This Week in Mets: Another injury puts more strain on Mets' depth
'Your conscience will never let you rest.'
'God bless it. I wouldn't want to live without strong misgivings.'
— 'Catch-22,' Joseph Heller
On Thursday in Port St. Lucie, Fla., David Stearns was asked about not bringing back Jose Quintana or José Iglesias — a pair of critical contributors to last year's NLCS team.
Advertisement
'We feel really good about our team,' Stearns said. 'We prepare for injuries. We feel like we have depth, and I'm excited to see what some of our other players, including some of our young players, would be able to do with that opportunity.'
Stearns and the New York Mets don't have to wait long to test that excitement.
Still more than two weeks from Opening Day, New York has lost two of its top starting pitchers in Sean Manaea and Frankie Montas, it's lost the presumed front-runner for its utility spot in Nick Madrigal, and now it's lost its starting catcher, Francisco Alvarez, for roughly the first month of the season.
In Stearns' first season in Queens, one of his greatest successes was quickly and consistently buttressing the Mets organization with quality depth. Players seldom discussed this time last year, such as Iglesias, became unexpected and significant parts of the team by the end of summer. We've covered this.
However, the loss of Alvarez is especially challenging for the Mets because it's a reminder of one spot their depth failed them in the first two months last season. Remember, the catcher's ligament tear in his thumb in April augured the Mets' woeful start to the season: The team went 17-28 during the time he missed, with Tomás Nido and Omar Narváez unable to provide serviceable depth.
It wasn't until June, when Stearns acquired Luis Torrens in a minor trade just before Alvarez returned, that the Mets resolidified the backstop. As well as Torrens played, it was Alvarez's return that really did it. The Mets' record when Alvarez started last season was 58-27, compared with 31-46 when he didn't. That's the difference between a 110-win team and a 65-win team, over 162. No, it isn't '72 Steve Carlton, but I did have to double-check.
And that's what happened during what was pretty clearly a frustrating offensive season for Alvarez, who dropped from 25 homers in 2023 to just 11 last season. Alvarez's defensive value manifested in less transparent ways. The Mets' ERA with him behind the plate (3.48) was nearly a run better than otherwise (4.36). Yes, take catcher ERA with a grain of salt, but maybe a smaller one here since New York didn't employ a personal catcher for any starters in 2024. (The possible exception here is that Alvarez missed May, the month in which the entirety of the Mets' bullpen imploded. It's a little difficult to pin down the correlation/causation meter there.)
Advertisement
Catching is not an area where the Mets have a readymade next man up. Without Manaea and Montas in the rotation, the Mets can still run a six-man rotation of starters with legitimate major-league experience. Without Madrigal as an infield reserve, they have several younger players to choose from as fill-ins. Without Alvarez, they have no third catcher on the 40-man roster, no prospect on the rise, and one other player with all of eight games of major-league time (Jakson Reetz). Catchers tend to hit the waiver wire late in spring, and there should be opportunities to add outside the organization.
What impressed those around the Mets so much in Stearns' first season was his ability to improve the team outside the traditional windows of acquisition (the offseason and the trade deadline). This is another early opportunity to prove it again.
Since I mentioned that each of the first two books I quoted from this season ('The Recognitions' and 'The Master and Margarita') were top 10 novels for me, a couple of commenters asked for a complete list. So here it comes, slowly, over the next eight weeks. Just check the epigraphs.
Also, maybe we'll end up doing more than 10.
The 1998 Mets used a team-record eight catchers that season, though the position was largely solidified by a certain May trade. Before Mike Piazza arrived, which catcher started behind the plate Opening Day, and which catcher finished Opening Day with a walk-off base hit?
(I'll reply to the correct answers in the comments.)
