I tested 9 of the best peanut butter brands — and I'm sticking with a classic
What's more nostalgic than a spoonful of peanut butter or a pillowy-soft PB&J sandwich? Nothing! I tested nine of the most popular brands, and quite a few were highly satisfying. The best peanut butter reminded me of the perfect school lunch on a sunny day — with a creamy texture and a salty, slightly sweet taste.
When I mentioned to friends that I would be testing this pantry staple, they were all quick to offer opinions. (It turns out everyone thinks they know the best store-bought peanut butter!) They also had lots of questions: Would I try creamy peanut butter? Crunchy? Organic? Salted? Because there are so many options, I stuck with creamy only (both conventional and organic) from peanut butter brands that are available in supermarkets across the country. I tasted them by the spoonful without jelly or bread to interfere with the flavor and mouthfeel.
As a culinary school grad who has worked in restaurants and written about food and cooking, I can appreciate the difference between old-school creamy peanut butter and the organic, all-natural version. I bought options across the spectrum from most processed to least, and the one that creamed the competition? Well, let's just say the brand is synonymous with peanut butter.
To narrow down the pool, I stuck with smooth peanut butter, ranging from processed to natural. When it came to tasting, I decided the best approach was to be a purist: Just open the jar, breathe in the aroma and dig in with a spoon. No bread, no jelly, no celery sticks.
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: As close to Skippy as you can get, Jif is a strong runner-up. It's creamy and rich, but the flavor isn't quite as craveable. It contains the same hydrogenated vegetable oil as most other conventional/processed peanut butter and has the same thick and spreadable texture you expect. It was yummy!
Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter: This was my first encounter with Peter Pan, but I know the brand has a cult following. Peter Pan has been around since 1920, at first under a different name but then coined "Peter Pan" as a nod to the character and the play. Like the other processed peanut butter, it spreads beautifully and feels lighter, but the intense sweetness was off-puting to me.
Justin's Classic Creamy Peanut Butter: I was so disappointed in Justin's, having tried and enjoyed the brand's almond and cashew butters. This was the worst-tasting natural peanut butter with little flavor to speak of and a hint of bitterness, plus grit. This peanut butter contained peanuts and palm oil.
365 by Whole Foods Market Unsweetened Creamy Peanut Butter: Made from only peanuts and salt, this was the least thick and creamy of the all-natural bunch. It's almost drippy in texture. The flavor was nutty enough and had a good kick of salt, but it's not winning medals.
Good & Gather Organic Peanut Butter: Another organic and all-natural option, Target's house brand spread contains only dry roasted peanuts. When shopping, I didn't realize that this is unsalted, which gave it a real disadvantage. The texture was smoother than others, though.
Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter: This alternate version of the classic Skippy is okay. Like some "natural" peanut butter, it has added palm oil, which keeps the oil and solids from separating and needing to be stirred. For my money, and if I'm going to submit to the sheer heaven that is processed peanut butter, I prefer the original Skippy.
Teddie All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter: This natural option contains only peanuts and salt and is thicker than some of the others. It has an earthy, authentic peanut flavor that would likely make a good addition to dips or sauces.
Now that you know which spread to buy, here's how to take your PB (or PB&J) sandwiches to the next level.
Got some sticky questions? We've got answers!
As far as snacking goes, peanut butter pairs perfectly with crunchy raw veggie sticks (celery, carrots and jicama all work) and sliced apples or banana. It's also delightful on top of rice cakes or as a dip for pretzels.
We recently tested a variety of nut butter to come up with a list of the healthiest nut butter, which included two tasty peanut butter options — Big Spoon Roasters Peanut Crunchy Peanut Butter and One Trick Pony SIlky Smooth Peanut Butter.
