As many benefits as possible should be made universal
I would prefer more careful decisions about which benefits were needed and making as many of them as possible universal, with a fairer tax system being used to recover money from those whose income is above the threshold selected.
READ MORE: Kate Forbes urges Westminster action as Scotland's economy shrinks
The Government should be giving serious consideration to Universal Basic Income as a way of reducing the poverty problem in this country, giving everyone at least the bare minimum necessary to live decently and enabling them to make decisions much more freely about their role in society: which job to take or go for, becoming more entrepreneurial and having the opportunity to participate more easily and more fully in the life of their communities.
Bob Gillespie
Glasgow
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Extra funding to ensure completion of new Glasgow primary school
The new money will support the refurbishment and extension of the former St James' Primary School in Calton area of the city, which has lain derelict for more than a decade. Although originally planned for completion in December 2025, the school is now expected to be handed over to the council towards the end of 2026. Once opened, Bun-sgoil Ghàidhlig a' Challtainn (Calton Gaelic Primary School) will become the fourth Gaelic-medium primary school in Glasgow and will have space for a total of 416 pupils. The most recent census shows that the number of Gaelic-speakers in Glasgow has increased by more than 80 percent since 2011. The school is being funded via the Scottish Government's Learning Estate Investment Programme (LEIP), which is intended to support the development of schools across the country and ensure that children are learning in environments that are fit for purpose. Councils have been able to apply for help to rebuild or refurbish schools, and in some cases create new education services, with dozens of projects approved since the first round of awards in 2019. Councils are responsible for the upfront costs of each programme, but can recoup up to half from the Scottish Government over a twenty-five year period. However, a significant number of existing projects are now running late and at least one – the Doon Valley Campus in East Ayrshire – has been cancelled due to escalating costs, and major concerns have been raised about the proposed new school on the Isle of Mull. Asked if the Scottish Government would consider providing further support for other LEIP projects, the Deputy First Minister did not rule out the possibility. In addition to the funding for the school refurbishment, the government also announced support for twelve further educational and cultural projects. The money will be provided via the Gaelic Capital Fund and will allow for developments including expanded teaching spaces and upgraded equipment in schools, as well as initiatives such as a two-day Gaelic music event in South Uist, the extension of a Gaelic cultural centre in Skye, and the transcription of historic Gaelic recordings. Speaking during her visit to the school site, Kate Forbes said: 'This school will build on the encouraging surge we have seen in the number of Gaelic speakers and learners in Glasgow and support the language's growth into the future. 'Gaelic medium education enriches communities and offers good value for money by providing better grade averages across all qualification levels despite costs being no greater than average. 'To support Gaelic's growth across Scotland, we are providing an additional £5.7 million for Gaelic initiatives this year. We are also progressing the Scottish Languages Bill which, if passed by MSPs, will introduce measures to strengthen the provision of Gaelic education.' Alison Richardson, headteacher of Bun-sgoil Ghàidhlig a' Challtainn, said: 'With Gaelic medium education continuing to flourish in Glasgow, our pupils and parents are excited and proud to be moving Bun-sgoil Ghàidhlig a' Challtainn into its very own repurposed school located in the East End. 'We look forward to supporting Gaelic's growth in the Calton area, where many spoke it in the past, and for the school to become a real focal point and asset to the local community.'
