Payments from drug firms to health professionals widespread, review finds
It recommends that the Health Service Executive should highlight that it does not support pharmaceutical industry payments to HSE healthcare professionals, accepting that such payments may influence behaviour in a negative way in terms of prescribing medicines.
Data analysis for 2023 for the study shows that drug companies in Ireland made 4,509 payments to healthcare professionals and healthcare organisations, amounting to over €14.4m that year.
The highest individual payment during the year by a drug company was €50,462 to a medical practitioner.
There were 3,508 payments to healthcare professionals, amounting to €5.5m and 64 payments that exceeded €8,000.
The review was conducted by Professor Michael Barry, Clinical Director of the National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics, which conducts assessments on the cost effectiveness of medicines for the HSE to consider, when making decisions on whether medicines should be made available for the public system.
Prof Barry has advised the HSE that it should demand a 100% disclosure rate for all healthcare professionals and healthcare organisations in receipt of payments from the pharmaceutical industry.
In his review of the 2023 payments, Prof Barry says that drug companies fund many healthcare settings, like hospitals and universities, where education and professional development take place. The industry also funds some medical societies.
Prof Barry said the concern is not only are some societies involved in the education, research and development of prescribers, but some may also be involved in generating treatment guidelines.
The payments by companies are publicly disclosed in accordance with the Irish Pharmaceutical Healthcare Association (IPHA) code of practice since 2016.
The details on the public website www.transferofvalue.ie come from up to 50 companies, including non-IPHA members.
The payments, officially called Transfer of Value, are made for research and development, donations and sponsorship (including medical education), consultancy fees, registration fees for health staff and travel costs to attend events.
The company that made the greatest number of payments to healthcare professionals was Novartis, with 374 such payments.
Abbvie paid the most to healthcare professionals, amounting to €880,952.
Prof Barry said that many would consider that the pharmaceutical industry should not have any role in the education of healthcare professionals and prescribers.
He said that the medical literature has highlighted that doctors with ties to industry may be more inclined than their colleagues to prescribe a brand name drug, despite the availability of a cheaper generic version.
Pharmaceutical industry 'committed to integrity and transparency'
The Irish Pharmaceutical Healthcare Association (IPHA) said that under the latest data for 2024, a record level of 98% of healthcare professionals had provided named transparency on the payments received.
It said that since 2016, companies have disclosed the financial payments, whether direct, or indirect, in cash or in kind, made to healthcare professionals and healthcare organisations.
It also said that the latest data for 2024, just published, shows that payments to healthcare professionals came to €5.6m, a 4% decrease on the 2023 figure.
It added that €178,169 was paid to 74 unnamed healthcare professionals last year, according to the data.
The IPHA said the total amount paid to healthcare organisations last year was also down 3%, at over €8.6m, compared to the previous year.
All healthcare organisations in receipt of the payments were disclosed individually last year, which the association said meant 100% transparency.
The IPHA said that while its members are required to disclose the payments, currently, of the 51 companies who publish their data through the platform, 11 are non-IPHA members and 40 are IPHA members.
The association said it is committed to integrity and transparency in all these interactions and the aim is to reach 100% named disclosure for healthcare professionals and it will support member companies in using legitimate interest, as a legal basis for making these disclosures under data protection law.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
12 hours ago
- Irish Times
Assessments of children who may have had unnecessary hip surgeries pushed back to next year
Children who may have been subjected to unnecessary hip dysplasia surgery must wait until next year before they are assessed by a team of external experts for a second medical opinion. In May, the HSE published an independent audit on hip surgery thresholds for children with developmental dysplasia of the hip. It examined 147 cases across three hospitals : Temple Street , the National Orthopaedic Hospital Cappagh and Crumlin Hospital . In Temple Street, 60 per cent of surgeries audited did not meet the clinical threshold for surgical intervention, while this was the case for 79 per cent in the Cappagh hospital. Following the report, the HSE announced it was commissioning an independent expert review panel that will work to review patient files to determine the appropriateness of the original decision to operate. READ MORE The HSE said then that the review panel would be set up within six months. However, a spokeswoman for the executive has now said it will be January before the review of individual cases begins. The health service issued an international call for experts, with applications accepted up until last Friday. 'Expressions of interest have been received from a wide range of regions including Ireland, the UK , the USA , Canada , Asia and other parts of Europe,' the spokeswoman said. 'These submissions will be subject to a shortlisting and recruitment process prior to the formal announcement of the panel, which is expected to convene in September.' She said an international expert has been identified and agreed to chair the external panel, and terms are being negotiated. The organisation is designing a 'robust scientific and methodological framework' for the review, which is expected to be agreed between September and December this year. 'It is expected that the review of individual cases will commence in January. This timeline reflects the complexity of the work involved and the need to ensure a rigorous and comprehensive approach,' it added. The HSE, Children's Health Ireland (CHI) and patient advocates held a meeting on the external review panel last Thursday. In a statement following the meeting, Hip Dysplasia Advocacy Group, a newly-established representative organisation, said there must be 'full transparency' between the HSE and the families regarding these reviews. It said 'everyone is left completely in the dark'. 'We strongly suggested they set up a webpage to inform families of updates in a timely manner and we hope to see this implemented swiftly,' the statement said. The advocacy group described the engagement with CHI at the meeting as positive, adding that the paediatric healthcare provider anticipates all follow-up appointments for affected children will be completed by the end of the year.