Some dogs absolutely love peanut butter as a treat, but dogs don't benefit from the added salt and sugar that humans may enjoy, so choose a peanut butter that's all-natural and unsalted, like Teddie All-Natural Unsalted Smooth Peanut Butter.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Park to honor memory of revered Beckley supporter
Dr. Thomas Warren Jarrett lived a rich, full life. When he passed away on Oct. 22, 2023, Jarrett left behind loving family, friends and colleagues and a community blessed and strengthened by his presence — as well as a litany of professional and personal accomplishments achieved during a successful journey through life. However, for the former Daniels orthodontist and longtime community leader, an impressive resume wasn't nearly as important as his friends and his community, Dr. Mike Kominsky, one of those friends, said Thursday. "He was just the kind of guy that liked to do things under the cover of darkness," said Kominsky, who formed a friendship with Jarrett over the years based on a shared love of the outdoors, as well as gardening. "He didn't look for the accolades or didn't want to be honored for what he did. "He was always instrumental in trying to beautify Beckley; Beckley was his passion." "He was really into family and hometown, and he really wanted to see Beckley make it," Kominsky added. "He was a wealthy man, but his wealth was his friends, really. He always wanted to never lose touch. ... Friendship was everything to him." Pete Torrico II — another Jarrett friend who helped Kominsky and others spearhead the creation of Tom Jarrett Memorial Park on Raleigh County Memorial Airport property in recent months under the auspices of the Beckley Area Foundation and in conjunction with Bob Runion and the airport authority — said the park is a fitting memorial to Jarrett in recognizing the impact he had on the Beckley area. Torrico, a lifelong Beckley resident who had an enduring friendship with Jarrett, said he and Jarrett were simply "just good buddies." According to Torrico, the first phase of the recent Beckley Area Foundation project has included upgrading a gravel lot at the Raleigh County Airport pond with paving, installation of a sturdy, bear-resistant trash can constructed by J & J Fabricating of Beckley, benches, a memorial plaque recognizing Jarrett's life, concrete work and a new handicap-accessible fishing pier. Also included in the effort has been the installation of a waterfall in the center of the pond. The pond is a special regulation area supervised by the WVDNR Wildlife Resources Section. "This is a DNR-supervised pond," said Torrico. "They came in, lowered the lake, cleaned it out and got all the vegetation out." The DNR stocks the pond on a regular basis. Phase 2 will include a shelter, which is in place but awaiting the placement of a metal roof. The site will eventually also include a 4-foot wide walking trail around the lake, said Torrico. The park project was funded by an earmark (matched locally) from the BAF based on $250,000 gifted to the organization from Jarrett's will, which was matched quickly by the public. More money has been raised of late from family and friends for future work, said Carrico. Torrico, who helped Jarrett form the popular Chili Night in Beckley, said the aim is to have the facility designated to be used for children, handicapped people and veterans for fishing. "Everything is handicap-accessible," he said. Torrico stressed that an organization named SAW (Service and Witness), a group of retirees who build handicap ramps for free for people who can't afford them, built the 8-foot by 50-foot fishing pier and the shelter labor-free, with the locals providing the materials. The project "kind of fit all of Tom's passions: fishing, flying, just outdoor conservation," said Kominsky, who added that Jarrett was "kind of just an infectious guy." "We were kind of next-door neighbors," Kominsky added. "Our gardening brought us together. He had a little garden over at Glade Springs and I'd go over every spring and help him start it. He invited me to work with him. That was just our passion, gardening and just enjoying life, and hiking also." In the future, wildflowers and some trees or shrubbery will be added to the project, Kominsky said. The Tom Jarrett Memorial Park will be dedicated on June 27 from 2 to 4 p.m. Dena Cushman, executive director of BAF, said it has been a worthy project for the organization and the community. "It's one of our bigger projects that we've done, and we've been looking for bigger, impactful projects," she said. "Dr. Jarrett was one of our past board members and a friend, so that means a lot to the foundation to be able to do this in his honor. "Also, it does help the people who want to use the park." She also said the project will benefit the airport as it serves as a successful