Spiritans' promise of redress must be ‘substantiated by actions', says abuse survivors group
Spiritan
congregation, which runs
Blackrock College
and other leading schools in
Ireland
, 'urgently needs to be substantiated by actions', survivors' group Restore Together has said.
It represents people who were sexually abused at Spiritan-run schools.
Group spokesman Philip Feddis said 'urgent delivery of a victim-centred, non-adversarial redress scheme is critical'.
Ongoing delays on the order's part are 'undermining the benefits of what has been delivered to date', he said.
READ MORE
His comments follow a
public commitment by Spiritan Provincial Fr Brendan Carr
to pay redress to survivors of
abuse
in the schools.
By last November, 359 survivors of abuse at Spiritan schools had come forward, including the 347 disclosed in the scoping inquiry report on abuse at private fee-paying schools published last September.
In an open letter on Monday to survivors of abuse by members and employees of the
Spiritans
, Fr Carr announced 'a restorative framework which we hope can help all to arrive at a different place in this painful and difficult journey'.
This, he said, was prepared 'with the help of Restore Together, One Voice, and other significant advocates and individuals who were abused in our schools and other contexts, who have engaged directly with us'.
Fr Carr said the Spiritans have established a 'finance advisory team, with the expertise to lead a strategic restructuring of the Province's assets'. It would 'fast-track the development of sustainable funding streams, including immediate and medium-term provisions for redress'.
He hoped that by the end of this summer he could 'provide a further, more detailed update of the progress we are making in forging new paths to create a just redress scheme'.
In response, Mr Feddis said 'victims/survivors will judge the statement based on actions and how soon they receive restorative justice in its entirety'. He stated that a redress scheme is the 'most urgent and important element'.
Delivery of a full restorative justice programme by the Spiritans is 'already long overdue', Mr Feddis added.
The order's 'ongoing delays' undermine what has been delivered to date – an apology and therapy – and 'diminishes the potential for restorative justice to have full effect for victims/ survivors', he said.
Victims and survivors must have 'active decision-making input' in determining what is best for their healing, Mr Feddis said, adding that 'justice delayed is justice denied, and that is where we are at'.
He said Restore Together will work intensively with the Spiritans to address how the three inactivated elements of the programme can be 'enabled as soon as humanly possible'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Widespread media coverage in India' of attacks on Indian people living in Ireland
Recent attacks on people from south Asia in Ireland have received 'widespread media coverage' in India and caused 'damage' to the State's reputation, the Department of Foreign Affairs has said. Weeks ago, leading Indian newspapers would rarely mention Ireland outside of their sports sections, detailing golf games, rugby matches and cricket fixtures, although with the occasional news story about Conor McGregor, often in regard to his civil rape trial. Now their reports on Ireland focus on a series of unprovoked attacks against people of south Asian origin living in Ireland. Their headlines refer to physical attacks on Indian men: a taxi driver, a data scientist, a sous chef, who, respectively, were left with 12 stitches, a broken cheekbone and in need of hospital treatment. READ MORE Others reported on a soon-to-be tech worker who arrived in Ireland three weeks before he was beaten, stabbed, robbed, and partly stripped in Tallaght, Co Dublin . He was filmed in this condition and the clips swiftly spread on social media, igniting a wildfire of misinformation about the man. Gardaí are investigating the incident as a potential hate crime. The mother of a six-year-old Irish-Indian girl who was allegedly attacked this week while playing with friends outside her home in Co Waterford has said her daughter 'is doing a little bit better'. Anupa Achuthan said her daughter Nia was punched in the face, had her hair pulled and was hit with the wheel of bike by a group of four or five boys about twice her age. They called her a 'dirty Indian' and told her 'to go back to India', Ms Achuthan said. Nia was born in Ireland, and her mother has worked as a nurse here for the past eight years. 