Andy Burnham wants to take Manchester underground
The Mayor of Greater Manchester said the city's transport network would have to go underground by 2050 if it is to keep up with the demand.
Outlining his ten-year strategy earlier this week, Burnham promised Britain's third largest city its 'best decade since the Victorian era'.
Burnham announced the eye-catching proposals, centred around a flagship underground hub at Piccadilly railway station.
Citing the limits of expanding the city's existing Metrolink tram network on the surface, Burnham announced he had instructed Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM) to 'start planning' for an underground network.
Manchester previously experimented with the concept of a 'Tube' like railway between its two major stations, Piccadilly and Victoria.
The plan, dubbed the 'Picc-Vic', was considered in the 1970s.
Trains would have run every two to three minutes in twin tunnels between the hubs, and ten minutes to areas outside of the city centre.
But it was abandoned after the Westminster government decided the costs were prohibitive, having been estimated at more than £9million (or £139million in today's money).
In his speech, Burnham said the Bee Network, which comprises of Manchester's Metrolink tram network as well as buses which have been brought under local authority control was fast reaching its capacity.
He said: 'We are building the Bee Network on the surface. If we achieve our economic ambitions, we will be struggling to manage.
'I am going to ask Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM) to look at options for underground services. We will work with the government to look at financing it.'
The new subterranean concept would be centred around a new interchange at Piccadilly Station, he said.
It would complement the existing tram system, which runs on a mix of dedicated lines and streets shared with road traffic.
As well as relieving congestion on the local and suburban rail network, it would offer better connectivity within the city centre.
A total of 42 million passenger journeys are made on the tram network alone – up from 25 million in 2012.
The idea of an underground station at the city's main rail terminus was previously considered as part of the now cancelled leg of HS2 and in plans for a new railway between Liverpool and Manchester.
In 1971, Manchester's then transport authority presented plans to go underground, with promotional artwork depicting Victoria Line style tube trains which would run on a 2.75 mile between Piccadilly and Victoria.
The Picc-Vicc railway formed part of a four-phase 25-year plan for Manchester's transport system.
The same decade, partially underground mass transit systems were established in both Liverpool and Newcastle.
But the Manchester scheme never took off after a failure to secure central government funding for the project, which would have cost £139million in today's money.
Instead, the city revived its tram network, closed in 1949. The Metrolink has expanded to 99 stops across 64 miles of track.
In 2012, remains of the tunnel scheme were discovered by two lecturers at the University of Manchester.
Dr Martin Dodge and Richard Brook found what would have been the beginnings of a station dug 30ft below the Arndale shopping centre.
One major obstacle to the project, like its 1970s predecessor, would be its inevitably huge cost, with underground railways notoriously expensive to develop and construct.
London's Elizabeth Line was delivered at a final cost of £18.8billion, significantly up from the £14.8billion originally budgeted for the scheme.
The cost of Burnham's ambitious 'tube' plans would certainly be measured in the billions, possibly as much as £10billion for what would almost certainly be a far shorter railway than Crossrail, an expert has said.
David Leeder, from consultancy Transport Investment Limited, said the mayor would struggle to deliver the scheme from local taxes and would instead rely on a grant from Westminster. More Trending
He told Metro: 'Yes, the rail infrastructure in Manchester is undoubtedly crowded, but how will a multi billion pound scheme actually be funded when we are on the precipice of a public spending and borrowing crisis?
'The city mayors are set up in such a way that their default answer is always 'by a grant from the DfT / HM Treasury, to be paid for by taxes that mainly fall on London and the south east'.'
He added that the scheme, given its complexity, could eat up 'hundreds of millions' in just the development stage, and would likely require operating subsidies in the region of 'tens of millions per annum'.
'The passenger volumes in Manchester are a fraction of those in London. Yes it was very hard to make an economic case for the Elizabeth Line, even with such huge volumes, so it will be harder still in Manchester', he said.
