Off-duty Toronto cop avoids jail time for teen's assault in ‘Kijiji deal gone bad'
An off-duty Toronto police officer guilty of assaulting a teenager during a 'Kijiji deal gone bad' has been handed a suspended sentence and 12 months probation.
Const. Calvin Au was also given a three-year weapons ban by Superior Court Justice Jennifer Woollcombe inside a Brampton, Ont., courtroom Wednesday.
'I am very concerned that despite his police training, Au demonstrated the unwillingness to assess the situation and then used excessive force,' Woollcombe said in part.
'In a situation where there were many other better options, his judgement was extremely poor.'
Au was found guilty of assault, but not guilty of assault causing bodily harm, in November for the April 26, 2021, incident involving 19-year-old Chadd Facey.
That day, off-duty Toronto police Const. Gurmakh Benning agreed to meet Facey to purchase an Apple Watch after he had posted on Kijiji to sell it.
Story continues below advertisement
2:08
Assault trial for Toronto cop begins
During the trial, court heard Benning had asked Au, his partner, to accompany him, given he viewed Au as more tech savvy and wanted him to authenticate the watch. Facey negotiated a price of $400 with Benning.
Dressed in plain clothes, the two met Facey in the parking lot at Beryl Ford Public School on Ironshield Drive, near Cottrelle Boulevard and Highway 50, in Brampton for the transaction.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
Benning had purchased the watch before realizing it was counterfeit. Facey took off and following a five-minute foot pursuit with Au, Benning caught up to him and got his money back.
At the trial, Benning testified that Au took Facey down, without saying anything, because he thought Au didn't know that he had already got his money back.
Au testified, in his own defence, that he didn't know Benning had got his money back and took down Facey because he was going to arrest him. However, he did not identify himself as an officer or say he was arresting Facey. Woollcombe said she found that problematic when she delivered her ruling.
Story continues below advertisement
Woollcombe said in her ruling she found Au used force that was 'excessive and unreasonable.'
'The force Au used was out of proportion with the objective of getting the money back,' Woollcombe said.
2:01
An off-duty Toronto Police officer has been charged with manslaughter.
Au was originally charged with manslaughter, but the charge was later downgraded to assault causing bodily harm. At the beginning of the trial, an agreed statement of facts was entered that said 'the Crown is not in a position to allege that Facey's death was caused by the interaction with Au.'
Benning had called 911 and told the dispatcher about the 'Kijiji deal gone bad' before the off-duty officers took off. Facey had called his friends who had earlier dropped him off at the location where the transaction took place after the rip-off. The friends testified they arrived on scene after the assault and picked him up.
Story continues below advertisement
A few hours later, Facey's friends noticed a bump on his forehead. He later died in hospital because of an intracerebral hemorrhage.
Woollcombe found that the forensic evidence was not clear on how Facey got a bruise on his forehead and said the Crown failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Au was guilty of assault causing bodily harm.
Crown prosecutors were asking Au to serve four months in custody, followed by 12 months' probation, as well as a five-year weapons ban and DNA order. Au's defence was asking for a conditional discharge and said a DNA order was not necessary
Woollcombe said Wednesday Au needed to be sentenced for the assault he was convicted of, and not for causing Facey's death.
'The sentence must not seek to punish him for Facey's death or the effect it's had on his family,' Woollcombe said.
'I'm mindful that any conviction will put Au's career in jeopardy. I do not think it is necessary to impose … a sentence that will inevitably result in his dismissal.'
Woollcombe ruled Au should have no communication with Facey's family, take anger management counselling as directed by his probation officer and be subject to a DNA order.
Should he remain employed by the Toronto Police Service, he should take remedial training and 50 hours of community service focused on improving relations between police and the Black community, Woollcombe ruled.
Story continues below advertisement
'While the incident has caused a loss of public confidence with police within the Black community, no evidence it was motivated because Facey was black; race was irrelevant to them,' Woollcombe wrote.
Au has been suspended with pay since the charges were laid, and is still facing charges under provincial legislation governing policing.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
14 minutes ago
- Global News
Nova Scotia woman who killed daughter granted day passes from prison, but not parole
A Nova Scotia woman who murdered her 12-year-old daughter in 2008 has been granted unescorted day passes from prison for 60 days. But the Parole Board of Canada has denied Penny Boudreau's request for day parole, saying she wasn't ready to live in a community even though she would be required to return to a supervised setting at night. Boudreau was sentenced to 20 years in prison for the Jan. 27, 2008, death of Karissa Boudreau, after pleading guilty to second-degree murder for strangling her only child. Earlier today, the parole board decided Boudreau's unescorted single-day passes from prison will be supervised in a way that ensures the safety of the community she chooses, while contributing to her reintegration into society. 7:58 Former RCMP Sergeant Writes Book On One of Nova Scotia's Most Infamous Murders During a hearing at the Nova Institution for Women in Truro, N.S., the board heard Boudreau had completed correctional programs and had worked with a mental health team while working as an assistant to the prison's chaplain. Story continues below advertisement But the panel also heard Boudreau admit that, on a scale from 1 to 10, she considered herself a 6 or a 7 when it came to assessing the progress she had made in prison. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'That means there's still work to be done,' a board member told the hearing 'The board thinks you're very conscious of the work that needs to be done on relationships, managing emotions and dealing with obstacles that can be highly stressful. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 18, 2025.
