RFK Jr. pushes a misguided ‘do your own research' line as he unveils MAHA report
Donald Trump and his White House team unveiled 'The MAHA Report: Making Our Children Healthy Again' to some fanfare on Thursday afternoon, and as The New York Times noted, 'The document echoes talking points Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has championed for decades.'
With this in mind, few were surprised when the White House report started crumbling under scrutiny. The Washington Post reported, 'Some of the report's suggestions ... stretched the limits of science, medical experts said. Several sections of the report offer misleading representations of findings in scientific papers.'
But also of interest was what RFK Jr. had to say shortly after the document reached the public. NBC News reported:
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who released a long-awaited report on the causes of chronic disease in children, said in an interview with CNN tonight that people should be skeptical of 'any medical advice' and that 'they need to do their own research.'
This, alas, is not uncommon advice from the secretary of health and human services. In fact, about a month ago, Kennedy sat down with Phil McGraw, the television personality known as 'Dr. Phil,' and the Cabinet secretary told the host that he advises parents of newborns to 'do your own research' before vaccinating their infants.
At a superficial level, this might even seem compelling to some people, at least at first blush. People do research online all the time, looking up movie reviews or the best place to buy a toaster, so what's wrong with people taking advantage of available resources when making decisions on matters related to science and health care?
In case the answer to this question isn't obvious, The Washington Post's Monica Hesse wrote a compelling column on this a few weeks ago.
It probably goes without saying, but just in case: Researching a vaccine is substantially more complicated than researching a stroller. You research strollers by typing 'best strollers' into Wirecutter and buying whichever one has cupholders. You research a vaccine by getting a PhD in immunology or cellular and molecular biology, acquiring a lab in which you can conduct months or years worth of double-blind clinical trials, publishing your findings in a peer-reviewed academic journal, and then patiently navigating the government and industry regulations that are required to make sure your vaccine is safe and effective.
Quite right. When the United States has a health secretary who talks about public health issues as if they're 'Choose Your Own Adventure' novels, it's a reminder that the country has the wrong health secretary.
I, for example, don't have a background in medicine or scientific research. So I'm not in a position to go online and make competent assessments on matters related to immunology. Instead, I rely on the scientific consensus crafted by knowledgeable and experienced scientific professionals, whose work has been subject to extensive scrutiny by other knowledgeable and experienced scientific professionals.
In other words, I can't do my own research, because I'm not qualified to do that research. People who know what they're talking about can do their own research, at which point the scientific canon takes shape.
RFK Jr. appears to approach these issues with the assumption that the scientific canon is inherently suspect because it's crafted by those who reject his conspiratorial and unscientific perspective. When he advises Americans to 'do their own research,' it's a recommendation rooted in the idea that people should poke around the internet until they find sites that give them information that seems true — or that they want to be true.
But that's not a responsible approach to public health. On the contrary, it's madness.
As my MSNBC colleague Zeeshan Aleem recently explained, 'Laypeople cannot understand more technical information about vaccine ingredients, efficacy reports or safety assessments on their own, since understanding that information requires specialized knowledge and a broader contextual understanding of the diseases they guard against. Instead, people have to rely on expert intermediaries to interpret and explain that information for them.'
That the incumbent U.S. secretary of health and human services doesn't understand this fact should be the source of widespread concern.