'She didn't understand what they were saying to her,' Ms Achuthan said. Nia's grandparents, living in Kerala, southern India, 'were so shocked' to hear of the 'really racist attack' on their granddaughter. They learned about it when it was reported in the Indian media, Ms Achuthan said. Noting the 'widespread media coverage in India', a Department of Foreign Affairs spokesman said there was 'no doubt that these attacks damage Ireland's reputation'. The work of Ireland's embassy in New Delhi to promote Ireland as a destination for students, tourism and business is also damaged, he said. 'The very small Irish community in India is equally appalled by these attacks,' the spokesman said. 'Concerns have been raised to the embassy from the Indian government, civil society organisations and the many Indian people with connections to Ireland.' Ireland's Ambassador to India, Kevin Kelly, wrote an article in the Hindustan Times, saying: 'The people of Ireland stand with the Indian community and will continue to stand firmly against racism in all its forms. 'The Indian community is an integral and valued part of Irish society. 'Indians living in Ireland are contributing immensely to our economy, our education and healthcare sectors, our research institutions and our cultural life.' More than 78,000 Indian nationals were living in the Republic of Ireland in 2023, population estimates from the Central Statistics Office show. This was under 2 per cent of the State's total population of about 5.2 million at that time. In all, 13,500 Indian nationals were granted skilled employment permits by the Department of Enterprise last year, amounting to a third of all permits issued. Many Indians in Ireland work for the healthcare service or in the tech sector. Nearly 18,500 Indian nurses and midwives are registered to work alongside their 54,000 Irish colleagues, figures provided by the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland in 2024 show. Chairman of the Ireland India Council, Prashant Shukla, warned of the effects these recent attacks were having on the Indian community in Ireland. 'Many individuals and families have contacted us expressing fear and uncertainty,' he said, saying some were even 'considering returning to India'. 'Ireland has traditionally been viewed as a friendly, safe and welcoming country, especially for students, professionals and families. Unfortunately the recent spate of violent incidents has begun to alter that perception.' Mr Shukla noted the widespread coverage of these attacks by the Indian media, saying the reaction in India had been 'one of shock, sadness, and growing concern ... public discourse is increasingly focused on the safety and wellbeing of Indian nationals abroad'. 'What we are now witnessing is a sharp and alarming escalation, both in frequency and brutality of attacks targeting members of the Indian community,' he said, identifying 'an emerging pattern that cannot be dismissed as coincidental or isolated'. 'There is palpable fear among Indian parents whose children live in Ireland and a sense of disbelief that such targeted violence could occur in a country with which India shares historically warm relations,' Mr Shukla said. He said the Ireland India Council had written to Tánaiste Simon Harris and Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan 'urging a co-ordinated, multi-agency response' to these attacks. The council is asking for 'formal recognition of these assaults as hate crimes' and an 'urgent establishment of a cross-departmental taskforce on hate crime and youth violence' among other recommendations. 'Above all, we urge Irish authorities to respond decisively and visibly to prevent the normalisation of such violence. Ireland's reputation as a safe and just society depends on how we handle moments like this,' Mr Shukla said. Ms Achuthan echoed this sentiment. In the aftermath of the attack on Nia, she said she received a response from 'so many lovely Irish people, many of whom I don't know personally'. Some told her they were 'ashamed to be Irish' in light of these attacks, 'but that's not right, nobody thinks this is a racist country', she said.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Dublin man accused of knife and hatchet attack at homeless accommodation refused bail
