'I have nothing to hide': New role for former chief of scandal-hit CHI cost State €123k in legal fees
Eilish Hardiman, who had been on medical leave in October 2023 when it became clear she would not be given a third term at the helm of CHI, subsequently took legal action in order to ensure her continued employment.
Addressing the issue at the Public Accounts Committee on Thursday morning, Ms Hardiman acknowledged that the terms of the settlement which saw her appointed as strategic programme director at CHI last year on an equivalent salary to the CEO of €184,000 are subject to a non-disclosure agreement. However, she insisted: 'I have nothing to hide."
She said she could not waive the terms of that NDA in order to address the matter further at the PAC as two other people were also involved in the agreement and would also have to waive their right to confidentiality.
Then minister for health, Stephen Donnelly, ruled that Ms Hardiman's contract should not be renewed in late 2023 amid the fallout from several scandals at CHI, including the insertion of non-medical grade springs into the spines of children during surgery and the alleged carrying out of unnecessary hip dysplasia surgeries on other children.
Ms Hardiman said that she had retained legal counsel when it became clear her contract would not be renewed due to 'an employment law matter', that being that she was entitled to a contract of indefinite duration as she had worked two separate five-year contracts as the head of CHI.
The committee heard that the legal cost of the mediation talks between Ms Hardiman and CHI which led to her re-appointment in the alternate role amounted to €123,000 after tax, and that bill had been footed by the Chief State Solicitor's Office.
2021 report
CHI's new chief executive Lucy Nugent said that 'in hindsight' the organisation should have informed both the Comptroller and Auditor General and the NTPF about a 2021 report into issues surrounding waiting list management, including the fact that a consultant had allegedly referred public patients to his own private weekend clinics.
She said, however, that the first she had heard about the report was when she received a media query regarding same in May of this year from the Sunday Times. Asked why she had not informed her successor about the report during the handover of the CEO function, Ms Hardiman said that 'a lot of the issues in the report had been addressed'.
She said the report was confidential and 'never intended to be shared'. 'The issues were known to management and had been raised with the HSE. What's most important is that it was raised through the proper channels,' Ms Hardiman said.
She conceded that she had never raised the matter with the Medical Council, something Ms Nugent has done recently on two occasions.
When asked why the matter had not been raised with the gardaí, as it had been by the HSE, Ms Nugent said she did not believe that the threshold for escalating matters in that fashion had been reached, adding that she did not believe the funds of the NTPF had been misused with regard to what had transpired.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
12 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on delayed hospital discharges: a perennial problem with serious consequences
The latest figures from the HSE show that there were delays in discharging 5,500 people from acute hospital care so far this year, leading to more than 85,500 lost 'bed days' in the system. In turn, this is contributing to delays in people getting through the A&E system and in particular more time spent on trolleys. And we know that, as well as causing discomfort, this also exposes the patients to higher clinical risk. What is formally called a delayed transfer of care occurs when a person is ready to leave the acute care system but remains occupying a bed. This is a perennial problem in the Irish hospital system and is part of a wider story of a growing and ageing population putting pressure on social services. This can happen for a number of reasons but generally involves older people who are waiting for an appropriate care programme at home, a bed in a step-down facility or space in a nursing home. Homelessness can be another issue. There has been some limited progress in recent years, with the 5,548 delayed patient transfers so far this year down from 6,6610 in 2023. But despite a range of action plans from successive ministers going back more than a decade, the issue remains a serious one. As well as contributing to the ongoing unacceptably high number of people on trolleys, an unnecessarily long stay in an acute ward also opens up the patient to greater risk of infection and means they are delayed getting on with their lives in a more appropriate setting. More funding for step-down facilities and home support packages will remain needed as the population ages. The lack of joined up technology in the Irish health system remains an issue. And delays in the administration of the support schemes for nursing homes - the Fair Deal scheme- and in the provision of home care packages are also factors. READ MORE Tackling delayed discharge remains a key issue for the hospital system . And it is also vital for the support and dignity of the largely older population and their families, who are seeking the best way forward after a period of hospital care.
