Elderly man's ramp request denied despite fall that left him on ground for hours
An elderly man's request for a ramp was rejected because he lives in a park home despite a fall that left him lying on the ground for hours.
James Sneddon, who lives in Glendevon Residential Park, in Perthshire, spent two hours on the ground before his neighbour Greg helped him.
'Sometimes when I go down and lose my balance, I go right down and I can't get back up, Greg comes and picks me up,' the 82-year-old told STV News.
'It's the same when I came back on a Saturday with my messages with my wife.'
Mr Sneddon requested a ramp from the Perth and Kinross Council but has been told under the Housing Act he doesn't qualify for support to adapt his home. STV News James Sneddon, who lives in Glendevon Residential Park, was left lying on the ground for two hours after a recent fall.
Perth and Kinross Council said there was no scope for them to award discretionary grants under current legislation.
'There's a lot of people disabled without a wheelchair – they forget that. This wheelchair is an excuse so they don't need to spend money,' Mr Sneddon said.
Park home residents feel discriminated against as current rules exempt mobile homes and lodges from funding for vital adaptations like ramps and wet rooms.
Lynn Cameron said she can't get access to help because she lives in her mobile home in Marlee Gardens, near Blairgowrie.
'We'd have wider doors for the wheelchair to get through, because some of them are quite narrow and you're barely making it through,' she told STV News.
'We would certainly have had a ramp, no problem.' STV News Lynn Cameron said because she lives in a mobile home she can't get help.
Park homes are a growing part of Scotland's housing stock with more than 8,000 people living in them across the country.
Because of that, there are calls for an increase in the rights and protections for people who make these houses their homes.
The issue has made its way to Holyrood and is forming part of a debate around the housing bill.
Scottish Conservative MSP Murdo Fraser said park home residents are being treated as 'second-class citizens'.
'Compared to people buying a brick and mortar home, park home residents don't have the same protections,' he said.
'There's no doubt that park home residents are being ripped off, we've got numerous examples across Scotland of some unscrupulous site developers who are doing everything they can to extract money from people, many of whom are quite elderly and vulnerable.'
He said beyond the new housing bill there is a lot more work to be done when it comes to protecting park home residents.
In a letter seen by STV News, the housing minister has requested council leaders consider supporting adaptations, where feasible.
The Scottish Government also said local authorities have a duty to ensure the needs of disabled residents are met, whatever their housing circumstances.
Housing minister Paul McLennan said: 'The Scottish Government is committed to making sure that those living in mobile homes on sites licensed for permanent residents have appropriate rights and protections, and I have written to Local Authorities to draw attention to issues raised in a recent members debate.
'As well as housing legislation, all local authorities have a duty under legislation to ensure that the needs of disabled or chronically ill residents, whatever their housing circumstances, are met.
'We plan to undertake a review of the current housing adaptations system, which will make recommendations on how best to improve and streamline the system and better target resources. Issues relating to adaptations to park and mobile homes will also be considered as part of this review.'
Perth and Kinross Council said it understood how 'frustrating' the situation is.
A Perth and Kinross Council spokesperson said: 'We understand how important it is for people to be able live independently in their homes where possible.
'If clients need major work done – such as installing ramps or wet rooms – Occupational Therapy can provide advice on securing charitable funding, if they are unable to access grant funding. They may also be eligible for further financial assistance through social work budgets.
'Private homeowners or tenants who require adaptations to their property can also apply for support through the Care and Repair Scheme which is managed by Caledonia Housing Association and funded by Perth and Kinross Council.
'However, under the terms of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2006 grants can only be awarded to permanent structures so, unfortunately, even when residents have permission to stay in a park home all year round they are not eligible for this funding.