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: M60 closed for hours after serious crash on motorway
MORE: I got a massive tattoo of this UK city to prove my love
MORE: BST Hyde Park issues update on headliner's health after sudden gig cancellation
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
12 hours ago
- Spectator
The boundless enthusiasm of Asa Briggs
It's doubtful whether Asa Briggs ever had an idle moment in his life. Bestselling historian, pioneer of the new universities of the 1960s, chronicler of the BBC, champion of adult education, academic globetrotter and much more besides, he possessed phenomenal energy. He was a miracle of the kind of boundless enthusiasm that his Victorian hero Samuel Smiles had extolled in his book Self-Help. Short and tubby, with large glasses, Briggs effortlessly outpaced academic colleagues who tended to be left panting behind him. A joke did the rounds that if a word were to be coined for a unit of intellectual energy it should be an 'Asa'. He was dubbed 'the last great Victorian improver' and 'the Lord Macaulay of the Welfare State'. While he subscribed to the political consensus of the postwar era –above all in his fervent belief in the power of education to overcome inequality and poverty– he also recognised how much the spirit of his own age owed to the vision of those Victorians who had enjoined a partnership between the individual and the state. His most important books, classics such as Victorian People and Victorian Cities, written while he was still a relatively young man, reclaimed the Victorians from the sneering condescension of the Bloomsbury Group. Yet later in his career he fought a rearguard action when, as Adam Sisman puts it, Mrs Thatcher pulled the rug from underneath him and remodelled 'Victorian values' in her own image. Like Thatcher, Briggs was born above a grocer's shop. He grew up during the 1920s in a nonconformist household in the northern industrial town of Keighley. By 1938, when he won a scholarship to Cambridge, he was marked out as a prodigy, a reputation cemented by his being awarded two first class degrees simultaneously, one in history, the other in economics from the LSE. His war service included a spell at Bletchley Park intercepting enemy signals. After the war he was appointed fellow in Politics, Philosophy and Economics at Worcester College, Oxford (where he returned as Provost in 1976). His geniality encouraged easy relations with the good and great. He drove across eastern Turkey and the Middle East in a Ford Zephyr with a favourite student, Rupert Murdoch; rubbed shoulders with Albert Einstein in a taxi in Chicago; and was the recipient of love letters from Iris Murdoch at a time when she was 'like a housewife going shopping' for affairs with other intellectuals. At the core of Sisman's biography is one of Briggs's greatest successes, his period at the newly created Sussex University. After becoming Vice-Chancellor there in 1967, he was able to spearhead the expansion of higher education as well as putting into practice 'a new map of learning', introducing multidisciplinary courses to encourage students to undertake a more holistic form of study. 'Suddenly it's smart to go redbrick,' trumpeted the Sun. Even student radicalism didn't faze Briggs. Jokingly, he attributed his ability to tackle demonstrators to his knowledge of the Chartists. After Sussex his career trajectory began to take a downward turn. He was still as much in demand as ever – as head of an Oxford college; as chairman, president and board member of innumerable institutions; as the official historian of the BBC (five volumes, criticised in some quarters for being factually top heavy and insufficiently analytical); and as the author of a staggering flow of books (he liked to have three on the go at once). But he badly overcommitted himself, delivering substandard work years late, or failing to deliver at all. Sisman keeps his head above water – just. One feels for him, while repressing one's own incipient weariness, as he painstakingly catalogues the books written (50) and unwritten (in double figures). Money played its part. 'I started from nothing and to nothing I could return,' Briggs wrote in a rare moment of self-reflection. That he should have found room in such a crowded life for a wife and four children is its own kind of miracle. Susan Banwell – who died in June this year (Briggs died in 2016) – was the 'dishy blonde' he married. Despite being devoted to him, she embarked on a number of discreet affairs following the birth of their last child. Clearly she resented at times the fact that life with 'an eminent Victorian' meant that 'a woman's noblest station is retreat'. Briggs was a kind and fundamentally decent man. He was also, in the opinion of an Oxford friend, 'not really a very subtle character'. None of this makes him an easy subject for a biographer and, given these circumstances, Sisman acquits himself well. The Indefatigable Asa Briggs marks the final volume in an unofficial trilogy of lives of British historians that Sisman has written over the past 30 years. Considering Briggs in the light of Sisman's two previous subjects – A.J.P. Taylor and Hugh Trevor-Roper – it's fair to guess that while Briggs never achieved the TV stardom of Taylor nor the witty, fastidious prose of Trevor-Roper, it is his legacy as historian and public figure that will last the longest.