This article was originally published on MSNBC.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
27 minutes ago
- CNBC
CNBC Daily Open: Recent gains in markets are likely just short-term optimism
Over the past week, Washington and Beijing have been trading barbs about violating their preliminary trade deal. Aside from that, higher steel and aluminum tariffs announced by U.S. President Donald Trump will kick in Wednesday. Amid all the trade tensions, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development slashed its U.S. and global growth forecast for this year and the next, citing "barriers to trade tighter financial conditions, weaker business and consumer confidence and heightened policy uncertainty." Investors, however, are still pushing up stocks, with Nvidia on Tuesday regaining the crown of most valuable public company. That said, CFRA Research's Sam Stovall thinks that the market is "going to just sort of bob and weave in the meantime until we start to get a clearer understanding, if we get one, of the outlook for earnings, GDP growth, etc." In other words, recent gains in markets aren't likely to be indicative of a longer-term trajectory. Where stocks go will depend on where the U.S. economy lands amid the developments surrounding tariffs. Markets in U.S. and Europe riseU.S. stocks climbed Tuesday, boosted by rises in chip stocks and more-than-expected job openings in April. The S&P 500 gained 0.58%, the Dow Jones Industrial Average advanced 0.51% and the Nasdaq Composite closed 0.81% higher. Europe's Stoxx 600 index edged up 0.09%, reversing losses from earlier in the day. Nvidia is king againNvidia shares added 2.8% Tuesday to close at $141.22, giving it a market capitalization of $3.45 trillion. That move puts the chipmaker ahead of Microsoft's $3.44 trillion cap, which means Nvidia is again the most valuable publicly traded company in the world. The stock has surged more than 23% over the past month as Nvidia's growth has persisted even through export control and tariff concerns. OECD slashes U.S. and global growth rate The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development drastically cut its growth forecast for the U.S. to 1.6% in 2025 from an earlier estimate of 2.2%, according to a Tuesday report. OECD also lowered global economic growth this year to 2.9% from 3.1%. "Substantial increases in barriers to trade" is one factor weighing down growth prospects, the report said. Inflation in the euro zone dips below 2%Euro zone inflation fell to 1.9% in May — below the European Central Bank's 2% target — on sharp declines in services, flash data from statistics agency Eurostat showed Tuesday. Economists polled by Reuters had expected the May reading to come in at 2%, compared to the previous month's 2.2% figure. Core inflation, which excludes energy, food, tobacco and alcohol prices, also eased, falling to 2.3% in May from 2.7% in April. Trump's bill is a 'disgusting abomination': MuskElon Musk in a Tuesday post on X described U.S. President Donald Trump's "big, beautiful bill" as a "disgusting abomination" and subsequently wrote that the bill "will massively increase the already gigantic budget deficit to $2.5 trillion (!!!)" Trump is still pressuring U.S. lawmakers to pass the bill, blasting Rand Paul after he said on CNBC's "Squawk Box" that he is "just not open" to supporting a $5 trillion increase in the debt ceiling. [PRO] Watch out for new stocks in S&PSeveral financial services stocks could be rotated into the S&P 500, according to Bank of America. Stocks added to the index often rise in value because funds that track the benchmark will add it to their portfolios, so investors should pay attention to the moves, which will be announced by the end of the week. Tesla's planned robotaxi launch in tech-friendly Austin has Musk playing catch-up in his hometown Tesla's long-awaited entry into the robotaxi market — expected later this month — will begin in Austin, Texas, which has emerged as a key battleground for self-driving technology. CEO Elon Musk wrote in a post on X last week that the company has been testing Model Y vehicles with no safety drivers on board in the Texas capital for several days. But while the market remains nascent, Tesla already faces a hefty amount of competition. Alphabet's Waymo, Amazon's Zoox, Volkswagen subsidiary ADMT and startup Avride are already present in Austin. "The winners of the space are emerging, and it's just a matter of scaling," said Toby Snuggs, head of sales and partnerships at Avride.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Antisemitism is on the rise. Here's how the West is reacting
President Donald Trump condemned the attack in Boulder, Colorado, on a group advocating for the release of Israeli hostages held by Hamas in Gaza. The police arrested a man who allegedly threw Molotov cocktails and used a makeshift flamethrower on a crowd of 20 people. The suspect, disguised as a gardener, yelled 'free Palestine' during the attack, according to eyewitnesses. He faces hate crime charges in federal court, according to The Associated Press. Twelve people suffered injuries. Trump on Monday said the attack 'will not be tolerated' and blamed former President Joe Biden's border policies for allowing the suspect to come to the U.S. Sources at the Department of Homeland Security and Immigration and Customs Enforcement told Fox News the suspect 'is an Egyptian national who overstayed his visa.' Trump promised that such 'acts of terrorism will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law' before expressing his condolences to the victims and Coloradans. This is one of the latest high-profile incidents of violence to make headlines. Late last month, another suspect chanting 'free Palestine' fatally shot two staff members at the Israeli Embassy in Washington, D.C., as they were leaving an event at the Capital Jewish Museum. The police identified the victims as Yaron Lischinsky, a Christian Israeli man, and Sarah Milgrim, a Jewish American woman, as the Deseret News reported. Antisemitism