Charity in legal action against minister for failing to act over Thames Water
Lawyers for River Action argue that Thames Water has breached its duties and violated its licence conditions seriously and repeatedly, making it the clearest possible case for special administration.
Special administration is a temporary insolvency and restructuring process for companies that provide essential public services such as water, energy and transport. It is designed to ensure continuity of service while the company is stabilised and restructured.
There is a bespoke special administration regime (SAR) for the water industry, which was created in 1991 and is designed to prioritise customers and services while putting financial interests second.
Reed has said that the government is stepping up preparations to take Thames Water into special administration, indicating he will reject pleas from the company's creditors for leniency from fines and penalties.
Thames Water's largest creditors control the utility and have made efforts to cut some of its debts and have offered to provide £5.3bn in new funding to try to turn it around.
But River Action's head of legal, Emma Dearnaley, said the time to use the SAR process was now. 'Enough is enough,' she said. 'Why hasn't the secretary of state used special administration to fix the water sector, starting with Thames Water?
'The government has the power but won't use it, or even explain when it might trigger this process. Apparently, the government has no policy at all. That's a fundamental failure of transparency and accountability, and it's unlawful.'
River Action has lodged an application for a judicial review against the secretary of state.
The claim argues that the government has failed to publish its policy on when it would use the SAR process, breaching core public law duties, and that ministers have failed to develop a policy at all, breaching obligations under habitats regulations and other planning and environmental laws.
Under section 24 of the Water Industry Act 1991, special administration can be triggered by a water company's failure to meet performance standards, including environmental pollution, and a breach of its statutory or licence duties in ways that are 'serious enough to make it inappropriate for the company to continue to hold its licence'.
Sign up to Down to Earth
The planet's most important stories. Get all the week's environment news - the good, the bad and the essential
after newsletter promotion
River Action argues that Thames Water clearly meets that threshold and has done so for years. Serious pollution incidents by Thames and other water companies were up 60% last year compared with the year before, data has revealed.
There were 75 serious pollution incidents in 2024, up from 47 in 2023, Environment Agency figures show. Three companies were responsible for 61, or 81%, of the incidents: : Thames Water with 33, Southern Water, 15, and Yorkshire Water, 13. Thames Water's serious incidents more than doubled.
A spokesperson for the government said: 'We are unable to comment on an ongoing legal challenge.'
Thames Water was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
a day ago
- Telegraph
Embattled Ofwat boss resigns amid sewage crisis
David Black has resigned as chief executive of Ofwat, just weeks after the Government called for the beleaguered water regulator to be scrapped. The watchdog confirmed on Tuesday that Mr Black will step down from his position at the end of August, with an interim successor to be announced in due course. It brings an end to Mr Black's tumultuous stint in charge of Ofwat, which has been subject to increasing criticism over its failure to tackle sewage spills. He has been the chief executive of Ofwat since April 2022, having initially joined the regulator in 2012. His planned departure comes after a review published last month by Sir Jon Cunliffe, which called for the water regulator to be abolished. In a damning assessment of Ofwat, the former deputy governor of the Bank of England criticised the 'deep-rooted, systemic' problems in the water sector, which have led to worsening pollution. It added that Ofwat had failed to prevent businesses in the water industry from 'making imprudent financial decisions'. This culminated in the crisis at Thames Water, which is facing the threat of nationalisation after failing to tackle a £17bn debt pile. Prior to the Cunliffe review, Steve Reed, the Environment Secretary, said Ofwat was 'clearly failing' as it had created a regulatory system that allowed the industry to 'get away with it'. He went further last month by scrapping Ofwat altogether, as he said that a new regulatory body will be introduced to mark the 'biggest overhaul of water regulation in a generation'. He added that a new regulator for the water industry would be given legal powers to intervene if customers are overcharged. The date of Ofwat's abolition has not yet been announced. After announcing his departure, Mr Black said: 'I have been privileged to be able to lead Ofwat, over the last four years, during which time we have achieved a huge amount together as a team for customers and the environment. 'The 2024 price review backed an investment programme of £104bn, along with a further £50bn investment in major new water resources, which will improve service, environmental outcomes and resilience in the years to come. I wish the team every success as they continue their important work.' Iain Coucher, the Ofwat chairman, added: 'David has worked, tirelessly, to bring about transformational change in the water sector. He has sought new regulatory powers and resources to hold companies to account, taken major enforcement action and provided funding and incentive packages that drive continual improvements for customers.'
