Marine conservation group claims damage to seabeds is a ‘national scandal'
The report – published in the run-up to the global UN Ocean Conference in Nice, France in June – is based on more than 300 seabed surveys that were carried out during a five-month period, with the work done in collaboration with Greenpeace UK.
It found that while habitats like maerl beds – which are formed by special seaweeds in shallow seabeds – and seagrass meadows are 'crucial parts of our biodiversity', it claimed in some areas these 'remain unprotected from destructive fishing practices'.
Open Seas – which successfully took the Scottish Government to court in 2023 – said while MPAs had been brought in 'to safeguard Scotland's most vulnerable marine ecosystems', it added that 'numerous MPAs lack effective management measures'.
As a result, it claimed this allowed 'harmful fishing practices', such as bottom trawling and scallop dredging to persist within their boundaries.
'This ongoing damage not only undermines the intended conservation goals but also threatens the very habitats these MPAs were established to protect,' the report stated.
Open Seas said its surveys 'uncovered clear evidence that in many cases these so-called 'protected' areas are merely lines on a map with little real world impact on marine conservation'.
One of the examples given was the Papa Westray MPA, which is located at the north end of the island of Papa Westray in Orkney.
The group said that despite the area being designated as an MPA 'there are still no restrictions against trawling and dredging within or even near the area'.
This, the report said, made it 'yet another example of a protected area that exists in name and not in practice'.
The waters around Papa Westray – where Ocean Seas said there were 'no real protections' in place, despite it being a designated MPA (Open Seas/PA)
The Open Seas research found that marine habitats in areas such as Papa Westray as well as Loch Creran in Argyll and Bute and the Sound of Jura on the west of Scotland are 'actively degraded'.
Open Seas accused the Scottish Government of failing to meet international targets under the UN convention on biological diversity and the global biodiversity framework.
The campaigning charity also claimed Scottish ministers have 'broken their own promises to protect the most sensitive and important' marine habitats.
Open Seas director Phil Taylor said: 'Scotland's marine protections are failing by design.
'Despite public statements and legal commitments, the Scottish Government is allowing destructive fishing inside supposedly protected areas.
'These failures are not only national scandals – they breach Scotland's international obligations to halt biodiversity loss and restore the health of our seas.
Together with Greenpeace UK, Open Seas carried out more than 300 seabed surveys as part of the research (Open Seas/PA)
'We have heard repeated promises to deliver for our seas and the coastal communities who rely on them from Scottish ministers – sadly those promises have been broken just as regularly.'
Mr Taylor continued: 'These are not just technical oversights – they are policy choices that carry environmental, legal and reputational risks.
'Scotland likes to be seen as a leader on the environment. But, as this report shows, we are still dragging our heels while the seabed is being dragged into decline. That must change, starting now.'
Will McCallum, co-executive director of Greenpeace UK, said: 'The lessons learnt in Scotland must be applied in all UK waters – allowing destructive industrial fishing practices like bottom trawling in marine protected areas is causing damage to fragile marine ecosystems and results in severe ecosystem degradation which is bad for everyone.'
However, he said the research had also shown that 'where areas are meaningfully protected, marine life can recover and flourish' – adding that this 'should give us hope for the oceans'.
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Management measures for the most vulnerable sites in the MPA network were implemented in 2016.
'Putting in place the remaining fisheries management measures for MPAs and further measures for the 11 Priority Marine Features most at risk from bottom trawling outside MPAs remains a top priority for this Government.
