Deport Zohran Mamdani Wall Street Journal Warns Trump May Have Just Sabotaged His Own Presidency
