I ‘physically' argued with John le Carre over spy novels, says ex-MI6 chief
The 89-year-old replied: 'I think in reality it isn't a reflection of character, it's a reflection maybe of circumstance and that there are occasions that are unavoidable in this profession where the circumstances become sinister and individuals are forced to act in a way which is disconcerting.
'I'm always trying to defend its integrity. For example, the big argument I had with Le Carré, and I did actually physically have it with him, was that he had made betrayal the currency of espionage.
'Of course it is sometimes but the stronger currency of espionage is trust and integrity, because if you're making a betrayal, particularly of an evil empire, the people helping you to make that have got to behave with absolute integrity and trust.'
The pair had a public argument in 2019, with Sir Richard hitting out at Le Carré at a literary festival. He called the author a 'counter-intelligence nihilist' and claimed most MI6 officers were 'pretty angry' with him.
Le Carré responded by suggesting that the spymaster was still angry about the author's opposition to the Iraq war.
He said that his 'cynicism', as Sir Richard called it, came from the betrayals of the double agents George Blake and Kim Philby who between them had caused the deaths, imprisonments or disappearances of thousands of agents.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Iran 'is hunting British spies using leaked kill list' - with fears they will be captured and used as 'bargaining chips'
Iran is plotting with the Taliban to hunt down British agents using a leaked database that exposed details of MI6 spies and UK Special Forces. Officials from Iran's Revolutionary Guards flew to Kabul last week to ask Afghanistan 's warlords for 'access' to the bombshell list at the centre of a two-year super-injunction drama in the UK. Earlier this month it was reported that Iran had begun efforts to get their hands on the highly sensitive list 'so they can hunt down MI6 spies'. But now it is understood that four IRGC officials - who are said to have travelled to Afghanistan without involving Tehran's civilian government - intend to capture British spies and use them as 'bargaining chips' in negotiations with the West over the nation's controversial nuclear programme, The Telegraph reported. In return, the Taliban wish to be formally recognised by Iran as the official rulers of Afghanistan. A senior Iranian official said the list had been handed over by the Taliban, adding: 'They [the IRGC officials] want to find British spies before the 'snapback' to have something to pressure London behind closed doors.' The spectre of Iran's extremists and the brutal Taliban regime co-ordinating efforts to hunt down British agents has been causing 'concern' in Whitehall, the Daily Mail reported earlier this month. A vital database of Afghans and UK officials putting 100,000 people 'at risk of death'. A soldier escorts a family at Stansted in May as part of a government scheme costed at £7billion smuggling migrants to Britain after a data-leak blunder exposed by the Daily Mail When the Daily Mail discovered this data breach disaster in 2023, the Government secured a draconian court order to hush it up, triggering a 23-month battle in secret courts for open justice. Last month the Government finally abandoned its super-injunction and the public discovered ministers had secretly agreed a £7billion scheme, including a mass evacuation programme to rescue thousands of Afghans who had worked for British forces. Ministers ordered lawyers to gag the Daily Mail and others with a second High Court injunction, to prevent the media revealing how the lost list had included details of more than a hundred MI6 spies, Special Forces and other UK officials. The so-called 'kill list' contains the names of 25,000 Afghans who were applying to a UK scheme to give sanctuary to those who had worked on the frontlines with British forces. The Daily Mail has seen a copy of the full dataset lost by the British government, and it is understood it also includes details of more than 100 British officials including MI6, Special Forces and senior military commanders, as well as MPs. Many of these were included to help officials verify legitimate claims. Although codes are used, and the list does not specifically identify any spies or special forces, it could be a valuable dataset for an enemy. It is understood that several people whose names appear on the list have been arrested in recent days by Iranian border forces. Daily Mail journalists faced jail by order of a Penal Notice if they revealed the Government's secret - or even breathed a word about the existence of the draconian court order Many have been released soon after, with the 'focus' said to be on detaining 'British spies'. This week, Britain, France and Germany threatened Iran with a 'snapback' - the return of economic sanctions that were imposed before 2015 if nuclear talks did not begin again by the end of this month. In 2015 a deal was struck between Iran and Western powers to curb its nuclear enrichment program in return for a lifting of banking and trade sanctions. With this deal due to expire on October 18, the official added: 'The IRGC is doing everything it can to find bargaining chips for talks before the deadline.' Meanwhile a Taliban official told The Telegraph: 'Some argued that we should not do any favours for the Iranians given how badly they are treating our refugees there, but if they were willing to recognise the Islamic Emirate [of Afghanistan] in return, that would not be a bad deal.' The so-called 'kill list' was accidentally leaked in February 2022 when a British soldier emailed the complete file to Afghan contacts instead of sending a small extract. A Government spokesman said: 'It's a longstanding policy of successive governments to not comment on intelligence matters but this once again underlines how serious the original data breach was and why the previous government have serious questions to answer about how this was ever allowed to happen.'
