Russian adoptee's PTSD claim denied by ACC over residency rules
The young man began to suffer PTSD brought on by abuse he suffered as a child in Russia.
Photo:
Unsplash
A Russian child who was adopted by New Zealanders and suffered physical abuse in his home country has had his claim for PTSD as an adult declined.
Despite a High Court and District Court ruling that the man was eligible for mental health cover, the Court of Appeal overturned their rulings, stating he was not entitled to cover for a mental injury, because the physical assault occurred when he was not a New Zealand resident.
The man, whose name is suppressed, was born in Russia in August 2001 and arrived in New Zealand as a three-year-old.
Twenty years later, while living here as a New Zealand citizen, he was diagnosed with PTSD, stemming from abuse he suffered before arriving.
ACC declined his claim for mental injury cover, stating the physical injury had occurred when he was not a New Zealand resident and therefore he was not entitled to compensation.
Under the Accident Compensation Act 2001, for mental injury to be covered, it must arise out of a physical injury, or be caused by certain criminal acts or a workplace incident.
The man challenged ACC's decision, which was overturned by the District Court and - on appeal from ACC - the High Court, which found his mental injury was suffered in New Zealand and therefore he was eligible for cover.
ACC took the case to the Court of Appeal, which had the task of determining where the physical injury occurred that triggered the mental injury.
The man's lawyers, Beatrix Woodhouse and Mathew McKillop, argued the PTSD diagnosis in 2019 marked the point at which the mental injury was suffered, and because he was living in New Zealand, this qualified him for cover.
The lawyers submitted that, although the act specified a physical injury must match the mental injury, it did not specify a location.
The Court of Appeal determined that how the personal injury was caused was critical.
"Causation is the primary consideration," the court said in its recently released decision. "A mental injury which has arisen because of a physical injury may well be latent - the date the mental injury is triggered or the symptoms manifest is no doubt dependent on a variety of circumstances," .
"But it is the physical injury which is the root of the mental injury. It is therefore the date and, in our view, the location of that physical injury which is the key to whether cover is available under the Act."
New Zealand's Court of Appeal is the last avenue to appeal ACC decisions.
Photo:
RNZ / Rebekah Parsons-King
The Court of Appeal determined the High Court and District Court erred in their decision-making, as the man was not a resident of New Zealand at the time of the abuse and, therefore, was not covered for ACC.
"The Act cannot be interpreted as intending to provide cover for injuries caused overseas to people who are not ordinarily resident in New Zealand. Such an approach would mean the scheme was required to fund the consequences of events outside its jurisdiction and over which it could have no influence.
"In our view, it is clear that Parliament intended to provide cover for mental injuries suffered because of physical injuries where the causative physical injuries occurred in New Zealand or, if suffered outside New Zealand, when the person was ordinarily resident in New Zealand when the cause occurred."
The parents of the man released a statement to NZME to the effect that they believed the decision was deeply unfair to their son.
"He is a New Zealander, adopted by New Zealanders under New Zealand law, and has known no other home," the statement said. "The Adoption Act is clear that an adoptee is to be treated as our natural-born child in every respect.
"Yet, due to an injury that occurred before his adoption, he is now denied ACC-funded treatment for a condition that only manifested later in life."
Their lawyer, Beatrix Woodhouse, said the Court of Appeal was the end of the road for all ACC claims.
"Therefore, this decision represents the definitive legal position on this issue," she said. "It sets a precedent for other cases with comparable facts."
ACC deputy chief executive for corporate and finance Stewart McRobie told NZME the organisation was seeking clarification of the law and acknowledged the Court of Appeal's decision.
"We also acknowledge the impact of the decision on the claimant, and empathise with them and their family."