The National
4 hours ago
- The National
Scottish city to open fourth Gaelic primary school after £2.4m funding
Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic Kate Forbes announced the investment as part of a £2.4 million package to support Gaelic schools and cultural initiatives across Scotland at the site in Calton today. The funding will complete the refurbishment and extension of the former St James' Primary School building to establish Bun-sgoil Ghàidhlig a' Challtainn (Calton Gaelic Primary School). Glasgow is home to the third largest number of children and young people in Gaelic education in Scotland with 740 primary pupils in 2023. READ MORE: 200 fans cram into Scottish trad pub for surprise Tide Lines set Census statistics from 2022 showed that 17,380 people in Glasgow had some Gaelic skills, an increase of 7911 people from 2011. The £2.4m funding will also support: the construction of a second classroom at West Primary School in Paisley the expansion of two Gaelic cultural centres in the Highlands cultural events through An Comunn Gàidhealach who will host this year's Royal National Mòd in Lochaber On a visit to the site of the new school, Forbes said: 'This school will build on the encouraging surge we have seen in the number of Gaelic speakers and learners in Glasgow and support the language's growth into the future. 'Gaelic medium education enriches communities and offers good value for money by providing better grade averages across all qualification levels despite costs being no greater than average. 'To support Gaelic's growth across Scotland, we are providing an additional £5.7 million for Gaelic initiatives this year. We are also progressing the Scottish Languages Bill which, if passed by MSPs, will introduce measures to strengthen the provision of Gaelic education.' READ MORE: 5 lost Gaelic words and phrases rediscovered in Scotland The new school, with space for 416 pupils, will be managed by Glasgow City Council. It meets a growing demand for Gaelic primary education in the city. Census figures published last year show a 45% increase in the number of people with some Gaelic skills in Glasgow compared to 2011. Alison Richardson, headteacher of Bun-sgoil Ghàidhlig a' Challtainn, said: 'With Gaelic medium education continuing to flourish in Glasgow, our pupils and parents are excited and proud to be moving Bun-sgoil Ghàidhlig a' Challtainn into its very own repurposed school located in the East End. 'We look forward to supporting Gaelic's growth in the Calton area, where many spoke it in the past, and for the school to become a real focal point and asset to the local community.'
The Herald Scotland
11 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Call for law changes to ensure ScotGov public inquiries are effective
It has come as it emerged the Scottish Government has admitted there is no legal requirement to monitor whether lessons learnt recommendations from inquiries are actually acted on. Those inquiries cover 20 years and range from the Edinburgh Tram Inquiry, the Vale of Leven Inquiry investigation into the occurrence of C. difficile infection to the the Stockline inquiry into the 2004 explosion at the ICL Plastics factory in Glasgow and the public investigation into the integrity of the fingerprint service. The current cost of all live inquiries has soared thirteen-fold over ten years to stand at nearly £180m and it is estimated the overall costs has reached nearly £250m since 2007. The cost of the five live major inquiries that are currently running eclipses the solitary one that was live ten years ago - and even those costs are spiralling. At the start of last year the live inquiries were costing £120m. Ten years ago the solitary major inquiry at the time into the Edinburgh Tram project came at a total cost of £13m. It was set up to establish why the capital's trams project incurred delays, cost more than originally budgeted and delivered significantly less than was projected. Edinburgh Trams were subject of an inquiry into soaring costs and delays But there are concerns that overall cost figures for inquiries could well be a lot higher as they do not include the costs to government departments, other public bodies and those participating. The Scottish Government was asked by a group of MSPs how many of the 197 recommendations, including 11 interim and a plan of action from a series of public inquiries since 2007 were implemented and what its role is in monitoring and ensuring lessons are learnt. But they were told that the law does not require ministers to act as overseer in this area, even though under the Inquiries Act 2005, the chairman of an inquiry must provide a final report to the ministers, setting out the facts determined by the inquiry panel and any recommendations where its terms of reference lay that out. Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes, response to questions about which recommendations were actioned did not spell out what of the 200 lessons were actually acted upon from inquiries formally established by ministers. READ MORE by Martin Williams: Why does Scotland hold costly 'lessons learnt' public inquiries Ministers warned over public inquiries secrecy as taxpayer cost soars by £60m in a year Swinney urged to act over 'stalled' lifeline funding of ferry fiasco firm Revealed: £400k public cost of ScotGov Euro 2028 ticket tout ban that 'won't work' 'People going bananas': New ferry fiasco hits vital island supplies 'Stretched to breaking': Nation loses 800 officers since formation of Police Scotland Instead she states that the Act "does not contain any provision for centrally monitoring over whether the accepted inquiry recommendations are actually implemented". And she added: "There is no legal obligation to respond to a report." The questions related to recommendations of concluded public inquiries since 2007, and also include the Penrose infected blood probe. She further states in answer to questions about what lessons have been learnt, that in practice, an area of government "will be identified as responsible for taking forward