Brazil's brave stand against Trump
But while the US has often failed to practice what it preached, now it does neither. President Donald Trump and the Republican Party have seen to that.
In his first term, Trump's contempt for the rule of law culminated in his attempt to overturn democracy's most important principle: the peaceful transition of power. He claimed – and still insists – that he won the 2020 election, even though Joe Biden received some seven million more votes, and even though dozens of courts ruled that there had been no significant electoral irregularities.
Anyone familiar with Trump may not have been surprised; the big surprise was that some 70 per cent of Republicans believe that the election was rigged. Many Americans – including a majority of one of the two major parties – have gone down the rabbit hole of outlandish conspiracy theories and disinformation. For many Trump supporters, democracy and the rule of law are less important than preserving the American way of life, which in practice means ensuring domination by white males at the expense of everyone else. For better and for worse, America has long provided a model for others to follow. And unfortunately, there are demagogues around the world more than willing to adapt Trump's formula of trampling on democratic institutions and repudiating the values that underpin them. A prominent example is Brazil's former president, Jair Bolsonaro, who went so far as to try to emulate the January 6, 2021, attack on the US Capitol to prevent Biden's election. That attempted coup on January 8, 2023, in Brasília was larger than the attack on the US Capitol, but Brazil's institutions held firm – and now they are demanding that Bolsonaro be held accountable.
Meanwhile, the US has been moving in the opposite direction since Trump's return to the White House in January. Once again, Trump has made it clear that he loves tariffs and abhors the rule of law – even violating the trade agreement he made with Mexico and Canada in his first term. And now, ignoring the US Constitution, which gives Congress the sole authority to impose taxes – and tariffs are just a particular tax on imports of goods and services – he has threatened to impose a 50 per cent tariff on Brazil unless it stops the prosecution of Bolsonaro.
Here was Trump violating the rule of law to insist that Brazil, which has adhered to all the strictures of due process in prosecuting Bolsonaro, do the same. Congress has never enacted tariffs as an instrument for inducing countries to obey a president's political dictates, and Trump could cite no law that gave him even a fig leaf for his unconstitutional actions.
What Brazil is doing stands in marked contrast to what has happened in the US. While the legal process had moved slowly but judiciously to hold to account those who had participated in the January 6 insurrection, immediately after his second inauguration, Trump used the president's pardon power to forgive all who had been duly convicted – even the most violent. Complicity in an attack that left five people dead and more than 100 police officers injured was no crime.
Like China, Brazil has refused to submit to America's bullying. President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silvacalled Trump's threat 'unacceptable blackmail,' adding, 'No foreigner is going to give orders to this president.'
Lula has defended his country's sovereignty not only in the domain of trade, but also in regulating US-controlled tech platforms. America's tech oligarchs use their money and influence worldwide to try to force countries to give them free reign to pursue their profit-maximising strategies, which inevitably cause enormous harms, including by serving as a channel of misinformation and disinformation. As in recent elections in Canada and Australia, Lula got a 'Trump bump' in national support as Brazilians recoiled from the US administration and rallied around him. But that wasn't what motivated Lula to take his stance. It was a genuine belief in Brazil's right to pursue its own policies without foreign meddling.
Under Lula's leadership, Brazil has chosen to reaffirm its commitment to the rule of law and democracy, even as America seems to be renouncing its own Constitution. It must be hoped that other leaders of countries large and small will demonstrate similar bravery in the face of bullying by the world's most powerful country. Trump has undermined democracy and the rule of law in the US – perhaps irreparably. He must not be allowed to do so elsewhere.