beautification project. Cushman said Jarrett's will provided $250,000 to the foundation with the stipulation that it be matched by the public. In addition to earmarking some of the funds for the memorial park project, the remaining funds are used to leverage more endowments, she explained. Jarrett's children also created a fund in his name at the time of his passing. For more information on the Thomas W. Jarrett Memorial Fund, which was established in memory of Jarrett by his children, or to explore starting a similar fund or leaving a legacy gift on behalf of a family member or friend, contact the BAF at 1210 South Kanawha St., Beckley, WV 25801, call BAF at 304-253-3806 or email info@ A local fisherman, 25-year-old Brendon Mann, of Beckley, was among those fishing on Thursday from the new pier at the park. Mann, who has been wheelchair-bound since 2021, said he appreciates the improvements made to the park, saying it makes fishing easier for him. "I love fishing," said Mann. "This pond has taught me patience. Because coming out fishing, you don't catch one every time. You just have to persevere through it. Come out when you want and when you can, and have a good time doing it and being in nature." • • • In 1977, Jarrett — a 1968 graduate of Greenbrier Military School who pursued his post-secondary education at WVU and St. Louis University — moved to Beckley and opened his orthodontic practice. According to his biographical information, he was an active member of the dental community and the Beckley area. He was a member of the American Dental Association and the WV Dental Association, as well as a member of the American Association of Orthodontics and past president of the WV Association of Orthodontics. Jarrett also served on the boards of the New River Dental Society and the Southern Association of Orthodontics, was a Diplomat of the International College of Dentists and a Diplomat of the American Board of Orthodontics. Besides that, he was on faculty at the WVU School of Dentistry in the orthodontics department for over 30 years. Beyond the academics, he loved his community and wanted to see it flourish, friends recall. He was on the board of directors of Beckley Area Foundation, instrumental in building the YMCA Youth Soccer Complex, founder of Citizen Southern Bank, and developer of Brookshire Professional Park. He was also involved in starting FORWARD WV as an economic development tool. He was an originator of Chili Night, a volunteer for Mac's Toy Fund, involved in the Youth Museum, helped design the Peace Totem, started Foster's Hardware Restaurant, contributed to the F.O.L.K. project and Operation Backpack, as well as being an advocate and supporter of the Raleigh County Humane Society, according to the biographical information. Both Torrico and Kominsky pointed this week to Jarrett's love of the outdoors and being in nature. He was appointed by the governor as a DNR commissioner. He loved to fish, hike, golf and bike. He was a founder of Glade Creek Trout Association, a champion golfer, a youth sport coach and a devoted father.
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Federal judge orders ICE not to remove trans migrant seeking asylum from Washington detention facility
A federal judge in Oregon on Tuesday issued an order barring Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) from removing a Mexican asylum seeker from a Washington detention facility, according to local reports. The migrant, a 24-year-old transgender woman identified as "O-J-M" in court documents, was arrested outside a Portland courtroom on Monday and transferred to the Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma, Washington. U.S. District Court Judge Amy Baggio, a President Joe Biden appointee, also demanded that ICE provide the exact date and time of the removal from Portland and explain why it was deemed immediately necessary. Federal Judge Refuses To Reconsider Order To Facilitate Deportee's Return To Us Baggio's order was prompted after O-J-M's attorneys said they were not aware of their client's location and filed a habeas petition, a legal request asking a court to determine whether a person's detention or imprisonment is lawful. The migrant's attorney, Stephen Manning, of Immigrant Law Group, told Opb that O-J-M was processed into the Tacoma detention center, but he had not been granted access to her since her transfer. Read On The Fox News App Her attorneys said O-J-M was abducted and raped in Mexico because of her gender identity and sexual orientation and was seeking asylum on those grounds. "They threatened to kill her because O-J-M is a transgender woman," her habeas petition states, per OPB. "Fearing for her life, she fled and sought asylum in the United States in September 2023." Us Judge Accuses Trump Admin Of 'Manufacturing Chaos' In South Sudan Deportations, Escalating