Councillor springs to defence of Trump
If Donald Trump ever found himself on the West Coast, he could count on at least one fan to roll out the regional council welcome mat.
Goldmining councillor Allan Birchfield sprang to the defence of the US President at this month's corporate services meeting, after the council's treasury adviser critiqued Mr Trump's tariff policies and their chaotic impact on financial markets.
Bancorp corporate manager Miles O'Connor was presenting the firm's quarterly report on the West Coast Regional Council's (WCRC) $14-million investment fund, and the global trends likely to affect interest rates — all backed up with graphs, facts and figures.
The US was moving away from acting in the world's interest towards an America-centric approach, he noted.
Traditionally 60% of the world's capital had gone to the US because it was seen as a safe haven in uncertain times, Mr O'Connor said.
Predicting profits and interest rates had become so difficult that some banks and major companies had given up forecasting completely, Mr O'Connor said.
The US president had also challenged the independence of the Federal Reserve by calling on its governor to cut interest rates.
"Now that's just not done normally by political leaders. You don't see our Reserve Bank being told by the prime minister you must drop rates. It's inherent in monetary policy that the central bank is independent of political influence."
Mr Trump had since reduced the 145% tarrifs on Chinese goods to 30%, and the markets had settled down somewhat, but some tariffs would be permanent and New Zealand exports would be affected, Mr O'Connor said.
"My view is (Mr Trump) probably won't go back to what he was doing; he probably didn't expect the reaction he got."
Two Trump policies that did make sense were US defence spending and ending "unfettered" immigration, Mr O'Connor said.
"I'm not totally opposed to what he (Mr Trump) does — some of the other policies I am slightly dubious about."
Cr Birchfield — whose goldmine office sports a large photo of Mr Trump, seized his opening.
"I'm pleased you're starting to give Donald a bit of credit ... you go on with the usual rhetoric, anti-Donald Trump.
"You say the US only does stuff in its own interest — you need to think about the US Navy — it guarantees freedom of trade — even for China [and] it's a huge cost on the US taxpayer."
Mr O'Connor agreed the US does protect world trade.
"But [the tariffs] are having an effect on our exports — we know that from some of our clients who've had orders cancelled."
Mr Birchfield continued, saying Trump has got huge problem of debt and a trade imbalance with China.
Mr O'Connor said the reason for the trade imbalance was that the US just could not match China's manufacturing capabilities.
Council chairman Peter Haddock put an end to the exchange, saying "we've had a shot across the bows by the US".
"We have to recognise the volatility in the world ... the best we can get out of it is lower interest rates."
■LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Kiwi businesses say Trump's tariffs more impactful than Covid, Global Financial Crisis
Kiwi businesses say US President Donald Trump's tariffs will have a more severe global impact than Covid-19 and the Global Financial Crisis, according to ASB's latest Business Survey.
Otago Daily Times
3 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
'Disgusting abomination': Musk slams Trump's tax and spending bill
Billionaire Elon Musk has plunged into the congressional debate over President Donald Trump's sweeping tax and spending bill, calling it a "disgusting abomination" that will increase the federal deficit. Several fiscally conservative Republicans in the US Senate supported the views Musk expressed in social media posts, which could complicate the bill's path to passage in that chamber. "I'm sorry, but I just can't stand it anymore," Tesla and SpaceX CEO Musk wrote in a post on his social media platform X. "This massive, outrageous, pork-filled Congressional spending bill is a disgusting abomination." He added: "Shame on those who voted for it: you know you did wrong. You know it." Musk's comments hit a nerve. Republican deficit hawks have expressed concerns about the cost of the bill, which would extend the 2017 tax cuts that were Trump's main legislative accomplishment, while boosting spending on the military and border security. The House of Representatives passed it by one vote last month, after the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office said the measure would add $US3.8 trillion ($NZ6.3tn) to the federal government's $US36.2 trillion in debt. The Senate, also controlled by Trump's Republicans, aims to pass the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act" in the next month, though senators are expected to revise the House version. Republicans on the Senate Finance Committee, which oversees tax policy, are due to meet with Trump at the White House on Wednesday afternoon to discuss making the bill's business-related tax breaks permanent, according to Senator Steve Daines, a panel member. Analysts have warned that such a move would greatly increase the measure's cost. Republican Senate Majority Leader John Thune said he disagreed with Musk's assessment about the cost of the bill and stood by the goal of passage by July 4. "We have a job to do - the American people elected us to do. We have an agenda that everybody campaigned on, most notably the president of the United States, and we're going to deliver on that agenda," the South Dakota lawmaker told reporters. Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson also dismissed Musk's complaints, telling reporters, "my friend Elon is terribly wrong". TEST OF INFLUENCE Musk's loud opposition to a bill that Trump has urged Republicans to pass presents a test of his political influence a week after leaving his formal role in the administration as a special government employee with the Department of Government Efficiency came to an end. As DOGE chief, he upended several federal agencies but ultimately failed to deliver the massive savings he had sought. The richest person in the world, Musk had spent nearly $US300 billion to back Trump's presidential campaign and other Republicans in last year's elections. But he has said he would cut his political spending substantially while returning to his role as Tesla CEO. The White House dismissed Tuesday's attack, just as Trump dismissed earlier Musk complaints about the legislation. "Look, the president already knows where Elon Musk stood on this bill," spokeswoman Karoline Leavitt said at a White House briefing. "It doesn't change the president's opinion. This is one big, beautiful bill, and he's sticking to it." REPUBLICAN DISAGREEMENTS Senate Republicans were divided about the bill even before Musk's missives. Deficit hawks are pushing for deeper spending cuts than the $US1.6 trillion over a decade in the House version, while another coalition of rural-state Republicans are pushing to protect the Medicaid healthcare programme for low-income Americans. One of the hawks, Senator Mike Lee, called on party members to use the Trump bill and future spending measures to reduce the deficit. "We must commit now to doing so, as this is what voters justifiably expect - and indeed deserve - from the GOP Congress," the Utah Republican said on X while reposting Musk's message. Republicans have a 53-47 seat majority in the Senate and can afford to lose support from no more than three members, if they expect to pass the legislation with a tie-breaking vote from Vice President JD Vance by a July 4 deadline. Another hardliner, Senator Ron Johnson, predicted that lawmakers would not be able to meet the deadline and secure an adequate number of cuts. Lee and Johnson are among at least four Senate hardliners demanding that the bill be changed to restrict the growth of the debt and deficit. The faction of party lawmakers determined to limit spending cuts to project Medicaid beneficiaries and business investments in green energy initiatives is of similar size. "I certainly have an interest in making sure people with disabilities are not harmed. But also, there's the broad issue of how does it affect hospital reimbursements," Senator Jerry Moran told reporters. "There's a set of my colleagues who are pushing to do more. And so it turns on how do you get the votes to pass a bill," the Kansas Republican said. Other Senate Republicans said lawmakers may have to look elsewhere to boost savings, including the possibility of leaving Trump's much touted tax break proposals for tips, overtime pay and Social Security benefits for later legislation. "Those are all Democrat priorities. I'm not sure why we shouldn't be doing that in a potential bipartisan bill to create headspace for this bill," said Republican Senator Thom Tillis.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Trump tariffs worse for NZ businesses than Covid-19 pandemic
US President Donald Trump delivers remarks on reciprocal tariffs during an event in the Rose Garden at the White House in Washington, DC, on April 2, 2025. Photo: AFP / Brendan Smialowski Two-thirds of Kiwi businesses think United States tariffs would have a more severe global impact than Covid-19 and the Global Financial Crisis over the next 12 months, with nearly 80 percent of exporters most concerned, a survey indicates. However, the Talbot Mills Research survey of more than 300 business leaders commissioned by ASB Bank indicates a quarter saw some opportunity in the tariffs. "The current market volatility and geopolitical tension may be our 'new normal', but we've been in positions of global uncertainty before and the research shows Kiwi businesses are already thinking about actions they can take to make their business more resilient and generate returns," ASB's executive general manager business banking Rebecca James said. "It's clear businesses view any proposed US tariffs as troubling, but it's pleasing that nearly a quarter of respondents see opportunity in tariffs too. New Zealand has a reputation on the world stage for ingenuity and a can-do attitude, and we want businesses to know there are things they can do to future-proof and manage risks in turbulent times." Donald Trump holds a chart with each country's tariffs, although some have been paused or changed since the announcement on 2 April, 2025. Photo: AFP / Brendan Smialowski President Donald Trump's America First trade policy is aimed at protecting US industries and addressing the trade deficit through tariffs. While tariffs were set at 10 percent for most countries, including New Zealand, there were some notable outliers including Chinese origin goods. Negotiations between China and the US were scheduled to begin this week, while the 10 percent baseline was paused for a 90-day period. Given the uncertainty, James said businesses were shifting their focus to closer to home. "The research shows a pendulum swing when it comes to trading partners, with businesses redirecting their attention to our close neighbours. "Location seems to be king, with our customers prioritising relationships much closer to home. "We're also seeing exporters maintaining high standards and doubling down on premium products to give us an edge on the global stage, even where it costs more for consumers." She said banks were seen as a critical support function for 39 percent of respondents, specifically for working capital support (31 percent), risk advice (26 percent) and trade finance (24 percent). "ASB has provided $4.6 billion to Kiwi businesses over the past five years including considerable support to companies looking to expand and navigate opportunities abroad. "We encourage companies doing business overseas to speak with their banker and engage with a trade specialist to ensure your business is in the strongest position." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