*
This story originally appeared in the
New Zealand Herald
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
34 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Clinic, operator see rise in NZ medical tourism to Turkey
At least five New Zealand groups offer assisted medical package deals to Turkey and they all started within the last two years. Photo: 123RF Istanbul may almost be on the other side of the world, but that is not stopping rising numbers of New Zealanders heading there for medical and dental treatment. Even when you include flights and accomodation, bariatric surgery in Turkey is significantly cheaper than getting it done privately in New Zealand. There are at least five New Zealand groups offering assisted medical package deals to Turkey and they all started within the last two years. One of them is Oceanscape group, run by Moana McCrae. Originally from Rotorua, she has lived in Bodrum on the Turkish coast for the past five years. She said New Zealand was increasingly seen as a fertile market . "In recent weeks we were approached by a hospital purely because we dealt with the New Zealand market," she told First Up . "They had seen some other hospitals doing the same and from what they're told, New Zealanders have higher obesity rates , [among] the worst in the world. "As well as that, our waiting list is huge, costs, affordability, accessibility, all of that, basically makes for them New Zealand an attractive market" The Vera clinic is a Turkish facility that offers hair transplants, cosmetic surgery and dental treatment. Marketing director Umut Öztürk says they've had a 650 percent rise in New Zealand patients this year, with the vast majority coming for dental work. He says cost is the number one reason people from other countries travel for dental work: "The same treatment for dental in their country is at least 10 times more than Turkey." While that does not quite apply to New Zealand, our dental costs are significantly higher. A single dental implant in Turkey costs around NZ$600 to $2000, depending on materials used. In Auckland, you are looking at approximately $5000 to $8000. Vera clinic's huge rise in Kiwi clients is no accident. It has advertised on a New Zealand news website and has collaborated with two Māori influencers. Turkey is not the only location experiencing a surge in medical tourism. Raywyn Short is travelling from Paeroa to Mumbai next month for a double knee replacement. "My knees are really sore. I can't stand for any real length of time. I can't do the things with my little great-grandson that I used to," she said. She is expecting to pay around NZ$20,000 for her surgery. She was quoted $31,000 to have one knee done privately here, and she was not prepared to go on the public waiting list. "I'm going to be 75 in February and the way that the health system here is I'd probably be around about 77 before I even got anything done here. I'm becoming more and more incapitated and inactive." Raywyn's husband died of cancer when she was in her 50s. She had to leave her job to care for him, and when she returned to the workforce, could no longer pay for health insurance. Raywyn chose India after reading about Claire Olsen, a Kiwi nurse who had a double hip replacement in Mumbai earlier this year Like Claire, Raywyn's surgery and travel is being arranged by Jackie Brown, who runs Bums, Tums and Gums. Brown, a travel industry veteran started the company in 2014 after getting a facelift in Thailand. The majority of her trips have been to Thailand and Mexico, but India is taking off. She has been impressed by the standard of care and the variety of treatments on offer. "They had dental there, they have everything. I mean they literally have everything from transplants to heart valve treatment, spinal fusion. They have everything." But medical tourism is not without risks . According to UK media reports, between 2019 and March 2024, 28 Britons died due to complications from surgery in Turkey. Just last week, a British man died after undergoing treatment at a hair transplant clinic in the Istanbul suburb of Besiktas. There have been no reports of New Zealand fatalities. But last year, 10 Turkish hospitals, including one where Kiwis were having weight-loss surgery, were shut after a corruption investigation following the deaths of 10 babies. McCrae's Oceanscape group did not work with that hospital. She said being based in Turkey allowed her to carefully choose which providers she used. "We vet all surgeons. I actually have my own medical consultant who will provide the background of many of the surgeons as well. Then there's different portals or ways to find that information if you know where to look that are credible, like JCI accreditation." Turkish Clinics and hospitals catering to foreign clients must be certified by the Turkish ministry of health. McCrae encouraged anyone considering treatment overseas to check qualifications thoroughly, and to have a video consultation with the surgeon. Robin Whyman of the New Zealand Dental Association. Photo: Supplied Robin Whyman of the New Zealand dental association urged people to look locally first. "People should talk to a dentist in New Zealand and find out what is actually involved in having the care done here," he said. "There are always options and there a lot of protections that come with having care undertaken in New Zealand. With a New Zealand practitioner, you know, obviously the registration side of that, but also the protections of things like the Health and Disability Commission and ACC around, particularly things like treatment injury." But he acknowledged people were struggling with the cost of dental care in New Zealand. "It's one of the things the Dental Association is talking about on a wide basis and talking about with New Zealand health system funders and others about how can we make dentistry more accessible. So of course we're concerned about that, but we're also concerned that what looks to be an upfront cost may not be the real cost of having dentistry done overseas." For many Kiwis, it is still a risk they are willing to take. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Cat throwing and online abuse: SPCA staff facing more threats on the job
