Survivors of male violence rallying at Dáil to call for ban on counselling notes in trials
A BILL WHICH seeks to completely ban the use of a complainant's private counselling notes in sexual offences trials will be debated in the Dáil tonight.
Ahead of the debate, therapists and victims of male violence, including campaigner Natasha O'Brien, will stage a demonstration outside Leinster House this afternoon at 3pm in support of the legislation.
The bill has been brought forward by TD Ruth Coppinger.
At the outset of her re-election last year, the Dublin West TD flagged that this would be
one of her priorities for the Dáil term.
Coppinger and campaigners outside the Dáil in April 2025.
Rollingnews.ie
Rollingnews.ie
In the last Government, then-Justice Minister Helen McEntee pledged to outlaw the practice completely, while current Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan has approved plans to significantly restrict their use.
As the law currently stands, a pre-trial disclosure hearing is supposed to take place ahead of a trial to decide if an alleged victim's counselling notes are relevant.
O'Callaghan said this provision in the law has 'not operated as intended'. Last month, he received Government sign-off to amend the law to require that an automatic disclosure hearing take place in all cases and remove the provision that allows for this step to be waived.
Coppinger, however, wants the Government to go even further and ban the use of counselling notes in trials related to certain offences outright.
This move has been supported by a number of counsellors and victims of male violence.
Speaking at a press conference on the issue earlier this year, a number of women spoke of the
trauma attached to having their private counselling notes read out in court.
Advertisement
Sarah Grace, a campaigner who was raped by a stranger who broke into her bedroom in 2019, described how navigating the justice system after the assault was 'the most traumatising and painful ordeal' she has ever had to experience.
'Including the sexual assault itself. And I understand the weight of those words,' she said at the time.
Grace said the 'most cruel blow came not at the hands of the man who violated my body', but at the hands of the justice system.
'A system that allowed the notes of my weekly therapy session, in what I believe to be the sanctity and privacy of a therapy room, to be read by the man who caused the very devastation that I was trying to rebuild myself from,' she said.
Another woman, Paula Doyle, who was raped in a park by her friend's husband, spoke out about how her experience of the Irish justice system in the aftermath of the assault was 'inhumane'.
'At times up to the trial, I even felt I was the one on trial,' Doyle said, referring to the use of her counselling notes.
Doyle described this as a 'personal intrusion' and a 'second violation'.
'My private counselling notes were requested by the DPP five months before our initial trial date. I don't have to go into it, you know what rape is. He took my body that night. He left it like a piece of rubbish in the hedges.
'How perverse is it now that he has taken time and he can read my notes, what I poured into my therapy sessions, my heart and my soul?
'I'm really still not able to put this completely into words, it just felt like such a second violation, but on a much, much deeper level.
'And it's done to this day under the supervision of the Department of Justice…where is the justice in that?,' Doyle asked during the press conference.
