Cheap excuses for betraying free speech
Or was it copyright concerns? Or maybe a staff revolt?
The film, The Road Between Us: The Ultimate Rescue, tells the story of a retired Israeli paratrooper who rescues his son and his son's family during the Oct. 7, 2023, attack on Israel by Hamas.
TIFF officials originally said the film was being pulled partly because the filmmakers hadn't procured the rights to Hamas's livestream footage of its massacre at the kibbutz where the son lived with his wife and two children.
But that excuse was not repeated in an e-mail TIFF CEO Cameron Bailey sent to the filmmakers explaining the festival's decision. Instead, he said 'the risk of major, disruptive protest actions around the film's presence at the Festival, including internal opposition, has become too great.'
A day later, Mr. Cameron apologized 'for any pain this situation may have caused' and denied that TIFF had censored the movie. He said he 'remains committed' to working with the filmmakers in order to 'allow the film to be screened.' (Late Thursday, TIFF said the movie would be part of the festival.)
TIFF pledges to work with filmmakers of Oct. 7 documentary after pulling premiere
Opinion: TIFF's latest censorship controversy is more than just a tiff. It's existential
So, then, what was it that prompted TIFF to cancel the premiere initially: the festival's concerns about the intellectual property rights of a terrorist organization, or the 'internal opposition' and the threat of 'disruptive protest actions'?
The latter is the better bet. This is the same organization that last year postponed screenings of a documentary, Russians at War, because it was 'aware of significant threats to festival operations and public safety.'
That film, which followed a Russian battalion into battle in Ukraine, was accused of whitewashing Russian war crimes and condemned as Moscow propaganda.
Chrystia Freeland, then the deputy prime minister, said she had 'grave concerns' about the film, while the Ukrainian Canadian Congress called for the resignation of TIFF's board.
A year later, and now that people have actually watched it, Russians at War is said by critics to be a courageous antiwar film about disaffected and angry Russian soldiers forced to carry out Vladimir Putin's illegal invasion of Ukraine. Moscow would never allow its citizens to watch this film.
A year after controversial TIFF premiere, Russians at War deserves to be seen
But it's not just TIFF that is cancelling shows and hiding behind unidentified threats to security these days.
This summer brought the sorry spectacle of federal and municipal officials cancelling performances by a D-list American country musician who makes his living preaching the most retrograde parts of the MAGA agenda.
After people protested, officials in cities where concerts were scheduled cited 'security concerns' to justify shutting them down, a move that of course gave Sean Feucht more visibility in Canada than he could have ever hoped for.
Two things connect these examples. One is the fact that the security threats cited as grounds for cancelling shows are never spelled out.
People have the perfect right to call for the cancellation of a screening or musical concert that doesn't jibe with their beliefs and values, but they do not have the right to threaten violence or disruption it they don't get their way.
At the same time, organizers should not be able to imply coyly and without evidence that protesters will act illegally. By ducking behind vague security concerns instead of exerting the right to show what they please, officials leave open the possibility that what they are really doing is capitulating to the loudest voices in a polarized debate.
The other disturbing commonality is that officials are failing to reflexively protect the invaluable right to freedom of artistic and political expression in Canada.
We have no doubt that if noisy protesters demanded the withdrawal of a TIFF movie because of its glorification of violence, TIFF officials would be the first to stand up for the filmmaker's right to artistic expression.
But when it comes to telling stories or singing songs that some deem offensive, that reflex has been replaced by a knee-jerk run for cover.