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
Spy in the Bag mystery: Expert claims he was asked to 'cover up' MI6 spook's death and reveals SIX glaring red flags that show he was murdered
It is exactly 15 years since MI6 spy Gareth Williams tragically died at the age of just 31. On August 16 2010, in one of the most mysterious and bewildering deaths ever on British soil, police said he impossibly folded himself inside a red North Face holdall in his bath. His Pimlico bathroom was spotless and officers found no evidence of Gareth's fingerprints on the padlock of the bag or even the rim of the bath that the bag was found in. Detectives found no signs of struggle and no bruises or marks on his body. The heating was on full blast - despite being the height of summer - the bathroom door was shut, the shower screen closed and the lights were switched off. The Welsh prodigy, considered a puzzle-solving genius, had been scooped up by GCHQ having completed his GCSEs in primary school, A-levels at 13 and his maths degree at 17. But the solution to the puzzle surrounding his own death, remains unsolved. MI6 had failed to notice that one of its analysts was missing from work and his spymasters only investigated his absence on August 23 after a call from his panicked sister. Gareth was then found serenely inside the bag, his hands neatly folded on his chest in an almost religious pose. The zip had been padlocked on the outside but the key to the lock was lying beneath his right buttock. Just eight days earlier he was seen happy and healthy on CCTV, buying cakes from Harrods and steaks from Waitrose. 24 hours later he was dead in his home Alderney Street in Pimlico - half a mile from MI6's headquarters on Vauxhall Bridge. Twice police have closed criminal investigations into his death, even though his inquest concluded he had been 'killed unlawfully', probably before he was put neatly in his bag. Detectives instead claimed they believe he was alone when he died and it was probably a tragic accident related to sex. Cash, unworn women's designer clothing and a wig were found in the flat along with his, and a mystery man's semen. Gareth's parents have long asked for privacy as they continue to grieve their beloved son. The case has been branded a whitewash and Peter Faulding, a world-leading confined space rescue and forensic search specialist, who tried 300 times to get in the same sized bag and concluded: 'Even Harry Houdini himself wouldn't have managed it'. Peter recreated the scenario as he helped the Met investigate the so-called Spy in the Bag case in 2010 but while detectives closed the criminal case, he is convinced that Gareth was murdered and there was a 'cover-up' by police and the secret services. What are the theories around the death of MI6 spy Gareth Williams? He zipped himself in the bag and accidentally locked it and suffocated. The Russian mafia assassinated him in a bid to stop him investigating money-laundering networks. He was killed by MI6 or American agents after stumbling on sensitive data, or because he threatened to make secret intelligence public. Mr Williams was killed by a lover during a bizarre sex game. It has been claimed he had close links with London's drag and bondage scenes. The spy locked himself in the bag and no one else was involved. He was poisoned. Agents killed Mr Williams then got into his flat through a skylight to destroy evidence. Mr Faulding has today claimed to the Daily Mail, for the first time, that he was asked by police to change his statement - but he refused. 'Gareth Williams should have been commended for his work with the security services not tarnished as a cross dresser. They just wanted to bury this case and leave Gareth's name being tarred', Mr Faulding told the Mail on the 15th anniversary of his death. 'My belief is that the bag was placed in the bath with Gareth dead already. No one in their right mind believes he was on his own. It is a physical impossibility. 'I had paramedics on standby and a knife on a string hanging around my neck to cut myself out. I could zip myself in but could not do up the padlock. Another yoga expert tried'. After trying hundreds of times to climb in, zip up the bag and lock it from the inside without leaving fingerprints on any surfaces, Mr Faulding concluded with certainty that Gareth could not get into the North Face bag alone. He was then invited to meet with senior investigating officers from the Metropolitan Police at the Wyboston Lakes National Crime and Operations Faculty. He said that a senior investigating officer told him in a meeting: 'You have probably seen that a 15-year-old girl has successfully climbed into a bag and zipped herself in. I would like you to rewrite your statement to acknowledge it can be done. 'I stood up and said "I am not playing your games", walked back to my helicopter parked on their fields and flew home'. He said: 'I have never spoken about this. But after the Nicola Bulley case, I realised things get covered up'. Mr Faulding is convinced that the lack of 'trace evidence' - such as DNA and finger prints as well as footprints - means Gareth was murdered. 'He was naked. The lights were out, the door closed, the heating was on full, the shower screen closed. Just back from a bike ride, he would have had to walk into the bathroom in the dark and closed the shower screen', Mr Faulding said. 'That alone would leave his marks all over the floor, light switch, footprints and fingerprints on the glass shower screen. 'Then he would have to climb into the bag close the zipper and the padlock from the inside, leaving more marks on it'. Mr Faulding, who was the same height and build as Gareth, tried to get himself in the same kind of bag hundreds of times. A leading yoga expert also did it - but also failed. He later gave evidence at the inquest and is absolutely clear that it is not credible to believe Gareth did it alone. The coroner found she was 'satisfied that on the balance of probabilities that Gareth was killed unlawfully'. Mr Faulding said: 'The coroner Dr Fiona Wilcox asked me what I thought happened. I said with respect I am not here as a detective. She said: "You have a very impressive CV and I would like your honest opinion. 