The debate in the Dáil is scheduled to take place tonight at 7.20 pm.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
4 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
New Annie McCarrick body find hopes with cadaver dog helping murder probe dig & suspect known to her quizzed over alibis
A DIG for the body of US woman Annie McCarrick is due to begin today — 32 years after she vanished, The Irish Sun can reveal. Advertisement 5 Annie McCarrick went missing on March 26, 1993 Credit: An Garda Siochana/PA Wire 5 A man in his 60s has been arrested as part of the investigation into his murder 5 Gardai have searched a house in Clondalkin in connection the probe but stressed the current occupants are not involved Credit: Padraig O'Reilly We have learned that the suspect — who was known to Annie — is being quizzed over more than five separate alibis which the It is understood the suspect denies any involvement in While he was being brought into custody yesterday, a digger, a skip, and power tools along with dozens of cops arrived at a home in Clondalkin in southwest The property has undergone extensive renovations over the years. Advertisement Read more on Annie McCarrick However, gardai stressed its current occupiers 'are not connected in any way' to the case. Officers are probing if Annie visited the house. The search there is expected to last a number of days involving both technical and forensic examinations. Senior sources say a cadaver dog, understood to be the Advertisement Most read in The Irish Sun American Annie was Despite Gardai 'committed to uncovering the truth' of Annie McCarrick's murder and disappearance After the case was upgraded to Both have assisted with inquiries over the years, with one of them interviewed abroad in recent times. Advertisement The second man was the suspect lifted between 7am and 8am yesterday morning when detectives from Irishtown Garda Station landed at his home, which is outside Dublin. Gardai conducted what sources say was a 'cursory search' of the property, but it was not invasive. 'DISCREPANCIES IN ACCOUNTS' The suspect, aged in his early 60s, is a married man. A source told The Irish Sun: 'Gardai are focusing on inconsistencies and discrepancies in the accounts previously given to them by this man." Advertisement The source revealed they are probing whether false alibis may have been created at the time. They added: 'There is fresh information in terms of what they are focusing on regarding what cropped up during the reviews of the case and developments with speaking to others too. "This man would have been known to Annie at the time of POTENTIAL ASSAULT PROBE The man can be questioned for 24 hours, excluding breaks for up to eight hours sleep, and will have to be released or charged today. Advertisement Gardai are also probing allegations the suspect The major arrest and search op is being led by an investigation team from the DMR South Central Division, Serious Crime Unit based at Irishtown Garda Station under the direction of a senior investigating officer. It also has the assistance of the Serious Crime Review Team, aka the Cold Case unit, along with the Garda National Bureau of Criminal Investigation. RESTRICTED AIRSPACE A temporary restricted airspace has been put in place by the Irish Aviation Authority over the search, banning drones from flying overhead. Advertisement Born on March 21, 1967, Annie was 26 years old at the time of her disappearance. Originally from 'There is fresh information in terms of what they are focusing on regarding what cropped up during the reviews of the case and developments with speaking to others too." An Irish Sun source As a teenager, Annie visited Ireland on a school trip and fell in love with the country and way of life. When she returned back to the US, she told her parents of her intention to return here to live. Advertisement She did and in the 1980s, she completed her third level studies at St Patrick's College, Drumcondra and at St Patrick's College, Maynooth before returning to New York in 1991. There she hit the books once more at Stoney Brook University, New York. DAY OF HER DISAPPERANCE She moved back to Dublin permanently on January 4, 1993, and settled into rental accommodation at St Catherine's Court, Sandymount, Dublin 4. On Friday, March 26 of that year, almost four months later, Annie spoke to her two other flatmates before they both headed off home for the weekend. Advertisement She made arrangements with other friends inviting them to her apartment for dinner the following day. But when they turned up that evening, she was not there. REPORT MADE On Sunday, March 28, her friends began to worry as they discovered she had not turned up to work all weekend. That evening, her pals discovered her groceries — that had been purchased by Annie on the Friday morning in Quinnsworth on Sandymount Road — had been left unpacked in shopping bags in her home. Advertisement A receipt confirmed the date and time of purchase as 26/03/1993 at 11.02am, and this is the last confirmed activity of Annie. She was reported missing by a friend at Irishtown Garda Station on the evening of Sunday, March 28, 1993. 'SHE WAS VERY RELIABLE' Tragically, Annie's mother Nancy had been due to meet up with her doting daughter on March 30 that year, just four days after the disappearance. Nancy travelled over but her intended holiday turned into a nightmare. Advertisement Speaking in 2023, Nancy, who is in her 80s now, said: 'She was funny. Yes, she was very reliable. "She was conscientious. She wasn't fearful. She couldn't find fault with Ireland. 