logo
Judge weighs reality of Trump ‘ideological' deportation policy as activists crackdown trial ends

Judge weighs reality of Trump ‘ideological' deportation policy as activists crackdown trial ends

The Hilla day ago
A federal judge on Monday questioned the true nature of the Trump administration's crackdown on pro-Palestinian campus activists during closing arguments of a bench trial over the controversial arrests.
U.S. District Judge William Young, an appointee of former President Reagan, must determine whether the so-called 'ideological deportation policy' exists, such that the administration singled out campus activists critical of Israel's war in Gaza unlawfully.
The plaintiffs, who make up several university associations, argued that the administration's policy is to revoke the visas and green cards of noncitizens based on their pro-Palestinian advocacy in aim of chilling speech.
'It is stifling dissent, your honor,' said Alexandra Conlon, a lawyer for the plaintiffs. 'That's the goal.'
But the Justice Department called the suggestion 'silly,' contending that the trial evidence demonstrated no such policy exists.
'This policy is a product of the imagination and creative conjuring of the plaintiffs,' said DOJ lawyer William Kanellis.
The arguments cap a roughly two-week trial over the crackdown, namely the arrests of and efforts to deport foreign-born students and faculty members linked to campus demonstrations. It was the first major trial of President Trump's second administration.
Across several days, green card-holding professors at U.S. universities took the stand to testify that the high-profile arrests of outspoken students, like former Columbia University pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil and Tufts student Rümeysa Öztürk, made them fearful and stifled their speech.
On Monday, Conlon argued that was the administration's goal. She referenced statements made by Trump and other officials lauding the arrests and said they were 'designed to terrorize' those who share the views of those who were arrested.
She also pointed to testimony from a senior Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), official that 'most' names his team was directed to investigate in March came from Canary Mission, a pro-Israel online blacklist that is anonymously run.
The site has been accused of doxxing people protesting Israel's war with Palestinian militant group Hamas but describes its mission as documenting individuals and organizations 'that promote hatred of the USA, Israel and Jews on North American college campuses and beyond.' Conlon called the group 'extremist.'
'The fact that's the pool of people the government started with shows you what the point of this policy was,' she said.
Young questioned whether the trial evidence showed Canary Mission is 'extremist' and said it seems 'perfectly appropriate' for the government to take leads from any source, noting that leads frequently come from a 'wrongdoer' or 'rival gang.'
But Conlon said those leads relate to alleged lawbreaking, where here, the leads amount only to criticism of Israel or the U.S.
'That's how you end up with someone like Ms. Ozturk being described as pro-Hamas,' she added, a reference to the student's arrest being publicly linked only to an op-ed urging her university's divestment from Israel.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio deemed several of the campus demonstrators threats to the nation's foreign policy, invoking a statute that makes deportable any noncitizen whose 'presence and activities in the United States' is thought to have 'potentially serious adverse foreign policy consequences.'
In a memo explaining the apparent threat posed by Khalil, Rubio cited the student's beliefs as justification for his deportation.
Young later expressed having 'trouble' with the apparent policy. Without making any formal findings, he said it seems to him that the new administration is implementing new foreign policy within the existing legal framework – efforts that fall squarely within executive powers.
The Justice Department argued that's exactly right. Ethan Kanter, another DOJ lawyer, said that noncitizens do not have equivalent rights under the First Amendment. The nature of those rights are 'context dependent' and tied to 'competing government interests in play.'
'That is what these cases demonstrate,' Kanter said, though noting that the judge does not have to rule on that matter to decide the case in the government's favor.
Young zeroed in on Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)'s use of masks as a cause of concern, saying he's not aware of any other law enforcement agencies in the U.S. that allow the practice.
He signaled disbelief in the government's contention that the agents were protecting their identities, instead suggesting that the 'common sense' interpretation might be that their objective is to 'spread fear.'
'Perhaps they're afraid what they're being called upon to do is of concern,' the judge said.
Kanter rejected that notion, asserting that those decisions came down to the 'judgment, experience and operational needs' of individual agents.
Kanellis, the other DOJ lawyer, compared the plaintiffs' case to the fictional Don Quixote's fight with windmills.
In the story, Quixote sees windmills and believes they are giants. He's flung off his horse while riding to 'fight' them and does not believe his squire who notes they are windmills, not giants, insisting they were changed.
'Plaintiffs in this case imagine lawful standards amount to some grand government conspiracy,' Kanellis said, adding the challengers have been 'knocked off their horse.'
But Young said another historical reference better befits the case.
He described King Henry II of England asking his court to rid him of a 'troublesome priest.' Two knights went out to 'hack down' the bishop. The president, Young said, has likewise raised various concerns about campus protests.
'He doesn't have errant knights, but he's got Stephen Miller,' the judge said, referencing the top White House adviser.
Young said he will issue a written ruling deciding the case but gave no indication of when it can be expected.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump announces 'massive' Japan trade deal
Trump announces 'massive' Japan trade deal

