logo
MDMA may have protected Nova attack survivors from trauma, study suggests

MDMA may have protected Nova attack survivors from trauma, study suggests

BBC News07-03-2025
As dawn approached on the morning of 7 October 2023, many of the partygoers at the Nova music festival near Gaza's border took illegal recreational drugs like MDMA or LSD.Hundreds of them were high when, shortly after sunrise, Hamas gunmen attacked the site.Now neuroscientists working with survivors from the festival say there are early signs that MDMA - also known as ecstasy or molly - may have provided some psychological protection against trauma.The preliminary results, currently being peer-reviewed with a view to publication in the coming months, suggest that the drug is associated with more positive mental states - both during the event and in the months afterwards.The study, carried out by scientists at Israel's Haifa University, could contribute to a growing scientific interest in how MDMA might be used to treat psychological trauma.It is thought to be the first time scientists have been able to study a mass trauma event where large numbers of people were under the influence of mind-altering drugs.Hamas gunmen killed 360 people and kidnapped dozens more at the festival site where 3,500 people had been partying."We had people hiding under the bodies of their friends for hours while on LSD or MDMA," said Prof Roy Salomon, one of those leading the research."There's talk that a lot of these substances create plasticity in the brain, so the brain is more open to change. But what happens if you endure this plasticity in such a terrible situation - is it going to be worse, or better?"
The research tracked the psychological responses of more than 650 survivors from the festival. Two-thirds of these were under the influence of recreational drugs including MDMA, LSD, marijuana or psilocybin - the compound found in hallucinogenic mushrooms - before the attacks took place."MDMA, and especially MDMA that was not mixed with anything else, was the most protective," the study has found, according to Prof Salomon.He said those on MDMA during the attack appeared to cope much better mentally in the first five months afterwards, when a lot of processing takes place."They were sleeping better, had less mental distress - they were doing better than people who didn't take any substance," he said.The team believes pro-social hormones triggered by the drug - such as oxytocin, which helps promote bonding - helped reduce fear and boost feelings of camaraderie between those fleeing the attack.And even more importantly, they say, it appears to have left survivors more open to receiving love and support from their families and friends once they were home.Clearly, the research is limited only to those who survived the attacks, making it hard to determine with any certainty whether specific drugs helped or hindered victims' chances of escape.But researchers found that many survivors, like Michal Ohana, firmly believe it did play a role - and say that belief, in itself, may help them to recover from the event."I feel like it saved my life, because I was so high, like I'm not in the real world," she told me. "Because regular humans can't see all these things - it's not normal."Without the drug, she believes she would have just frozen or collapsed to the floor, and been killed or captured by the gunmen.
Clinicians in various countries have already experimented with MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) in a trial setting - though only Australia has approved it as a treatment.Countries that have rejected it include the US, where the Food and Drug Administration cited concerns about the design of the studies, that the treatment may not offer long-lasting benefits, and about the potential risk for heart problems, injury and abuse.MDMA is classified as a Class A drug in the UK, and has been linked to liver, kidney and heart problems.In Israel, where MDMA is also illegal, psychologists can only use it to treat clients on an experimental research basis.The preliminary findings from the Nova study are being closely followed by some of those Israeli clinicians experimenting with MDMA as treatment for PTSD after 7 