'I told her that I believe Gareth was murdered. I turned towards his family in court. They looked at me and mouthed "thank you" with gratitude and validation'. A forensic review by Scotland Yard found that 'no new DNA' was found, therefore it was more likely that Williams was alone when he died The Welsh maths prodigy after completing his GCSEs at 10, A-Levels at 13 and then getting a first-class degree from Bangor University at just 17. He was discovered by Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) while doing a PhD in Mathematics at the University of Manchester, and brought on board as a codebreaker. He worked at the headquarters there in Gloucestershire, before his secondment to MI6 in London to work as technical support on a highly sensitive operation. Williams was last seen alive buying cakes in Harrods and peppered grilled steaks in Waitrose. That same evening he had also planned to meet a colleague. The next day he had been expected to chair a MI6 meeting having just returned from a hacking conference in Las Vegas. Despite this, MI6 only investigated his absence more than a week later, on August 23, after a call from his sister. At the time theories surrounding his death ran wild, from sex games gone wrong to a targeted assassination by a hostile state. Peter Faulding ruled out MI6 involvement, telling the Mail today: 'If the service got rid of Gareth it wouldn't be in a bag in the bath for the world to see'. Coroner Fiona Wilcox concluded in 2012 that the plethora of unanswered questions, a lack of a struggle and the Houdini-standards contortionism needed to get inside the bag and lock it alone, without leaving any prints, all pointed to a 'third-party involvement', calling Gareth's death 'criminally mediated' and 'unlawful'. But in 2013, after a three-year investigation by Scotland Yard, its detectives concluded the opposite and said there was no evidence of anyone else in the flat and that Gareth probably died alone as a result of somehow accidentally locking himself inside the bag. The case was reopened in 2021 to allow for a new forensic investigation using more modern technology on items of 'significant' interest such as a towel. But despite a bewildering lack of answers about what happened in the so-called 'Spy in the Bag' case, the Met again closed its investigation last year after it found 'no evidence' that disproves their main theory that he was alone. There were no new findings of DNA, nor that a third party was present at the time of Williams' death, Scotland Yard said. Bewildering questions on how and why it happened, many armchair detectives have theorised that the 31-year-old, an expert on mobile phones, may have been murdered by a foreign state or even Russian Mafia because of his work investigating money-laundering networks. He was not believed to be in a relationship at the time of his death, however during the investigation six boxes of unworn women's designer clothing worth £20,000 and a orange wig were found in the apartment. Mr Williams's family have long suggested foul play, with two police sources claiming some of Williams' work was focused on Russia - and one confirming reports he had helped the US's National Security Agency trace international money-laundering routes used by organised crime groups including Moscow-based mafia cells. But police confirmed that there is no criminal inquiry, no suspects and no new evidence. MI6 colleagues said he was a 'quiet bloke' who 'got on with his work'. 'When he had a drink with work colleagues, he had an orange juice and left.' Retired Met Detective Chief Superintendent Hamish Campbell said in 2021 that he believes Mr Williams was involved in sexual activity before his death. In an interview with the Sunday Times, Mr Campbell said the death was different from the hits on Russian defectors Alexander Litvinenko in London in 2006, and Sergei Skripal in Salisbury in 2018. 'What would have been achieved by killing a junior analyst?' Campbell asked. 'He was a phone analyst, an expert in terms of mobile phones and the transference of data. What would the Russians or any other state have achieved by killing him?'
BBC News
3 days ago
- BBC News
West Mercia Police to cut staff jobs as it tackles £8m shortfall
Staff posts are to be cut at West Mercia Police as the force tackles an £8m budget gap, even though redundancies have already been police force for Herefordshire, Shropshire and Worcestershire has not confirmed to the BBC how many posts will go but has said the shortfall must be and crime commissioner (PCC) John Campion said there were issues about the distribution of police funds that had not been fixed by current or previous governments, an "unfairness" he had raised on several BBC has approached the Home Office for a response. Chief constable Richard Cooper said: "The difficult decision we have made, to make further police staff redundancies, is certainly not something we would choose to be doing."He said protecting people from harm remained the force's priority and it stood by its neighbourhood policing commitment. 'Action is being taken' The force had already made "significant savings" by cutting police staff, which are non-officer posts, but additional savings needed to be found, which included a further reduction in police staff roles, he force said it had continued to face challenges because of government funding not keeping pace with inflation and a growing demand on also revealed the cost of the workforce this year had been underestimated, because of the number of officers reaching higher pay points, and its officer cost was "higher than was budgeted for".The PCC said: "I want to reassure our communities that action is being taken to address these issues and ensure that the force is able to continue delivering an efficient and effective service and keep communities safe."Criticising how the government distributed funds to police, he said the force also faced growing mandates from government dictating how money should be and the chief constable were making best use of all resources, but it was "not enough", he said. Follow BBC Hereford & Worcester on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