and political violence are on the rise in the U.S. According to the Anti-Defamation League, more than 9,350 instances of antisemitism were recorded in 2024, a 344% increase over the past five years. The White House is putting up a fight against colleges by directly negotiating for more oversight with prestigious educational institutions like Harvard University. The Federal Task Force to Combat Anti-Semitism led the fight against Harvard and other universities where antisemitic incidents have been reported. Several states are also taking note of a rise in hate crimes against American Jews in the U.S. and proposing legislation to address this troubling trend. In Colorado, Gov. Jared Polis, who is Jewish and represented the state in Congress for a decade, condemned the Boulder attack publicly and through a letter signed by more than two dozen state and local leaders. Here's what other Western states are proposing. A recent bill from the state House, which was passed in the state Senate, would ban educators in Arizona's public schools and colleges from teaching antisemitism. Teachers and university professors can be held liable if they are found to be teaching or promoting antisemitism. Rep. Michael Way, a Republican, introduced the bill to make schools a place of learning, 'not breeding grounds for hatred and discrimination,' he said in February. 'Arizona has zero tolerance for antisemitism, and this bill ensures that our classrooms are free from the toxic ideology that fuels division and hostility,' the press release said. The state's teacher's union wrote a letter to Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs, opposing the bill, which, they argue, 'strips Arizona public school educators of professional liability protections if they face accusations of antisemitism.' The letter added the bill doesn't address 'racism, sexism, anti-LDS bias, Islamophobia, or other forms of bigotry.' HB2867 also does not cover incidents of antisemitism at private schools supported by taxpayer-funded vouchers. The Democratic-led Nevada Legislature passed a bill that defines antisemitism for discrimination investigations. The language in the bill, now on the governor's desk, defines antisemitism as 'a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish Individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.' It uses the widely used definition provided by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance. Jolie Brislin, regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, told the Las Vegas Review-Journal this definition 'does not limit free speech or punish criticism of Israel.' The final vote on the bill came a day after the attack in Boulder. Two Jewish teenagers from Las Vegas — 15-year-old Ethan Cohen and 14-year-old Meyer Delee — helped put a spotlight on the bills that designate Jan. 27 each year as 'International Holocaust Remembrance Day' and define antisemitism for the Nevada Equal Rights Commission. Like other states in the West, members of California's Legislative Jewish Caucus initially pursued a bill to create standards for what's acceptable coursework for the state's ethnic studies classes. They wanted to prevent students from being exposed to dangerous content in classrooms. But the caucus shifted strategies and decided to widen the scope by backing a law that strengthens the processing of discrimination complaints to include educators and board members and install an 'antisemitism coordinator' for the state. 'There have been troubling reports of incidents of antisemitism happening within the very spaces meant to foster inclusion and critical thinking,' state Sen. Akilah Weber Pierson, D-La Mesa, chair of the Legislative Black Caucus, told J-Weekly. Her caucus supports the bill. 'We've heard allegations that some educators and even school board members have made comments that marginalize or exclude Jewish voices.' Activists who support Palestine said the bill censors people who criticize Israel.
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Man caught scaling Mar-A-Lago wall wanted to 'marry' Trump's granddaughter, 'spread the gospel': report
A man detained by the Secret Service early Tuesday morning after attempting to jump the wall at President Donald Trump's Mar-A-Lago resort, reportedly told law enforcement that he wanted to gain entry to "spread the gospel" to Trump and marry his teenage granddaughter. Anthony Thomas Reyes, 23, was arrested by the Palm Beach Police Department early Tuesday morning after attempting to unlawfully enter the president's Florida resort, according to booking records from the Palm Beach Sheriff's Office. The police report detailing the incident reportedly chronicled how Reyes, who was previously arrested over the New Year's holiday after once again trying to illegally enter Mar-a-Lago, told officers he wanted to get into Trump's resort to "spread the gospel" to the president and marry his granddaughter, Kai. Reyes was initially arrested on trespassing charges and given a $1,000 bond, but his bond was subsequently raised to $50,000, according to records from the Palm Beach Sheriff's Office. Federal charges could likely follow. The president was in the nation's capital at the time of the incident. "An adult male was arrested early Tuesday morning by the Palm Beach Police Department for unlawfully entering the Mar-a-Lago Club property in Florida. Shortly after midnight, the individual scaled a perimeter fence and triggered alarms," the U.S. Secret Service told Fox News Digital. "U.S. Secret Service personnel detained him without incident at the scene. Palm Beach Police officers responded to the scene and took the individual into custody, charging him with occupied trespassing." Reyes's Tuesday arrest was not the first time he tried to enter the president's Florida compound, according to the Palm Beach Daily News. Per the arrest report, according to the local outlet, Palm Beach police issued a warning to Reyes for trespassing at Mar-a-Lago on New Year's Eve, when Trump was present at the property.