Irish Independent
21 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Anti-sunscreen ‘lies' sweeping social media are dangerous, dermatologist warns
Influencers on platforms such as TikTok are claiming in posts that chemicals in sunscreen are dangerous. Some viral clips have gone so far as to claim 'the sun does not cause skin cancer'. Reality TV star Sam Faiers from The Only Way Is Essex was criticised when she recently posted that none of her family used sunscreen as she believed it was 'full of toxic ingredients'. Professor Anne Marie Tobin, the HSE's national clinical lead for dermatology, said there is 'absolutely no truth' to the claims and warned that misinformation is particularly dangerous for the Irish population. She said 75pc of Irish people have skin that is at risk of burning on exposure to the sun, 'and never tan or tan only after a long time, so they're at particular risk of skin cancer'. It makes no sense to me. It's anti-science, anti-evidence — it's just untrue The consultant dermatologist at Tallaght University Hospital said there is no evidence to suggest the chemicals in sunscreen are harmful. 'It makes no sense to me. It's anti-science, anti-evidence — it's just untrue. By not using sunscreen, people are increasing their risk of cancer. Apart from the risk of skin cancer, exposure to the sun really damages your collagen, that's incredibly ageing.' Prof Tobin said sunscreen has decades of scientific backing, and added: 'It originated in Western Australia, where they have a very high skin cancer rate. There's good evidence to show that it works. Skin cancer is entirely preventable. Unlike certain cancers, like colon cancer, you can completely avoid it.' She said the rates continue to be 'very high' in Ireland, despite the availability of sunscreen for several decades. One blistering sunburn in childhood or adolescence more than doubles your chances of developing melanoma in later life,' she added.
The Journal
a day ago
- The Journal
Baby girl killed with her parents in Israeli airstrike on Gaza
AN ISRAELI AIRSTRIKE in Gaza killed a baby girl and her parents today, hospital officials and witnesses said, while families of hostages called for a 'nationwide day of stoppage' in Israel to express growing frustration over 22 months of war. The baby's body, wrapped in blue, was placed on those of her parents as Palestinians prayed over them. Motasem al-Batta, his wife and the child were believed to have been killed in their tent in the crowded Muwasi area. 'Two and a half months, what has she done?' neighbour Fathi Shubeir said. 'They are civilians in an area designated safe.' Muwasi is one of the heavily populated areas in Gaza where Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said Israel plans to widen its coming onslaught. The mobilisation of forces is expected to take weeks, and Israel may be using the threat to pressure Hamas into releasing more hostages taken in its October 7 2023 attack that sparked the war. Families of hostages fear the coming offensive further endangers the 50 hostages remaining in Gaza, just 20 of them thought to be alive. They and other Israelis were horrified by the recent release of videos showing emaciated hostages, speaking under duress, pleading for help and food. Advertisement A group representing the families has urged Israelis onto the streets on Sunday. 'Across the country, hundreds of citizen-led initiatives will pause daily life and join the most just and moral struggle: the struggle to bring all 50 hostages home,' it said in a statement. The United Nations is warning that levels of starvation and malnutrition in Gaza are at their highest since the war began. Palestinians are drinking contaminated water as diseases spread, while some Israeli leaders continue to talk openly about the mass relocation of people from Gaza. Another 11 malnutrition-related deaths occurred in Gaza over the past 24 hours, the territory's health ministry said today, with one child among them. That brings malnutrition-related deaths during the war to 251. The UN and partners say getting aid into the territory of more than two million people, and then on to distribution points, remains highly challenging with Israeli restrictions and pressure from crowds of hungry Palestinians. The UN human rights office says at least 1,760 people were killed while seeking aid between May 27 and Wednesday. It says 766 were killed along routes of supply convoys and 994 in the vicinity of 'non-UN militarised sites', a reference to the Israeli-backed and US-supported Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which since May has been the primary distributor of aid in Gaza. Elsewhere, a 20-year-old Palestinian woman described as being in a 'state of severe physical deterioration' has died after being transferred to Italy for treatment, a hospital said today. The patient was admitted to Pisa University Hospital late on Wednesday and died yesterday. She was removed from Gaza as part of a humanitarian mission and arrived with a 'with a very complex, compromised clinical picture', according to the hospital. Related Reads UN says at least 1,760 people have been killed while seeking aid in Gaza since late May She died after entering a respiratory crisis and subsequently going into cardiac arrest, the hospital said in a statement. Hospital staff had performed tests and started supportive therapy before she died, the statement said. The woman, named by Italian media as Marah Abu Zuhri, had arrived in Italy with her mother. Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said almost 120 Gazans – 31 patients and their families – had been flown to Rome, Milan and Pisa on three planes. In a post on X, Tajani said it was the 14th medical evacuation of Palestinians that Italy had conducted since January 2024, and the largest. The hospital did not specify whether the woman had suffered from malnutrition, but said that she had arrived in a 'state of severe physical deterioration.'
