2025 Fantasy Baseball rest-of-season rankings: Starting Pitchers
We're over 20% of the way through the fresh MLB season, so it's a good time to kick off the Shuffle Up series. And we'll start with the position everyone asks about the most: starting pitchers.
Pitchers are the sirens of fantasy baseball, forever teasing us and misleading us. Most pitchers, even the best of them, are constantly tinkering with their approach, their arsenal, their mechanics. And of course, throwing a baseball is a very unnatural act, so you never know who's the next pitcher to need downtime — or a lost season.
You want to make the fantasy baseball gods laugh? Rank the pitchers.
And that's what the Shuffle Up series aims to do. What's below is a set of salaries that reflect how I would price the starting pitching market if I were entering a fresh draft today, or considering pickups or trades. What's happened to this point is merely an audition.
[Smarter waivers, better trades, optimized lineups — Yahoo Fantasy Plus unlocks it all]
The salaries are a combination of stats to this point, observations, gut feel and special sauce. You'll have many disagreements, of course, because that's why we have a game. I did a courtesy rank of the currently-injured pitchers at the bottom, but I will not discuss or debate that part of the list. Everyone can decide for themselves what a hurt pitcher is worth.
In the weeks to follow, we will shuffle other positions. Assume a 5x5 scoring system as always, and away we go.
The Big Tickets
$29 Tarik Skubal
$27 Paul Skenes
$25 Zack Wheeler
$24 Michael King
$24 Garrett Crochet
$23 Hunter Brown
$23 Yoshinobu Yamamoto
$23 Bryan Woo
$22 Hunter Greene
$22 Cole Ragans
$21 Logan Webb
$21 Jacob deGrom
$20 Max Fried
$20 Joe Ryan
$20 Chris Sale
So far, so good with the new version of deGrom, the so-called "dial it back" ace. His fastball is down a tick to 96.9 mph, which is intentional. The Rangers have been proactive in getting deGrom out of games, only pushing him past 90 pitches once.
I know there's no universal way to save the pitcher in the modern game, but when Texas quickly lifted deGrom with huge leads in his last two starts, I nodded my head. It's prudent. The strikeout rate has dropped and the walk rate is up, though 2.13 BB/9 is still excellent. There's also been an uptick in ground balls.
If this is the trade-off that has to happen, and we merely accept deGrom as a strong pitcher and not a demigod who separates himself, I can live with that. I'm just glad we can watch him every five days, and he hasn't had any setbacks.
Fried has been a godsend for the Yankees thus far, but see the story for what it is. His expected ERA is 3.27, much higher than the 1.01 on the back of the card. His ground-ball rate bails him out of trouble and he doesn't walk many batters, but the strikeout rate is merely average. He's getting positive results from his four primary pitches, with the cutter notably improved this year. His ratios from his last two Atlanta years are still the way to bet.
Legitimate Building Blocks
$19 Freddy Peralta
$18 Nick Pivetta
$18 Carlos Rodón
$18 Framber Valdez
$17 Nathan Eovaldi
$17 Dylan Cease
$17 MacKenzie Gore
$16 Jesús Luzardo
$16 Seth Lugo
$15 Kodai Senga
$15 Luis Castillo
$15 Pablo López
$14 Bailey Ober
$14 Kris Bubic
$13 Spencer Schwellenbach
$13 Zac Gallen
Gore has long been viewed as a future ace; maybe that future is now. His walk and strikeout rates are moving in the right direction. The batted-ball profile validates his early ratios, and his Savant page is a glorious display of red sliders pushed to the right. It's interesting that, for his career, he has reverse splits — lefties hit him better than righties — but it's nothing to be alarmed about. I wish the Washington defense were better, but Gore misses so many bats, he doesn't need as much help as the average pitcher. He's occupying a slot much higher than whatever you projected in March. This feels legit.
Is Lugo the most underrated starting pitcher in baseball? He's been a full-time rotation guy since 2023, with these returns: 3.57/1.20 in 2003, 3.00/1.09 last year (where he was quietly Cy Young runner-up) and a 3.07/1.05 push to this season. The K/BB rate isn't as tidy this year as what we're used to, and the batted-ball profile says he's about a run fortunate on the ERA. I'm not sweating any of that. This breakout story is 66 starts deep now, I'm trusting the results.