Irish Examiner
15 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
HIV carries 'a big societal stigma' in Ireland despite progress in treatment
A 'persistent stigma' remains around HIV in Ireland, despite progress in treating the condition. The Cork Sexual Health Centre highlighted the stigma as revealed in its latest annual report. The report states that it provided 860 rapid HIV tests last year, as well as 677 HIV support and counselling sessions. The chairman of the centre, Ciaran Lynch, said: 'Whilst there have been very significant advances in the treatment of HIV and Aids over the last number of decades, there still is a big societal stigma associated with the condition. "Dealing with the issue is both dealing with the condition itself but also the stigma that can be associated with it. 'A lot of that is a result of people being uninformed as to the progress that has been made in treating the condition since the early 80s. In the 80s, a diagnosis of HIV would inevitably lead to full-blown Aids. "But the progress in the treatment has meant that most cases do not progress to Aids, and people can live a very fulfilling and very regular life with the treatment that is now available," Mr Lynch added. HIV is a serious, chronic illness that affects the body's immune system. It requires treatment and management for life. Antibodies Earlier this year, findings published in the Irish Journal of Medical Science — which analysed over 6,000 serum samples from bloods tests ordered by GPs, which were tested in eight hospital laboratories — revealed that analysis of bloodwork from over 1,000 people from the Cork region found HIV antibodies in 1.05% of samples, approximately three times the national average. It came as the HSE launched the "You, Me, and HIV" campaign to help reduce the stigma experienced by people living with HIV here. Survey results released to coincide with the launch of the campaign showed that 70% of people do not know that a person with HIV cannot pass it to sexual partners when they are on effective treatment. Mr Lynch said there is also a stigma around transgender issues. 'As society progresses and we see very progressive developments, such as marriage equality and tolerance of difference, new differences emerge and become visible, and that is where the transgender community actually is," he said. Those issues come with their challenges as well, as the previous ones did. There are the challenges of societal understanding and societal acceptance, and both go hand in hand The centre's executive director, Fiona Finn, said the relocation of the centre from Peter's St to the South Mall means the team at the centre is now ready for 'the next phase of its journey, continuing to provide vital services, raise awareness, and advocate for minority populations especially those living with HIV and trans people'. The report noted that there was a 26% increase in demand for post-termination counselling at the centre last year, rising to almost 330 sessions. Meanwhile, 328 counselling sessions were provided for members of the LGBT+ community last year. The centre has been in existence for more than 30 years, providing sexual health education, advocacy, and support services. The centre says its focus is on 'inclusivity and respect', with services including pregnancy counselling, sexual health workshops, and rapid HIV testing, as well as serving as a collection point for SH24 self-test kits.
Irish Times
21 hours ago
- Irish Times
5,500 patients have stayed in Irish hospitals longer than medically necessary this year
More than 5,500 patients have been in hospital for longer than medically necessary so far this year, with 29 patients having stayed in hospital for more than six months due to delays in accessing care they need in the community. A delayed transfer of care occurs when a patient is ready to leave inpatient care but is still occupying a HSE -funded bed. It happens for a variety of reason, including delays in accessing home care, delays in accessing residential care, homelessness or complex care needs, among others. An internal HSE report found there have been 5,548 delayed transfers up to August 5th, 2025. This has resulted in 85,556 lost bed days. The number of delayed discharges has decreased when compared to the same periods in previous years. Up to August, 2023, there were 6,610 patients in hospital longer than necessary, while in 2024 the number was 6,235. READ MORE According to the latest report, 74 patients have been in hospital this year despite being medically fit for discharge for three or more months, while 29 have been there for six or more months. Every week, on average, there are 404 patients in hospital who are well enough to be discharged. Galway University Hospitals have the highest weekly average at 44, followed by Letterkenny University Hospital (33) and Sligo University Hospital (26). The hospital with the lowest average number is St Luke's Radiation Oncology Network, with zero. In the week ending August 5th, there were 393 delayed transfers, of which almost two-fifths related to delays in accessing nursing homes or residential care settings. Forty-seven patients were delayed as their funding application for nursing home support had not yet been submitted and 12 patients were waiting for their application to be reviewed. A further 47 had been approved for funding but were waiting to secure a place in a care setting, while 20 patients were awaiting step-down placements at community nursing units, district hospitals or HSE facilities. Complex clinical needs is another cause behind the delayed transfers, the HSE report shows. There were 22 patients with behavioural, verbal or cognitive issues who were awaiting access to dementia-specific services in the week ending August 5th. Twelve patients were waiting for a 'bespoke residential placement' due to challenging behaviour that requires specialist management. The HSE is seeking to reduce delayed discharges to alleviate pressure on public hospital beds, which are often in high demand, resulting in more than 100,000 patients waiting on trolleys last year. Delayed discharges are also a concern as they increase a patient's chances of contracting a healthcare-associated infection. A HSE spokesman said to help reduce delayed hospital exits, the executive provides temporary financial support for patients who are medically discharged but unable to return home. 'This funding facilitates timely transfers to private nursing homes or convalescent care, helping to free up acute hospital beds,' he said. The spokesman said discharge delays can occur where patients are awaiting arrangement of suitable home support or residential care and they have complex clinical needs or legally complex circumstances. 'Delays experienced in identifying a suitable nursing home place for a patient can be caused by such beds to meet a patient's specific needs not being available in the area at that time,' he said. 'Some geographic areas are currently experiencing challenges in securing nursing home beds due to a shortage of available nursing home beds in the area.'
