Senate parliamentarian allows GOP to keep ban on state AI rules
The decision, announced by lawmakers over the weekend, followed weeks of speculation from both parties over whether the provision would overcome the procedural hurdle known as the Byrd Rule.
The parliamentarian's decision will allow the provision to be voted on in the budget reconciliation process with a simple-majority vote.
It comes after Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), the chair of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation, altered the language of the House's version in hopes of complying with the Byrd Rule, which prohibits 'extraneous matters' from being included in reconciliation packages.
Under their proposal, states would be prohibited from regulating AI if they want access to federal funding from the Broadband Equity, Access and Deployment (BEAD) program.
The House's version called for a blanket 10-year moratorium on state laws regulating AI models and systems, regardless of funding.
Still, some GOP members remained skeptical it would pass the Byrd Rule. Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) said last week it was 'doubtful' the provision survives.
The provision has further divided Republicans, while Democrats are largely against it.
While many Republicans are concerned with overbearing regulation of the emerging tech, a few GOP members argue it goes against the party's traditional support of states' rights.
Republican Sens. Marsha Blackburn (Tenn.) and Ron Johnson (Wis.) told The Hill they are against the provision, while Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) said he is willing to introduce an amendment to eliminate the provision during the Senate's marathon vota-a-rama if it is not taken out earlier.
The provision received pushback from some Republicans in the House as well.
A group of hard-line conservatives argued in a letter earlier this month to Senate Republicans that Congress is still 'actively investigating' AI and 'does not fully understand the implications' of the technology.
This was shortly after Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) confirmed she would be a 'no' on the bill if it comes back to the House with the provision included.
'I am 100 percent opposed, and I will not vote for any bill that destroys federalism and takes away states' rights, ability to regulate and make laws when it regards humans and AI,' the Georgia Republican told reporters.
Several Republican state leaders and lawmakers are also pushing back.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
39 minutes ago
- New York Post
Beto O'Rourke slams Trump admin, compares 2025 America to 1933 Germany
Former Texas Rep. Beto O'Rourke remarked how he 'can only imagine the history books' that will be written about the people of 2025, and likened it to 1933 Germany on Wednesday. The Democrat appeared with Gov. Gavin Newsom, D-Calif., on the governor's podcast 'This is Gavin Newsom,' where he commented on Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton investigating his Powered by People PAC for allegedly violating the law by assisting Texas state Democrats' travel out of the state to avoid a quorum during a redistricting standoff. Advertisement O'Rourke lauded the efforts of the Texas Democrats, calling them some of the 'very last lines of defense' of democracy. By contrast, he predicted Republicans, and by extension, the Trump administration, would be remembered similarly to the rise of the Nazi Party in Germany. 'I can only imagine the history books written 100 years from now looking at the people of 2025,' O'Rourke said. 'It's the way, you know, you and I when we were in school, we're looking at the people in Germany in 1933. That guy's named chancellor in January of that year. In 53 days, he has destroyed German democracy.' Democrat Beto O'Rourke speaks alongside elected officials gathered for a rally ahead of a public hearing on the proposed congressional redistricting on Saturday, July 26, 2025 in Houston. Houston Chronicle via Getty Images Advertisement He continued, 'The parliament or the congress, their legislature, passed these enabling laws just like the Republicans are doing in Congress today that said anything you want, you go out and do it. And he goes from being this buffoonish, clownish thug who can barely hold power to the undisputed master and dictator of the German people. And I know this s— doesn't repeat, but it sure as hell rhymes.' O'Rourke has frequently compared President Donald Trump and his administration to Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party. In 2019, O'Rourke attacked Trump's family separation policy at the border and accused him of calling all immigrants an 'infestation.' 'Now, I might expect someone to describe another human being as an infestation in the Third Reich. I would not expect it in the United States of America,' O'Rourke said. O'Rourke made his comments on California Governor Gavin Newsom's 'This is Gavin Newsom' podcast. Youtube/This is Gavin Newsom Advertisement He defended his comments days later saying, 'Calling human beings an infestation is something that we might've expected to hear in Nazi Germany… Describing immigrants — who have a track record of committing violent crimes at a lower rate than native-born Americans — as rapists and criminals. Seeking to ban all Muslims — all people of one religion — what other country on the face of the planet does that kind of thing?' In 2021, O'Rourke also warned the US could become Nazi Germany within 10 years despite Trump losing the 2020 election. Fox News Digital broke the news earlier that day that Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, has called for the Justice Department to also investigate O'Rourke's PAC for potentially violating the law by raising funds for Texas Democrats fleeing the state.