Talk Them Up, Talk Them Down
$12 Aaron Nola
$12 Sonny Gray
$12 Jack Flaherty
$11 Tyler Mahle
$11 Tanner Bibee
$11 Drew Rasmussen
$11 Bryce Miller
$10 Casey Mize
$10 Robbie Ray
$10 Clay Holmes
$10 Kevin Gausman
$10 Tony Gonsolin
$9 Tylor Megill
$9 Reese Olson
$9 Brady Singer
$9 Nick Lodolo
$9 Matt Liberatore
$9 Chris Bassitt
$9 Brandon Pfaadt
$9 Cristopher Sánchez
$9 Shane Baz
$9 Taj Bradley
Maybe we're firmly in "what you see is what you get" territory with Nola. His fastball has dropped down to 90.9 mph, after living in the 92s for eight straight years (for what it's worth, velocity often lags in the early part of a season and Nola feels that's the case here). His 4.61 ERA is basically what he's earned from his batted-ball profile. The Phillies might have the worst defense in the National League, so Nola pitching to contact comes at a price. He should be good enough to start for a mixed-league contender, but I've stopped expecting ace things from Nola.
Because Mize is a sturdy 6-foot-3 and 212 pounds and he was the top pick in his draft class, it's easy to imagine we're looking at a horse in the Roger Clemens/Zack Wheeler mode. That's never going to be Mize. He's not a strikeout guy. Plus control and a decent ground-ball rate have sparked his quasi-breakout so far, and his expected ERA (2.91) is right in line with the front-door 2.70. Detroit's defense isn't exactly airtight, but it's better than average. Stay grounded with the upside dreams, but Mize has shown enough to be considered a full-season story.
Some Plausible Upside
$8 Roki Sasaki
$9 Griffin Canning
$8 José Berríos
$8 Max Meyer
$8 Yusei Kikuchi
$7 JP Sears
$7 *Ben Casparius
$7 Dustin May
$6 Jackson Jobe
$6 José Quintana
$6 Gunnar Hoglund
$6 Sandy Alcantara
$6 Ryan Pepiot
$6 Luis Severino
$6 Matt Boyd
$5 Tyler Anderson
$5 Andrew Heaney
$5 David Peterson
$5 Hayden Wesneski
The Dodgers are looking to stretch out Casparius; he was the secondary pitcher Monday (four innings, one run) after a one-inning opener. That gloriously K/BB rate speaks for itself (28 punch outs, five walks) and the fastball pops at 96.0 mph. The Chavez Ravine infrastructure is a plus, too.
So many Japanese pitchers have seamlessly onboarded to the majors, perhaps I was unrealistic with my initial Sasaki expectations. The strikeout rate is low, the walk rate a screaming problem at the moment. Remember: the ball is different in America, not to mention the cadence of a rotation. His back class from NPB is what's keeping me from collapsing his salary completely.
I wish I had a good theory for Alcantra's struggles. Walks are way up, of course, and the strikeout rate is low — and he was never a strikeout dominator anyway, even in his Cy Young season. Miami wants to trade Alcantara at some point this year, but you need something to sell. Maybe drawing the White Sox on the weekend and Tampa Bay next week will improve the story, but whatever ceiling we might have dreamt about in March, it's long gone now. I would not be averse to selling low.
Bargain Bin
$4 Shane Smith
$4 Andrew Abbott
$4 Tomoyuki Sugano
$4 Brayan Bello
$4 Ronel Blanco
$4 Merrill Kelly
$4 Justin Verlander
$4 Gavin Williams
$4 Mitch Keller
$4 Jameson Taillon
$4 Michael Wacha
$3 Tanner Houck
$3 Grant Holmes
$3 Jake Irvin
$3 Mitchell Parker
$3 Jeffrey Springs
$3 Lance McCullers
$3 Nick Martinez
$3 AJ Smith-Shawver
$3 José Soriano
$2 Clarke Schmidt
$2 Bowden Francis
$2 Jack Leiter
$2 Lucas Giolito
$2 Erick Fedde
$2 Michael Lorenzen
$2 Zack Littell
$2 Ben Lively
$2 Taijuan Walker
$1 Stephen Kolek
$1 Luis L. Ortiz
$1 Landen Roupp
$1 Jordan Hicks
$1 Logan Allen
$1 Osvaldo Bido
$0 Eduardo Rodríguez
$0 Ben Brown
$0 Miles Mikolas
$0 Will Warren
$0 Tobias Myers
$0 Sean Burke
$0 Andre Pallante
$0 David Festa
$0 Dean Kremer
-$1 Chase Dollander
-$1 Patrick Corbin
Burke and Sugano are near the top of the good luck leaderboard, with ERAs that should be a couple of runs higher. Burke is also supported by the worst set of teammates in the American League, of course, and Sugano's Baltimore club is probably the biggest disappointment in the A.L. this year.
