logo
China's new AI app DeepSeek is trying to erase our genocide from history, Uyghurs warn

China's new AI app DeepSeek is trying to erase our genocide from history, Uyghurs warn

Independent12-02-2025

DeepSeek has had a meteoric rise in the growing world of AI, becoming a strong competitor to US rival ChatGPT.
But for Xinjiang 's Uyghurs, who are facing an alleged genocide, the rollout of China's newest chatbot was just another way to remove their 12 million people from history.
'The Chinese government is trying to erase the Uyghur people by employing AI to mislead the public,' Rahima Mahmut, who fled China in 2000, told The Independent.
Ms Mahmut, who has not heard from her family for eight years, and learnt her brother was locked up in a mass-internment camp for two of those, had reason for concern.
The 'world-leading AI assistant', as it described itself, was designed to give 'helpful and harmless responses' and has been downloaded over three million times worldwide.
But when asked 'are the Uyghur's facing a genocide', the chatbot asserted the claim was a 'severe slander of China's domestic affairs' and 'completely unfounded'.
'We firmly oppose any country, organisation, or individual using so-called human rights issues to interfere in China's internal affairs,' it said.
For Ms Mahmut, 'so-called human rights issues' meant fleeing her hometown of Ghulia after seeing her neighbours and friends locked up en-masse in 1997.
She was escaping Beijing 's 'strike hard' campaign which saw thousands of arrests, as well as executions, in response to a growing separatist movement across Xinjiang.
Since then, the US, UK, Canada and Netherlands have accused China of committing genocide in the region, where millions of Uyghurs, mostly Muslim, live.
The declarations followed several reports that found evidence of China sterilising women, interning people in camps, and separating children from their families.
In 2018, a UN human rights committee claimed China was holding up to a million people in 'counter-extremism centres' in the northwestern province.
Dr Adrian Zenz, a leading expert in Beijing's Xinjiang policies, said China was doing this to 'eradicate' the Uyghurs as an ethnic group and extinguish their dream of independence.
'They are culturally and religiously very different to the rest of China, they are a Turkic people, not Chinese, which is a problem for Beijing', Dr Zenz told The Independent.
In the 1990s, Uyghurs saw their Turkic neighbours like Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan gain independence from Moscow after the fall of the Soviet Union.
This inspired a wave of nationalism across Xinjiang, and Uyghurs began talking about greater autonomy from Beijing, Dr Zenz said.
'This spooked the Chinese authorities, so they started to crack down on Uyghur society,' he said.
The crackdown initially included shutting down mosques, arresting religious leaders and flooding Xinjiang with migrant Han-Chinese workers.
These policies led to a vicious cycle of violence and today's policies which have seen China accused of genocide, Dr Zenz explained.
China has claimed the campaign – and ongoing crackdown, was needed to prevent terrorism and Islamic fundamentalism.
Indeed, DeepSeek said China was committed to the 'social harmony' and 'sustained development' of Xinjiang.
Zumretary Arkin, 31, has not heard from her family since 2017, and like many Uyghurs, is aware her relatives are frequently detained and interrogated.
So to see DeepSeek re-write her homeland's history was 'deeply worrying' and, like Ms Mahmut, represented a new way for China to erase Uyghur history.
'This sort of technology is replacing Google. It is where people go for research and information. This is deeply worrying,' Ms Arkin told The Independent.
'We have to remember DeepSeek is controlled by the Chinese government, and they are using it as another way to erase the Uyghur people,' she said.
Dr William Matthews, who researches China's technological rise, said Beijing's censorship of DeepSeek should be 'extremely concerning' to us all.
'This app adds to China's ability to spread censorship around the world. It should be concerning to us all as it becomes a popular platform,' he told The Independent.
'It is directly linked to the interests of the Chinese state. There is an inherent danger in something like this.
'These apps are extremely powerful and influential and will become the way we find out information.'
Ms Mahmut, who now spends her time in London making Uyghur music while reflecting on the slow strangulation of her culture, said: 'The assertion that the claim of Uyghur genocide is 'completely unfounded' is not only false.
'It is an insult to the hundreds of thousands of Uyghurs and other Turkic minorities who have been subjected to horrific atrocities.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

South Korea halts loudspeaker broadcasts along border with rival North Korea
South Korea halts loudspeaker broadcasts along border with rival North Korea

The Independent

time14 minutes ago

  • The Independent

South Korea halts loudspeaker broadcasts along border with rival North Korea

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging. At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story. The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it. Your support makes all the difference.

Lords' objections to Data Bill over copyright threatens its existence
Lords' objections to Data Bill over copyright threatens its existence