October.Dr Anna Harwood-Gross, a clinical psychologist and director of research at Israel's Metiv Psychotrauma Centre, described the initial findings as "really important" for therapists like her.She is currently experimenting with using MDMA to treat PTSD within the Israeli military, and had worried about the ethics of inducing a vulnerable psychological state in clients when there is a war going on."At the beginning of the war, we questioned whether we were able to do this," she said. "Can we give people MDMA when there's a risk of an air raid siren? That's going to re-traumatise them potentially. This study has shown us that even if there's a traumatic event during therapy, the MDMA might also help process that trauma."
Dr Harwood-Gross says early indications of therapeutic MDMA use are encouraging, even among military veterans with chronic PTSD.It has also upended old assumptions about the "rules" of therapy - especially the length of sessions, which have to be adjusted when working with clients under the influence of MDMA, she says."For example, it's changed our thoughts about 50-minute therapy sessions, with one patient and one therapist," Dr Harwood-Gross told me. "Having two therapists, and long sessions - up to eight hours long - is a new way of doing therapy. They're looking at people very holistically and giving them time."She says this new longer format is showing promising results, even without patients taking MDMA, with a success rate of 40% in the placebo group.Israeli society itself has also changed its approach to trauma and therapy following the 7 October attacks, according to Danny Brom, a founding director of the METIV Psychotrauma Centre at Herzog Hospital in Jerusalem, and a senior figure in the industry."It's as if this is the first trauma we're going through," he said. "I've seen wars here, I've seen lots of terrorist attacks and people said, 'We don't see trauma here'. "Suddenly, there seems to be a general opinion that now everyone is traumatised, and everyone needs treatment. It's a wrong approach."What broke, he said, is the sense of security many Jews believed Israel would provide them. These attacks uncovered a collective trauma, he says, linked to the Holocaust and generations of persecution.
"Our history is full of massacres," psychologist Vered Atzmon Meshulam told me. "As a psychologist now in Israel, we are faced with an opportunity to work with lots of traumas that weren't previously being treated, like all our narratives for 2,000 years."Collective trauma, combat trauma, mind-altering drugs, sexual assault, hostages, survivors, body-collectors, the injured and the bereaved - Israel's trauma specialists are facing a complex cocktail of issues from the clients now flooding into therapy.The scale of that mental health challenge is mirrored in Gaza, where vast numbers of people have been killed, injured or left homeless after a devastating 15-month war - and where there are scant resources to help a deeply traumatised population.The war in Gaza, triggered by the Hamas attacks on Israeli communities in October 2023, was suspended in January in a six-week truce, during which Israeli hostages held by Hamas were exchanged for Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails.But there is little sense on either side that the peace and security needed to begin healing has arrived.The truce expired last weekend, with 59 Israeli hostages still in Hamas captivity. Many Gazans are waiting, with their bags packed, for war to resume.Meanwhile Nova survivor Michal Ohana says she feels that with the passage of time, some are expecting her to have moved on from the attacks, but she is still affected."I wake up with this, and I go to sleep with this, and people don't understand," she told me. "We live this every day. I feel the country supported us in the first months, but now after one year, they feel: 'OK, you need to go back to work, back to life.' But we can't."
Additional reporting by Oren Rosenfeld and Naomi Scherbel-Ball
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Latest: Israeli strikes in Gaza kill at least 21 people, health authorities say
The Latest: Israeli strikes in Gaza kill at least 21 people, health authorities say