(Top photo of Francisco Alvarez: Gordon Donovan / Associated Press)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC Sports
35 minutes ago
- NBC Sports
Report: New York to ask Dallas for permission to talk to Jason Kidd about becoming head coach
The New York Knicks — searching for a new coach after the firing of Tom Thibodeau, who led them to the Eastern Conference Finals — are expected to ask permission of the Dallas Mavericks to talk to Jason Kidd about coming to Manhattan, reports Marc Stein of The Stein Line in his latest Substack missive. 'The New York Knicks are expected to formally request permission to speak to the Dallas Mavericks' Jason Kidd about their coaching vacancy in coming days, league sources say... A precise hierarchy of potential Knicks targets to replace Thibodeau has yet to emerge, but some in league coaching circles believe that Kidd... is at the top of New York's wish list.' Kidd coached Brunson for a year in Dallas, and the two had a good relationship (Brunson's issues in Dallas were about his next contract and feeling lowballed and disrespected, not the coaching). Two big questions emerge here. First, would Dallas give permission for New York to talk to Kidd? Mavs ownership/management can say no, which is reportedly what Houston would do if New York called about Ime Udoka (Stein wrote that the Knicks would like Udoka, but knows they would be turned down if they asked). As a standard practice, if the coach is open to it, teams will let their coach have those conversations with another team, but if things get serious and the coach wants to move on then draft compensation has to come back to the coach's current team (and the Knicks are not flush with draft picks to send to Dallas). Kidd signed an extension with Dallas that runs through 2027 and by all accounts is happy there, Stein reports. Second, would Kidd want the job? ESPN's Tim MacMahon said on the outlet's 'Hoop Collective' podcast that Kidd's 'ears would perk up' at the idea, adding that the Knicks need to bring in a 'relationship guy' and Kidd fits that bill. 'Listen, one of the names that's been thrown out there is a man who's under contract with another team, but definitely a guy who has relationships not just with Jalen Brunson but with a lot of people in that organization, and that's Jason Kidd. And what I will say about that is I would not dismiss that possibility.' Kidd was hired to be the Mavericks' coach by former owner Mark Cuban. In the wake of the ownership change and the Luka Doncic trade, would he want out? Dallas still has talent on the roster, including Kyrie Irving (out for most or all of next season with a torn ACL), Anthony Davis, and incoming No. 1 pick Cooper Flagg, as well as solid players such as P.J. Washington, Naji Marshall, and others. If the Knicks can't get Kidd or Udoka, where do they turn next? They reportedly want an experienced head coach, which would rule out former assistant Johnnie Bryant (who is now in Cleveland and was a finalist for the Suns job). Michael Malone is out there, but he is seen as similar to Thibodeau in leaning too heavily into his starters and being set in his ways. Former Cavaliers, Lakers and most recently Kings coach Mike Brown is available, he is a defense-first guy, but is he an upgrade over Thibodeau that takes them to the next level? The Knicks moved on from Thibodeau without a replacement lined up, which could make this search messy.
Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox Renew Rivalry In Differing Spots In The AL East
The quirks in a schedule often get scenarios like the one about to unfold, the Yankees and Red Sox starting their season series. Ever since the schedule was reduced to 13 divisional games in 2023 to accommodate playing every team, sometimes it has taken a while for a divisional rivalry to get going and this year it is the case for the Yankees and Red Sox, who will start their season series this weekend. It is the third straight season the Yankees-Red Sox are starting in June. Last year, it began June 14 in Fenway Park and the Yankees began their month-long slump they eventually recovered from by winning 94 games and their first AL pennant since 2009. Two years ago, it began June 9 at Yankee Stadium a week after Aaron Judge crashed into the fence in right field at Dodger Stadium to effectively doom the Yankees to a lost summer of 82 wins. At this point, the Yankees and Red Sox are in different places. The Yankees enter the series with a nice lead atop the AL East where they have resided every day since beating the Kansas City Royals on April 14. The Yankees are there because of Judge's flirtation with .400, which has him hitting .392 to go along with an astounding 1.251 OPS while playing all 61 games. They are there because the offseason moves following the loss of Juan Soto to a massive 15-year deal with the Mets, a storyline that figures to get all sorts of play over the weekend when FOX follows its coverage of the Belmont Stakes on Saturday and ESPN puts the game up against Game 2 of the NBA finals between the Pacers and Thunder. The Yankees and Red Sox may be hard-pressed to replicate the end of Game 1 between the Thunder and Pacers when Tyrese Haliburton hit the game-winner with three-tenths of a second. The first installment of the 13-game series is about the Yankees going about their business in the matter-of-fact way they are doing thus far. One thing not happening is Max Fried getting his first start in the rivalry since he pitched Thursday, though he might pitch next weekend in Fenway. Fried has been everything and more the Yankees could have hoped for, getting to 8-1 through his first 11 starts with the mix of dominance and grit. The latter occurred Thursday when Fried put two on with two outs in the first and then won an eight-pitch battle with Carlos Santana. Santana's at-bat started a run of 11 straight retired hitters and 15 of 16 though there were several long counts and 16 foul balls. It was the kind of outing the Red Sox hoped Fried would provide for them but Fried opted for the eight-year, $218 million deals to join a rotation headed by Gerrit Cole. Cole is three months removed from Tommy John surgery on his elbow thus the storyline with him and Rafael Devers is on hold until next season. Cole underwent the surgery about six months after a bizarre intentional walk to Devers, who is 9-for-33 in their matchups. Devers was playing third base back then and has yet to see the field this year. Devers was moved off the position when Alex Bregman was signed and is still only hitting as Bregman recovers from a quad strain sustained May 23. Devers got the game-winning hit in the game after Bregman's injury but the Red Sox went from five to 9 1/2 games out since. They head to the Bronx with eight losses in 11 games, including five by one run, an area where the Red Sox dropped 17 of 23 so far. The rough start through 64 games is part of a team with an MLB-worst 53 errors after struggling defensively last season when Devers made 12 errors and had a .961 fielding percentage in his 130 games at third. Naturally all of Boston's faults are after some raised expectations, leading to questions about Alex Cora's job security and it is secure based on comments chief baseball officer Craig Breslow made this week on WEEI. This weekend will be hyped because the Red Sox-Yankees often are, though nothing will be like 2003 through 2007. It will be about the Yankees continuing to go about things in their business like matter and the Red Sox trying to find their footing to climb closer to .500 and eventually over the break-even mark.