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
Ofwat CEO David Black to step down amid intense scrutiny of water sector
The chief executive of Ofwat is to step down at the end of the month, after the government announced the abolition of the under-fire water regulator for England and Wales. David Black is preparing to leave the role after four years, amid intense scrutiny of water companies and their regulators. Ofwat said the government will appoint a new interim chief executive before its abolition. The regulation of the English and Welsh water industry has become a key political issue in recent years, including during last year's general election, amid a wave of anger over sewage spilling into Britain's rivers and seas. Black's decision comes as the government and the environment secretary, Steve Reed, prepare for what they have billed as the biggest overhaul of water regulation since the industry was privatised in 1989. Ofwat has become a lightning rod for criticism of the sector, including over decades of underinvestment in infrastructure such as reservoirs and water treatment works while companies paid vast sums in dividends and other fees to their owners. Last year, the regulator gave a green light for water companies to raise average bills by 36% over the next five years in order to pay for upgrades. After the decision to abolish the regulator, Black felt he had to go, according to a person familiar with internal discussions at Ofwat. However, the board did not want Black to leave, and tried to persuade him to stay, the person said. One water company chief executive said they felt he was the wrong figure to take the fall. Black said: 'I have been privileged to be able to lead Ofwat over the last four years, during which time we have achieved a huge amount together as a team for customers and the environment. The 2024 price review backed an investment programme of £104bn, along with a further £50bn investment in major new water resources which will improve service, environmental outcomes and resilience in the years to come. I wish the team every success as they continue their important work.' Black was appointed interim chief executive in April 2021, and was permanently appointed a year later. He had risen through Ofwat's ranks after joining as director of economics in 2012. Iain Coucher, Ofwat's chair, thanked Black and said: 'David has worked tirelessly to bring about transformational change in the water sector. He has sought new regulatory powers and resources to hold companies to account, taken major enforcement action and provided funding and incentive packages that drive continual improvements for customers.' The decision to replace Ofwat, revealed by the Guardian, was made after a review published last month by Sir Jon Cunliffe, a former deputy governor of the Bank of England, found that the sector was 'broken', and recommended combining powers from four regulators, including Ofwat, into one. The interim boss of Ofwat will have to immediately tackle several urgent issues. The UK's biggest water company, Thames Water, has been locked in talks to try to agree leniency on fines from the regulator, which it has said will be necessary for its lenders to inject billions of pounds of new funding as part of an attempted takeover. The regulator has also faced criticism over pay for water companies deemed by some politicians as excessive, and over the effectiveness of an effort to ban bonuses for the worst polluters. Ofwat was this week directed to scrutinise £1.3m in previously undisclosed pay for Yorkshire Water boss Nicola Shaw, after the Guardian revealed the existence of the payments via Yorkshire's offshore parent company. The department for the environment, food and rural affairs was approached for comment.
Reuters
a day ago
- Reuters
CEO of UK's water regulator Ofwat to step down
LONDON, Aug 5 (Reuters) - Britain's Ofwat said on Tuesday its chief executive, David Black, would step down following a government decision last month to abolish the water regulator. In a statement, which came after Sky News first reported the story, Ofwat announced that Black has decided the "time is right to pursue new opportunities" and would step down at the end of August. An interim replacement is set to be appointed in due course, the regulator added. It comes after environment minister Steve Reed said last month he had agreed to abolish Ofwat as part of a regulatory overhaul. Britain will create a new powerful regulator for its water industry following public fury over sewage spills.
