Dining across the divide: ‘I see the welfare state as bloated, corrupt'
Voting record Usually Conservative. Intends to vote Reform next time
Amuse bouche Philip ate the first-ever Viennetta. Fresh out of university, he worked at Unilever, and they placed him with Wall's ice-cream. It was one of the happiest days of his life; he loves ice-cream
Occupation Wine buyer
Voting record Always Labour, but would vote Green if they stood a chance in his constituency
Amuse bouche Doug is writing a book about the neuropsychology of taste – all the intangibles, from ambient noise to memory, that affect the way we perceive flavour
Doug He seemed very friendly – I felt relieved. I'm not an argumentative type, and I felt that if we were going to disagree about things, we'd do it in a nice way and we'd be able to draw back from it.
Philip He's a reasonable guy, like me. He likes to meet new people, and chat, and get a different perspective on life. I think we really hit it off.
Doug I had fontina and sliced-potato pizza. Philip had an egg on his, and I thought, 'I know, I'll have an egg on mine. Why not? Live dangerously.' But that was a silly idea.
Philip We had some starters, and I had a 'nduja pizza; I never know how to pronounce that.
Doug People who are disabled, or have mental health problems or long-term illnesses, need to claim disability benefits – there aren't a lot of people taking the piss here. There should be more help. Benefits are so complicated, and cost so much to administer – there must be a better way.
Philip I was quite shocked when I discovered working tax credit. If a business can't afford to pay people what they need to live on, they shouldn't be in business. How on earth did we get to a stage where we pay people who go to work? He cited social arguments, which were reasonable – I came back with a counterargument, because he runs a business: 'Do you pay your people enough that they don't have to claim benefits?' He said, 'Yeah, of course.' And I said, 'What about your competitors who don't? Aren't they getting an unfair advantage?'
Doug The current government and the last government have tried to demonise claimants, but the problem is with employers. It must be more progressive to reduce business costs and ensure that workers are better paid. When people can't afford to live, they need to be able to top up. The minimum wage isn't really a living wage.
Philip I see the welfare state as bloated, corrupt. Even Rachel Reeves is starting to agree with me now. The state can't keep paying people to stay at home, and to go to work.
Sign up to Inside Saturday
The only way to get a look behind the scenes of the Saturday magazine. Sign up to get the inside story from our top writers as well as all the must-read articles and columns, delivered to your inbox every weekend.
after newsletter promotion
Doug Philip thinks that the world has always experienced climate change and there's nothing humans can do about it. He implied that the net-zero targets were a waste of time.
Philip I'm not a denier, just the opposite – I say the climate always changes, it's changing minute by minute, decade by decade. I don't think anyone other than a historian in 500 years' time will be able to say what caused it. There's a degree of hubris, as well. King Canute got laughed at for thinking he could have that effect.
Doug We're at an existential tipping point. We're already the agents of so many catastrophes. He says the world's population is too big – I agree, but I don't see how you get around that. You can't just tell countries to breed less.
Philip I'm a strong recycler: I'm always praising myself when I put the bins out, how little there is in the black bin. You've got to do everything you can – but for every coal-fired power station we shut, the Chinese open 10.
Doug He's against dogs. Not dogs in principle, but in cities, frightening the public, barking, possibly biting. I can understand that if he's had a negative experience with a dog. I love dogs.
Philip A dog larger than a small child should be regulated as a dangerous dog. It should be muzzled.
Doug We left it very nicely; I sent him a bottle of rosé. I'd meet again. There must be other things one could talk about other than politics.
Philip We parted on good terms. He was fun, and his book sounds fun as well.