It will be interesting to see how patient the Giants are with Hicks — he has an ERA over six, but the expected number is a reasonable 3.51. Hayden Birdsong has been excellent in long relief — Monday's hiccup to the side — and is ready if anyone in the rotation has an extended slump or an injury. Landen Roupp, the team's No. 5 starter, could be on notice, too.
Courtesy Injury Ranks — Not for Debate
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
39 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Red Sox hit 5 home runs and overcome 2 by Judge in 11-7 win over Yankees
NEW YORK — Carlos Narváez put Boston ahead with a three-run homer against his former team, and the Red Sox overcame two home runs by Aaron Judge in an 11-7 victory over the New York Yankees on Sunday night. Rafael Devers also went deep as Boston equaled a season high with five longballs to take two of three games at Yankee Stadium in the first series this season between the longtime rivals. Narváez signed with the Yankees in 2015 and broke into the big leagues with them last year, getting into six games before New York traded him to Boston in December. The rookie catcher gave the Red Sox a 5-3 lead in the sixth inning by lifting a fastball from Carlos Rodón (8-4) into the left-field seats. Judge hit a pair of two-run homers for his fourth multihomer game this season and the 43rd of his career. He connected in the first off rookie Hunter Dobbins (3-1) and again in the ninth, ending the night with a .396 batting average. Boston rookie Kristian Campbell hit a two-run homer to the short porch in right field off Rodón in the fifth. Abraham Toro and Trevor Story hit back-to-back solo shots in the eighth off Jonathan Loáisiga. Jarren Duran had a two-run single off Yankees reliever Tim Hill in the sixth. Toro added an RBI double in the ninth. Dobbins allowed three runs and four hits in five innings. A day after telling the Boston Herald, 'If the Yankees were the last team to give me a contract, I'd retire,' Dobbins heard little reaction from the crowd of 45,140. DJ LeMahieu homered in the fifth to give New York a 3-2 lead. Rodón permitted five runs and three hits in five-plus innings. The left-hander lost for the first time in eight decisions since April 13. Garrett Whitlock retired LeMahieu on a bases-loaded grounder to end the sixth after the Yankees had cut it to 7-5. … Aroldis Chapman, the seventh Boston reliever, fanned Anthony Volpe with two on for his 11th save. Boston scored 27 runs in the series, its most in a three-game set at Yankee Stadium since 2005. … Loáisiga has allowed four homers in nine appearances since returning from elbow surgery. Red Sox RHP Brayan Bello (2-1, 3.91 ERA) opens a three-game series in Boston against Tampa Bay RHP Shane Baz (5-3, 4.96) on Monday night. Yankees LHP Max Fried (8-1, 1.78 ERA) opposes rookie LHP Noah Cameron (2-1, 0.85) in the opener of a three-game series Tuesday at Kansas City. ___ More AP baseball:
Washington Post
an hour ago
- Washington Post
Padres believe all their close wins have helped prepare them for 1st matchups with Dodgers this year
MILWAUKEE — The San Diego Padres are about to face the reigning World Series champion Los Angeles Dodgers for the first time since their memorable NL Division Series matchup. They believe all the close games they've played lately prepared them for this test. San Diego's last seven games have been decided by a total of eight runs, a stretch that continued Sunday when Manny Machado's seventh-inning homer gave the Padres a 1-0 win and series victory over the Milwaukee Brewers. 'We know who we're going to run up against, and we definitely got ready for it this week,' Machado said. This run of close games actually started earlier than that. Thirteen of San Diego's last 14 games featured a margin of no more than two runs, and the Padres have gone 9-5 during that stretch. 'These are kind of the games we've been playing the last 2½ weeks here now,' infielder Jake Cronenworth said. 'They're just kind of become the norm for us. I think (if) you can win these one-run games and win them late – good pitching, good defense and timely hitting – that's kind of the recipe for success.' Now they finally get to measure themselves against the Dodgers in seven of their next 10 games. The Padres and Dodgers begin a three-game series Monday at San Diego before meeting again in Los Angeles for a four-game set starting June 16. The Padres and San Francisco Giants are a game behind the Dodgers in the NL West standings after all three teams won Sunday. 