Billionaire Magnier claims his name being 'slaughtered' in court
Bloodstock billionaire John Magnier has complained of his alleged unfair treatment as he faces cross examination over a failed €15 million land deal in the High Court.
The founder of the world famous Coolmore Stud at the start of Thursday's hearing asked the judge's permission to address the court.
Advertisement
He said he thought he was being "treated unfairly" Wednesday, by the opposing senior counsel for Barne Estate Martin Hayden SC during cross examination.
He claimed counsel "unfairly went after" his good name and Mr Magnier declared he came to court for "protection, not to be slaughtered".
Lawyers acting for Mr Magnier have claimed before the High Court that a US-based construction magnate, Maurice Regan, the preferred buyer, engaged in a "full-frontal assault" on Mr Magnier's claimed deal to buy 751 acres of land in Tipperary for €15 million.
Mr Magnier's proceedings claim that Barne Estate reneged on the alleged deal, preferring to sell the land at the higher price of €22.25 million to Mr Regan, the founder of the New York building firm JT Magen.
Advertisement
Mr Magnier – along with his adult children, John Paul Magnier and Kate Wachman - wants to enforce the alleged deal.
They say the deal was struck at an August 22nd, 2023, kitchen meeting at Mr Magnier's Coolmore home.
They also claim an exclusivity agreement that was in effect from August 31t to September 30th stipulated that the estate would not permit its representatives to solicit or encourage any expression of interest, inquiry or offer on the property from anyone other than Mr Magnier.
Barne Estate has been held for the benefit of Richard Thomson-Moore and others by a Jersey trust.
Advertisement
The Magnier side have sued the Barne Estate, Mr Thomson-Moore and three companies of IQEQ (Jersey) Ltd group, seeking to enforce the purported deal, which they say had been "unequivocally" agreed.
The Barne defendants say there was never any such agreement and subsequently they preferred to sell the estate to Mr Regan.
Mr Regan is not a party to the case.
At the High Court on Thursday , Mr Magnier repeatedly told the court that when it came to legal and financially detailed matters that he hired experts who would decide and report on the progression of land deals for him.
Advertisement
Mr Magnier said "I don't think you believe me - I am not a solicitor" to Mr Hayden and said that he was answering the same questions "again and again and when I answer you look out the window".
Mr Hayden said he was being "polite" to Mr Magnier in letting him finish his answers but that after any "rambling" by the plaintiff he would still be asked to specifically address the question originally asked.
Mr Magnier told Mr Hayden that while he was "smarter than me" he was not going to allow Mr Hayden to put "your words in my mouth, I am not going to do that".
Mr Magnier claims that on the night the Thomson-Moores went to another room in Coolmore to ring the trustees of Barne to get the go-ahead on the deal and returned with the permissions needed.
Advertisement
Mr Hayden said that phone records show that neither the Thomson-Moores nor estate agent John Stokes, also present at the meeting, made any contact with the trustees.
"You had to come up with another story which was that they said they were calling them," said Mr Hayden.
"They did say they were going to call. I have not changed my story at all. It's unfair to say so. It's untrue," said Mr Magnier.
"I shook hands with the three people who were there," he said, adding "my word is my bond".
Mr Magnier said that it was his suggestion to present a "no strings attached €50K" in two envelopes on September 7th, 2023, to Mr Stokes who gave it to the Thomson-Moores because the family were allowing Mr Magnier's people onto the land, were resisting bids and claimed that Mr Stokes had told him the family were "strapped for cash"
Mr Hayden said that it will be Mr Stokes' evidence that he never said the family were strapped for cash.
However, the money was returned to the Magniers days later and Mr Magnier told the court that it was his estimation that this was a signal that the family had now changed their minds and were going with the higher bid.
The case continues before Mr Justice Max Barrett.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
32 minutes ago
- BBC News
Is Champions League defeat end of an era for Inter?