This is an alarming development in Canada. In difficult times, we need people in positions of authority to stand up for freedom of expression – not look for excuses to abandon it. That never ends well for anyone.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
13 minutes ago
- CTV News
BC Greens leadership to take youthful turn, with contenders' average age of 30
B.C. Green Party Leadership candidates Emily Lowan, left to right, Jonathan Kerr and Adam Bremner-Akins are shown in a composite image of three undated handout photos. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Handout — B.C. Green Party (Mandatory Credit) VICTORIA — Stuart Parker was 21 when he became the leader of the B.C. Greens in 1993 after campaigning against McDonald's use of ozone-damaging foam packaging. He said youth alone won't be enough to sustain the next leader of the Greens, in a race where the average age of the contenders is just 30. 'So yes, I got in as the young, radical urbanite, but I maintained my leadership of that party for seven years by spending my time on the road,' said Parker, who has also run for the New Democrats and more recently has worked for the B.C. Conservatives. Parker said he campaigned not on his age, but by shaking as many hands as possible, and meeting and listening to people. The Greens' leadership contest, with a voting period from Sept. 13 to 23, features 24 year-old Emily Lowan, who is an organizer with Climate Action Network Canada, 23-year-old student Adam Bremner-Akins, and family doctor Jonathan Kerr, the elder of the group at 44. By comparison, the last two Green leaders, Sonia Furstenau and Andrew Weaver, were 54 and 59 respectively when they stood down. Lowan and Bremner-Akins have no doubts that they are experienced enough to lead. 'I absolutely think I am, and I don't think that is just arrogance,' Lowan said, adding she has a 'decade of extremely relevant experience as a movement-builder, as a campaigner and a policy researcher.' Bremner-Akins, meanwhile, pointed to his experience on the party's provincial council and two runs as candidate for the party. 'It's not always used on the younger end of the spectrum, but age is just a number,' Bremner-Akins said. 'Whether you are in your 60s, 70s 80s or 20s — it is just a number, and I have been through a lot. If people want to know, I'm seasoned. I have been fired for union organizing. I have taken on roles inside the party. I have run for election.' UBC political science lecturer Stewart Prest said having two candidates in their 20s offered a 'silver lining' for the party, because it was a chance for renewal and to distinguish the party from rivals. But there were also risks. 'At same time, it makes it that much harder to make the claim that they're a party ready to govern, that they are ready to compete and offer an alternative both to the NDP and to the Conservatives,' he added. 'So, I don't know that there is a single personnel choice here available to the Greens to turn things around.' Whoever wins, the B.C. Greens are leaning into the youth movement, both rhetorically and logistically. The party's website describes the contest as 'an opportunity for a bold new vision, fresh energy, and renewed commitment to building a sustainable, just, and prosperous British Columbia.' And party membership is free for everyone aged 14 to 29. Party members as young as 16 can vote in the contest. That emphasis isn't solely the Greens' domain. The NDP's 2022 leadership contest let members as young as 12 vote, while the Conservatives' 2023 race set the age limit at 14. Neither of the Greens' two MLAs, Rob Botterell and Jeremy Valeriote, who is the interim leader, are seeking the leadership. The Greens may have maintained a presence in the legislature after last year's election, but the party's vote share dropped from about 15 per cent to just above eight per cent, amid an increasingly polarized political environment. Prest added that 'barring a change in the electoral system ... there's only so much the Greens can do here to remain relevant.' He said the Greens should instead focus on a regional strategy. Kerr, a twice-elected municipal councillor in Comox on Vancouver Island and vice-chair of the Comox Valley Regional District, disagreed. He said his leadership campaign tour across B.C. showed 'there is Green support everywhere,' including in northern and central B.C., where voters want to see forestry practices that focus on conservation, selective logging, and value-added production to keep mills open. 'People care and see what we've been doing isn't working,' he said. 'I am focused on the environment and climate. That is how I got involved with the Greens. But I'm equally focused on creating a clean economy, a new economy that's better.' When asked whether young party members should take a flyer from a 44-year-old, Kerr chuckled. 'Isn't that funny?' he said. 'I'm the old guy in the race.' Lowan said she was running because the party needed a 'true organizer to bring this party back to life,' so it can 'be a strong thorn in the side of the governing party.' Over the years, the party had lost its youth base and connection to social and climate movements, she said. She said she wanted 'to challenge the oligarchs that really run the show in the premier's office,' as well as projects she said were jeopardizing the climate and affordability. She said the Greens need to move in 'lockstep' with social and climate movements, with young people, workers, renters and Indigenous communities for the party to have a future. 'In this moment of time, the Greens have a real crossroads, between fading into the background, or choosing to be a bold, galvanizing party,' she said. Bremner-Akins said the party needed a leader 'who lives with the problems we're facing in the province, whether that's housing affordability, the rising cost of living, the existential threat of climate change we're facing,' he said. He added that people 'need someone who isn't just passionate about issues' but 'lives with them and is motivated to deal with them because people are frustrated' by the lack of 'relative urgency' from governments. Kerr said both Lowan and Bremner-Akins were 'great young leaders' with much to offer, saying as leader he would work to get them elected as MLAs alongside him. Prest cautioned that there was no guarantee the next leader of the Greens would win a seat in the legislature, let alone the two other candidates. But he said the two younger candidates' presence in the race pointed to an 'area of potential growth for the Greens'- young, progressive voters disenchanted with the NDP on issues including the environment and energy, after nearly a decade in office. Parker, who also led the B.C. Ecosocialist party before resigning in 2020 over comments that critics called transphobic, said the Greens were currently 'incapable of being relevant' in B.C. politics. But he had some advice. 'If you are a radical party, people are supposed to be offended by your opinions,' Parker said. 'If you are not offending anybody, you are doing it wrong.' The result of the leadership contest will be announced Sept. 24. This report by Wolfgang Depner, The Canadian Press, was first published August 14, 2025.