Global News
32 minutes ago
- Global News
Rural Alberta man says he was shot at, run over by thieves targeting neighbour's property
An Alberta man recently sustained a broken leg after he says he was shot at and run over by a pickup truck while checking on his neighbour's property. He says he also fears rural crime in the province is getting worse. 'They don't seem to have any fear,' Mike Stuber told Global News while speaking about the people he encountered in central Alberta just after 9 a.m. on Friday. Stuber said suspicious activity was seen at his neighbour's property near Barrhead, Alta., and he went to check it out as she feared a theft was taking place while she was away. He said he drove up the driveway and saw several people. He then got out of his pickup truck and started to take photos of the suspects with his phone when they spotted him. 'They took a shot at me with a rifle with a scope on it,' Stuber alleged, adding that he then tried to get back to his truck to leave. 'They were in the vehicle, took off and ran over me.' Story continues below advertisement He said the suspects hit his truck as they fled the scene and that his leg was broken in five places. After being taken to an area hospital, he was airlifted to Grande Prairie for further treatment. Stuber said while he realizes police are doing their job in his area, he believes violent criminals need to face steeper consequences from the justice system and that they sometimes 'get out with a slap on the wrist and they're back out in the community doing it again.' Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Cpl. Mathew Howell, a spokesperson for the Alberta RCMP, said that the suspects have yet to be identified by police but that a search was conducted by officers from various area detachments and the suspect vehicle was found. He said officers were called Friday morning about three or four suspects believed to be trying to break into a vehicle on the property Stuber went to check on, but the suspects were already gone when they arrived. 'Initial reports say that a shot was fired,' Howell said. 'We're uncertain where the shot was fired towards or in what manner. We do know that the suspects got into that Ford F-350.' Howell suggested what happened to the victim during daylights hours took him aback somewhat. 'When I got the initial reports, it was shocking to see,' he said. Story continues below advertisement Mike Stuber's son, Trevor Stuber, told Global News he was driving to a rural property at the time the incident unfolded and saw a police vehicle speed past him. Around the same time, he said he missed a call from his mother. When he pulled over, he called her back. 'She said my dad was run over. … She was kind of distraught.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "She said my dad was run over. … She was kind of distraught." Trevor Stuber said like his father, he has concerns about what he believes is an escalation in crime in rural areas. 'All the neighbours here have young kids,' he said. 'And these people are willing to do this to an elderly man.' He added that while he believes 'the cops do their job,' he worries that criminal offenders will not be sufficiently punished to deter them from doing it again. 'It's been such a quiet place for years,' Trevor Stuber said. '(What happened to my father) gives me chills.' 'The frustration is understandable,' Howell said of the Stubers' concerns. He said that police hope once investigators finish inspecting the suspect vehicle, they may have evidence that points to a suspect or suspects. Howell said maintaining unobstructed lines of sight on rural properties is one way property owners can mitigate the chance of thieves targeting them, or to help them see it if a crime is happening. He also said speaking with neighbours and telling them when you leave the property is a good idea, as is installing cameras on a property if possible. Story continues below advertisement According to Howell, the RCMP encourages rural Albertans to report all potentially criminal incidents, even if they are minor, as it can help police identify when a crime trend is occurring in a particular area. 'It creates a crime stat so we know something is going on,' he said. –with files from Global News' Morgan Black
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Wiretap investigation uncovers deadly tow truck turf war in Ontario
A major wiretap investigation has blown open a violent criminal network allegedly operating inside the Greater Toronto Area's towing industry. Toronto police allege the criminal networks are behind a wave of shootings, arsons and violent crimes aimed at seizing control of the multi-million-dollar towing business. Police said an investigation, dubbed Project Yankee, led to the arrest of 20 people and 111 charges, including 52 counts of conspiracy to commit murder. According to police, the suspects were members of a self-made group known as 'The Union,' described as a tightly-organized criminal ring of tow truck operators vying for dominance in the industry. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'The group was believed to be responsible for numerous acts of violence intended to gain control over the towing industry,' said Chief Supt. Joseph Matthews on Wednesday. Story continues below advertisement In a video released by police, a suspect is seen throwing a Molotov cocktail at a property in Toronto in March, in an apparent attempt to terrorize a business rival. 'This was a form of intimidation directed at the victim, who is part of the tow truck industry,' Matthews said. Police said the months-long wiretap operation helped disrupt multiple murder plots and stop planned attacks before they were carried out. 'Various initiatives, task forces and investigations have led to dozens of arrests, hundreds of charges and many crime guns seized, all tow truck industry-related,' said Chief Myron Demkiw Wednesday. Police executed 14 search warrants and seized multiple weapons, including two firearms. Among the items confiscated were three bulletproof Cadillacs, believed to have been used by members of the group. In 2024, 63 shooting and firearm discharge incidents were linked to tow truck-related disputes, accounting for almost 13 per cent of all shootings and firearm discharges in Toronto. So far in 2025, these incidents have continued to occur, currently accounting for approximately 15 per cent of the total. Due to a publication ban, police cannot release further details about the accused or specifics involving the connection between each tow truck-related incident. Story continues below advertisement The investigation remains ongoing.
