Mother of 5 kids and WV doctor: Consider risks of Senate Bill 460
Recently, I testified before the West Virginia House Committee on Health and Human Resources about Senate Bill 460 which would weaken our childhood immunization laws for child care and school entry.
West Virginia has long been a national champion in ensuring that our child care and school entry immunization laws remain strong. Naming all of the benefits of ensuring these policies remain in place would have pushed me over the 3-5 minutes I was allotted for my testimony. I would like to supplement my testimony to the West Virginia legislators and others who are following this bill with this editorial.
Our immunization policies help maintain our robust herd immunity to protect those who are vulnerable. When the argument is made that if one immunizes, they shouldn't have anything to worry about if someone else doesn't is faulty.
My kids attend school in West Virginia. One of their classmates was diagnosed with congenital neutropenia. This disease makes her susceptible to bacterial illnesses. It is imperative that those around her are immunized so that she remains protected when attending school. She is one example of numerous immunocompromised children that attend private and public schools in West Virginia who need and deserve protection. Thank you to her mom for allowing me to share her story.
On a personal note, a relative in my family recently returned to school and obtained her nursing degree. She is now a nurse working in West Virginia. Despite receiving the immunization, she is unable to generate an immune response to the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine. She is on the medical front lines caring for our community's sickest, and our herd immunity is the strongest protection she has against measles, mumps, and rubella. Thank you to my relative for allowing me to share her story.
Similarly, our teachers who are caring for our kids and starting families of their own need protection when they are pregnant. Pregnant women who are not immune against rubella due to waning immunity or an inability to generate an immune response to immunization are vulnerable to passing rubella to their unborn infants.
In 2019, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported 32,000 children were born with congenital rubella. About 33% of infants with congenital rubella die before their first birthday.
Since the start of 2025, three of five states that border West Virginia have reported measles cases — Kentucky, Maryland and Pennsylvania. Last year, measles did find its way to West Virginia. Due to the efforts of our public health officials in disease containment and contact tracing as well as our current immunization policy for school and child care entry, our one case of measles remained just one case.
Our modern day travel capabilities make everyone a target for diseases like measles appearing in our communities. If we let our guard down, it will make us susceptible to more cases and potential outbreaks. A measles outbreak is something that West Virginia cannot afford. And I mean this from a standpoint that we cannot afford the money and manpower it would take to contain and manage an outbreak. Most of all, we cannot afford to risk death and disability to those living in our great state.
Finally, Texas is reeling from the death of a child from measles. This was a rude awakening by many that children in fact can die from measles. Now is not the time to let our guard down. What I love about West Virginia is how we can come together as a state when a neighbor or loved one experiences hardships. We do not want to come together and mourn the loss of a child from a terrible disease such as measles knowing that their death could have been prevented.
I am asking our legislators to think about the ones already born and the ones yet to be born. I am asking our legislators to understand that schools and child care settings are high-risk settings, and that our day care workers, teachers, school staff and children across West Virginia need the best protection against terrible diseases that are easily transmissible but preventable through immunization.
Children in West Virginia are precious and deserve a chance at life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Senate Bill 460 puts their chance at risk. It is not a risk worth taking. I ask that our legislators reject changes to our current immunization requirements for child care and school entry.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
an hour ago
Georgia man may have tried to enter CDC campus two days before he attacked agency
NEW YORK -- The Georgia man who shot at Centers for Disease Control and Prevention buildings on Aug. 8 apparently tried to enter the campus two days earlier but was turned away by security, according to an internal CDC email. Security video indicates 'a very high likelihood' that the 30-year-old shooter — Patrick Joseph White — tried to enter the campus on the late afternoon of Aug. 6, the email said. 'The video evidence does not 100% confirm the person's identity' but law enforcement thinks it was White, according to the email sent to CDC employees on Thursday. 'The probing of a site is a common practice for individuals planning to engage in violent acts,' Jeff Williams of the CDC's security office wrote in the email. The Associated Press viewed a copy of the email, which was first reported on by Stat News. White blamed the COVID-19 vaccine for making him depressed and suicidal. On Aug. 8, he opened fire from a spot at a pharmacy across the street from CDC's main entrance. He killed a police officer and fired more than 180 shots into CDC buildings before killing himself. No one at CDC was injured. Williams, in his email, said: 'Due to our existing security protocols, the shooter did not attempt to enter campus on Friday, August 8, prior to the attack.' A spokesperson for the Georgia Bureau of Investigation said the investigation is active and ongoing. "We have no further information to release at this time,' said the spokesperson, Sara Lue. ___ AP reporter Jeff Amy in Atlanta contributed. ___ The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Science and Educational Media Group and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
.png&w=3840&q=100)
Miami Herald
2 hours ago
- Miami Herald
63 pounds of rodent and primate meat confiscated at Michigan airport, officials say