Yahoo

time13 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Trump announces 'massive' Japan trade deal

Donald Trump announced Tuesday a "massive" trade deal with Japan, marking a key breakthrough for major US trade partners as they scramble to strike agreements before the end of the month. In an attempt to slash his country's colossal trade deficit, the US president has vowed to hit dozens of countries with punitive "reciprocal" tariffs if they do not hammer out a pact with Washington by August 1. The breakthrough makes Japan one of five countries to have signed an agreement -- along with Britain, Vietnam, Indonesia and the Philippines -- after Trump promised in April he would get "90 deals in 90 days". "We just completed a massive Deal with Japan, perhaps the largest Deal ever made," he wrote on his Truth Social platform. He said that under the deal, "Japan will invest, at my direction, $550 Billion Dollars into the United States, which will receive 90% of the Profits". He did not provide further details on the unusual investment plan, but said it "will create Hundreds of Thousands of Jobs". Japanese exports to the United States were already subject to a 10 percent tariff, which would have risen to 25 percent on August 1 without a deal. Duties of 25 percent on Japanese autos -- an industry accounting for eight percent of Japanese jobs -- were also already in place, plus 50 percent on steel and aluminium. Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said that the autos levy had now been cut to 15 percent, sending Japanese car stocks soaring, with Toyota and Mitsubishi up around 14 percent each. "We are the first (country) in the world to reduce tariffs on automobiles and auto parts, with no limits on volume," he told reporters. "By protecting what needs to be protected, we continued the negotiations with an aim to reach an agreement that meets the national interest of both Japan and the United States," Ishiba added. "In this agreement with President Trump, I think we were able to realise such an agreement." - Rice imports - However, Japan's trade envoy Ryosei Akazawa, who secured the deal on his eighth visit to Washington, said the 50 percent tariffs on steel and aluminium would remain. Akazawa also said that increased defence spending by Japan -- something Trump has pressed for -- was not part of the agreement. Trump said Tuesday that Japan has also agreed to "open their Country to Trade including Cars and Trucks, Rice and certain other Agricultural Products, and other things". Rice imports are a sensitive issue in Japan, and Ishiba's government -- which lost its upper house majority in elections on Sunday -- had previously ruled out any concessions. Japan currently imports 770,000 tonnes of rice tariff-free under its World Trade Organization commitments, and Ishiba said it would import more US grain within this. Ishiba said Wednesday that the deal does not "sacrifice" Japan's agricultural sector. Tatsuo Yasunaga, the chair of Japan Foreign Trade Council welcomed the trade deal announcement but said the business community needed to see details to assess its impact. "I highly commend the fact that this major milestone has been achieved and dispelled the uncertainty that private companies had been concerned about," Yasunaga said. Naomi Omura, an 80-year-old voter, said it was "disappointing that Japan cannot act more strongly" towards the United States. Tetsuo Momiyama, 81, said that Ishiba "is finished... It's good timing for him to go." Reports claimed Wednesday that he aims to step down soon following the election debacle. - China talks - Trump has been under pressure to wrap up trade pacts after promising a flurry of deals ahead of his deadline. The White House on Tuesday also laid out details of a deal with Indonesia, which would see it ease critical mineral export restrictions and also face a 19 percent tariff, down from a threatened 32 percent. Trump also said that levies on the Philippines, another close strategic US ally, would be cut by one percentage point to 19 percent after hosting President Ferdinand Marcos. But negotiations are still ongoing with much larger US trading partners China, Canada, Mexico and the European Union. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said Tuesday that he would meet his Chinese counterparts in Stockholm next week. Leaders of the world's two biggest economies imposed escalating, tit-for-tat levies on each other's exports earlier this year, reaching triple-digit levels. But in talks in Geneva in May they agreed to lower them temporarily until August 12. bur-stu/dan Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Judges in Epstein, Maxwell grand jury records cases want more details from DOJ
Judges in Epstein, Maxwell grand jury records cases want more details from DOJ

