Vape bans: Slippery slope for legal governance
The court found that state authorities had overstepped their powers by refusing to renew licences issued under federal law, thereby infringing on the rights of a legally licensed business and violating the Federal Constitution.
This landmark ruling is more than just a win for the gaming industry; it underscores a critical principle: state governments cannot override federal law at will.
Yet just months later, we are seeing the same pattern emerge again, this time with the vape industry.
Kedah has announced it will no longer renew licences for vape-related businesses, with the goal of a complete ban by 2026. Other states such as Pahang, Terengganu and Perlis are following suit.
This trend raises urgent questions about the balance of power in our federal system. What started with gaming licences is now extending to vape.
Tomorrow, will it be food and beverages? Or wellness and lifestyle services?
If states are allowed to selectively shut down federally regulated sectors, Malaysia risks descending into legal fragmentation, where trade and commerce depend more on local politics than national law.
Act 852: A necessary legal anchor
Rather than allowing states to adopt unilateral bans, the federal government must focus on fully enforcing Control of Smoking Products for Public Health Act 2024 (Act 852) across the country.
Act 852 was passed after years of consultation and debate. It represents a balanced and structured approach to regulating smoking and vaping products, protecting youth, ensuring product safety, and reducing public health risks while allowing regulated access to adults.
Its successful enforcement is not just a health issue; it is a legal imperative. If states are allowed to disregard it through political or moralistic motivations, the Act's legitimacy will be compromised.
From a legal standpoint, only a consistent, centralised framework can ensure that public health regulations are enforced uniformly, fairly, and in accordance with constitutional principles.
Legal uncertainty hurts rule of law, public confidence
One of the hallmarks of a sound legal system is predictability. Businesses, consumers, and civil society should be able to rely on a stable set of laws and policies.
When that stability is undermined by states choosing to selectively ban certain industries, it weakens the rule of law and opens the door for selective enforcement, politicisation of trade, and judicial overload from legal disputes.
This also affects the very communities the bans claim to protect. Instead of driving behaviour change, bans often push products into illicit channels, where there is no age restriction, no safety oversight, and no taxation.
This undermines the public health objectives of Act 852 and increases enforcement burdens.
The way forward: Uphold the law, not politicise it
The lesson from the Sports Toto ruling is clear: state governments do not have the authority to override federal laws with blanket bans. Vape should not be the next legal battleground.
The federal government must assert the supremacy of laws passed by Parliament and ensure that public health policies are governed by national interest, not fragmented by state agendas.
Act 852 provides the legal tools to regulate the vape industry effectively. What's needed now is not more bans but better enforcement.
Malaysia must decide whether it wants to be governed by clear laws or discretionary bans. The answer will determine whether our legal system continues to uphold constitutional order or gives way to a patchwork of conflicting state policies.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Borneo Post
35 minutes ago
- Borneo Post
PBB supreme council member sworn in as senator for second term
Ahmad swears in as senate member in Parliament today. – Bernama photo KUALA LUMPUR (July 23): Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) supreme council member Datuk Ahmad Ibrahim was today sworn in as a senator for a second term. He took the oath of office before Dewan Negara president Datuk Awang Bemee Awang Ali Basah. Ahmad was reappointed by the Sarawak State Legislative Assembly for a three-year term, effective today and running until July 22, 2028. Previously, Ahmad, 55, served as a senator from July 22, 2022, until July 21 this year. Meanwhile, Awang Bemee, in his speech, welcomed Ahmad's reappointment and reminded all senators to remain well-informed on current issues, while upholding the principles and responsibilities of the Dewan Negara as the country's highest legislative body. At a press conference after the ceremony, Ahmad said that his reappointment was a mandate to continue defending the rights and privileges of Sarawak, within the framework of the Federal Constitution and the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (MA63). The Kanowit native pledged to carry out the trust placed in him with greater determination, enthusiasm and dedication, supported by fellow members of the Senate. 'Let us continue to move forward, not merely as a voice of protest, but as a voice of hope – not to divide, but to strengthen unity. 'It is not only about defending Sarawak's place in Malaysia, but also about shaping the future of the nation, with a strong and resolute Sarawakian voice as its backbone,' he said. – Bernama Ahmad Ibrahim Dewan Negara lead PBB Sarawak senator swearing in
Barnama
an hour ago
- Barnama
Ahmad Ibrahim Sworn In As Senator For Second Term
KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 (Bernama) -- Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) supreme council member Datuk Ahmad Ibrahim was today sworn in as a senator for a second term. He took the oath of office before Dewan Negara president Datuk Awang Bemee Awang Ali Basah. Ahmad was reappointed by the Sarawak State Legislative Assembly for a three-year term, effective today and running until July 22, 2028. Previously, Ahmad, 55, served as a senator from July 22, 2022, until July 21 this year. Meanwhile, Awang Bemee, in his speech, welcomed Ahmad's reappointment and reminded all senators to remain well-informed on current issues, while upholding the principles and responsibilities of the Dewan Negara as the country's highest legislative body. At a press conference after the ceremony, Ahmad said that his reappointment was a mandate to continue defending the rights and privileges of Sarawak, within the framework of the Federal Constitution and the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (MA63). The Kanowit native pledged to carry out the trust placed in him with greater determination, enthusiasm and dedication, supported by fellow members of the Senate. 'Let us continue to move forward, not merely as a voice of protest, but as a voice of hope - not to divide, but to strengthen unity. 'It is not only about defending Sarawak's place in Malaysia, but also about shaping the future of the nation, with a strong and resolute Sarawakian voice as its backbone,' he said.