SPCA staff say they are dealing with verbal abuse on a daily basis. Photo: RNZ / Angus Dreaver SPCA staff say an increasing amount of physical and verbal threats is one of the primary reasons for leaving the job. There have been 70 incidents of verbal and physical threats reported so far this year, but the animal welfare protection agency believes the numbers are much higher, with some staff just putting up with daily abuse. In one case, a worker in Hawke's Bay had a cat thrown at them. SPCA general manager for animal services Dr Corey Regnerus-Kell told Checkpoint there had been assaults, vandalism, physical threats, vehicles attacked with batons and a lot of abuse on social media. He said the abuse was directed at staff around the country who were just trying to do the best job they could. "One of the primary reasons we actually see people leave is because of the abuse that they received. The team work tirelessly, making very hard decisions every day and they all want to help as much as they can, but they also know that at the end of the day they are a charity and they can only do as much as they can within those means. "Sadly we've had to put the Christchurch centre into numerous levels of lockdown, so whether they have been real or perceived threats, we do take the safety of staff very highly at SPCA and we do want to make sure people are protected." Regnerus-Kell said the SPCA was hoping for a bit more empathy and compassion when people contacted them to ask for help. "If people actually listen to the help we are offering, and not just hearing 'no, we won't take them', then I think we will be on the track to success." He said the case of a cat being thrown at staff was another instance where the organisation struggled to get across what it could and could not do. Dr Corey Regnerus-Kell says there have been assaults, vandalism, physical threats, and attacks on vehicles. Photo: SPCA Regnerus-Kell said the SPCA was there for the sick, injured and vulnerable animals in the community. "So those animals that can't really fend for themselves, so if there is a new litter of puppies that has just been born and abandoned on the side of the road, those are the animals we would look at. "We don't help the owned, healthy animals, and we have to be really clear that owning an animal is a responsibility, not a right. The SPCA is not here to be a rehoming service, the onus is on the owner." He said the issue was about managing the resources it had. "If everybody who didn't want an animal came to us there is just no way we could cope, and that's the same with every rescue group across the country. "We're doing our best, where we can." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
16 hours ago
- RNZ News
Two-month-old Bellamere Arwyn Duncan's death 'must be a turning point', says pharmacist
Bellamere Duncan died at Starship Hospital on 19 July. Photo: Supplied The death of a two-month-old baby who died after being given medication that was more than 13 times the prescribed dose is a "symptom of a much deeper, systemic issue," a member of the national executive of the Pharmaceutical Society says. RNZ earlier revealed Bellamere Arwyn Duncan died at Starship Hospital on 19 July. A Manawatū pharmacy dispensed an adult dosage of phosphate to the two-month-old's parents. A provisional post mortem report said she died from phosphate toxicity. The revelations have prompted the Ministry of Health and Health New Zealand to "urgently" undertake a joint review into the incident with MedSafe visiting the pharmacy to ensure it was safe to continue operating. The Pharmacy Council, which is also investigating, said it was "clear that an awful error has occurred". On Friday, the owner of the pharmacy emailed Bellamere's parents and told them an intern pharmacist misread the prescribed dosage of medication. Afterwards, a trainee technician, who was handling a phosphate product for the first time, did not notice the dosage error. Then a registered pharmacist who carried out the final check did not pick up that the prescription was for an infant and that it was new medication. The intern pharmacist has since been suspended, and the registered pharmacist has resigned. Do you know more? Email Lanny Wong a pharmacist, director of Mangawhai Pharmacy and a member of the national executive of the Pharmaceutical Society, told RNZ on Tuesday Bellamere's death was "not simply a one-off mistake". "It's a symptom of a much deeper, systemic issue. The current model prioritises volume over value, this incentivises speed at the expense of safety. "For years, community pharmacies have grappled with operating under this fundamentally flawed funding system, marked by chronic underinvestment and relentless workload pressures. Skilled staff are increasingly difficult to retain, and experienced pharmacists are burning out or leaving the profession altogether. The very people relied upon to be the final checkpoint before a medicine reaches a patient are now overstretched, under-resourced, and unsupported." CAPTION: Bellamere Duncan's parents were given an adult dosage of phosphate by the pharmacy. Photo: Supplied Wong said in healthcare there were multiple layers of safeguards that were meant to save an error from happening. "But when there are gaps in every layer, caused by workload