Axios

time14 minutes ago

  • Axios

Judges in Epstein, Maxwell grand jury records cases want more details from DOJ

Two federal judges on Tuesday gave the Department of Justice until next week to provide more details in its request to unseal grand jury transcripts from the prosecutions of Jeffrey Epstein and his associate Ghislaine Maxwell. The big picture: "The court intends to resolve this motion expeditiously," the two Manhattan judges wrote in similar court orders. "However, the Court cannot rule on the motion without additional submissions from the government." The orders came the same day as Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche announced Tuesday that he's seeking a meeting with Maxwell, who is serving a 20-year sentence in Florida after being found guilty of sex trafficking and other charges in 2021. The Trump administration has faced pressure from even typically loyal MAGA circles to act after the DOJ and FBI concluded there's no evidence that Epstein kept a "client list" and that the convicted sex offender and disgraced financier was not murdered. Driving the news: U.S. District Judge Richard Berman, who was overseeing Epstein's case before he was found dead in his cell in 2019 while awaiting trial on charges of sex-trafficking minors, requested that the DOJ provide a more detailed memorandum by July 29 on making the case for unsealing grand jury transcripts related to the case. Obama-appointed U.S. District Judge Paul Engelmayer, who's overseeing Maxwell's case, requested the same and on the same date. Victims and representatives for Epstein and Maxwell in the cases have until Aug. 5 to file submissions, according to the orders. What they're saying: "According to the government, Epstein harmed over one thousand victims," noted the Clinton-appointed Berman. "Each suffered unique trauma. Sensitive information relating to these victims is intertwined throughout the materials." Context: Grand jury transcripts are typically kept secret under federal criminal procedure rules, but federal judges can release them under special circumstances.

Jerome Powell should resign, top economist Mohamed El-Erian says, citing a scandal Trump hasn't even mentioned
Jerome Powell should resign, top economist Mohamed El-Erian says, citing a scandal Trump hasn't even mentioned

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Jerome Powell should resign, top economist Mohamed El-Erian says, citing a scandal Trump hasn't even mentioned

