Minister denies migrant returns deal leaves open human rights loophole
Dame Angela Eagle denied the agreement with France would allow for spurious claims to be used to avoid deportation after shadow home secretary Chris Philp questioned the wording of the document.
The 'one-in, one out' deal coming into effect on Wednesday will see migrants ineligible to stay in the UK sent back across the Channel, in exchange for taking those who have links to Britain.
The agreement contains a clause that says in order for people to be returned to France, the UK must confirm they do not have an 'outstanding human rights claim'.
Critics have argued this could risk bogus applications being made to frustrate the deportation process and cause delays.
Mr Philp said on Tuesday this section offered 'an easy loophole for lawyers', adding that 'France will not give us any data on the people they are sending our way… so we have no idea who they really are'.
Borders minister Dame Angela said he was wrong, and that the clause was included 'precisely to ensure no-one can use 'clearly unfounded' human rights claims to avoid being returned'.
She added: 'And we will do full security checks on any applicants, and reject anyone who poses a risk.'
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper conceded earlier that the accord is not a 'silver bullet' to stop small boat crossings, but marked a step change as migrants will be sent back across the Channel for the first time.
Speaking to the BBC, she declined to put a number on how many people would be returned under the agreement ahead of time, saying that she believed it could aid criminal gangs.
She added: 'We will provide regular updates, people will be able to see how many people are being detained, how many people are being returned, and it is right that we should be transparent around that.'
Speaking to reporters earlier, Tory leader Kemi Badenoch said the deal would likely result in only small numbers of migrants being swapped with France and is 'not going to make any difference whatsoever'.
Asked whether the Conservatives were partly to blame for the immigration and asylum situation, she told reporters: 'No I don't accept that at all, because what Labour are doing is just rubber-stamping all of the applications and saying they're processing.'
It has been reported that about 50 a week could be sent to France. This would be a stark contrast to the more than 800 people every week who on average have arrived in the UK via small boats this year.
Bruno Retailleau, France's interior minister, said the agreement 'establishes an experimental mechanism whose goal is clear: to smash the gangs'.
The initial agreement will be in place until June 2026.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Metropolitan Police arrest more than 200 protesters at London demonstration defying Palestine Action ban
The Metropolitan Police have arrested more than 200 protesters in support of Palestine Action — despite the group being proscribed as a terrorist organisation. Organisers Defend Our Juries said up to 700 people, including Left-wing activists and Muslim community leaders, gathered in Westminster on Saturday afternoon in defiance of the ban. It came after the first three people to be charged with supporting Palestine Action in England and Wales were named. Jeremy Shippam, 71, of West Sussex, Judit Murray, also 71, of Surrey, and Fiona Maclean, 53, of Hackney in east London, will appear at Westminster Magistrates' Court on September 16. Today, a crowd sat on the grass inside Parliament Square holding placards which read 'I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action', with the vast majority remaining silent. Several others erected signs that read 'Palestine Action terrorises Britain while Hamas hides in hospitals, schools and mosques'. Prior to the protest on Parliament Square, the group claimed Scotland Yard were preparing for the "largest mass arrest in their history". Lisa Nandy, the Culture Secretary, had urged members of the public to stay away from events supporting proscribed organisations. The Met said a "significant number of people" were seen "displaying placards expressing support for Palestine Action', with a further four detained for assaults on officers. Among those arrested included quakers, a blind wheelchair user and former Guantanamo Bay detainee Moazzam Begg. As the gathering drew to a close at 4pm, police tightened their cordon around the remaining demonstrators, with one elderly man volunteering to be arrested next because of the wait. Onlookers applauded the protesters and shouted 'shame on you' and 'pigs' at officers making arrests. Another march organised by the Palestine Coalition set off from Russell Square via Aldwych and the Strand and assembled on Whitehall. Meanwhile, activists from Greenpeace rebranded bus stops across the capital with posters reading: 'Protesting genocide is not terrorism.' A spokesman for Defend Our Juries said the protest was an "embarrassment" for Yvette Cooper, the Home Secretary, because the police were only able to detain 'a fraction' of those breaking the law. However, the Met denied claims made by the organisers, saying: 'After arrest, they were taken to prisoner processing points in the Westminster area. 'Those whose details could be confirmed were bailed, with conditions not to attend any further protest in support of Palestine Action. 'Those whose details were refused or could not be verified were taken to custody suites across London.' The Met has been forced to draw officers in from neighbouring constabularies to help form a 'significant policing presence' in the city this weekend. On Sunday, there will be a 'National March for the Hostages' in central London organised by the pro-Israeli collective Stop the Hate. This is a major embarrassment to Yvette Cooper Defend Our Juries In July, MPs voted to outlaw Palestine Action, meaning support for the group is now a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison under the Terrorism Act 2000. Palestine Action's website was also been blocked in the UK after a last-minute legal challenge to suspend the group's proscription failed. It comes after two Palestine Action activists broke into RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire and sprayed two military planes with red paint. The Home Office has defended the proscription, saying the move is 'not about Palestine' and does not affect the right to protest on Palestinian rights amid Israel's war against Hamas. A spokesman said: 'It only applies to the specific and narrow organisation whose activities do not reflect or represent the thousands of people across the country who continue to exercise their fundamental rights to protest on different issues. 'The decision to proscribe was based on strong security advice and the unanimous recommendation by the expert cross-government proscription review group. 'This followed serious attacks the group has committed, involving violence, significant injuries and extensive criminal damage.'