A man (43) accused of carrying out a knife and hatchet attack on a fellow resident at a homeless accommodation service in Dublin has been remanded in custody. Stephen Crosbie was charged with assault causing harm to the injured man who was stabbed on Wednesday at the Peter McVerry Trust house on the New Cabra Road in the city's northside. He was refused bail by Judge Cephas Power at Dublin District Court. Garda Aileen Deely told Judge Power the accused made no reply when charged with the offence, which can carry a 10-year sentence. READ MORE She objected to bail due to the seriousness of the allegations, as well as concerns about witness intimidation and the accused's potential to fail to appear in court. Garda Deely stated the victim suffered multiple stab wounds which resulted in a punctured right kidney, knife injuries to his leg and back and a blow to his head with a hatchet. The court heard it was believed the alleged attack stemmed from a debt owed by the injured resident to Mr Crosbie, who had lent him €200 earlier, after which €100 was repaid. It was claimed that due to the amount outstanding, there was a row, and Mr Crosbie went to his own room and returned with a hatchet and a knife and began attacking the other resident in a hallway. He allegedly began swinging the knife and then the hatchet, striking him on the forehead. The man was taken to the Mater Hospital for emergency surgery, and the accused was arrested in the vicinity. The bail hearing was told there was CCTV footage of the incident, and the garda expected the case would ultimately be sent to the Circuit Court, which has greater sentencing powers. The court heard the accused was verbally abusive and threatened to throw urine on officers after being brought to a local Garda station. Defence solicitor Murrough O'Rourke suggested the judge could impose strict conditions. He added Mr Crosbie was from Dublin, his parents were dead, he had one sibling in the city and 'is not going to go anywhere'. The garda said no terms would alleviate her concerns; one of them was that the two men could end up coming across each other in another hostel in the city. Mr O'Rourke suggested his client could be ordered to stay away from specific homeless services. Judge Power said the defence made a reasonable argument against the witness intimidation and failure to appear in court fears. However, he held that the difficulty was the other basis – the seriousness of the charge and the extent of the injuries. He denied bail and remanded Mr Crosbie in custody. He will appear at Cloverhill District Court on Tuesday. Legal aid was granted.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Robert Dunne, son of former supermarket tycoon Ben Dunne, dies in New York
The death has taken place of Robert Dunne, son of the former head of Dunnes Stores, the late Ben Dunne. Mr Dunne, who was 50, died peacefully in New York on August 1st. He is to be buried on Monday in Castleknock Churchyard, Dublin, following a Requiem Mass at St Mochta's Church, Porterstown, Clonsilla. The Brehon Law Society of New York, where Mr Dunne worked as a lawyer, said it was with 'deep respect and remembrance' that it heard of the death of its President Emeritus. 'Rob's unwavering dedication to justice, his leadership within the Brehon Law Society, and his enduring commitment to the Irish-American legal community leave a lasting impression,' it said, announcing that a month's mind Mass is to be held in New York on September 4th. READ MORE Mr Dunne grew up in Castleknock, Co Dublin, attended Trinity College Dublin and the London School of Economics, worked in Dunnes Stores in the Ilac Centre, Dublin, and later moved to the US to work as a lawyer. He is survived by his mother, Mary, siblings Mark, Caroline and Nicholas, and wider family. Condolences posted on recalled his time in Castleknock, at Trinity, in the Ilac Centre, and in the US. 'I lived in NYC for twenty years and attended many interesting legal events invited by Rob. His laughter was infectious and wit, second to none. May he rest in peace,' said Antoin, formerly of Manhattan. In a moving interview with The Sunday Independent last year Mr Dunne spoke about being the son of one of the State's top business figures and a man whose life was filled with extraordinary controversy. Among the events he recalled was his father being kidnapped by the Provisional IRA in 1981, being arrested in Florida in 1992 when having a panic attack after taking cocaine, and the way his mother stuck with her husband during the ensuing controversy and his father's continuing struggles with cocaine. 'I think my dad developed what we would now call PTSD and he needed counselling,' Mr Dunne said in respect of the effect of the kidnapping. The fallout from the events in Florida included an audit being commissioned of Dunnes Stores accounts, which led in time to revelations about payments to Michael Lowry and the late Charles Haughey, and the associated inquiries by the McCracken and Moriarty tribunals. Mr Dunne told the newspaper that it was the events in Florida and the fallout from them that led to his decision to study law. He eventually set up his own firm in New York. Asked what he would say to his father, who died in 2023, Mr Dunne said he would tell him he couldn't have had a better father. 'You made lots of mistakes, but you owned all of them. Please know that I am nothing but proud of you.'