'It's crazy that we haven't faced them,' reliever Jason Adam said. 'I'm excited for the series. I'd take this team over any team in baseball, top to bottom. I'd go to battle with them against anybody, so I'm excited for the series. Yeah, that's our focus. We took care of business here. Now, fly home and take care of business there.' How unusual is it for these NL West foes to wait this long before facing off? Aside from the pandemic-delayed season of 2020, the last time the Dodgers and Padres didn't meet until this late in a season was 2000. 'I used to think about the schedule and look at it and then think, 'Wow, that's odd,' ' manager Mike Shildt said. 'And then I started taking a holistic picture of the schedule. The schedule's got to be a nightmare to put together. There's just going to be quirks in it.' This has become one of baseball's top rivalries, thanks in part to their recent postseason showdowns. San Diego defeated the top-seeded Dodgers 3-1 in the 2022 NL Division Series before losing 4-1 to the Philadelphia Phillies in the NL Championship Series. Last year, the Padres had the Dodgers on the brink of elimination before falling 3-2 in the NL Division Series. The Padres led that series 2-1 and had a chance to close it out at home, but they fell 8-0 as eight Dodgers pitchers combined on a shutout. The Dodgers then returned home to win 2-0 in Game 5 as Yoshinobu Yamamoto outdueled Yu Darvish. Darvish hasn't pitched for San Diego yet this season as the 38-year-old right-hander recovers from inflammation in his throwing elbow, but the Padres still have an outstanding pitching staff. San Diego has allowed a total of 15 runs over its last seven games and has three shutouts in that span. Sunday marked the Padres' MLB-leading 12th shutout of the season. The Padres have needed that stellar pitching because their lineup has struggled at times. Machado has gone 12 of 31 this month and has three homers in his last four games, but two-time All-Star Fernando Tatis Jr. is hitting .185 since the start of May. That combination of impressive pitching and inconsistent hitting is producing plenty of close games, and the Padres are winning most of them. They're hoping that provides a long-term payoff. 'I think it's not only a help for (preparing for) the Dodgers,' Adam said. 'It's a help for all the future. It's a help for the playoffs. Very rarely are you blowing out a team in the playoffs. Of course, we love blowouts when they happen, and we love winning by 20, but the reality is there's a lot of important games played that are really close. A team that can battle together and win those games is special. That's what we have here.' ___ AP MLB:
New York Times
2 hours ago
- New York Times
Red Sox pound Yankees with 5 home runs to win series in New York
NEW YORK — After a walk-off win last Wednesday, the Boston Red Sox had a big, three-game trip looming to face the New York Yankees in the Bronx. 'They're all big (wins),' manager Alex Cora said last week. 'But it starts in New York. We've just got to go over there and win the series.' The way the Red Sox have played this season, one step forward and two steps back on repeat, Cora's words seemed like another pie-in-the-sky optimistic proclamation, something a manager says because he has to. Advertisement But Sunday night, his words became reality as the Red Sox took two of three from New York, trouncing the Yankees 11-7 in the finale on the strength of five home runs and a solid performance from their rookie starter. It marked just the fifth time in a regular-season road game against the Yankees that Boston homered five or more times, but their first since 2010. 'Overall, a good weekend,' Cora said. 'Some kids played in this environment for the first time, and they played loose. They did a good job. And now we just got to be ready for tomorrow.' Even in their loss Friday, when Walker Buehler was pounded for seven runs (five earned) in two innings of work, the Red Sox offense made a game of it before losing 9-6. Saturday, Garrett Crochet wasn't his best but still kept New York in check as Boston's lineup showed up again, posting 10 runs in a win. Sunday, the Red Sox were determined not to waste the weekend. Yankees starter Carlos Rodon held the Red Sox to one hit through the first four innings before Ceddanne Rafaela drew a two-out walk in the fifth and Kristian Campbell