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
UK arrests 200 backing banned pro-Palestine group
Police in London arrested at least 200 people Saturday for supporting Palestine Action at the latest and largest protest backing the group since the government banned it last month under anti-terror laws. The UK capital's Metropolitan Police said it expected to make further arrests at the demonstration in Parliament Square, as organisers claimed only a "fraction" of the hundreds who turned out had been detained. "That claim simply isn't true," the Met said in a statement, noting some of those there were onlookers or not visibly supporting Palestine Action. "We are confident that anyone who came to Parliament Square today to hold a placard expressing support for Palestine Action was either arrested or is in the process of being arrested." The government banned the group days after several of its activists broke into an air force base in southern England, causing an estimated £7 million ($9.3 million) of damage to two aircraft. Britain's interior ministry reiterated ahead of Saturday's protests that its members were also suspected of other "serious attacks" that involved "violence, significant injuries and extensive criminal damage". But critics, including the United Nations and NGOs like Amnesty International and Greenpeace, have lambasted the move as legal overreach and a threat to free speech. - 'Unprecedented' - A group called Defend our Juries, which organised Saturday's protests and previous demonstrations against the ban, said "unprecedented numbers" had risked "arrest and possible imprisonment" to "defend this country's ancient liberties". "We will keep going. Our numbers are already growing for the next wave of action in September," it added. Attendees began massing near parliament at lunchtime bearing signs saying "oppose genocide, support Palestine Action" and other slogans, and waving Palestinian flags. Psychotherapist Craig Bell, 39, was among those holding a placard. He branded the ban "absolutely ridiculous". "When you compare Palestine Action with an actual terrorist group who are killing civilians and taking lives, it's just a joke that they're being prescribed a terrorist group," he told AFP. As police moved in on the demonstrators, they applauded those being arrested and shouted "shame on you" at officers. "Let them arrest us all," said Richard Bull, 42, a wheelchair-user in attendance. "This government has gone too far. I have nothing to feel ashamed of." - NGOs opposed - London's Met Police and other UK forces have made scores of similar arrests on previous weekends since the government outlawed Palestine Action on July 5. Anyone expressing support for a proscribed group risks arrest under UK anti-terror laws. Police announced this week that the first three people had been charged in the English and Welsh criminal justice system with supporting Palestine Action following their arrests at a July 5 demo. Being a member or supporting the group is now a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison. Seven people have so far been charged in Scotland, which has a separate legal system. Amnesty International UK Chief Executive Sacha Deshmukh wrote to Met Police chief Mark Rowley this week urging restraint be exercised when policing people holding placards expressing support for Palestine Action. The NGO has argued arrests of such people are in breach of international human rights law. A UK court challenge against the decision to proscribe Palestine Action will be heard later this year. jj/dc
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
More than 200 arrested over Palestine Action support and assaults in London
Police have made 200 arrests of people supporting banned group Palestine Action and four for assaulting officers as protesters gathered in central London. Hundreds attended Saturday's demonstration in Parliament Square, organised by Defend Our Juries. The Metropolitan Police said it would arrest anyone expressing support for Palestine Action. In a statement, Scotland Yard said 200 arrests were made for showing support for a proscribed organisation by 3.40pm 'with more to follow'. There were a further four arrests for assaults on officers. The force said the detained protesters were taken to prisoner processing points in the Westminster area, and those whose details could be confirmed were bailed, with conditions not to attend any further protest in support of Palestine Action. Those whose details were refused, or could not be verified, were taken to custody suites across London, the Met added. The crowd, sat on the grass inside Parliament Square, could be seen writing 'I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action' on white placards at 1pm, with the vast majority remaining silent. Several demonstrators carrying placards that read 'Palestine Action terrorises Britain while Hamas hides in hospitals, schools and mosques', briefly walked along the crowd before being led away by police officers. Other clusters of protesters who were not holding placards gathered around the Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela statues in the square singing pro-Palestinian chants. Officers were holding individual demonstrators sat on the edge of the grass before escorting them through swelling crowds to police vans parked on the edge of the square. A separate group of officers attended a protester lying next to the fenced-off Emmeline Pankhurst statue. They later began arresting protesters sat in the middle of Parliament Square. The officers lifted the protesters – some sitting and some lying flat – off the ground before escorting them away. Onlookers applauded the protesters and shouted 'Shame on you' at the police making arrests. Protesters who were still sat in the middle of Parliament Square stood up together at 2pm and held their placards in the air. One person was also arrested at a separate Palestine Coalition march, which set off from Russell Square heading to Whitehall via Aldwych and the Strand. The arrest was 'for a placard showing support for Palestine Action', Scotland Yard said. Membership of, or support for, Palestine Action is a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison under the Terrorism Act 2000. Earlier this week, the first three people to be charged with supporting Palestine Action in England and Wales were named. Jeremy Shippam, 71, Judit Murray, 71, and Fiona Maclean, 53, have all been charged with displaying an article in a public place, arousing reasonable suspicion that they are a supporter of a proscribed organisation after their attendance at a previous demonstration last month. Hundreds have been arrested in the wave of Defend Our Juries protests across the UK since the ban was implemented by Home Secretary Yvette Cooper last month. A Home Office spokesperson said: 'The Home Secretary has been clear that the proscription of Palestine Action is not about Palestine, nor does it affect the freedom to protest on Palestinian rights. 'It only applies to the specific and narrow organisation whose activities do not reflect or represent the thousands of people across the country who continue to exercise their fundamental rights to protest on different issues. 'Freedom to protest is a cornerstone of our democracy and we protect it fiercely. 'The decision to proscribe was based on strong security advice and the unanimous recommendation by the expert cross-government proscription review group. 'This followed serious attacks the group has committed, involving violence, significant injuries and extensive criminal damage.'