Malaysiakini
an hour ago
- Malaysiakini
National Debt Under Control Amid Reforms, Say Economists
Malaysia's sizable national debt does not pose a threat to the country's long-term prosperity, thanks to its strong economic fundamentals and prudent fiscal management, according to economists. Dr. Goh Lim Thye, senior lecturer at Universiti Malaya's Faculty of Business and Economics, said the national debt — recorded at RM1.22 trillion or 63% of GDP as of April 2024 — needs careful oversight but does not inherently pose a risk. 'In assessing debt sustainability, the focus isn't on the absolute size of debt, but rather on the country's ability to service it without hampering economic growth or triggering instability,' Goh told FMT. He noted that Malaysia maintains a diversified economy, solid fiscal capacity, and consistent access to both local and global capital markets. Moreover, international confidence in the country's financial stability remains high. 'All three major credit rating agencies — S&P, Moody's, and Fitch — reaffirmed Malaysia's investment-grade ratings in 2024,' said Goh, who also serves as deputy dean of development at the faculty. 'These affirmations reflect investor confidence that Malaysia is managing its fiscal position responsibly and advancing key reforms.' IMF Endorses Reform Measures Malaysia's reform efforts have also received praise from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), which welcomed the government's fiscal consolidation agenda and the enactment of the Public Finance and Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA) in its March report. The IMF noted that current policies are aimed at rebuilding fiscal buffers, supporting economic growth, and enhancing social protection, while maintaining macroeconomic and financial stability. The FRA, passed in 2023, is seen as a cornerstone for improving fiscal governance and long-term sustainability. The IMF also highlighted that Malaysia's economic conditions provide a strategic opportunity to advance structural reforms. Under the Madani Economy framework, the government has laid out policy objectives focused on income growth, digitalisation, climate change mitigation, and good governance. Reforms Strengthening Fiscal Outlook MIDF Amanah Investment Bank's head of research, Imran Yusof, echoed the positive sentiment, stating that the government's fiscal and structural reforms are creating a stronger foundation to manage debt effectively. 'We believe the government is moving in the right direction — aiming for higher surpluses and reduced deficits,' he said. The unity government's consolidation measures are already showing results. The fiscal deficit narrowed from 5% of GDP in 2023 to 4.1% in 2024, outperforming its 4.3% target. The 2025 deficit is projected to decline further to 3.8%. Malaysia has also reduced new borrowings — RM75 billion in 2024, down from RM93 billion in 2023 and RM100 billion in 2022. Imran said the focus should be on the debt-to-GDP ratio rather than the total debt amount. Since the deficit stems primarily from development spending, which is considered long-term investment, it can be justified if GDP continues to grow. 'As long as Malaysia maintains a balanced operating budget and nominal GDP keeps rising, the national debt remains manageable,' he said. A Legacy of Crisis and Mismanagement Goh emphasised that the current debt level is largely inherited and not a result of the current administration's policies. 'The elevated debt stems from legacy issues and extraordinary crisis-related spending,' he explained, pointing to massive outlays during the Covid-19 pandemic and the long shadow of the 1MDB scandal. Between 2020 and 2022, the Perikatan Nasional-led government rolled out over RM530 billion in stimulus measures, including over RM100 billion in direct fiscal injections. While these moves helped preserve jobs and prevent economic collapse, they significantly increased public debt. The 1MDB scandal also saddled the government with long-term obligations and dented investor trust, said Goh. 'While some of these liabilities have been addressed, the broader fiscal impact and opportunity costs remain,' he said. 'The challenge now is to rebuild resilience — and encouragingly, the government appears to be taking solid steps in that direction.' Source: FMT The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini. Interested in having your press releases, exclusive interviews, or branded content articles on Malaysiakini? For more information, contact [email protected] or [email protected]