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
The Red Sox need to make some noise against the Yankees
While barely avoiding a sweep at the hands of the Angels isn't something to celebrate, the Boston Red Sox have to be feeling pretty good about themselves after Wednesday's walk-off win. They need to channel all that good mojo this weekend against the first-place Yankees in New York. The AL East rivals will square off for the first time this season with a three-game set in the Bronx. The 38-23 Yankees have the third-best record in baseball and look determined to win it all after coming up short last October. It's the exact opposite of what the Red Sox have looked like this season. Boston is still licking its wounds after going just 11-17 in May and a 2-2 start to June, despite facing some lackluster opposition. Alex Cora's club did not take advantage of an easy part of the schedule and sits at just 30-34 on the year -- 9.5 games back of New York. If this isn't a make-or-break series for the Red Sox, it's pretty darn close. They're reaching a desperation point, winning just three times in their last 10 games. Over the last 11 games, Boston has by one run five times thanks in large part to the team's lack of fundamentals all over the diamond. The Yankees, meanwhile, have won three of four, eight of their last 11, and 12 of their last 16 games. They're in the top three in most offensive categories, thanks to an absolute monster season from Aaron Judge so far. The MVP favorite is hitting a ridiculous .392 (the best in MLB) with a 1.250 OPS (also first) with 21 homers (third) and 50 RBI (fifth). The New York offense isn't just a one-hit wonder though, with solid hitters up and down the lineup. First baseman Paul Goldschmidt is slashing .323/.380/.471 for the season. Centerfielder Trent Grisham is second on the team with 13 homers, while DH Ben Rice has left the yard a dozen times. Cody Bellinger has been solid with nine homers and 10 doubles. Jazz Chisholm returned last series and went 5-for-11 with a homer and two runs scored as the Yankees took two of three from the Guardians. The Red Sox will send Garrett Crochet to the bump Saturday night, so the team should be competitive for at least one game this series. But Boston really needs a series win, which they've done just twice in their last seven series. A good series win against the Yankees could push the Red Sox in the right direction at a difficult part of the schedule. After a visit from the Rays next week, the Yankees will be at Fenway Park next weekend. Boston then heads out West for series against the first-place Mariners, first-place Giants, and the Angels team that just took two of three at Fenway Park. Red Sox-Yankees Pitching Matchups The Red Sox luck out a bit this weekend, as they'll avoid New York ace Max Fried. The lefty tossed six shutout innings of one-run ball against Cleveland on Thursday, so the Red Sox won't see Fried and his 1.78 ERA. Here's who will toe the rubber for the two teams over the next three days: Friday: Walker Buehler (4-3. 4.44 ERA) vs. Will Warren (3-3, 5.19 ERA) Grisham is batting just .211 in 19 career at-bats against Buehler, but two of his four hits were homers. Chisholm is 3-for-7 in his career against the righty. Judge is 0-for-2 against Buehler with a strikeout. Saturday: Garrett Crochet (5-4, 1.98 ERA) vs. Ryan Yarbrough (3-0, 2.83 ERA) No one on the Yankees has more than three career at-bats against Crochet. Bellinger is 2-for-2 against the Boston ace with a homer. Judge is 1-for-2 with a single and a strikeout, while Goldschmidt is 0-for-3 with two strikeouts. Rafael Devers has the most at-bats of all Red Sox hitters against Yarbrough, going 6-for-27 (.222) with a double, a homer, and six RBI. Sunday: Hunter Dobbins (2-1, 4.06 ERA) vs. Carlos Rodon (8-3, 2.49 ERA) This will be the first time the Yankees see Dobbins, who is coming off five innings of one-run ball against the Angels on Monday night. Dobbins came out of the bullpen that evening after former New York prospect Richard Fitts was roughed up for six runs (five earned) in the first inning. While Boston avoids Fried this series, they do not avoid Rodon, who has been spectacular for New York. We'll definitely be seeing Rob Refsnyder in the Boston lineup Sunday night, as he's 4-for-12 with two doubles, a homer, and three walks in his career against Rodon.