San Francisco Chronicle
39 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Los Angeles school year begins amid fears over immigration enforcement
LOS ANGELES (AP) — Los Angeles students and teachers return to class for the new academic year Thursday under a cloud of apprehension after a summer filled with immigration raids and amid worries that schools could become a target in the Trump administration's aggressive crackdown. Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Alberto Carvalho has urged immigration authorities not to conduct enforcement activity within a two-block radius around schools starting an hour before the school day begins and until one hour after it classes let out. 'Hungry children, children in fear, cannot learn well,' Carvalho said in a news conference. He also announced a number of measures intended to protect students and families, including adding or altering bus routes to accommodate more students. The district is to distribute a family preparedness packet that includes know-your-rights information, emergency contact updates and tips on designating a backup caregiver in case a parent is detained. The sprawling district, which covers more than two dozen cities, is the nation's second largest with more than 500,000 students. According to the teachers' union, 30,000 students are immigrants, and an estimated quarter of them are without legal status. While immigration agents have not detained anyone inside a school, a 15-year-old boy was pulled from a car and handcuffed outside Arleta High School in northern Los Angeles on Monday, Carvalho said. He had significant disabilities and was released after a bystander intervened in the case of 'mistaken identity,' the superintendent said. 'This is the exact type of incident that traumatizes our communities; it cannot repeat itself,' he added. Administrators at two elementary schools previously denied entry to officials from the Department of Homeland Security in April, and immigration agents have been seen in vehicles outside schools. DHS did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment. Carvalho said that while staffers and district police officers cannot interfere with immigration enforcement and do not have jurisdiction beyond school property, they have had conversations with federal agents parked in front of schools that resulted in them leaving. The district is partnering with local law enforcement in some cities and forming a 'rapid response' network to disseminate information about the presence of federal agents, he said. Educators worry about attendance Teachers say they are concerned some students might not show up the first day. Lupe Carrasco Cardona, a high school social studies and English teacher at the Roybal Learning Center, said attendance saw a small dip in January when President Donald Trump took office. The raids ramped up in June right before graduations, putting a damper on ceremonies. One raid at a Home Depot near MacArthur Park, an area with many immigrant families from Central America, took place the same morning as an 8th grade graduation at a nearby middle school. 'People were crying, for the actual graduation ceremony there were hardly any parents there,' Cardona said. The next week, at her high school graduation, the school rented two buses to transport parents to the ceremony downtown. Ultimately many of the seats were empty, unlike other graduations. One 11th grader, who spoke on the condition that her last name not be published because she is in the country without legal permission and fears being targeted, said she is afraid to return to school. 'Instead of feeling excited, really what I'm feeling is concern,' said Madelyn, a 17-year-old from Central America. 'I am very, very scared, and there is a lot of pressure.' She added that she takes public transportation to school but fears being targeted on the bus by immigration agents because of her skin color. 'We are simply young people with dreams who want to study, move forward and contribute to this country as well,' she said. Madelyn joined a club that provides support and community for immigrant students and said she intends to persevere in that work. 'I plan to continue supporting other students who need it very much, even if I feel scared,' she said. 'But I have to be brave.' Some families who decide that the risk is too great to show up in-person have opted for online learning instead, according to Carvalho, with virtual enrollment up 7% this year. The district has also contacted at least 10,000 parents and visited more than 800 families over the summer to provide information about resources like transportation, legal and financial support and are deploying 1,000 workers from the district's central office on the first day of classes to 'critical areas' that have seen immigration raids. 'We want no one to stay home as a result of fears,' Carvalho said.