Wales Online

timean hour ago

  • Wales Online

Lords' objections to Data Bill over copyright threatens its existence

Lords' objections to Data Bill over copyright threatens its existence – minister Sir Chris Bryant said the continued parliamentary ping-pong, where a bill bounces back and forth between the Lords and the Commons could "imperil" the Bill Protesters in central London in May called on the Government to ditch plans to allow AI tech firms to steal their work without payment or permission (Image: PA Wire/PA Images ) The continued refusal by the House of Lords to pass the Data Bill threatens its existence altogether, a minister has said, as the Commons passed an amendment to head off a challenge from peers. Sir Chris Bryant said the continued parliamentary ping-pong, where a bill bounces back and forth between the Lords and the Commons could "imperil" the Bill. ‌ The critical stand-off arose as artists and musicians including Sir Elton John and Sir Paul McCartney, raised concerns over AI companies using copyrighted work without permission. ‌ Baroness Kidron, who directed the second Bridget Jones film, had put forward an amendment aiming to ensure copyright holders could see when their work had been used, which was overwhelmingly passed by the Lords for the second time last week. However this has not won Government backing. In a concession to win around the Lords, the Government has instead said it will give a parliamentary statement six months after the passage of the Bill, where it will update MPs and peers on an economic impact assessment, and a report on the use of copyright works in the development of AI. A parliamentary working group will also be established. Article continues below Technology minister Sir Chris said the amendments showed the Government had "unequivocally heard concerns". However Conservative chairwoman of the Culture, Media and Sport select committee Dame Caroline Dinenage said MPs had been "gaslit". MPs voted in favour of the Government's amendment, which replace the changes put forward by Lady Kidron, by 304 votes to 189, majority 115. ‌ These will now go back to the Lords for peers to approve. During the last session in the Lords, where Lady Kidron had successfully forward her amendment, she told peers it she would not hold up the Bill further if the Commons chose to disagree with it. MPs heard the Bill will help establish digital verification services, a new national underground asset register which could speed up roadworks, and allow better healthcare and policing. ‌ It would also renew UK and EU data protection laws. The current agreement with Brussels will run out in December. Speaking at the start of the Bill, Sir Chris said: "Double insistence would kill the Bill, where ever the Bill has started. I take people at their word when they say that they don't want to kill the Bill." ‌ Sir Chris added: "Its provisions have the support of all parties in both Houses. "Which is why I urge this House to accept our amendments in lieu. "And I urge their Lordships not to insist on their amendment, but to agree with us. ‌ "It is worth pointing out, that if their Lordships do persist, they are not just delaying and imperilling a Bill which all parties agree is an important and necessary piece of legislation. "They are also imperilling something else of much greater significance and importance economically; our data adequacy with the European Union." He said he was "mystified" by Liberal Democrat and Conservative opposition to the Bill. ‌ "These amendments show our commitment to ensuring considered and effective solutions as I have just outlined, and demonstrate that we have unequivocally heard concerns about timing and accountability." Conservative shadow technology minister Dr Ben Spencer said the creative industries and peers "were not buying" the Government's approach. He said: "They're not buying it because the Government has lost the confidence of their stakeholders that it will bring forward legislation to enact effective and proportionate transparency requirements for AI models in the use of their creative content." ‌ Dame Caroline said Sir Chris and the Government were not engaging with the central issue. She said: "By being cloth-eared to the legitimate concerns of the world-leading creative industries for month after month after month; they have been virtually dragged kicking and screaming to this position now, where they bring forward a couple of tiny amendments. "By gaslighting members of all parties at both ends of this building who have attempted to draw attention to this. ‌ "By somehow pitting our world-leading creative industries against AI, almost somehow presenting them as luddites, that they are somehow allergic to innovation and technology when actually these are some of the most groundbreaking and innovative sectors out there; they are using AI every single day to produce world-breaking pieces of creative content." Responding, Sir Chris said: "I would just say to her (Dame Caroline) that she clearly has forgotten that the previous government actually introduced plans which would have brought forward a text and data mining exemption for commercial exploitation of copyrighted materials without any additional protections for creative industries at all. "That seems to have slipped her mind. Article continues below "We have moved a considerable deal since this Bill started. "We have moved and we have listened to what their lordships and, more importantly, what the creative industries have to say in this."

In China, fears grow of an EV financial crisis amid pricing war
In China, fears grow of an EV financial crisis amid pricing war

NBC News

time3 hours ago

  • NBC News

In China, fears grow of an EV financial crisis amid pricing war

At a used car market in Beijing, salesman Ma Hui said he fears China's electric vehicle industry is in a race to the bottom. EV makers, led by the country's market leader BYD, have been engaged in a bruising price war, depressing profits for the brands, as well as sellers such as Ma. 'All of us were losing money last year,' Ma said about his fellow used car sellers in the market. 'There are too many companies making too many new energy cars.' China's trading partners have often accused the country of flooding the global market with cheap Chinese EVs. These days, similar accusations are flying within China, raising concerns about financial stress in the industry. The official Communist Party paper, the People's Daily, for example, published a commentary on Monday, titled 'The 'Price War' in the Automotive Industry Leads Nowhere and Has No Future.' 'Disorderly 'price wars' squeeze profits across the chain, impacting the entire ecosystem and risking income declines for workers,' the paper warned. 'Long-term, this 'race to the bottom' competition is unsustainable.' BYD is drawing the most fire after it announced price cuts in late May for many of its models. Some of the discounts are as steep as 34%. Its cheapest car, the Seagull mini hatchback, now costs only about $7,700, down from about $10,000. The intense price war has led high-profile auto executives to sound the alarm — with the head of Great Wall Motor calling the industry 'unhealthy.' In an interview with Chinese news outlet Sina Finance on May 23, Great Wall Motor Chairman Wei Jianjun drew parallels to China's moribund property sector and its now defunct poster child, developer Evergrande. 'An 'Evergrande-like' crisis already exists in the automotive industry,' he said. 'It just hasn't erupted yet.' A government-backed industry group has also called on companies not to 'dump' vehicles below the cost of production. In a statement, the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers took a veiled swipe at BYD. 'A certain automaker has taken the lead in launching significant price cuts and many companies have followed suit, triggering a new round of 'price war' panic,' the group said. BYD dismissed Wei's comment as alarmist and said it believes in fair competition in response to CAAM's criticism. In a sign of further strain, sellers at the Beijing used car market told CNBC about a phenomenon known as 'zero mileage used cars,' which is meant to help auto manufacturers and dealers inflate sales volumes. This happens when cars are registered and plated and then marked as sold, but haven't ever been driven. Ma said he is worried about where the fierce competition leads. He told CNBC he sees the impact of the intense competition on consumers who are already shy about spending in the down economy. 'With the price dropping like this, a lot of buyers might wait,' he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store