'Fisheries management measures will be implemented in 2025 for Offshore MPAs and as soon as possible for Inshore sites following the completion of the required statutory assessments and public consultation.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
3 hours ago
- BBC News
Parents on low wages struggling to get school uniform grant
Parents on low wages in parts of Scotland are struggling to access financial support for school uniforms that would be available in other council areas, the BBC has of Scotland's councils pay the grant to people on universal credit who earn a salary from employment of less than £850 a month - roughly equal to 16 hours a week at minimum some councils will pay the clothing allowance to people earning as much as twice that amount. The Child Poverty Action Group is calling for thresholds to be raised across Scotland, saying parents can easily be in poverty and not qualify for the support. Scottish government guidance says families on low incomes should be able to access a minimum of £120 a year for a primary pupil and £150 for a secondary pupil - figures which have not risen for three years. But the eligibility for who gets the cash is set by local councils and varies widely across the 120,000 pupils receive the clothing grant but Jen, a single parent who lives in Balloch with her 10-year-old son, says she is angry and frustrated that she does not works 22 hours a week in a care home but struggles to cover her her income leaves her above the £933 a month threshold for the school uniform grant set by West Dunbartonshire a few miles up the road in the Stirling Council area, Jen's income would put her well below its £1,851 threshold and she would qualify for the majority of Scotland's councils stop the grant when families on Universal Credit have earnings of over £850 a month, the same criteria that is used for free school eight councils allow people on much higher incomes to claim the allowance, with some using council tax rebate or housing benefit as criteria. Jen says she spends about £450 a year on school uniform and shoes for her son."It makes you a bit anxious, of the feeling of how you're going to be able to afford all these clothes, because kids grow dramatically," she says."They're one clothes size one minute and then they've just shot right up. "They can go to school one minute and then they wake up the next day and go, 'oh my shoes don't fit'." Jen says: "We all want our kids in the best kind of stuff so they're not getting bullied in school."She says she is angry that by working 22 hours a week she is just over the limit for accessing the grant."We are trying to work and better ourselves for our kids and then we aren't getting the help at the end of it," she says. Leading campaign organisation, The Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG), is calling for thresholds to be raised across Spencer, CPAG's cost of the school day project manager, said the school uniform grant should be available to all parents on Universal Credit, as the benefit itself is an indicator of low income. Universal Credit is a paid to those who are out of work or on low incomes - 37% of recipients across the UK are in employment."It would make it more fair and consistent across the country and most importantly it would mean that more children on low incomes would be receiving this vital support," Ms Spencer said."Parents tell us that uniform is a really difficult and a big cost for them, especially in larger families where you've got uniform to buy for lots of children." Julia Grindley, of the Edinburgh uniform bank charity, says she sees many people who are in poverty who end up at her door because they are not eligible for state support. "About 40% of children who are referred to us for a clothing crisis pack are not eligible for the School Clothing Grant even though they are living in poverty," she said. "Many of those have one or two parents who are working. "If they earn just £10 over the threshold they can actually end up worse off than families that are not working."It's very frustrating that families have to come to us because they can't access things that they really should be eligible for." School funding grant In 2018 the then education secretary John Swinney announced reforms to the school clothing grant saying it would "remove the stress and stigma which can often be associated with struggling to afford essential school items".But councils set very different thresholds for those on universal credit to receive an award.A West Dunbartonshire Council spokeswoman said: "We are committed to supporting low-income families and our threshold for eligibility for a school clothing grant is more generous than the offer in 70% of other authority areas across Scotland."The Scottish government said it had provided funding of £14.2m for the school funding grant this year.A spokesman said: "Our funding helped to create a national grant level which provides eligible families with at least £120 to help with the cost of clothing for school for each child."Local authorities are responsible for the administration and distribution of this grant. "We are aware that local authorities apply differing eligibility criteria and would encourage synergies so that families on similar income levels in different areas are treated fairly."Last year, the Scottish government published guidelines on how to make uniforms more accessible and affordable. They said schools should use generic items and colours that could be bought from a range of suppliers, promote uptake of the school clothing grant and ensure branded items are not encouraged. What's the solution? West Calder High School in West Lothian has completely re-designed its uniform to make it more affordable and accessible. The school asked pupils and the local community what they wanted to wear, in line with the new government guidance. The pupils asked for comfort and style and opted for a t-shirt and hoodie rather than a blazer and tie. Older pupils still wanted a shirt and blazer to differentiate them from young pupils but all the items are available through the school to cut the Gerry Higgins said the school now buys the basic uniform in bulk and sells a full uniform to parents for £10. He said a traditional uniform with shirt and tie would cost £56."You will have young people who will deliberately not come into school because of the cost of the school day," he said. "It might be that they don't realise that is the reason but they cannot afford to look the same as other young people."