In a surprising turn, top economist Mohamed El-Erian has broken with convention among financial leaders by publicly calling for Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell to resign. El-Erian's comments, issued via social media and elaborated in press interviews, are remarkable not only for their candor, but for their counterintuitive reasoning: El-Erian believes Powell should step aside to protect the institution's independence in the face of multiplying political attacks. Most financial leaders who are insisting that Powell resist the pressure he's facing from Trump are the exact opposite, citing central bank independence as the reason Powell must stay. As the White House has ratcheted up its criticism of Powell, speculation has grown about potential leadership changes at the Federal Reserve. Donald Trump has been outspoken in his demands that Powell cut interest rates, a concern that El-Erian shares. But the scandal advanced by the Trump administration over Powell's oversight of a $2.5 billion office renovation is not part of El-Erian's critique. El-Erian, who has been an inflation hawk for nearly all of the 2020s, largely agrees with the White House on inflation, even if they may be coming at it from different angles. Trump likely wants rate cuts as a way to spur the economy ahead of the 2026 elections, although Trump demanded rate cuts in similar fashion in the last decade, when both he and Powell were in their first terms. The cuts that eventually resulted surprised economists as inflation stayed under control for a time—but the surge in 2021 was the biggest since the early 1980s. El-Erian was on the record then and now about saying that Powell undermined the Fed's credibility on inflation throughout this episode. On Tuesday, he stated that if Powell were a CEO in the corporate world, he would have already been forced out over the central bank's recent stumbles. Among the missteps: the Fed's much-derided assertion in 2021–2022 that inflation was 'transitory,' which delayed rate hikes and contributed to price spikes; the 2022 'insider trading' scandal involving several senior Fed officials; and the 2023 banking crisis around the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank, which prompted what El-Erian termed a 'damning' internal report. In the first regard, El-Erian was often critical of Powell's reference to 'transitory' inflation, calling it a 'protracted gross mischaracterisation' in a December 2022 op-ed for the Financial Times. At that time, Powell was awaiting an Inspector General report on stock trading during the pandemic by two central bank governors. They were ultimately cleared, but the watchdog chastised both of them—and indirectly Powell—for undermining public confidence in the central bank, the same topic with whic El-Erian is still concerned. Although Powell was never accused of wrongdoing regarding the trading controversy, the episode led to stricter rules for central bank leaders and further eroded public confidence. Finally, the collapse in Silicon Valley Bank was unrelated, but chief regulator Michael Barr criticized lax oversight in an April 2023 report, arguing that it was partially responsible for one of the biggest banking failures in American history. El-Erian, former CEO of PIMCO and current president of Queen's College, Cambridge, told Axios and other outlets that Powell should bow out to defend the credibility and autonomy of the central bank. 'If your objective is to protect the independence of the central bank,' he told Axios, 'then it's better that he step down than he stays and the attacks multiply.' El-Erian warned that further assaults could undermine trust in the Fed with serious economic consequences. A 'lame duck' chair, and more attacks to come Powell, whose term expires in May 2026, is in a weakened position, El-Erian argued. The announcement of his replacement is expected by year end, and with a limited ability to steer policy, he is essentially a 'lame duck.' El-Erian argued that continuing attacks—regardless of their origin—will escalate so long as Powell remains in the role, increasing the risk of lasting reputational harm to the Fed. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent's comments on Monday, calling for an examination 'of the entire Federal Reserve institution,' only heightened El-Erian's concerns. 'That is a red flag,' he said, suggesting the administration is widening its criticism beyond Powell to target the Fed itself. El-Erian predicted that if these political threats to central bank independence persist, markets could see a weaker dollar, higher interest rates, and a more volatile yield curve—destabilizing the economy further. Independence versus political pressure Trump's criticism of Powell has also expanded to the cost and management of the Fed's $2.5 billion renovation of its historic Washington, D.C. headquarters. Trump and his administration have accused Powell of mismanaging the project and potentially violating oversight rules, describing the renovations as 'ostentatious' and possibly 'fraudulent.' Specific complaints have included claims about luxury features such as rooftop gardens, private dining rooms, and executive elevators—many of which Powell refuted as either standard building updates or mischaracterizations by the administration. Trump has suggested that Powell's handling of the office renovation could be sufficient grounds for removal, although no evidence of fraud has been presented. In contrast, economist El-Erian's opinion of the real scandal is based on institutional credibility and internal scandals. El-Erian points to a series of reputational crises under Powell's leadership, with special emphasis on a high-profile insider trading scandal involving several senior Fed officials. In 2021 and 2022, some key regional Fed presidents were revealed to have been trading securities during periods when they had privileged policy information. Although Powell himself was cleared of wrongdoing by an independent watchdog, El-Erian argues that these scandals have eroded public confidence and harmed the Fed's credibility. The economist emphasized that the best outcome would be for the attacks to cease and for Powell to serve out his term in peace—though he considers that highly unlikely. El-Erian said the best-case scenario is for Powell to stay and attacks on the Fed to end, but he doesn't see that happening, making clear his conviction that a voluntary departure by Powell could help stem the tide and limit further damage. For this story, Fortune used generative AI to help with an initial draft. An editor verified the accuracy of the information before publishing. This story was originally featured on Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store