@Project Syndicate, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Observer
7 hours ago
- Observer
South Korea reaches trade deal with Trump
SEOUL, South Korea — President Donald Trump announced a trade deal with South Korea on Wednesday, putting 15% tariffs on South Korean goods, much higher than they were just a few months ago but lower than Trump had threatened. Under the terms, South Korea will make $350 billion in investments in the United States and purchase $100 billion of liquefied natural gas. Trump said in a social media post that South Korea's president, Lee Jae Myung, would visit Washington in two weeks to make further announcements. Trump had threatened to impose 25% tariffs on South Korea unless a deal was reached by Friday. In an important concession from Trump, South Korea's car exports will face 15% tariffs, down from the rate of 25% that the president had already imposed on cars from most of the world. The agreement follows other trade deals that have been concluded in Asia. Although many details remain to be hammered out, the White House has announced that goods from Japan and the European Union will face 15% tariffs, the Philippines and Indonesia 19%, and Vietnam 20%. Among the Asian countries still without agreements are Malaysia, Taiwan and Thailand. India, a key American ally, is also without a deal, and Trump threatened it Wednesday with a 25% tariff. The Trump administration and China have agreed to a truce after inflicting sharp trade penalties on one another in the spring. Lee confirmed that South Korea had reached a trade deal with the United States. The deal 'removes uncertainty' over the country's export industries, he said in a social media post. Of the $350 billion that South Korea has pledged to invest in the United States, Lee said, $150 billion will be dedicated to helping South Korean companies entering the American shipbuilding industry. 'There aren't that many countries that can restore the shipbuilding capacity of the U.S., particularly given that China is a strategic rival,' said Seungjoo Lee, a professor of political science and international relations at Chung-Ang University in Seoul, South Korea. 'That's why the United States and Japan included cooperation on shipbuilding in the agreement, and in terms of capacity, South Korea is in a better position.' The rest of the funds will be used to help South Korea invest in the semiconductor, technology and energy sectors in the United States. Kim Yong-beom, the chief policy coordinator in Lee's office, said that South Korea had pushed for a 12.5% tariff 'until the very end' but Trump did not budge. 'The president said everyone is 15%,' he said at a news conference. It's been a long road for the South Koreans, who had to restart U.S. trade talks when a new government was elected in June. Lee received a reprieve five weeks into the job, when Trump extended his original July 9 deadline for a deal to Aug. 1. However, the country's negotiators had to compete for time with Trump administration officials who were attempting to conclude dozens of agreements at once on difficult issues such as market access for agricultural goods. Howard Lutnick, the U.S. Commerce Secretary, said in a social media post that tariffs on South Korean automobiles would be set at 15%, a rate that matches the levy recently imposed on cars from Japan and the European Union. He also said South Korea will 'not be treated any worse than any other country on semiconductors and pharmaceuticals.' He said U.S. tariffs on imported steel, aluminum and copper would remain unchanged. South Korea's two semiconductor giants, SK Hynix and Samsung, have built factories in the United States with the help of subsidies granted under former President Joe Biden. Some other large South Korean manufacturing investments have seen declining prospects after Congress canceled electric vehicle subsidies. Lee had recently met with the leaders of several of his country's largest companies to discuss what they could bring to the table. Executives from Hyundai, Samsung, and Hanwha were in Washington this week, South Korean news outlets reported. Tami Overby, a partner at DGA Group Government Relations and previously president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Korea, said the promised new investment was a concession to the reality that tariffs would make goods shipped from South Korea less competitive in the American market. 'I don't think they have a choice,' Overby said. 'I don't think any country has a choice. This is how the president has decided to do it, and you either get on board or you pay higher tariffs.' South Korea's economy is highly dependent on exports of goods and services, which accounted for 44% of its GDP in 2023. That's twice the rate of its neighbor Japan, another export-driven economy. South Korea ran a trade surplus of $66 billion with the United States in 2024, nearly four times what it was in 2018, when Trump revised the U.S.-Korea Free Trade Agreement. The U.S. auto tariffs, previously set at 25% for nearly all imported vehicles, have eaten into the sales of major South Korean car brands. Profits at Hyundai declined 16% in the second quarter compared to the previous year, as the company has largely absorbed the costs of the duties so far. U.S. officials have been pushing South Korea to balance trade with the United States, open its market to U.S. exports, and walk back proposed digital regulations that are seen as benefiting South Korean giants over American tech firms. Trump did not mention anything about digital services. In his announcement, Trump said the $350 billion investment from South Korea would be 'owned and controlled by the United States, and selected by myself, as President,' and that South Korea 'will be completely OPEN TO TRADE with the United States, and that they will accept American product including Cars and Trucks, Agriculture, etc.' However, Kim, a government policy official, stated that the countries had not agreed to any changes to South Korea's rules regarding agricultural imports, particularly beef and rice. Farming is politically sensitive in South Korea, and the government has recently stated that it will draw a 'red line' and remove the country's beef and rice markets as a possible concession in trade talks. South Korea is the largest foreign market for U.S. beef. Still, the American cattle industry had demanded that the country lift its import restrictions on beef over 30 months old, which South Korea has banned since 2008 over concerns that it could introduce mad cow disease. Some of the issues between the allies, such as sharing defense costs, were not included in the deal, according to the South Korean government. The agreement was confined to trade issues, it said. Those other issues are expected to be discussed when the two presidents meet in the coming weeks. Trump, who called South Korea a 'money machine' last year, has spoken about using trade negotiations as a forum for asking the country to cover more of the costs of maintaining the U.S. military presence there, which includes approximately 28,500 troops. This article originally appeared in
