Zambian govt argues in court that it was never Edgar Lungu's wish to be buried in SA
The court is hearing arguments from the government and Lungu's family over where the head of state should be buried.
Lungu died in South Africa in June while receiving medical attention in the country.
The Pretoria High Court halted his burial ahead of Monday's court battle.
Arguing on behalf of the Zambian government, Advocate Ben Stoop has referenced the minutes of meetings between the family of Lungu and the Zambian government, saying it was clear that the former president did not want to be buried in South Africa, and it was his wish for his remains to be repatriated back home.
In June, Lungu's family tried to have him buried in South Africa, saying they did not want Zambia's current president, Lungu's political nemesis, Hakainde Hichilema, present at his funeral.
But Advocate Stoop said the family and the State agreed on a programme for the repatriation and the funeral programme, which stipulates that Hichilema would be present when dignitaries are welcomed and during the programme.
Stoop further argues that in Zambian law, there is a clear judicial precedent, stating that with a person of significant national interest, the wishes of that person and the family must yield to the broader public interest.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
ANC and DA trade barbs over City of Tshwane's cleaning levy
The DA accused the City of Tshwane of wasting taxpayers' money. The City of Tshwane (CoT) used three advocates and hundreds of papers to argue, and lose, the cleaning levy case in the Pretoria High Court last Thursday. The court ruled that the fee was illegal and invalid. AfriForum approached the court to set aside the metro's decision to impose a new mandatory monthly levy of R194.37 (excluding VAT) on approximately 260 000 households and businesses within the metro. AfriForum argued that the levy amounted to illegal and unfair double taxation, especially in cases where residents do not benefit from the metro's refuse removal service and are forced to use private service providers, she said. ALSO READ: Tshwane and Joburg squeeze residents for cash Tshwane MMC accuses DA of introducing cleaning levy However, the MMC for Environment and Agriculture Management, Obakeng Ramabodu, clapped back and said the City of Tshwane will appeal this judgment as it believes a cleaning levy, aimed at improving the maintenance of landfills, is necessary. He also accused the DA of introducing the levy while it was running the city. 'Much has been made of this cleansing levy, and it must be noted that a cleansing levy is not unique to the City of Tshwane. A cleansing levy was introduced in Tshwane between 2016 and 2021 by the erstwhile government, which now claims to take exception to it,' he said. DA accuses Tshwane of wasting taxpayers' money DA Tshwane caucus leader, Cilliers Brink, said his party will write to the city manager to investigate the handling of the cleaning fee. Brink said the judgment in the Pretoria High Court setting aside the cleaning levy revealed the extent to which Tshwane's ANC-led coalition is wasting taxpayers' money. 'AfriForum took the levy on review, and the judge was scoffing at the city's conduct of the case. Not only did the court point to the failure of the city to produce policy documents on which its defence was based, but [it] also criticised the overreach of the city in employing three advocates to argue the case and producing hundreds of pages of socially irrelevant documents,' he said. Brink stated that the cost of every page and billable hour for the advocates was at the expense of the residents of Tshwane. 'The irony is that this money is spent to justify a levy which the city cannot even explain. 'In the paragraph, the judge even issues a warning to the city's legal representatives of the professional, ethical implications of pulling up such a bad case,' he added. ALSO READ: Levy court battle far from over Brink said when the levy was debated in council, the DA rejected the idea of such a levy as a way of filling the city's coffers. 'The same budget which raised the levy did not increase the allocation for city cleanings. The ANC-coalition didn't actually plan to spend the money on city cleansing,' he said. Brink questioned the City of Tshwane's decision to appeal the court judgment on the cleaning levy. 'If the city's legal team could not even produce documents that the city relied on to defend the levy in court, it's unclear how they would sustain an appeal.'
Eyewitness News
a day ago
- Eyewitness News
Edgar Lungu's family files papers for leave to appeal High Court judgement
JOHANNESBURG - The family of former Zambian President Edgar Lungu have filed papers for leave to appeal Friday's High Court judgement. Earlier on Friday, Gauteng Judge President Aubrey Ledwaba delivered an order that Lungu's remains be repatriated to Lusaka for burial. However, the family has filed papers on their intention to apply for leave to appeal the judgement in the supreme court. It has been two months since the former Zambian head of State died in Johannesburg while receiving medical attention. The court battle - which has taken place in the same time frame in South African courts - between the Zambian government and the Lungu family is far from over. ALSO READ: Court orders Edgar Lungu's remains be repatriated back to Zambia The Lungu family has approached the High Court for leave to appeal its judgement in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA). In its papers the family argues that the full bench, which heard the matter earlier this week, erred in granting the Zambian government its wish to repatriate president Lungu's body. On Friday, the court agreed with the Zambian government that an agreement was reached between the State and the family in meeting in June for Lungu's remains to be repatriated and for a State funeral to be held for him in Lusaka. But the family disputes this, saying the court failed to consider the full set of events between the parties in that meeting. The High Court will now consider the Lungu family's application for leave to appeal and if granted the matter will be heard in the SCA.
TimesLIVE
2 days ago
- TimesLIVE
High court orders repatriation of ex-Zambian leader Edgar Lungu's body
The Pretoria high court on Friday ordered the repatriation of former Zambian president Edgar Lungu's body for a state funeral, siding with Zambia's government over his family who wanted him buried in South Africa, not in the presence of his successor. Lungu, Zambia's head of state from 2015 to 2021, died in South Africa on June 5 while receiving medical treatment. The high court halted plans for Lungu to be buried in Johannesburg on June 25, hours before a private ceremony was due to start. Zambia's government had approached the court arguing that Lungu should be given a state funeral and buried at a designated site in the Zambian capital Lusaka, like all other presidents since independence from Britain in 1964. Lungu's family said he did not want incumbent President Hakainde Hichilema, a long-standing political rival and his successor, at his funeral.