'It makes a huge difference to hear her case has been upgraded to a murder investigation. 'A GRAVE TO VISIT' You never know, it might prompt someone to come forward after all these years. Advertisement 'As for justice or retribution, I have no interest in it at all. "My fondest wish would just be to find out what happened to her. To be able to have a grave to visit.' Gardai said that they will continue to keep the family of Annie fully updated in relation to the investigation and have been fully apprised of the developments. INFORMATION APPEAL A spokesman said: 'An Garda Siochana appeals to anyone with information, no matter how small or insignificant that they might believe it to be, to contact the investigation team. Advertisement 'Any information will be welcomed by the investigation team, and will be treated in the strictest confidence. The investigation team can be contacted at Irishtown Garda Station on 01 666 9600 or anyone who wishes to provide information confidentially should contact the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111.' 5 After searches at the property in Clondalkin dogs are set to be brought in on fresh searches Credit: Garrett White - Commissioned by The Sun Dublin 5 Annie's family are being kept updated on the probe progress Credit: Garrett White - Commissioned by The Sun Dublin Advertisement
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
The numbers say we need private rental investment to address housing crisis
Some of our most challenging social and economic problems arise from the success of the economy . For example, if the recovery from the 2008 financial crisis had been much slower, there would have been fewer jobs to attract back emigrants, or skilled employees from round the world. The huge rise in employment since 2013, and the related rise in the population – up 8 per cent between 2016 and 2022 – has filled the government's tax coffers and raised living standards for all. However, it has put severe pressure on the housing market . We have yet to find a solution that will deliver the major increase in housing stock needed for a successful economy. Almost a decade ago, the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) highlighted a need, at the time, to build 30,000 houses a year. We have averaged just two-thirds of that over the intervening period. READ MORE However, the ESRI also pointed to a funding gap. Unlike the madness of the 2000s, households are now constrained to borrow in a prudential fashion, limiting how many people could become homeowners. That has meant a substantial financial gap – one that, if 30,000 houses were to be built, could only be met by Government investment or by private investment in rental property. Last March's ESRI Quarterly Economic Commentary returned to the theme. Now, with the continuing success of the economy, there is a need to build at least 50,000 houses a year but it's likely that those who can afford to buy their own home will account for just a little more than half of these. The Government has also to fund a major increase in water and transport infrastructure to allow the expansion of the housing stock. [ Housebuilding in Dublin to stall within three years if wastewater plant not delivered Opens in new window ] Thus, without a massive increase in taxation, a prudent government can only finance, directly or indirectly, a minority of the required new builds. As a result, the private rental sector will be essential to fund a large chunk of the required new homes. Without willing institutional investors, we will have no prospect of solving the housing crisis. As noted yesterday by the Central Bank governor, this is not happening. The introduction of rent controls a decade ago has made it increasingly difficult to attract commercial investment. Potential returns on investment in Ireland have been lowered by rent caps, by uncertainty around planning, by building costs, and by politicised rent controls. Those who could fund the extra homes can choose to invest in other countries instead. The experience worldwide with rent controls is that they are good for existing tenants but that, over time, the supply of new apartments dries up as they cannot be financed, given the impact of rent controls on investor returns. The impact is exacerbated when population, and thus demand, is growing strongly. More than a century ago, as a wartime measure, Ireland introduced rent controls on unfurnished accommodation. My wife grew up in a rent-controlled house that her parents had moved into in 1941. However, over time, new supply of unfurnished rental accommodation vanished, and only furnished tenancies – outside the rent control system – became available. [ Explainer on rent changes: How will tenants be impacted by the plans for Ireland's rental market? Opens in new window ] Particularly as inflation took off in the 1970s, real rents in the controlled sector plummeted. This rent control was found unconstitutional in 1981. The latest proposals from the Government don't deal effectively with the challenge of encouraging private investment in homes to rent. Without private capital, there will continue to be a funding gap relative to the need, and ambition, for new