STV News
20 hours ago
- STV News
Plans to transform historic Meat Market given £4.4m boost
Plans to transform a meat market site in the East End of Glasgow have received a £4.4m cash boost. The City Deal grant will include £1.9m each from the UK and Scottish Governments. The site of the Bellgrove sheds has lain dormant since the 1990s, but the new plans will transform it into a 'thriving hub'. The derelict Victorian sheds will be developed into a flexible site that will include sports facilities, a bar and bistro, event space, a learning centre, and an enterprise incubator to support small businesses. Glasgow City Council The City Deal grant will include £1.9m each from the UK and Scottish Governments. A community growing space is also planned, and the B-Listed Meat Market Superintendent's House will be stabilised ahead of its future development as an active travel hub. The plan also includes a 'linear park,' which will create an active travel route between Bellgrove Street and Melbourne Street. A 'wide-ranging heritage activity programme' is also planned on site to encourage community involvement and help preserve its rich history. Patrick Flynn, chair of the Meat Market Community Interest Company, said the board is 'delighted' with the significant investment. 'We have undertaken significant community consultation to ensure that the proposed works at the Meat Market reflect the aims of local people in terms of community use and job and training opportunities,' he added. 'Our Board are striving to successfully develop the exciting projects that make up this significant regeneration initiative.' Councillor Susan Aitken, leader of Glasgow City Council and Chair of Glasgow City Region Cabinet, said: 'I am delighted that City Deal funding will contribute toward this fantastic project, which will see heritage assets brought back into positive use, and the transformation of this key site, which has lain dormant for many years. 'Re-imagining the listed Meat Market sheds into a flexible, accessible space for communities and businesses will deliver both local and wider benefits, whilst the new linear park running through the site will improve its connectivity to the city centre and wider neighbourhood, and provide attractive, safer routes that encourage more people to walk, wheel and cycle.' Deputy first minister Kate Forbes said: 'Building on investment we have already made, we are contributing £5.6m to this project to provide a bustling hub in the heart of Glasgow's East End where people can shop, work and socialise. 'This adds to the work we are supporting to transform disused land across the East End into places where people can live, businesses can invest, and communities are able to thrive. 'To create jobs and tackle poverty, the Scottish Government is providing £62.15m towards regeneration projects over the course of this financial year. These initiatives will help to revitalise town centres, derelict sites and green spaces to benefit people across Scotland.' UK Government Scotland Office minister, Kirsty McNeill, added: 'I'm delighted that £1.9m UK Government funding will help transform this derelict Glasgow site into a thriving hub for community, sport and local businesses. 'This is our Plan for Change in action – investment to drive economic growth and improve lives by building a fairer country with equal opportunities for all. By genuine partnership working with the Scottish Government and local partners here and across Scotland we will deliver a decade of national renewal.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
BBC News
20 hours ago
- BBC News
Andy Burnham says he debated release of airport brawl footage
Andy Burnham has told how he questioned whether footage of the lead-up to a brawl at Manchester Airport could have been released to give a "broader picture" of what happened. A Greater Manchester Police officer is under investigation for allegedly leaking wider footage of the incident on 23 July to the media, after an initial video of an officer kicking a man's head went clip sparked protests and led Burnham, the mayor of Greater Manchester to consider whether more footage of the incident "could be put in the public domain".Mohammed Fahir Amaaz, a 20-year-old student from Rochdale, was later found guilty of attacking two female police officers in the brawl. Officers had tried to arrest Amaaz after he assaulted a member of the public, with a video of police restraining him after the brawl inside Terminal 2 going of the build-up to the incident, where Amaaz assaulted the female officers, was then leaked the Manchester Evening News (MEN).What caused the Manchester Airport brawl? Footage shows how violence eruptedThe Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) has confirmed its investigation is related to this footage and the allegation it was shared by the officer "during an active police investigation without any legitimate policing purpose".Amaaz and his brother Muhammad Amaad will face a retrial next year after a jury could not reach verdicts on allegations they assaulted another police officer. Sarah Lester, the editor of the MEN has published an opinion piece, questioning whether the IOPC investigation is in the public interest."How much taxpayer money is being spent on this - while the justice system groans under the weight of backlogs and delays?" she said the wider footage published by the newspaper "provided critical context" and pointed out that the protests "stopped overnight".Ms Lester also said senior figures in Manchester, including within GMP told the newspaper privately that they were "relieved, even grateful" that the MEN released the told the Local Democracy Reporting Service he did question whether or not the footage could be put into the public said: "In a world where things are moving so quickly – and where partial footage is out there and people are forming judgement somewhere – I think there is a question about the sort of public policy approach to releasing information."But he said any release would need to be handled carefully to avoid prejudicing a criminal said: "The IOPC have a job to do and I can't cut across them carrying out their work. What I can say is that I raised some broader issues with the Home Office in the aftermath." Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