The Independent

time3 hours ago

  • The Independent

The Latest: Israeli strikes in Gaza kill at least 21 people, health authorities say

Israeli strikes in Gaza killed at least 21 people late Tuesday and early Wednesday. More than half of those killed were women and children, health authorities said. Desperation is mounting in the Palestinian territory of more than 2 million, which experts say is at risk of famine because of Israel's blockade and nearly two-year offensive. A breakdown of law and order has led to widespread looting and contributed to chaos and violence around aid deliveries. More than 1,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces since May while trying to get food in the Gaza Strip, mostly near aid sites run by an American contractor, the U.N. human rights office said Tuesday. More than 100 human rights groups and charities signed a letter published Wednesday demanding more aid for Gaza and warning of grim conditions causing starvation. More than 59,000 Palestinians have been killed during the Israel-Hamas war, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, which is part of the Hamas-run government and staffed by medical professionals. Its count doesn't distinguish between militants and civilians, but the ministry says that more than half of the dead are women and children. The U.N. and other international organizations see it as the most reliable source of data on casualties. Here is the latest: Overnight strikes kill at least 21 One Israeli strike hit a house Tuesday in the northwestern side of Gaza City, killing at least 12 people, according to the Shifa Hospital, which received the casualties. The dead included six children and two women, according to the Health Ministry's casualty list. Another strike hit an apartment in the Tal al-Hawa area in northern Gaza, killing at least six people. Among the dead were three children and two women, including one who was pregnant. Eight others were wounded, the ministry said. A third strike hit a tent in the Naser neighborhood in Gaza City late Tuesday and killed three children, Shifa Hospital said. The Israeli military did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the strikes. It blames Hamas for civilian casualties because the militants operate from populated areas. Human rights groups and charities demand more Gaza aid In the letter issued Wednesday by 109 human rights and charity groups, they warned of a dire situation pushing more people toward starvation. They said they were watching their own colleagues, as well as the Palestinians they serve, 'waste away.' The letter slammed Israel for what it said were restrictions on aid into the war-ravaged territory. It lamented 'massacres' at food distribution points, which have seen chaos and violence in recent weeks as desperation has risen. 'The government of Israel's restrictions, delays, and fragmentation under its total siege have created chaos, starvation, and death,' the letter said. The letter called for aid to be scaled up as well as for a ceasefire. ` Israel says that it has allowed the entry of thousands of trucks since May and blames aid groups for not consistently delivering goods.

More than 100 aid agencies say 'mass starvation' spreading across Gaza
More than 100 aid agencies say 'mass starvation' spreading across Gaza

BBC News

time4 hours ago

  • BBC News

More than 100 aid agencies say 'mass starvation' spreading across Gaza

Update: Date: 08:15 BST Title: Gazans collapsing in the street from hunger, UN agency reports Content: A 14-year-old Palestinian boy, who medics say is malnourished, pictured on a bed at Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza on Tuesday The UN's humanitarian agency Ocha released a new update on Tuesday, warning of "the rapid collapse of the last lifelines keeping people alive". Citing local health officials, it says: Update: Date: 07:58 BST Title: Malnutrition starkly on the rise, WHO official tells BBC Content: A World Health Organization (WHO) official has told the BBC of seeing children in Gaza who look younger than their age because of malnutrition. Speaking to our colleagues on the Today programme, WHO representative for the West Bank and Gaza Dr Rik Peeperkorn says malnutrition is "starkly on the rise" in Gaza. "In 2025 only, we talk about nearly 30,000 children who are malnourished," he explains. Dr Peeperkorn visits Gaza frequently, and describes how on his latest trip, his team "saw a child in a malnutrition ward... a child that looks like they're two when actually they're five". "The lack of basic food supplies is affecting everyone," he adds. "It's even affecting our colleagues in Gaza, a kind of lethargy all over." Update: Date: 07:36 BST Title: 33 dead from malnutrition in 48 hours, Hamas-run ministry said on Tuesday Content: A GHF aid point near the Nuseirat refugee camp in the central Gaza Strip, photographed in June As conditions deteriorate in Gaza, the Hamas-run health ministry is now dividing its death toll into categories. Yesterday, it said that 33 people, including 12 children, had died from malnutrition the past 48 hours, bringing the total to 101, including 80 children overall. It also said 1,026 people have been killed by Israel's military while seeking food aid since the US- and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) distribution system began on 27 May. A slightly higher figure, 1,054, figure was used by the UN on Tuesday. According to the UN, about 87.8% of Gaza is now covered by Israeli evacuation orders or is within Israeli militarised zones, leaving the 2.1 million population squeezed into about 46 sq km (18 sq miles) of land. In total, the Hamas-run health ministry reports at least 59,029 people have been killed in Gaza since 7 October 2023, when the Israeli military launched a campaign in response to the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 were taken hostage. Update: Date: 07:19 BST Title: Israel says 950 trucks' worth of aid waiting for distribution in Gaza Content: A still from a video shared by IDF spokesman Nadav Shoshani, which he says shows aid inside Gaza Despite criticism from humanitarian organisations, Israel says crucial supplies are waiting in Gaza, ready to be delivered to Palestinians. Israel Defense Forces (IDF) spokesperson Nadav Shoshani shared a video of "950 trucks worth of aid", which he says are "for international organizations to pick up and distribute to Gazan civilians". "This is after Israel facilitated the aid entry into Gaza," he adds. The aid agencies do not dispute there is undistributed aid inside Gaza. In their statement, they say "tons" of aid and critical supplies are waiting "just outside Gaza, in warehouses – and even within Gaza itself". But, these organisations claim that they have been "blocked from accessing or delivering them" by Israeli government restrictions. Israel, though, says the system - run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) since May - prevents supplies being stolen by Hamas. On Tuesday evening, Israeli Army Radio quoted Cogat as saying Hamas was "conducting a false campaign regarding the humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip, as a pressure tool within the negotiations". Update: Date: 07:11 BST Title: 'Those we serve are wasting away' Content: As we just reported, more than 100 international aid organisations and human rights groups are warning of mass starvation in Gaza - while pressing for governments to take action. The letter says aid distributions in Gaza "average just 28 trucks a day"; the UN has previously suggested that a minimum of 600 lorries a day are required to feed the population of two million people. "As mass starvation spreads across Gaza, our colleagues and those we serve are wasting away," the groups say, before calling for a ceasefire, as well as the opening of crossings and a full flow of food through a "UN-led mechanism". The groups say access has been "denied" to "tons" of crucial supplies, and accuse Israel of false promises around plans to scale up aid "when there is no real change on the ground". Yesterday, the Israeli military body responsible for co-ordinating aid deliveries, Cogat, insisted that Israel acts in accordance with international law. It said it facilitates the entry of aid, while ensuring it does not reach Hamas. Update: Date: 07:06 BST Title: More than 100 aid agencies say mass starvation spreading across Gaza Content: Jacqueline HowardLive editor More than 100 aid agencies, including Save the Children and Médecins Sans Frontières, have released a joint statement "sounding the alarm" over what they say is "mass starvation" across Gaza. "Palestinians are trapped in a cycle of hope and heartbreak, waiting for assistance and ceasefires, only to wake up to worsening conditions," the statement says. Israel has acknowledged a significant drop in supplies reaching Gazans. But its officials say the food is there - and instead point to the aid agencies for not getting it to the people. For their part, the aid agencies have long reported issues in co-ordinating safe passage with Israel to distribute aid. Over recent days, the Hamas-run health ministry has reported dozens of recent deaths from malnutrition, while the agencies say hundreds have been killed while seeking aid in the past two months. We'll have all the latest news and reaction on this page, so stay with us.