CBC
35 minutes ago
- CBC
How BAMBII uses her 'DJ brain' to produce genre-blending electronic music
BAMBII is a Toronto-based DJ and producer whose innovative, genre-defying sound won her electronic album of the year at last year's Juno Awards. Since then, she's opened for Jamie xx and performed at music festivals around the world, like Glastonbury and the Montreux Jazz Festival in Switzerland. But BAMBII's journey into music was anything but clear cut. Unlike some artists who found support from a record label early on, BAMBII achieved her music dreams by carving out her own space in the electronic music world. More than 10 years ago, she founded JERK, a wildly popular rave series that centres queer and Caribbean communities. Those parties helped her become a better DJ while also allowing her to play the music she and her friends wanted to dance to. "I was DJing for like two seconds," BAMBII tells Q guest host Garvia Bailey in an interview. "I had no idea even truly, actually, how to DJ. I just knew I needed to hear these songs in this space.… What that grew into and the responsibility of it came later." WATCH | BAMBII's full interview with Tom Power: After her DJ sets started blowing up, the next step for BAMBII was to learn music theory and how to produce her own songs. Her Juno-winning EP, Infinity Club, mixes global club music with Jamaican genres such as dancehall, reggae and dub. Now, she's back with her follow-up, Infinity Club II, which proves just how expansive electronic music can be. "People don't know how varied or conflicted the electronic space is," BAMBII says. "It's very much a faux pas and very much taboo to bring in different sub-genres into that space as a DJ or even as a producer…. I'm not consciously trying to actually make a statement. It's just representative of how I grew up and the travel I've done, which is pretty extensive as a DJ." Growing up in Toronto as an only child, BAMBII was listening to an eclectic mix of music, from Bruce Springsteen to Buju Banton. "Basically anything my mom was listening to, I was listening to," she says. "I feel like my mom kind of set the tone for having an eclectic taste. I mean, I wouldn't even label it. Just being open-minded." WATCH | Official video for Mirror: In many ways, her approach to producing music is the same as her approach to DJing. "I produce with DJ brain and I feel the best thing about DJs is their ability to hold their memories," she says. "As a DJ you have about 2,000 favourite songs. You're very familiar with large amounts of music and you're very familiar with patterns in music, and obviously genres and sub-genres…. It's taking you a bunch of different places [and] it's making unlikely connections."
CBC
35 minutes ago
- CBC
d'bi.young anitafrika's story goes to show that every artist needs nurturing
The award-winning artist, playwright and dub poet d' anitafrika broke onto the Canadian theatre scene when they were cast in Trey Anthony's play Da Kink in My Hair. But their life in the arts started way before that. They were only three years old when they realized they were destined to be a griot (a storyteller). In an interview with Q guest host Garvia Bailey, anitafrika credits their mom, the pioneering Jamaican dub poet Anita Stewart, for inspiring their passion for storytelling and nurturing them as an artist. "I actually had a blueprint," anitafrika says. "My mother was the blueprint…. She took me to the library every Saturday. My mother taught me how to read when I was two. She gave me a lot of autonomy…. So the environment was there for me to be nurtured, and my mother provided a mirror of possibilities for me." WATCH | d' anitafrika's full interview on Q: Though anitafrika was raised to freely express themself without shame, after they moved from Jamaica to Canada at age 15, their natural artistic vibrancy and exuberance wasn't always understood or encouraged. "I experienced deep, deep self-loathing because I couldn't understand what was so strange about me," they say. "Racism was something I'd never encountered before. I had encountered classism because I grew up working class … [but in Canada, there was] a real rejection and a real demonization of Jamaican-ness because remember, this is 1993." Luckily, anitafrika was able to find "femtors and mentors" to help guide them through the difficult periods of their life. While studying at McGill University, anitafrika met educator and journalist David Austin, who helped them overcome their self-loathing and lean into their talent for storytelling. "He was specifically talking about the way that I had been speaking," they say. "So five years into being in Canada, I had this unrealistic accent, which was my attempt at covering my Jamaican-ness. I had this unrealistic persona that was, again, an attempt at survival in a hostile environment…. Somehow he had seen through all of that and had seen into this young person who had the gift of storytelling, who had a gift of communication, but was burying those gifts." This year, anitafrika is celebrating a major milestone as their critically acclaimed Sankofa Trilogy turns 20. The three solo plays of the trilogy — benu and word! sound! powah! — follow three generations of Jamaican women from their experiences of growing up to motherhood. You can catch anniversary stagings of The Sankofa Trilogy, which has now been adapted into a multi-cast production, from Aug. 13 to 17 at The Theatre Centre in Toronto.