turned the tide with a two-run shot to tie the score at 2. Hey KC, thanks for the new ballgame! — Red Sox (@RedSox) June 9, 2025 The next inning, Boston's bats exploded for five runs. Rodon hit Rafael Devers, then walked Rob Refsnyder before Carlos Narváez made him pay with a three-run shot to left to push the Red Sox ahead 5-3 and force Rodon's early exit. With a 2.49 ERA to start the night, the five runs Rodon allowed tied a season high. He had given up four runs only once in his previous nine starts. The Red Sox kept at it and loaded the bases before Jarren Duran hit a two-run single to make it 7-3. Jarren makes it a 5-run inning! — Red Sox (@RedSox) June 9, 2025 In the eighth, Abraham Toro and Trevor Story hit back-to-back solo homers to pad Boston's lead, and in the ninth, Devers clubbed a solo shot to give the team some necessary insurance against a dangerous Yankees lineup. The thing you should know about Raffy is he's so good at baseball. — Red Sox (@RedSox) June 9, 2025 'The Campbell (homer) was huge. The Narváez one, that was huge,' Cora said. 'Here, no lead is safe. Raffy, Toro, we take them all, but those two swings were huge for us today.' Campbell, who's been struggling at the plate, had a 2-for-3 night, adding to a two-hit night from Saturday. His tying homer in the fifth marked his first home run since April 29. Advertisement But Narváez's go-ahead shot had even more significance. The catcher whom the Red Sox acquired from the Yankees in a trade this winter returned to Yankee Stadium for the first time this weekend. The 26-year-old rookie, who appeared in six games for New York last season, has emerged as a force behind the plate for the Red Sox while also taking on an important role in an injury-depleted lineup. He was anxious to perform well in his return to New York. GO AHEAD, NARVI. — Red Sox (@RedSox) June 9, 2025 'I was in my head a little bit to bunt there, to be honest,' Narváez said of that point in a tie game with two runners on. 'I talked to (third-base coach Kyle Hudson) and was like, 'OK, I'm just going to be aggressive,' and then that happened. Just happy I found some barrel, and then we came back and won the game.' With Alex Bregman on the injury list, Cora has started to hit Narváez in the cleanup spot to take advantage of how well Narváez is hitting. 'The at-bat is good; it's really good,' Cora said. 'It just happens, right now, he's hitting in the middle of the lineup. In a perfect world — we don't live in one — he should be hitting seventh for us and making this a deeper lineup. But I think we're hitting our stride. The production from Romy and Toro has been amazing. 'Like I said before the game, these are the 26 guys that we have (on the roster), and we're going to maximize the roster and use it to our advantage. And it was a good weekend.' Meanwhile, on the mound, Hunter Dobbins held New York in check over five innings, allowing three runs. It marked the first time in over a week that the Red Sox received back-to-back starts of five innings or more, after Crochet's six innings Saturday. 'He was good,' Cora said. 'Gave us enough. We've seen a trend with him in the fifth, sixth inning — the stuff ticks down — so give us five. We move on to the bullpen, and we got 27 outs.' Advertisement Dobbins allowed a two-run homer to Aaron Judge in the first inning, then a solo shot to DJ LeMahieu in the fifth to give the Yankees a 3-2 lead, but the Red Sox added five runs in the sixth. New York pulled within 7-5 on a sacrifice fly off Brennan Bernardino and a bases-loaded walk from Garrett Whitlock, but Whitlock got a groundout to end the threat in the sixth. Toro and Story padded the lead in the eighth. The Red Sox have not made it easy on themselves this season and still sit at 32-35 in early June. But if they can continue to pile up more wins like they did this weekend, they'll be headed in the right direction. After three games against the Tampa Bay Rays at home this week, the Red Sox have a rematch at Fenway Park next weekend against the Yankees. Cora has seen his team's momentum wiped out all too often and didn't want to get ahead of himself with the series win this weekend. 'Let's see how we react tomorrow,' he said. 'It'll be very important for us tomorrow to go to Fenway and play good baseball against a good team. (The Rays are) playing good baseball, so we have to be ready.' (Photo of Carlos Narváez's three-run homer in the sixth: John Jones / Imagn Images)