Additional reporting: Kitty Drake
Doug and Philip ate at Doughnation, London WC2. Want to meet someone from across the divide? Find out how to take part
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
2 hours ago
- Spectator
Jess Phillips: ‘I'm being controlled by aggression and violence'
Jess Phillips begins her interview with Iain Dale at the Edinburgh Fringe with a meandering homage to her hometown, Birmingham, which is still in mourning for Ozzy Osborne. 'Birmingham is like a village. I can link anyone in my family to someone in your family in three steps. Barbara Cartland is from Birmingham. Lawn tennis was invented on the Cartland estate. I grew up around Ozzy Osbourne's first son, Louis. I count them as good friends. My son went to the funeral procession. And Sharon is a lovely, lovely woman.' Phillips makes a promise to her host. She offers to recruit Sharon as part of his All Talk line-up at next year's festival. 'We could do a double header,' she says. Phillips seems to prefer the company of her family and her old social circle to her political allies. After entering parliament, she told her best friend, Amy, that she'd appeared on Question Time. 'Did you win?' said Amy who assumed that Question Time was Mastermind. Phillips jokes about her popularity. 'In Birmingham, I am quite beloved. I'm like Birmingham royalty. But it's a very low bar, isn't it?' Then they get down to politics. Dale asks about Phillips's resignation from the shadow front bench in November 2023 over a motion tabled by the SNP calling for a ceasefire in Gaza. She couldn't support the motion without returning to the back benches which she found agonising. 'I had to stake my life's work on it.' But she faced loud calls from her constituents to support the ceasefire. 'The clamour got considerably strong. And the pressure.' Dale asked her to specify. 'Pressure? What do you mean?' She chooses her words carefully and doesn't mention that her constituency is 45 per cent Muslim (according to the 2021 census.) 'I've always known it mattered greatly to my constituents. Some are of Kashmiri heritage. And there are Irish communities and I'm Irish myself. And both communities understand the idea of annexation. They understand that lines drawn on a map can lead to violence. … The pressure was in no way aggressive,' she adds, 'in no way aggressive.' A moment later, she qualifies this and admits to 'a smattering of aggression.' She explains that passions are likely to run high when controversial issues are aired. She praises the Labour whips who helped her to manage her departure. 'I didn't peacock about it.' And she was rewarded with a return to the front bench when Labour won power last July. Keir Starmer expressed his support for her in public. 'He made a bee-line towards me across a very busy room and gave me a cuddle.' She needed that cuddle. The battle for her seat in 2024 was mired in controversy. 'I've never known a breakdown of democracy like it.' She says that her opponent, 'the independent candidate,' brought in external canvassers. 'From London,' she believes. 'We couldn't advertise where we were going. They were haranguing voters. There were fireworks thrown, tyres slashed and constituents threatened at polling stations. And I have to say they were almost exclusively men.' She told her sons, aged 16 and 20, to keep away from the count. 'I thought, I'm being controlled by aggression and violence.' She won by 693 votes but her opponent asked for a recount. The returning officer refused. 'She was incredibly professional,' says Phillips. 'And absolutely tiny. About five-foot nothing. And she was encircled by men, shouting at her. It made me fucking furious.' After the count, Phillips exchanged a handshake with each of her defeated opponents. 'The independent candidate refused to shake my hand. Petty little idiot.' Jonathan Ashworth had a similar experience in Leicester South where he narrowly lost to the independent, Shockat Adam. Phillips now regrets her decision not to publicise her opponent's tactics for fear of tarnishing the image of her constituency. 'Lots of journalists came and I kept them away. I didn't want the people who live there to look bad.' Dale moves to lighter matters and asks about her experience with civil servants. 'You have to be careful what you say [inside the department.] If you say 'tag all men' someone will draft a paper about it.' On her first day, she was asked if she preferred the stairs or the lift. She chose the stairs and a note was duly entered in an official file. 'Minister likes to use the stairs.' Now she can't enter the building without being ushered away from the lift and towards the stairs. 'But I don't like to use the stairs!' Dale suggests that she might be offered a job at the foreign office. 'I don't think so. And diplomacy needs to change,' she says. 'It should be more about doing down the pub together.' He asks her if she's met Nigel Farage. She hasn't but she praises the Reform member, Nora Kamberi, who stood against her last year. 'Lovely woman.' Encouraged by Dale, she goes off on a tangent about Boris Johnson. 'He's nothing like he is on TV. Nothing like that. He's nervous and awkward, like a shy boy. He wasn't unpleasant or anything but he was like a kid. Kicking his feet.' Phillips briefly stood for the Labour leadership in 2020. Does she still dream of forming her own administration? 'It's a hard job, being prime minister. I wouldn't boss it. I absolutely wouldn't boss it. I think I'd be a basket-case after about 15 minutes. And I'd drink a lot. But it would be entertaining.' Dale asks her to name her favourite Tory MP. 'Simon Hoare,' she says, 'and Priti Patel.' The second name elicits a gasp of horror from the Edinburgh crowd. Phillips explains that Patel was deeply affected by the assassination of David Amess who represented an Essex constituency close to her own. After Amess's death, Patel telephoned Phillips every Sunday evening 'to see if I was all right.' Patel was home secretary at the time. This gesture meant a lot to a safeguarding minister who believes her job should not exist. 'I hate that there's someone with the words 'violence against women and girls' in their title.' Dale ends with the 'Angela Rayner question.' It's a challenge rather than a query. Earlier in the day, Dale tried it with Rachel Reeves by innocently asking her to name the most outstanding member of the Labour cabinet. Reeves stayed loyal to Starmer and nominated the colourless environment secretary, Simon Reed. Dale frames the question differently and asks Phillips if Labour has a successor to Barbara Castle. Phillips spots the trap and steps over it deftly. 'We've had numerous successors,' she says. 'Margaret Beckett, Margaret Hodge, Harriet Harman and Yvette Cooper.'