homes. That means the housing crisis, caused by the gap between high demand and low supply, will continue. If we want to build 50,000 or more homes a year, rent for new lets should be unrestricted. For those currently protected, it would be traumatic to revert immediately to market rents so that a continuation of some restrictions on rents for existing protected tenants is warranted. Initially, if rent controls were ended for new builds, there would be little effect on protected tenants. However, rents on new builds could rise more rapidly than consumer prices. What would put a lid on ever-increasing rents would be the resulting supply response. If investors were convinced that by building lots of apartments they would get their money back, supply would, over time, increase to meet the needs of the economy, choking off any surge in rents. From the 1930s to the 1950s, in much more difficult economic circumstances, Ireland built tens of thousands of social homes, and ended the tenement scourge. Today's housing challenges are different, but we should have the know-how and the imagination to tackle this most urgent of social problems.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Quango Cull': Almost as many State agencies now as in aftermath of financial crash
The total number of State agencies has almost returned to the peak it reached before a so-called 'quango cull' was announced following the 2008 financial crash, information released by Government departments shows. A 'quango' is typically defined as an organisation to which Government departments have devolved some degree of responsibility, and which are, in most cases, funded by the State. Certain agencies, such as AirNav Ireland, Coimisiún na Meán, and the Home Building Finance Agency are self-financing and do not receive funding from the State. When in opposition in the run-up to the 2011 general election, Fine Gael promised a 'quango cull' and a 'burning of the quangos', believing there to be far too many in the State. There were almost 300 such agencies by the time tough austerity measures were announced in 2010. READ MORE A subsequent 2016 review by Dr Richard Boyle for the Institute of Public Administration (IPA) found a net total of 37 agencies had been abolished in the interim. Although 62 had been shut down in total, 25 new agencies were established over the five-year period. [ Vow to scrap quangos unashamedly populist Opens in new window ] Of the 62 abolished, just 10 ceased to exist entirely. The other 52 were either merged with another organisation or combined to create new bodies. However, newly released information shows at least 33 new quangos will have been created between the end of 2015 and the end of 2025. At least four more – including AirNav Ireland, which provides air traffic management – have directly replaced another agency. In replies to parliamentary questions submitted by Fianna Fáil TD John McGuinness , 14 of the 15 Government departments disclosed new quangos established since 2015 (the Department of Health was not in a position to provide the information requested). The information supplied showed a total of 33 have been created, or planned, across the 15 departments, in addition to four that have been renamed or had their role expanded (including Coimisiún na Meán , the broadcasting and online media regulator, and AirNav Ireland). The Department of Justice has established the largest number of new agencies with 10 quangos introduced since 2015. They include Cuan (set up in 2024), the agency that deals with domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. Other new agencies established under the Justice umbrella include the Independent Examiner of Security Legislation, which reviews the effectiveness of related laws; the Office for Community Safety; the Judicial Council; the Legal Services Regulatory Authority; and the Gambling Regulatory Authority of Ireland. While the department could not provide information, several large agencies have been established in the health sector. They include Children's Health Ireland (CHI) and the Decision Support Service. Two more – a pandemic and emerging threats agency, and the Assisted Human Reproduction Regulatory Authority – are proposed by the end of 2025. Other significant agencies created in the past decade include An Coimisiún Toghcháin, the Maritime Area Regulatory Authority and Home Building Finance Ireland. Despite its early objection to 'quangos', Fine Gael's post-2011 coalition with Labour saw a more modest reduction, with an estimated 13 per cent of agencies abolished during that government's term in office. Details of more recent agencies were furnished in replies to a series of parliamentary questions tabled by Mr McGuinness who noted that during his time chairing the Public Accounts Committee, it had been difficult to establish how many there were. 'Many of these quangos are getting enormous amounts of money and because they are one step removed from the department, there is not a direct route to audit their finances by the Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG),' he said. 'The so-called burning of the quangos never happened. It's hard to see how many of them are adhering to good practices in terms of governance, as they are not subject to the same scrutiny as Government departments. 'We need legislative change to make the C&AG responsible for all those agencies,' he said.