'We appreciate how frustrating this situation is for homeowners but there is no scope for us to award discretionary grants under current legislation.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Drug consumption room leads to abandoned needles complaints
The figures, which go up to May 20, 2025, are thought to be the 'tip of the iceberg' with fears residents may be handling the issue themselves instead of lodging an official report. The number of police call outs within the vicinity of the building can also be revealed. The police data includes Police Scotland's BA18 beat, which includes Hunter Street, Bell Street and parts of Duke Street. Councillor Allan Casey, city convener for addictions, said the facilities was part of the solution - not the problem. The Herald reveals the data days after the Scottish Government confirmed suspected drug deaths had risen by a third between January and March 2025. There were 308 such deaths in the first three months of the year, up 33% during the same time in 2024. Official reports suggested suspected drug deaths in Scotland 'remained at a high level', with cases up by 76 when compared to October and December 2024. Read more: Scotland's first drug consumption room opened in January under a three-year pilot project which allows clients to inject illegally-bought heroin or cocaine under medical supervision. The specific aim of the facility is to reduce overdoses and drug-related harm. Between January and March, 143 people visited The Thistle Centre a total of 1,067 times. Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain confirmed that users would not be prosecuted for possessing illegal substances while at the facility. However, the data obtained by the Scottish Tories also revealed police officers have been called to the surrounding areas of Hunter Street 195 times since the facility opened. Between January and May, officers responded to 95 incidents relating to theft, 23 for public nuisance, 19 for disturbance and 13 for specific drugs or substance misuse. Other incidents included intrusion, noise, abduction and extortion, sexual offences, vehicle crime and assault. Annie Wells, drugs spokeswoman for the Scottish Tories, urged the Scottish Government to call time on the 'reckless' experiment. She said the Scottish Government instead should back the Right to Recovery Bill, introduced to Holyrood by former Scottish Tory leader Douglas Ross, which looks to enshrine the right to treatment for alcohol or drug addiction. She said: 'SNP ministers are completely detached from reality. Their flagship drug consumption room is making life a misery for local residents. Read more: 'They pinned all their hopes on state-sponsored drug taking, but their solution is failing. Drug deaths are still climbing and locals are left to pick up dirty needles just to keep their streets safe. 'The Thistle is piling even more pressure on our already overstretched police officers. 'SNP ministers really don't have a clue what's going on. They think putting needle bins on the streets will fix things, when in reality it will just normalise drug use. 'SNP ministers should call time on this reckless experiment and finally back the game-changing Right to Recovery Bill, which would enshrine in law a right to treatment.' After suspected drug death figures were revealed on Tuesday, the Scottish Government stressed numbers 'fluctuate from quarter to quarter', adding that 'care should be taken not to interpret movements between individual calendar quarters as indicative of any long-term trend'. The data also showed there were 166 – or 14% - fewer drug deaths in the 12 months to March 2025. Councillor Casey told The Herald: 'Annie Wells' remarks are not only detached from reality but dangerously misleading. To suggest that crime and drug use are new problems in this community is a blatant denial of decades of challenges that this community has faced. 'The Thistle facility is not the cause of these issues — it is part of the solution. With 38 overdose reversals already under its belt in just 5 and a half months, the Thistle has undoubtedly saved lives that would have otherwise been lost. Calling for its closure is reckless and shows a complete disregard for the health and wellbeing of vulnerable people and their families. 'Ms Wells was due to visit the Thistle this week as part of her role on the Criminal Justice Committee to hear directly from staff about the vital, life-saving work they are doing — yet she couldn't even be bothered to show up. This absence speaks volumes about her unwillingness to engage with the facts and the people on the ground. 'Ms. Wells owes those whose lives have been saved, their families and the wider community struggling with addiction, a clear explanation of why she wants to shut down a proven, life-saving service. Instead of spouting empty rhetoric, she should support real, evidence-based harm reduction strategies — something SNP ministers have shown the courage to do while critics like her cling to failed, outdated approaches.' The Scottish Government has been asked for comment.