For the second time in a week, authorities said they confiscated wild animal meat from the Detroit Metropolitan Airport. During a baggage examination, 11 pounds of rodent meat was found by agriculture specialists, according to an Aug. 20 news release from U.S. Customs and Border Protection. The meat was from Togo, a country in West Africa, officials said. Days later, 52 pounds of primate meat was found at the airport, agents said. That meat had been originally declared to be antelope from Gabon, a nation in Central Africa. The bushmeat, which refers to meat from wild animals such as bats, cane rats and primates, was found with travelers who also had other 'undeclared agriculture items in their possession,' officials said. 'These recent bushmeat interceptions are significant in bringing attention to the illegal importation of bushmeat through our ports of entry,' Port Director Fadia Pastilong said. 'This also showcases how we work with our partner agencies to prevent a potential disease outbreak.' The meat was turned over to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The travelers were each fined $300, agents said. Bushmeat from specific regions have a 'significant communicable disease risk, and is illegal to import into the U.S.,' officials said. 'We routinely find various agriculture items and oddities—live giant snails, animal skulls, and exotic food items—but most times it's not a malicious act,' Director of Field Operations Marty C. Raybon said. 'Despite this, it's our duty to protect the homeland and preventing certain food and animal products from entering the U.S. is essential to public health.' Authorities said it's rare for primate meat to be intercepted at the Detroit Metropolitan Airport and rodent meat is confiscated sporadically. 'In parts of Africa, bushmeat is considered a cultural delicacy and is often consumed raw or subject to minimal processing, which increases risk of disease proliferation. Ebola, mpox, and other emerging diseases can have catastrophic consequences if they enter human populations,' officials said.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
California resident tests positive for plague in Lake Tahoe, officials say. What are the symptoms and how common is it?
The California Department of Health has been notified of this recent case. A Lake Tahoe resident has tested positive for the plague, California health officials confirmed on Tuesday. The resident is believed to have been bitten by an infected flea while camping in South Lake Tahoe. The infected individual is recovering at home and is receiving medical care, El Dorado County officials said in a press release. 'Plague is naturally present in many parts of California, including higher elevation areas of El Dorado County,' Kyle Fliflet, El Dorado County's acting director of public health, said in the release. 'It's important that individuals take precautions for themselves and their pets when outdoors, especially while walking, hiking and or camping in areas where wild rodents are present.' Though extremely rare, humans may still contract the plague. Prior to the current case, the most recently reported case in El Dorado County was in 2020. Exposure was also likely to have occurred in the South Lake Tahoe area. Two individuals were reported with the human plague in 2015 in Yosemite National Park when they were exposed to infected rodents or their fleas. Those were the first reported human cases in the state since 2006. All infected individuals have since recovered. Outside of California, a human case of the plague was detected in Pueblo County, Colo., in July 2024. Prior to that, a child in Colorado died after contracting the illness in 2021. What is the plague? The plague is a rare disease that affects humans and other mammals. It is caused by a germ called Yersinia pestis. Humans typically get the plague through a flea bite from an infected rodent or by handling an infected animal, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The Mayo Clinic lists these animals as potential carriers of the plague in the western United States: Rats, mice and voles Squirrels, rabbits and prairie dogs Ground squirrels and chipmunks Pet cats and dogs, as well as coyotes and wild cats may also be infected with the plague if they eat small animals with the disease and pick up their fleas. What are the symptoms? There are three types of plague. According to the Mayo Clinic, symptoms can vary depending on which type is contracted. Bubonic plague Bubonic plague causes swelling of the lymph nodes. Swollen lymph nodes, also known as buboes, appear in the armpits, groin or neck with this type of plague. The size of these buboes vary between less than half an inch to about 4 inches. Additional symptoms of bubonic plague can include: Sudden high fever and chills Headache, tiredness and not feeling well in general Weakness, muscle aches Skin sores (in rare cases) Septicemic plague Septicemic plague happens when plague bacteria multiply in the bloodstream. Buboes may not be present in this case. Early symptoms include: Sudden high fever and chills Extreme weakness, stomach pain, diarrhea and vomiting More serious symptoms can develop with advanced disease and organ failure. These symptoms include: Bleeding from the mouth, nose or rectum, or under the skin Signs of shock, such as seizure, rash and low blood pressure Blackening and death of tissue (gangrene), most commonly affecting fingers, toes, ears and nose Pneumonic plague Pneumonic plague affects the lungs. While it may begin in the lungs, the disease can also spread from infected lymph nodes to the lungs. Symptoms can show up within hours after exposure and quickly worsen. These symptoms include: Sudden high fever and chills Cough, with bloody mucus Difficulty or irregular breathing Chest pain, headache and weakness Upset stomach and vomiting How common is the plague? The risk of getting the plague is very low, according to the Mayo Clinic. In the United States, an average of seven people get the plague every year. The risk of death for those who contract the plague in the U.S. is about 11%. How do you treat it? The plague can be treated with antibiotics. People who contract pneumonic plague are isolated during treatment to prevent the spread of the disease. Those caring for infected people should wear protective gear like masks, eyewear, gowns and gloves. How do you prevent it? There is no vaccine available for the plague at this time, though antibiotics can help prevent infection if you are exposed to it. Solve the daily Crossword