Times of Oman
14 hours ago
- Times of Oman
"We're talking to them," Trump after imposing 25% tariffs, penalty on India
Washington DC: US President Donald Trump said on Wednesday that Washington is continuing trade negotiations with India. In response to ANI, if the US remains open to negotiating with India on the tariff front, Trump stated, "We're talking to them now. We'll see what happens. Again, India was the highest or just about the highest tariff nation in the world, one of the highest, 100 points, 150 points or percentages. So India was one of the highest in the world. They had 175 per cent and higher than that." After announcing a 25 per cent tariff and penalties for purchasing Russian oil, he emphasised that India is one of the countries imposing high tariffs on the US. He made the comments during a press conference at the White House, held to mark the signing of a Congressional bill. Earlier, Trump, taking to Truth Social, announced a 25 per cent tariff on India in addition to a penalty for buying Russian oil. The tariffs will be imposed starting August 1, he further stated. "Remember, while India is our friend, we have, over the years, done relatively little business with them because their Tariffs are far too high, among the highest in the World, and they have the most strenuous and obnoxious non-monetary Trade Barriers of any Country," Trump stated in his post. "Also, they have always bought a vast majority of their military equipment from Russia, and are Russia's largest buyer of ENERGY, along with China, at a time when everyone wants Russia to STOP THE KILLING IN UKRAINE - ALL THINGS NOT GOOD! INDIA WILL THEREFORE BE PAYING A TARIFF OF 25%, PLUS A PENALTY FOR THE ABOVE, STARTING ON AUGUST 1st. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER. MAGA!" the post added. The US President, during the conference, further clarified the terms of the penalties imposed on India, noting New Delhi was part of the BRICS grouping and calling the alliance "anti-United States." He further accused the alliance of its "attack on the dollar." "We're negotiating right now, and it's also BRICS. They have BRICS, which is basically a group of countries that are anti-United States, and India is a member of that, if you can believe it. It's an attack on the dollar, and we're not going to let anybody attack the dollar. It's partially BRICS, and it's partially the trade. This trade situation is a deficit. We had a tremendous deficit," Trump stated. He emphasised India-US ties, calling Prime Minister Narendra Modi a "friend," while noting the US trade deficit with India. He further noted that it "doesn't matter too much" if the India-US deal reaches a certain tariff. "As you know, Prime Minister Modi is a friend of mine, but they don't do very much business in terms of business with us. They sell a lot to us, but we don't buy from them. You know why? Because the tariff is so high. They have one of the highest tariffs in the world. Now they're willing to cut it very substantially. But we'll see what happens. We're talking to India now," the US President said. "We'll see what happens. It doesn't matter too much whether we have a deal or whether we charge them a certain tariff. But you'll know at the end of this week. August 1st is a very big day for this country because money is going to pour into the United States like we've never seen before," he added. This announcement follows an earlier move on April 22, when Trump imposed a 26 per cent tariff on Indian goods imported into the US, before later pausing those "reciprocal" levies.
Times of Oman
14 hours ago
- Times of Oman
China hits back at US over tariff threats, says "coercion, pressuring will not achieve anything"
Beijing: China on Wednesday responded strongly to the US suggestion that it will significantly raise tariffs if China continues to purchase Russian oil, saying "coercion and pressuring will not achieve anything." "Response to US suggestion that it will significantly raise tariffs if China continues to purchase Russian oil: China will always ensure its energy supply in ways that serve our national interests," Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun wrote on X. "Tariff wars have no winners. Coercion and pressuring will not achieve anything. China will firmly defend its sovereignty, security and development interests," the Chinese spokesperson said. On Tuesday, US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said he had warned Chinese officials that continued purchases of sanctioned Russian oil would lead to significant tariffs due to legislation in Congress, but was told that Beijing would protect its energy sovereignty, The Straits Times reported. Wrapping up two days of US-China trade talks in Stockholm, Bessent said he also expressed US displeasure at China's continued purchases of sanctioned Iranian oil, and its sales of over USD 15 billion worth of dual-use technology goods to Russia that have bolstered Moscow's war against Ukraine, the Singapore-based news outlet reported. Bessent said legislation in the US Congress authorising Trump to levy tariffs up to 500 per cent on countries that purchase sanctioned Russian oil would draw US allies into taking similar steps to cut off Russia's energy revenues, as per The Straits Times. This comes after US President Donald Trump's decision on Monday to shorten the 50-day deadline given to Russian President Vladimir Putin, setting a new deadline of 10 to 12 days to reach a peace deal with Ukraine. Speaking to reporters alongside UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer from his golf resort in Turnberry, Scotland, Trump stated that, "I'm going to make a new deadline of about 10 or 12 days from today. There's no reason in waiting," adding that "I want to be generous, but we just don't see any progress being made." Trump emphasised that he doesn't want to impose harsh measures on Russia, but he's willing to do so if necessary. "It would be sanctions and maybe tariffs, secondary tariffs. I don't want to do that to Russia," he said.