pressures, fatigue, underinvestment or broken systems and those gaps align, the error breaks through." Pharmacists were being asked to interpret complex prescriptions, perform clinical calculations, and provide personalised counselling, often while working under intense pressure and tight deadlines, she said. "In Bellamere's case, it appears the pharmacist had to calculate a specialised paediatric dose and explain a precise paediatric-dosing schedule to the whānau. This is work that requires expertise, care, and time, and yet the pharmacy was reimbursed less than the cost of a cup of coffee. That's not just unsustainable. It's unsafe." She said Bellamere's death "must be a turning point". "It's not just about fixing one pharmacy or one process, it's about fixing the system around pharmacy. "That means investing in safety, funding time to think, check and counsel, and designing a workforce strategy that ensures every community has access to skilled, supported pharmacists." [h ]The medication error In their email to Bellamere's parents the owner of the Manawatū Pharmacy included a summary of what happened. The owner said the pharmacy's standard dispensing process involved intern pharmacists entering each prescription into the dispensary computer. The pharmacy used a dispensing system called Toniq. A technician would then use the information in Toniq and the prescription to identify the medication and put the correct amounts in containers. The labels were then printed out and placed in a basket with the original prescription and the medication. A registered pharmacist would then check the prescription, the labels and the medication itself before it was given to the patient. The owner said the pharmacy received the prescription by email on 1 July from Palmerston North Hospital. The prescription was entered into Toniq by an intern pharmacist. "This person unfortunately misread the prescribed dosage and entered the prescription dose as '1 tablet twice daily' rather than '1.2 mmol twice daily'," the owner said. The Toniq system then generated an original label for the prescription. "This includes a warning label with the patient's age, if they are under 18 years old, and if the patient has not been prescribed the medication before. "The second warning prompts the checking pharmacist to counsel (speak with) the patient or their caregiver about how to take the medication." The product was supplied in tubes of 20 tablets. The trainee technician printed out three further labels. They were to be placed on the three tubes that were being dispensed. "This was the trainee technician's first time handling a phosphate product. She was also unfamiliar with the mmol dosage. She did not notice the dosage error as a result. She put the original prescription, labels and the medication in a basket on the dispensing bench for the registered pharmacist to check. "Unfortunately, the original label and the warning label was not kept with other items." The registered pharmacist who carried out the final check did not pick up that the medication was for an infant, the owner said. "In addition, it was not identified that this was a new medication. The fact that the warning label was not retained contributed to this error." The owner said the intern pharmacist had been suspended by the Pharmacy Council. The registered pharmacist had taken leave and then resigned. "This person does not intend to return to work in the immediate future," the owner said. The pharmacy was "urgently re-evaluating our dispensing and checking protocols and reinforcing safety checks at every stage". "We are actively recruiting additional staff to help manage our workloads. In addition, we are engaging an independent pharmacist from outside the Manawatū region to conduct a full review of our dispensing procedures and provide further guidance on system improvements." The owner said the pharmacy was "fully co-operating" with investigations being carried out by MedSafe, the Pharmacy Council and the police on behalf of the coroner. The owner signed off the email with "heartfelt apologies and regret". Bellamere's parents Tempest Puklowski and Tristan Duncan said after reading the email they did not blame the intern pharmacist for what happened. "My first initial reaction after reading it was I felt really bad for the intern," Puklowski said. "I don't blame him for the mistakes. I blame whoever was meant to be looking over his shoulder, whoever put him in that responsibility and just left him to it." Puklowski said it should have been picked up that the medication was for a baby. "It just seems like there's something lacking there that could have avoided it being missed or messed up," she said. Duncan said the system "needs to be better". Tempest said she remained "frustrated and angry" about her daughter's death. "It's just an endless sort of questioning of how and where it went wrong, to the point of, yeah, how could it have been avoided? "Obviously, those questions don't do much now, which then brings on the sadness of just knowing that she could still be here if these things were pulled up on initially, if maybe the intern wasn't left just to do the job by themselves. Or if you know something else is put in place, we would've never even gotten it and then we wouldn't be beating ourselves up for giving it to her." Duncan said the past two weeks since Bellamere's death had been "really hard". "Just empty is the only word that really comes to mind," he said. "It's unfair. Just stolen away by a singular document. That's what it comes down to." Puklowski said the couple "don't really know what to do with ourselves really". They were now waiting to see what happened with the multiple investigations that are under way. "I want things to change," Duncan said.