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Reeves acknowledges voter disappointment amid fresh call for wealth tax
Chancellor Rachel Reeves says that Labour must deliver change to earn victory in the next election, acknowledging that some voters are disappointed with the party's progress. She said she is also 'impatient for change' but stressed that ministers cannot implement everything at once, highlighting her responsibility for financial prudence. These remarks coincide with growing public concern over Sir Keir Starmer 's government, whose approval rating recently reached an all-time low. Ms Reeves defended the government's tax policy, saying it has found the right balance despite the challenge of addressing public finance deficits. The discussion follows former Labour shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds' call for a wealth tax, as recent polling indicates a significant perception of chaos within Sir Keir's administration.
Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Labour minister Chris Bryant says he was sexually abused by theatre boss as a teen
Labour minister Sir Chris Bryant broke down in tears as he described being left feeling like a '16-year-old whore' by Michael Croft, the founder of the National Youth Theatre Sir Chris Bryant has said he was sexually abused as a teenager by the founder of the National Youth Theatre. The Labour minister broke down in tears in an interview as he described being left feeling like a "16-year-old whore" by Michael Croft, the head of the prestigious drama group. He told the Sunday Times that Mr Croft, who died in 1986, invited him to dinner every night when he was attending the company in London in the summer of 1978, aged 16. Sir Chris claimed one night he went back to Mr Croft's house, and came back from the toilet to find his host, who was 40 years his senior, naked except for a silk robe. The MP said Mr Croft then asked him for sex, which he felt he had no option but to go through with. Speaking ahead of the release of his book 'A Life And A Half: The Unexpected Making Of A Politician', Sir Chris said: "I don't like telling this very much because I've not told it very often. "It was always the same Italian in King's Cross. He would eat and drink, I would eat, then he would theoretically give me a lift home, except I always ended up at his house." Sir Chris says Mr Croft never made an advance towards him again, with the pair remaining friends. An ordained minister, he agreed to conduct Mr Croft's funeral. But he said he was angry over the abuse of power - and had internalised the shame. "He behaved absolutely appallingly, it's despicable," Sir Chris said. "Michael, in my case, managed to spot somebody who was gay at a time when nearly all homosexuality was illegal - certainly very frowned on - so presumed that people would keep a secret." He said at least one friend during his National Youth Theatre days was also abused by Mr Croft. The 63-year-old also said he has been sexually assaulted by five male MPs during his time in Westminster, although he has not named or reported them. "There was no system for doing so and I was frightened it would make me look bad," he said. He said he felt homophobia in Parliament has declined during his 24 years as an MP. A statement on the National Youth Theatre website said: "We are grateful to Chris Bryant for disclosing to our team the historical abuse he suffered in the company in the 1970s. We are very sorry that this happened to him and to others who have previously shared with us their accounts of historic abuse by the same perpetrator. "As we set out in a public statement on the case in 2017, we stand in solidarity with all victims of abuse and encourage anyone who has experienced abuse, no matter how long ago, to speak to someone and access support. "In this case the perpetrator has been deceased since 1986, but all reports made to us will be dealt with in accordance with our robust and formalised safeguarding policy and practice. "While Chris writes he doesn't feel damaged by what happened, we recognise that being subjected to an abuse of power can have lasting consequences for many, in different ways. "Anyone getting in touch will be listened to and treated with care and respect by trained professionals, in line with our certified trauma-informed practice. "We are grateful to Chris for his support of our organisation today, and acknowledgement of how different a charity we are in 2025 to the one he encountered in the 1970s, with thorough safeguarding practices and policies in place."