The end of an era for Inter Milan?As Paris St-Germain dismantled Inter 5-0 to win their first Champions League - in the biggest final victory ever - it may have given the Nerazzuri a sense their own rebuild is needed this summer, albeit on a tighter starting XI at Allianz Arena cost about £403m to assemble, compared to the roughly £137m Inter shelled out for their starting boss Simone Inzaghi - whose own future is uncertain - put out the third oldest side in Champions League final history. Seven of the same starting XI that lost to Manchester City two years ago in Istanbul started again here."The players deserve great credit. They gave it their best shot. I wouldn't change these players for anything else," said Inzaghi after the game - while failing to guarantee he would still be in charge for next month's Fifa Club World they just could not cope with the youth of PSG, as what had the potential of being a treble-winning season just weeks ago ends up as Francesco Acerbi, Yann Sommer and Henrikh Mkhitaryan, Inter were the first side to start three players aged 36 or older in a European Cup or Champions League final."As the game progressed and the scoreline was progressing as well, they did look like one of the oldest teams in the competition," said BBC Match of the Day pundit Nedum what now - and what could they learn from PSG? New players? New manager...? Before this final, Inter president Giuseppe Marotta said owners Oaktree, who took over the club last year, wanted to go down a model of "investments in slightly younger profiles who represent a real asset".If they even had a sliver of doubt before the Munich showdown against PSG they will be even surer said: "The club is strong. The club supports us. We've signed two players for next season."He was referring to Dinamo Zagreb and Croatia midfielder Petar Sucic, 21, and presumably Marseille's Brazilian winger Luis Henrique, 23 - who has been strongly boss continued: "We know we have to sign more. The club supports us all the way."On Saturday, they just could not cope with PSG's pace, energy, movement and invention. Left-back Federico Dimarco was questionable for the opening two goals, although he had been hauled off long before PSG started notching up record that was despite resting several of their starters for the final day of the Serie A season, even though the title was up for grabs. Inter did win their game that day, but Napoli took the title."Tonight we were more tired than PSG. We didn't play well. We weren't fresh," said Inzaghi."They were always there on the second balls. We played our league until Friday. They won their league a couple of months in advance."But they will have to find new clubs for some of their players if they do decide a refresh is in order. None of their starting XI in Munich is out of contract in the an average age of 30 years and 242 days, it was the third oldest starting XI in a Champions League final. PSG's players were, on average, five years and 146 days who will be doing the rebuild?Inzaghi, who led Inter to last season's Serie A title and two Italian Cups, is considered a highly talented coach, and would have probably have been seen as one of the elite had his side won this. He has been heavily linked to Saudi club Friday's pre-match news conference inside Allianz Arena he did nothing to play down suggestions this could be his last game in after the game he did not commit either."It's not the right time to talk about my future," he said. "We're extremely disappointed. It's awkward to talk about my future now. "We'll be talking about the fact we won no silverware this year."When asked if he would be in charge for the Club World Cup, which starts next month, he said: "I cannot answer this question now. I came here out of respect for you [media]. I'm hurting from a sporting point of view. "Defeats make you stronger. We've been through this before. We lost in Istanbul and the following year we won the league.""This is going to feel much worse for the Inter Milan players than their defeat to Manchester City in the 2023 final," said ex-City defender Onuoha."They played well in that game, but tonight they offered nothing."I think when you as a professional walk off the field like that, in a game where you haven't lost a player, I think it is a real cause for concern."Italian football journalist James Horncastle, speaking on BBC Radio 5 Live, added: "Inter felt that this was the only thing they were missing."Once again, they have to watch another team celebrating and jumping around and partying."They have won a lot but they have lost a lot. But that's just part of sport."Speaking about the defeat two years ago against City, Inzaghi added: "We know defeats can make you stronger. Tonight's defeat hurts a lot just like the loss in Istanbul. They were two very different matches. "We've been through this. We can get going again all together."Opponents PSG have just completed an overhaul of their own - although it was about egos and not Mbappe, Lionel Messi and Neymar - a front three of players who all thought they were the star - have gone out the door in recent Inter will not have the resources of PSG's Qatari owners.
Daily Mail
38 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Top Gun! British fighter jets will soon carry nuclear weapons for the first time ever as part of biggest defense expansion since the Cold War
British fighter jets will soon carry nuclear weapons for the first time as part of biggest defense expansion since the Cold War. Sir Keir Starmer is looking to purchase several fighter jets capable of firing tactical nuclear weapons. The sensitive talks include Defence Secretary John Healey and Admiral Sir Tony Radakin who are looking to buy US fighter jets capable of launching gravity bombs with lower power than conventional nuclear weapons. The decision is backed by the prime minister and talks with the Pentagon are under way according to The Times. The news comes as Sir Keir is readying himself to launch a strategic defence review on Monday from a dockyard. He is expected to expand the UK's nuclear deterrence and its contribution to NATO but will not commit to specific capabilities. Mr Healey has insisted the Government will reach its target of hiking defence spending to three per cent GDP by 2034. It comes after the Government previously set out a goal to reach the target during the next Parliament, after meeting its promise of increasing spending to 2.5 per cent of GDP by April 2027. However the Defence Secretary has promised a 'certain decade of rising defence spending', according to The Times, and said there was 'no doubt' the UK would meet its target. Mr Healey told the newspaper: 'It allows us to plan for the long term. It allows us to deal with the pressures.' The Government is looking at the roles, capabilities and reforms required by UK armed forces as part of its strategic defence review (SDR). It will explore 'deliverable and affordable' solutions 'within the resources available to defence within the trajectory of 2.5 per cent'. Earlier this year, Sir Keir announced the targets, where he said 'increasing the resilience' of Britain was 'vital' 'in an ever more dangerous world.' 