recommendations (where appropriate) and ensuring delivery where they are accepted". She said recommendations may also be made by an inquiry relating to other parties, such as public bodies, "which would be for their consideration". The current cost of the two live inquiries into health-related issues including the Covid-19 pandemic currently stands at £64.3m. There were no live health-related public inquiries ten years ago, although in the decade previously, there were two which together cost £22.8m. Over £12m of legal and administrative costs has been incurred by NHS bodies alone responding to public inquiries since 2021. NHS National Services Scotland (NSS) which is a core participant in the long-running Scottish Covid-19 pandemic inquiry and has participated in two further public probes says it has spent £3.1m since 2021/22 in responding to public inquiries through legal and other administrative costs. On top of that a further £9m in legal services for public inquiries was provided to NHS Scotland boards by the NSS's Central Legal Office. NSS, which reports directly to the Scottish Government, and works at the heart of Scotland's health service, providing national strategic support services and expert advice to NHS Scotland, suggested an independent advisory body could be established to decide whether a public inquiry should be held and hold to account those probes that did go ahead. It suggested that the current processes for monitoring public inquiry costs are "inadequate" saying that they are not reimbursed "or reported consistently". The NSS said that the advisory body could have a role in assessing the costs. "Tight terms of reference are essential when a public inquiry is established to ensure value for money" they said. NSS said that the inquiries' effectiveness "can vary considerably". It said that work was needed to look at each concluded inquiry in Scotland against its terms of reference and examine what the has been achieved. It said that that would allow effectiveness "to be measured in more detail". It said a new advisory body could examine what opportunities there area for learning lessons, whether it would be effective and whether it would be value for money. It could also ensure a consistency of approach and oversee costs that are incurred. And it suggested that a law could be introduced to ensure that lessons are learnt from public inquiries, indicating that in terms of lessons learnt "consistency and cascading out can be challenging". The independent advisory body could "support consistency in cascading lessons learned". Section 28 of the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Death etc (Scotland) Act 2016 introduced a requirement that those to whom recommendations are directed must provide a response within eight weeks to set out what changes have been made or are proposed. Alternatively it has to provide the reasons why no action is being taken. It suggested a similar law that is brought in for public inquiries "requiring participants in public inquiries to report to parliament with their written response to the inquiries' reports". Lord Hardie, the man in charge of the Edinburgh tram probe has admitted there were limitations when inquiries like the one he oversaw was established by the Scottish Government as non-statutory, which he says he was not consulted over. He has said in correspondence seen by the Scottish Government that this led to him being unable to access material held by the City of Edinburgh Council and resulted in the refusal of key witnesses to co-operate. The most expensive and longest running of the current probes is the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry into historical abuse of children in residential care that was formally established in October 2015 - ten months after the Scottish Government announced that it would happen. Concerns have been raised about delays and mounting costs - which was running at £78.211m at the start of last year and has risen to £95.3m as of March 2025. The second most expensive live public probe is the Scottish Covid-19 inquiry which started in August 2022 to examine Scotland's response to and the impact of the pandemic and to learn lessons for the future. It had run up costs of £12.816m by the start of last year. And by December last year it was at £34m. The Scottish Hospitals Inquiry chaired by Lord Brodie QC which is examining issues of safety and wellbeing issues at two Scots health establishments had cost £14.33m at the start of last year after opening in August 2020. It had risen to £23.6m in December 2024. It is examining complaints around the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH) in Glasgow, and the Royal Hospital for Children and Young People (RHCYP) and Department of Clinical Neurosciences in Edinburgh. Its final report is expected to be issued at the end of next year after calls for further evidence. The latest inquiry into Sam Eljamel, who harmed dozens of patients and left some with life-changing injuries, was launched last month and has racked up £1.08m in costs so far - before hearing any evidence. Mr Eljamel was head of neurosurgery at Dundee's Ninewells Hospital until his suspension in December 2013. He resigned a year later and is now believed to be operating in Libya. At the start of last year, the Herald revealed the cost of live inquiries at that point was at £120m, while the Scottish Parliament launched an inquiry last month into their cost effectiveness last month. MSPs are to further consider the role of public inquiries today. Research suggests the total cost of all public inquiries launched over the last 18 years, in today's prices, is at £230m so far. A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Public inquiries are set up when no other avenue is deemed sufficient given the issues of public concern. In many cases, such as the Scottish Covid Inquiry, they are set up with the support of, or in response to calls from, the Scottish Parliament. "Public inquiries operate independently of government and the chair has a statutory duty to avoid unnecessary costs.'