NBC News
40 minutes ago
- NBC News
Federal agents in Trump's crime crackdown set up checkpoint in popular D.C. nightlife area
WASHINGTON — Steps away from a YMCA, popular bakery and local pharmacy, a group of law enforcement officers across several agencies turned a busy intersection in a mixed residential-commercial area of Washington, D.C., into a police checkpoint Wednesday night as part of President Donald Trump's directive to crack down on crime in the nation's capital. Uniformed officers with the Metropolitan Police Department stood alongside Homeland Security Investigations personnel and several plainclothes agents at one of the first checkpoints set up since Trump temporarily put D.C. police under federal control and deployed the National Guard. More than 100 protesters soon gathered, heckling law enforcement as they stopped cars approaching the checkpoint and in some cases flagged the vehicles for additional investigation. Some protesters began warning drivers to avoid the checkpoint. Protesters, federal agents and local officers all dispersed without incident. The Metropolitan Police Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the checkpoint and any potential arrests. Members of the National Guard, roughly 800 of whom were activated this week to support law enforcement in the city, were not seen at the checkpoint. A White House official said Wednesday that the deployment of National Guard troops would be 'significantly higher' throughout the week, and that the operation would expand from evening shifts to working around the clock. The increased law enforcement presence has drawn mixed reactions from D.C.-area residents — some are praising the crackdown on crime while others are criticizing Trump for his administration's tactics. "I know every inch of the city, and to have seen over the years the deterioration of public places, either with graffiti or with people who are homeless, I couldn't be more encouraged by the fact that there are people now that really want to say, 'Stop let's make this better,'" said Christopher Her, a Maryland resident who previously worked in D.C. Morgan Komlo, who's lived in Washington for 10 years, disputed Trump's characterization of the city as unsafe, pointing to falling violent crime rates. She called Trump's news conference announcing the federalization of the city's police "scary" and warned that a further exertion of executive power could result in protests. "I thought it was scary," Komlo said. "I also have lived here long enough to know D.C. is not going to stand for much, and I was here in 2016 when there was a lot of protesting" after Trump won the election. D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser on Tuesday characterized Trump's takeover of local police as an "authoritarian push" during a virtual event she held with constituents where she rejected the president's assertion that there's been a spike in crime. But the Democratic mayor conceded that while she opposes Trump's actions, he has the authority to carry out his executive order. "We all need to do what we can in our space, in our lane, to protect our city, to protect our autonomy, to protect our home rule, and get to the other side of this guy and make sure we elect a Democratic House so that we have a backstop to this authoritarian push," Bowser said. According to federal data released in January, violent crime in the district for 2024 was at its lowest level in more than three decades, and down 35% from the previous year. In Monday's order, Trump cited several high-profile violent acts in justifying his decision to deploy National Guard troops and take control of the D.C. police, including the fatal shootings of a congressional intern in June and two Israeli Embassy staffers in May. The directive to federalize D.C. police lasts for the 30-day maximum, barring legislation passed by Congress to extend that period. Trump told reporters at the Kennedy Center on Wednesday that he plans to submit a bill that will include a request to extend his police takeover. 'We're going to need a crime bill that we're going to be putting in, and it's going to pertain initially to D.C.,' he said. 'We're going to be asking for extensions on that, long-term extensions, because you can't have 30 days.' Passage of such a bill would be highly unlikely since it would need Democratic support in the Senate. National Guard troops began arriving in D.C. on Tuesday, the first tranche of nearly 800 soldiers activated by the Army to assist law enforcement in carrying out Trump's order. Roughly 30 National Guard troops were on the ground Tuesday evening, joining 750 uniformed Metropolitan Police Department officers in conducting anti-crime operations across the city. A senior Army official told NBC News that the 800 National Guard troops are expected to be operational by the end of the week. Roughly 100-200 of those troops will be supporting law enforcement at any given time once all of them are deployed, according to a spokesperson for the Army. The primary focus of their work is providing law enforcement administrative help and protecting federal personnel and property, multiple U.S. officials told NBC News. The troops are not expected to engage in direct law enforcement activities. According to data provided by the administration, federal law enforcement personnel have helped make more than 100 arrests since Monday, a third of which have resulted in firearm-related charges. Including the federalized D.C. officers, more than 1,450 personnel participated in Tuesday's effort, according to administration figures Wednesday. That count included dozens of Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents who are joining personnel from the FBI, Drug Enforcement Administration and Secret Service. Roughly 40 agents within the Homeland Security Investigations division, which typically focuses on long-term probes into transnational crimes, have joined federal personnel in an effort to mitigate crime in the city irrespective of whether those crimes are directly related to immigration. Combating unlawful immigration, a consistent focal point of Trump's presidency, is also playing a role in Trump's D.C. police takeover, with agents from ICE's Enforcement Removal Operation carrying out "targeted" stings this week to arrest immigrants. A spokesperson for ICE said that an operation at a Home Depot "resulted in arrests of criminal illegal aliens convicted of assault, theft and gang activity." 'The President was clear, he will make DC safe and beautiful again, and ICE is proud to be a part of the solution alongside our federal law enforcement partners. This includes both immigration enforcement and efforts to combat crime in support of the US Marshals Service," the spokesperson said in a statement.