STV News
12 hours ago
- STV News
Recall of Flamingo Land resort plans 'a disaster', say campaigners
Campaigners say the decision to re-examine the proposals for a Flamingo Land resort on Loch Lomond are 'tragic' and a 'disaster'. The future of the major tourist attraction on the banks of the loch is in doubt after the Scottish Government decided to recall the plans. It comes weeks after the Government's planning reporter upheld an appeal from the theme park operator but added 49 conditions to the application. Public finance minister Ivan McKee said on Tuesday that the application raises issues of national significance due to its impact on the national park area. McKee previously said that the Government backed the 'impartial, expert opinion that was based on evidence' which led to planning permission in principle being granted – overturning the Loch Lomond and The Trossachs National Park's decision to reject the proposals. The final outcome will be now be decided by Scottish ministers. John Urquhart, chair of conservation group the Friends of Loch Lomond and the Trossachs, said the U-turn is a 'potentially tragic' and a 'disaster'. 'The development offers so much in terms of economic development, but also in conservation terms', he told STV News. 'Not many people seem to understand that because they've been fed a lot of nonsense by individuals like Ross Greer, who's an expert in manipulating social media. Putting out stories that there's going to be a theme park here. 'It's going to destroy Loch Lomond? Rubbish. It's actually going to bring lots of benefits.' STV News John Urquhart, chair of conservation group the Friends of Loch Lomond and the Trossachs. Under the £43.5m proposals, Lomond Banks would see two hotels, more than 100 lodges, a waterpark and monorail built on the site at Balloch, West Dunbartonshire. However, concerns have been raised by environmental and conservation campaigners who have long opposed the development and say it will lead to the 'irreversible' loss of woodland. The Scottish Greens say more than 50,000 people have used a portal on their website to write to McKee. Scottish Greens MSP Ross Greer said: 'This is the right move by ministers and a huge victory for the fifty thousand people who joined the Scottish Greens' campaign for the decision to be recalled. 'I am glad that Ivan McKee has decided to do the right thing and use his power to intervene to protect Loch Lomond from destruction. 'The evidence of the damage it would do to one of Scotland's most iconic locations is overwhelming. Once ministers consider the flood risk, loss of ancient woodland, hundreds of additional cars which would be brought onto notoriously congested roads and the litany of other devastating impacts it would have, I am sure they will reject the mega-resort application and finally end this decade-long saga. 'People across Scotland expect their Government to protect our natural heritage. 'Given previous mistakes, including the approval of Donald Trump's golf course despite local objections and serious environmental concerns, this is an opportunity for Ministers to show that they have learned and will now put people and planet ahead of greedy developers.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The National
13 hours ago
- The National
Canadian space firm unveils new Edinburgh office
PCI Geomatics, a leading firm in Earth observation, has opened its new office at the Future's Institute in the Scottish capital as it aims to become a key player in Scotland's space industry. PCI Geomatics, operating under the name Catalyst, gathers and analyses information about Earth's physical, chemical, and biological systems using remote sensing technologies and uses the data it collects to provide climate-related information. The Toronto-headquartered firm has more than 40 years of experience and joins more than 180 other companies that are already contributing to Scotland's satellite design and manufacturing industry. READ MORE: Scottish Government 'short-changed by £1bn' by Rachel Reeves, Finance Secretary says Business Minister Richard Lochhead welcomed the news as he said Scotland's space sector has grown at a 'phenomenal pace'. He said 'Scotland is well on the way to becoming a European leader in the space sector. PCI's arrival adds to Edinburgh's considerable reputation as a 'data capital' and takes us closer to our ambition to capture £4 billion of the global space market. 'The number of space-related organisations based in Scotland rose by 25% within a year, with the sector's total income increasing by 65%, demonstrating the phenomenal pace of growth and scale of opportunity before us. 'This is why the Scottish Government appointed its first ever Space Envoy, Daniel Smith, last year who is boosting Scotland's global standing and helping businesses forge strategic partnerships and identify new opportunities.' PCI said its business aligns 'strongly with Scotland's growing reputation' in space-enabled applications which includes more than 30 companies dedicated to observing and protecting Earth from space. The company is now recruiting for multiple roles in Scotland. PCI has also joined the industry body Space Scotland and participated in a recent Scottish Earth Observation showcase at the British Embassy in Denmark. President and CEO of PCI, June McAlarey, said she is excited to see the business expand into Scotland. She said: 'Scotland's rising profile in the global space economy has been unmistakable. When exploring locations to complement our Canadian headquarters, the UK quickly stood out as a strategic gateway to Europe and the Middle East. 'We now have a growing team across the UK and are excited to expand our Scottish office in the coming weeks.' Dr. Craig Brown, investment director at the UK Space Agency, also welcomed the news as he said Earth observation technology is vital to keeping the world safe. He said: 'Scotland's space sector attracts significant levels of private investment and is playing an important role in unlocking the value of space data for the wider economy. 'We welcome the presence of international companies like PCI as a key driver of innovation, expertise and creation. 'This new development supports our commitment to grow the space economy across the whole of the UK and to advance Earth observation technology, which is a vital tool for protecting our planet.'