'In an ever more dangerous world, increasing the resilience of our country so we can protect the British people, resist future shocks and bolster British interests, is vital,' he said The new defence money will be found by reducing UK overseas aid from 0.5 per cent to 0.3 per cent of GNI (gross national income), according to the Government. This move was one , which prompted then-international development minister Anneliese Dodds to resign. 'You have maintained that you want to continue support for Gaza, Sudan and Ukraine; for vaccination; for climate; and for rules-based systems,' she told the Prime Minister. 'Yet it will be impossible to maintain these priorities given the depth of the cut.' NATO heads of government are set to meet in The Hague, in the Netherlands, next month. Addressing the alliance's parliamentary assembly in Dayton, USA this month, NATO secretary-general Mark Rutte said he assumed The Hague would agree 'on a high defence spend target' of 5 per cent. A Ministry of Defence spokesperson said: 'This Government has announced the largest sustained increase to defence spending since the end of the Cold War - 2.5 per cent by 2027 and 3 per cent in the next parliament when fiscal and economic conditions allow, including an extra £5 billion this financial year. 'The SDR will rightly set the vision for how that uplift will be spent, including new capabilities to put us at the leading edge of innovation in Nato, investment in our people and making defence an engine for growth across the UK - making Britain more secure at home and strong abroad.'
Daily Mail
38 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
How the England Lionesses' turbulent week ended in triumph... and raised hope of more Euro glory this summer, writes TARA ANSON-WALSH
As major tournament preparations go, England 's build-up to this summer's European Championship has been anything but conventional. To say the last week has been a turbulent one for England head coach Sarina Wiegman would be an understatement. Aside from the news dominating the headlines — the sudden retirement of fan-favourite Mary Earps — Wiegman was dealt another blow with the withdrawal of Millie Bright from the squad. The centre-back, who captained England to the World Cup final in Australia two years ago, described on a podcast how she was 'mentally and physically' at her limits. Speaking to former Lioness Rachel Daly, Bright said: 'That is a really hard decision but I think you know better than anyone — sometimes you just have to take that time for yourself. You need to value your mental health and body, and just say that no, right now is not the time for you.' Pressed on whether she can expect the Chelsea captain — who partners Leah Williamson at the heart of the defence — back for the Euros, Wiegman said: 'We'll stay in contact and I hope she feels better soon, but I don't know that at the moment.' The absence of Earps and Bright from the dressing room leaves a leadership vacuum and there are doubts over other key Lionesses. Lauren James is yet to return after pulling up with a hamstring injury a month ago, while Georgia Stanway, who hadn't played since last December, remains a balancing act. The midfielder came on for the last 15 minutes against Portugal on Friday, but it remains to be seen how her knee responds. Ella Toone and Alessia Russo missed the game with calf injuries, though Wiegman said these were 'not long-term' issues. The Dutch coach dislikes anyone on the outside getting wind of an upset within her walls but she could not silence the noise surrounding Earps's shock withdrawal, no matter how skilfully she batted off questions about her team's unity by reiterating 'we must move on'. While Portugal have routinely fallen short on the international stage, they are a team who have often been a thorn in England's side — eking out draws in their last two meetings in the build-up to the 2023 World Cup and more recently in the Nations League. So the Lionesses' six-goal victory — with only two games to go before they begin their Euros defence — served as a powerful statement of intent. With Wiegman due to name her Euros squad on Thursday, the players' focus quickly returned to how they would best book a seat on the plane to Switzerland. Youngsters Grace Clinton, Jess Park, and Aggie Beever-Jones capitalised on the extended absences of some of Wiegman's stalwarts. While it was 21-year-old Beever-Jones' hat-trick that stole the show, Clinton, 22, and Park, 23, showed again that they belong in this team. Clinton, the Manchester United central midfielder, worked relentlessly between the boxes and proved useful defensive cover. Manchester City's Park showed her physicality at No 10, fending off Dolores Silva before picking out the perfect pass for Beth Mead to run on to and score England's fourth. Responding to a question about how the off-pitch drama may have affected the team's mentality, Clinton appeared unfazed, saying: 'The off-pitch stuff is sad and sometimes people feel it more than others. We are all professionals here and when we do step on the pitch, we all know we've got a job to do and it's good that we've done it tonight.' Four different goalscorers and a hat-trick on her Wembley debut for Beever-Jones was certainly one way of changing the narrative. Up next are world champions Spain, where a victory will put an end to any concerns that these Lionesses have let the last week get to their heads before another monumental summer.