How Gaza's aid crisis broke Hamas and starved the Strip
How Gaza's aid crisis broke Hamas and starved the Strip

Telegraph

time16 hours ago

  • Telegraph

How Gaza's aid crisis broke Hamas and starved the Strip

When Israel launched its controversial US-backed aid plan for Gaza, it aimed to stop Hamas's alleged profiteering from the seizure and sale of humanitarian supplies. The aid delivery plan overseen by the controversial Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) has proved a blood-soaked catastrophe. The Gazan health authorities report that hundreds of people have been killed by gunfire as they queue for food at the GHF aid points controlled by Israeli troops and American contractors. It has also caused Hamas's worst financial crisis in decades, Israeli officials report. The terror group has been unable to pay its fighters or repair its network of tunnels and hideouts beneath the Strip. Cash shortages have also left Hamas reportedly unable to pay salaries for police or ministry employees. Money reserves amassed before, or during the early stages of, the war have run short, while Israeli strikes have devastated the leadership and fractured its grip on the besieged territory. Hamas for years received large sums from Iran, Qatar and others, and was also able to tax cross-border commerce. Israel has long alleged that Hamas also made money by seizing and selling international aid entering Gaza, though this has been denied by the United Nations and aid agencies. That income ended, officials say, when Israel imposed a blockade in March, and then began using the GHF, set up jointly by the US and Israel, to run aid hubs and bypass UN-run distributions. The UN, the European Commission and major international aid organisations have said they have no evidence that Hamas has systematically stolen their aid. The Israeli government has not provided proof. Twenty-eight countries including Britain, this week condemned the new aid arrangements, amid widespread reports of starvation, and hundreds of people being shot as they tried to get food. The countries' joint statement described as 'horrifying' the recent deaths of over 800 Palestinians who were seeking aid, according to the figures released by Gaza's Health Ministry, which is run by Hamas, and the UN human rights office. 'The Israeli government's aid delivery model is dangerous, fuels instability and deprives Gazans of human dignity,' the countries said. 'The Israeli government's denial of essential humanitarian assistance to the civilian population is unacceptable.' Palestinian health officials have said at least 101 people have died of hunger during the conflict, most of them in recent weeks. Food that does arrive in the coastal Strip is often sold and resold at extortionate prices, said Rabiha Abdel Aziz, a 75-year-old mother of nine living in a displacement camp in western Gaza. 'I don't know how people can eat,' she told The Telegraph, explaining that the family can no longer even afford a kilo of flour, which currently costs £26. She said: 'My grandchildren wake up in the morning and ask me for a piece of bread that we don't will we get the money to buy food at this price? We are dying of hunger and bombing.' 'People collapse in the streets' Salem Jehad, a father of four who is living in a camp west of Gaza city, said he was unable to find milk for his newborn son. He said: 'All my children have lost half their weight, and I am the same. Most people don't have money. 'Two years without work during the war, with the crossings closed and aid entering scarcely, people are collapsing in the streets from weakness and hunger. We drink water with salt to satisfy our hunger.' Mr Jehad said access to food had dramatically worsened since GHF took over the distribution and he wanted a return to the previous UN-run model. The UN said on Tuesday that Israeli forces had killed more than 1,000 Palestinians trying to get food aid in Gaza since the GHF began operations in May. Aid distributions have been marred by chaotic scenes and frequent reports of Israeli forces firing on people waiting to collect rations. Israel's military has disputed previous death tolls, but has said its troops have at times fired warning shots, and it is investigating accusations of civilian deaths. Mr Jehad said: 'Now we are running into death traps. Gazans are dying to bring a kilo of flour and rice. Hamas's mistake over 'strategy of suffering' Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, who leads the Realign for Palestine lobby group, said that Hamas had counted on the humanitarian crisis to bring the war to an end. He told the Post: 'Hamas's strategy relied on the suffering of Gazans. 'But when this strategy failed, it foolishly doubled down on this approach, in large part because it had nothing else in its toolbox to deal with Israel's ferocious reaction to Oct 7 and the world's inability to stop it.' Lior Akerman, the head of national resilience at the Institute for Policy and Strategy (IPS) at Reichman University, and a former chief of staff in Shin Bet, Israel's MI5, said Hamas had 'almost completely disintegrated in the Gaza Strip'. He said: 'All the senior commanders were killed and all the frameworks of the fighting disintegrated. 'Today, in the absence of commanders, Hamas members in the Gaza Strip are operating like independent, armed militias. 'In every area, the terrorists continue to do the best they can with the weapons they possess, and they are effectively waging a guerrilla war against the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). 'This type of fighting could last for years and wear down the IDF in a never-ending war.' Truce negotiations held up Israel and Hamas are holding indirect talks in Doha aimed at reaching a 60-day truce and a hostage release deal. But there has been no sign of a deal yet, and discussions have reportedly been held up by Hamas's negotiators in Doha being unable to reach representatives in Gaza since late last week. Ronen Solomon, an Israeli intelligence analyst, said as Hamas had been degraded in Gaza, the group's centre of gravity had shifted to abroad. He said that with only Izz ad-Din al-Haddad, commander of the Gaza City Brigade, remaining as a senior figure in Gaza, 'a dramatic change has occurred'. 'The centre of gravity shifted from the Strip to Hamas abroad,' he said. 'And in particular to Khalil al-Khayya, who was very much involved in the planning of Oct 7 and continues to lead an extremist line from the Hamas base in Qatar.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store