Edinburgh Reporter
6 hours ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
West Lothian High schools see significant improvement in exam results for fifth year in a row
West Lothian High schools have seen significant improvement in exam results for the fifth year in a row. Pupils in what one councillor called the 'pandemic generation' showed results above the Scottish average and comparable schools across Scotland. The pass rates topped 76% for sixth year pupils, members of the Education Policy Development and Scrutiny Panel heard. Siobhan McGarty, head of secondary education told councillors: 'In each of the measures, performance of West Lothian schools and learners has significantly outperformed both the national average and the virtual comparator.' Over the five-year period 2020 to 2025, the percentage of S4 learners attaining 5+ awards at SCQF Level 5 has shown improvement. West Lothian was significantly above the National and Virtual Comparator in this measure between 2020 and 2024. The percentage of pupils achieving five or more awards at SCQF Level 5 has risen from 60% in 2020 to 76% in 2024. Over the same period for the Scottish average the figures remained static at 55%. In the sixth year the percentage of pupils awarded 5 + Awards at SCQF Level 6 rose from 52% in 2020 to 54% in 2025. This compares to the national average of 38% to 39% in the same years. The percentage of sixth years achieving 1+ Awards at SCQF Level 6 rose from 73% to 83% between 2020 and 2025 compared to a national static average of 66%. Heather Hughes, the local EIS rep told the meeting: 'These results are testament to the hard work of all staff. It's not just the teachers currently teaching the young people. We are a team and that team starts even at the early years. It's fantastic. 'It worries me that we are still pushing to raise attainment further because that has massive workload implications on our staff, but for now just a very big congratulation to all teaching and non-teaching staff and the young people.' SNP depute group leader Pauline Stafford said: 'A huge congratulations to the young people and their teachers for these really great results. Just looking at these years, back to 2019, and what these young people have had to come through and how resilient they have had to be. 'This is the pandemic generation – it is really positive to see these rising pass rates right across Scotland and the closing of the attainment gap just shows the resilience of young people, so congratulations to them.' Committee chair Councillor Andrew McGuire said: 'I would echo that. A huge congratulations to them. I was at West Calder yesterday and talking to two sixth years and the penny hadn't dropped until I was talking to them about a school camp that West Calder is having this week. They didn't get to go on that because when they were in the first year the pandemic was on. So that particular cohort of young people who sat their exams this year have been through some of the strangest experiences that we could ever imagine. 'For them to come out with pass rates to have improved is tremendous, and it benefits peoples' life chances enormously. So we are incredibly proud of everyone. Thanks to all our hard-working staff. I agree with Heather entirely; it's not a one-year thing. It starts from the moment they set foot in an educational establishment in West Lothian, so I'm very proud that we continue to perform extremely well. Long may it continue.' By Stuart Sommerville, Local Democracy Reporter Like this: Like Related
Edinburgh Live
11 hours ago
- Edinburgh Live
West Lothian's 'pandemic generation' of students 'over-perform' in exam results
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info West Lothian high schools have seen significant improvement in exam results for the fifth year in a row. Pupils in what one councillor called the 'pandemic generation' showed results above the Scottish average and comparable schools across Scotland. The pass rates topped 76% for sixth year pupils, members of the Education Policy Development and Scrutiny Panel heard. READ MORE: West Lothian community centre group to 'dissolve' next year due to running costs Siobhan McGarty, head of secondary education told councillors: 'In each of the measures, performance of West Lothian schools and learners has significantly outperformed both the national average and the virtual comparator.' Over the five-year period 2020 to 2025, the percentage of S4 learners attaining 5+ awards at SCQF Level 5 has shown improvement. West Lothian was significantly above the National and Virtual Comparator in this measure between 2020 and 2024. The percentage of pupils achieving five or more awards at SCQF Level 5 has risen from 60% in 2020 to 76% in 2024. Over the same period for the Scottish average the figures remained static at 55%. In the sixth year the percentage of pupils awarded 5 + Awards at SCQF Level 6 rose from 52% in 2020 to 54% in 2025. This compares to the national average of 38% to 39% in the same years. The percentage of sixth years achieving 1+ Awards at SCQF Level 6 rose from 73% to 83% between 2020 and 2025 compared to a national static average of 66%. Heather Hughes, the local EIS rep told the meeting: ' These results are testament to the hard work of all staff. It's not just the teachers currently teaching the young people. We are a team and that team starts even at the early years. It's fantastic. 'It worries me that we are still pushing to raise attainment further because that has massive workload implications on our staff, but for now just a very big congratulation to all teaching and non teaching staff and the young people.' SNP depute group leader Pauline Stafford said: 'A huge congratulations to the young people and their teachers for these really great results. Just looking at these years, back to 2019, and what these young people have had to come through and how resilient they have had to be. 'This is the pandemic generation – it is really positive to see these rising pass rates right across Scotland and the closing of the attainment gap just shows the resilience of young people, so congratulations to them.' Committee chair Councillor Andrew McGuire said: 'I would echo that. A huge congratulations to them. I was at West Calder yesterday and talking to two sixth years and the penny hadn't dropped until I was talking to them about a school camp that West Calder is having this week. They didn't get to go on that because when they were in the first year the pandemic was on. So that particular cohort of young people who sat their exams this year have been through some of the strangest experiences that we could ever imagine. 'For them to come out with pass rates to have improved is tremendous, and it benefits peoples' life chances enormously. So we are incredibly proud of everyone. Thanks to all our hard working staff. I agree with Heather entirely, it's not a one year thing. It starts from the moment they set foot in an educational establishment in West Lothian, so I'm very proud that we continue to perform extremely well. Long may it continue.' Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