Feud Oregon sanctuary laws prevent it from having long-term immigration detention facilities, and -- aside from temporary holding cells at the Portland ICE office -- the nearest immigration detention center is the Tacoma facility. OPB reported that O-J-M sought asylum at a port of entry along the California-Mexico border, where she was arrested, detained and released. Since then, O-J-M has attended ICE check-ins and filed her formal asylum claim in February. In April, immigration officials began removal proceedings against O-J-M, the outlet reports, citing the migrant's attorneys. Manning told Willamette Weekly that his client had not committed a crime while in the U.S. During a mandatory court hearing for her asylum case in Portland on Monday, ICE attorneys moved to dismiss O-J-M's case entirely—effectively stripping her of both the case and the legal protections it provided. Afterward, ICE agents apprehended O-J-M. That led to Innovation Law Lab Attorney Jordan Cunnings, who also represents O-J-M, saying the arrest was a "dangerous attempt by ICE to circumvent due process, speed up deportations, and eviscerate the right to asylum." "This unethical behavior goes against the values we hold as Oregonians, ensuring that everyone is welcomed and included in our state," Cunnings said, per Koin. Portland Mayor Keith Wilson said that the city "stands unwavering in its commitment to sanctuary policies," adding that Portland "will not obstruct lawful federal enforcement operations," per Willamette Weekly. Fox News Digital has reached out to ICE and Homeland Security for article source: Federal judge orders ICE not to remove trans migrant seeking asylum from Washington detention facility
Fox News
4 days ago
- Fox News
Federal judge orders ICE not to remove trans migrant seeking asylum from Washington detention facility
A federal judge in Oregon on Tuesday issued an order barring Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) from removing a Mexican asylum seeker from a Washington detention facility, according to local reports. The migrant, a 24-year-old transgender woman identified as "O-J-M" in court documents, was arrested outside a Portland courtroom on Monday and transferred to the Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma, Washington. U.S. District Court Judge Amy Baggio, a President Joe Biden appointee, also demanded that ICE provide the exact date and time of the removal from Portland and explain why it was deemed immediately necessary. Baggio's order was prompted after O-J-M's attorneys said they were not aware of their client's location and filed a habeas petition, a legal request asking a court to determine whether a person's detention or imprisonment is lawful. The migrant's attorney, Stephen Manning, of Immigrant Law Group, told OPB that O-J-M was processed into the Tacoma detention center, but he had not been granted access to her since her transfer. Her attorneys said O-J-M was abducted and raped in Mexico because of her gender identity and sexual orientation and was seeking asylum on those grounds. "They threatened to kill her because O-J-M is a transgender woman," her habeas petition states, per OPB. "Fearing for her life, she fled and sought asylum in the United States in September 2023." Oregon sanctuary laws prevent it from having long-term immigration detention facilities, and -- aside from temporary holding cells at the Portland ICE office -- the nearest immigration detention center is the Tacoma facility. OPB reported that O-J-M sought asylum at a port of entry along the California-Mexico border, where she was arrested, detained and released. Since then, O-J-M has attended ICE check-ins and filed her formal asylum claim in February. In April, immigration officials began removal proceedings against O-J-M, the outlet reports, citing the migrant's attorneys. Manning told Willamette Weekly that his client had not committed a crime while in the U.S. During a mandatory court hearing for her asylum case in Portland on Monday, ICE attorneys moved to dismiss O-J-M's case entirely—effectively stripping her of both the case and the legal protections it provided. Afterward, ICE agents apprehended O-J-M. That led to Innovation Law Lab Attorney Jordan Cunnings, who also represents O-J-M, saying the arrest was a "dangerous attempt by ICE to circumvent due process, speed up deportations, and eviscerate the right to asylum." "This unethical behavior goes against the values we hold as Oregonians, ensuring that everyone is welcomed and included in our state," Cunnings said, per KOIN. Portland Mayor Keith Wilson said that the city "stands unwavering in its commitment to sanctuary policies," adding that Portland "will not obstruct lawful federal enforcement operations," per Willamette Weekly. Fox News Digital has reached out to ICE and Homeland Security for comment.
